Are anti-survivalists a big thing?
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Are anti-survivalists a big thing?
If there is ever a man made apocalypse, would it be terrible if any people survived?
I feel that there are people who want mutually assured destruction to mean assured death for all humans, because otherwise the threat isn't big enough and/or fascism or communism might rise again.
To be clear, I would find this idea appalling, and I don't believe current weapons are likely to do that, but I am inclined to paranoia and worry that someone somewhere is working towards it.
I feel that there are people who want mutually assured destruction to mean assured death for all humans, because otherwise the threat isn't big enough and/or fascism or communism might rise again.
To be clear, I would find this idea appalling, and I don't believe current weapons are likely to do that, but I am inclined to paranoia and worry that someone somewhere is working towards it.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: Are anti-survivalists a big thing?
I don't think that anyone tries to destroy humanity on purpose but it will surely come to that if the Great Capital won't stop destroying the environment in the ceaseless hunt for profit.
Communism is hope though.
Communism is hope though.
Armed with a Cintiq+4+bless I'm off to fight bad taste!
Take a look at my art and t-shirts
Take a look at my art and t-shirts
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Are anti-survivalists a big thing?
It's not clear "how many changes are necessary" for human race to change into some different ideas/behaviours and/or if truly let's call it "a certain level of evilness" is really "native/intrinsic/develop" inside the human mind "naturally" ( and can't never be removed ).
Evolution takes very long time, I SUPPOSE it could be even possible for human race to go totally extinct and maybe something else take its place, given really long time. But would it better ? Would the planet be still abithable ? Will it be "the new better race that don't make war but they all cooperate nicely for the common good" .. .. a set of insects surviving a barren radiation poisoned really hot/cold land living on dunno what ?
Anyway worries not, the sun won't last forever and LONG before it explodes Earth will become "a hell of fire" at some point with no athmosphere at all ( when the sun starts to enter the red-giant phase ) and when it'll cool down Earth will be all super cold at nearly absolute 0.
And yes "unless we break some INCREDIBLE barrier of phisics/we discover something really INCREDIBLE, assuming it does exist" there's NOTHING/NOWHERE close we can go and hope to survive, the history of planet Earth IS doomed at a certain expiry date ( the one of the sun ).
Or maybe "best hope" we do really manage to create some sort of "immortal digital AI" ( mind you in space even machines spoil, micrometeors, radiation, all sort of incredible crap", space is a very dangerous envirronement * ) and/or perfection hibernation and "point a spaceship to some HOPEFULLY habitable exoplanet and HOPE it gets there intact" .. in some many thousands of years ..
And then what ? HOPE we can do something to survive once we get there.
Or have an "AI wandering in space" that will be a sort of "database of what we have been" with .. probably absolutely no purpose or much future.
So yeah "or we really evolve/turn into something magic at some point" or human race is well doomed by design of the planet we live in.
Will we have ever time to turn/become "something better" .. who knows ? Or how many times we need or not need to be totally destroyed to change into something different ?
Evolution takes very long time, I SUPPOSE it could be even possible for human race to go totally extinct and maybe something else take its place, given really long time. But would it better ? Would the planet be still abithable ? Will it be "the new better race that don't make war but they all cooperate nicely for the common good" .. .. a set of insects surviving a barren radiation poisoned really hot/cold land living on dunno what ?
Anyway worries not, the sun won't last forever and LONG before it explodes Earth will become "a hell of fire" at some point with no athmosphere at all ( when the sun starts to enter the red-giant phase ) and when it'll cool down Earth will be all super cold at nearly absolute 0.
And yes "unless we break some INCREDIBLE barrier of phisics/we discover something really INCREDIBLE, assuming it does exist" there's NOTHING/NOWHERE close we can go and hope to survive, the history of planet Earth IS doomed at a certain expiry date ( the one of the sun ).
Or maybe "best hope" we do really manage to create some sort of "immortal digital AI" ( mind you in space even machines spoil, micrometeors, radiation, all sort of incredible crap", space is a very dangerous envirronement * ) and/or perfection hibernation and "point a spaceship to some HOPEFULLY habitable exoplanet and HOPE it gets there intact" .. in some many thousands of years ..
And then what ? HOPE we can do something to survive once we get there.
Or have an "AI wandering in space" that will be a sort of "database of what we have been" with .. probably absolutely no purpose or much future.
So yeah "or we really evolve/turn into something magic at some point" or human race is well doomed by design of the planet we live in.
Will we have ever time to turn/become "something better" .. who knows ? Or how many times we need or not need to be totally destroyed to change into something different ?
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
- Little stoned kiwi
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4598
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
- Location: Christchurch
Re: Are anti-survivalists a big thing?
While I consider the Marxist Communist Utopia to be out of our grasp, we should reach for it.grue wrote:Communism is hope though.
If they think you're crude, go technical; if they think you're technical, go crude. I'm a very technical boy.
- Little stoned kiwi
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4598
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
- Location: Christchurch
Re: Are anti-survivalists a big thing?
My pick is robots. Which will be very cool.gilesgoat wrote:Will we have ever time to turn/become "something better" .. who knows ?
If they think you're crude, go technical; if they think you're technical, go crude. I'm a very technical boy.
Re: Are anti-survivalists a big thing?
Humanity won't become extinct. Some will survive, will return to the caves, Earth will recover itself in the meantime, and sometime later, maybe a few thousand years, civilization will return and maybe that time around will find a better system than the capitalism we have now.
Re: Are anti-survivalists a big thing?
If I remember it correctly, in roughly 0.75 billion years the natural changes to the sun as it ages will prevent plants from doing photosynthesisgilesgoat wrote: Anyway worries not, the sun won't last forever and LONG before it explodes Earth will become "a hell of fire" at some point with no athmosphere at all ( when the sun starts to enter the red-giant phase ) and when it'll cool down Earth will be all super cold at nearly absolute 0.
By the time we get to 1 billion years the continuing changes to the sun will have evaporated the Earth's oceans, its thought that is how Venus became the hellscape it is now,
the evaporation with release the stored carbon and CO2 and sulphur from volcanic action will finish Earth's conversion into Venus 2.0 over the long run.
2-3 billion may see a weakening of the magnetosphere leading to the slow degradation of the atmosphere but not before Venus 2.0 melts is crust.
Then 4 - 7.5 billion years or so the Red Sun version of the Sun will swallow the planet whole.
Eventually the core of the sun will shrink, start burning Helium and become a white dwarf, blowing the Red Sun outer shell away which will become a planetary Nebula
- Little stoned kiwi
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4598
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
- Location: Christchurch
Re: Are anti-survivalists a big thing?
Living in caves probably is the better system.
If they think you're crude, go technical; if they think you're technical, go crude. I'm a very technical boy.
Re: Are anti-survivalists a big thing?
Marxism is the analysis of the relations between every participant of the production process. It's not a system.Little stoned kiwi wrote:While I consider the Marxist Communist Utopia to be out of our grasp, we should reach for it.grue wrote:Communism is hope though.
Communism is the suggested aim that we could attain after capitalism. It is not described in any way by any Marxist or even Marx himself. It is linked to capitalism because we should keep every [positive] invention regarding the means of production instead of trying to "re-invent the wheel", something that almost all of the tries in history did wrong in one way or another.
No matter where anyone stands regarding communism, I prefer to believe that the majority of the world's population, even though they have come to believe that the system is unassailable, wants the good of all people as opposed to the good of a tiny minority.
Armed with a Cintiq+4+bless I'm off to fight bad taste!
Take a look at my art and t-shirts
Take a look at my art and t-shirts
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Are anti-survivalists a big thing?
What about Socialism ?grue wrote:Marxism is the analysis of the relations between every participant of the production process. It's not a system.Little stoned kiwi wrote:While I consider the Marxist Communist Utopia to be out of our grasp, we should reach for it.grue wrote:Communism is hope though.
Communism is the suggested aim that we could attain after capitalism. It is not described in any way by any Marxist or even Marx himself. It is linked to capitalism because we should keep every [positive] invention regarding the means of production instead of trying to "re-invent the wheel", something that almost all of the tries in history did wrong in one way or another.
No matter where anyone stands regarding communism, I prefer to believe that the majority of the world's population, even though they have come to believe that the system is unassailable, wants the good of all people as opposed to the good of a tiny minority.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Are anti-survivalists a big thing?
It's the transitional stage between the state as a tool (used by the workers to persecute their enemies/capitalists) and its dissolution.gilesgoat wrote:What about Socialism ?
Socialism in capitalism though is just a populist trick.
Armed with a Cintiq+4+bless I'm off to fight bad taste!
Take a look at my art and t-shirts
Take a look at my art and t-shirts
- RedOktober
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4788
- Joined: Sun Sep 04, 2005 11:15 pm 0
- Location: Stalin's Organ
- Contact:
Re: Are anti-survivalists a big thing?
I don't believe we are unique or special in the universe, and the Earth has a track record of bouncing back from seemingly total disasters.
Sadly, whatever comes after would undoubtedly be as badly put together and fragile as we are.
Sadly, whatever comes after would undoubtedly be as badly put together and fragile as we are.
Sponsoring terrorism at £1 per mile.
Re: Are anti-survivalists a big thing?
This is an interesting quirk of the human psyche.
We're forever beating ourselves up about our own failings, acting as if we're an inherently evil species, without noticing the obvious.
It's found in religions.
The Abrahamic thing that we're "born sinners". Christian hymns are full of "Oh, God, you are so awesome, while we're such scum, we're like shit upon on your shoes, unworthy to even contemplate your majesty" doing-oneself-down nonsense. Whilst Buddhism is less directly self-insulting, it's still totally your fault that you're still here, in the realm of "life is suffering", because of anything less than absolutely perfect karma (one tiny karmic mistake and, yup, you're doing yet another lap of existence all over again - and, presumably, before Buddha solved the problem of how to obtain Nirvana, folks were doomed to an infinite repeat of existence forever, except by an "infinite monkeys on infinite typewriters" coincidence, that you got it all 100% perfect by random coincidence).
You find it in Victorian notions of "all things bright and beautiful". Nature is God's wonderful theme park of perfection, and we're the fucking scum what ruined it all.
A meme repeated throughout culture, from the human hunters in Bambi being "inherent evil" whenever they show up, or the same in the innumerable "nature good, man evil" tropes, such as, you know, in Avatar.
And this is found in the environmental movement too. Or leftist notions about the purity of our foods, having "no artificial colours or preservatives" - organic is awesome, but man-made is scum (even though, strictly, what the word "organic" actually means in science is that it's carbon-based. "Organic chemistry" basically means "the chemistry of carbon").
It's the Catholic guilt trip. Constantly self-flagellating that we're evil and terrible and unworthy scum. Like, the Catholics actually make a fetish out of that, but it's not as if all of humanity, in general, isn't forever doing this.
But I mentioned that we fail to notice the obvious. And what I mean by that is that an actually "inherently evil" creature would not actually constantly beat themselves up about their mistakes and failures all the time like this.
The fact that we're so obsessed with saying that we're "inherent evil" actually proves that we're not inherently evil at all, if you think about it.
The truly evil creature - that has evil inherently within their nature - would just commit evil and have no remorse nor regrets of any kind whatsoever. Now THAT would be "inherent evil", because that's literally what "inherent" means, right?
But, nah, what we've actually got is limited beings - because we're not omniscient, and don't know the future at all, so we're always operating in an environment of imperfect information - who're making cock-ups, honest mistakes, misinterpretations and then, upon realising we've fucked shit up, start self-flagellating with great enthusiasm.
Which, indeed, does reach fatalistic, almost suicidal, levels of "well, nature would be better off, if humanity was just wiped out completely".
Okay, sure, except nature is, of course, not remotely perfect - "red in tooth and claw" - and most animals live an utterly torturous life in the wild, and what's the fucking point of any of this, if you haven't got a sufficient self-aware species left to appreciate how fucking awesome everything supposedly is (which it actually isn't, see point one)?
The hilarious paradox that, in pursuit of an unattainable moral perfection, we've somehow found ourselves praying for GENOCIDE, for pity's sake.
And this is the real point about "good" and "evil", of course. No-one wakes up of a morning and thinks "how can I be really evil today?". No, the mad bastard who goes on a shotgun rampage or kamakazis a plane into a building thinks that they hear God in their heads, giving them an existential "mission" to save everyone's soul or something. The neo-Nazi eugenicist reckons he's "preserving our genetics" and just increasing the "Lebensraum" for all these supposedly "perfect" Aryan people.
"Evil" is not an actual thing. It's not some entity that floats around and "infects" people to do bad, like a disease you can catch.
It's a misunderstanding of reality that leads you to think that you're doing the correct thing, while you are, in fact, doing absolutely the wrong thing.
The 9/11 kamakazi pilots reckoned they were doing Allah's work to prevent Western "Jahiliyyah" (a state of ignorance of God) from spreading into the Islamic hearts, through the medium of Hollywood blockbusters, Levi jeans and folks drinking Pepsi. Jack the Ripper murdered prostitutes - we can't know for sure, as we still don't know who it actually was, but there seems very clearly to be some Victorian / Abrahamic "sex negative" morality motivating it all, that they felt they were "purging" these sex workers from "infecting" the populous or something like that.
You get the gist. And, indeed, ironically, the true "evil" - if we can say that such a thing exists - here is the level of supreme confidence with which these people hold the conviction that they're doing a good thing. They're so convinced, they're actually defying natural human instincts to not go around murdering people in pursuit of some ideal of "perfection" that cannot possibly exist.
To provide the counter-arguments, humans have pets - animals that provide us no genetic advantage to preserve - as genuine family members. We have animal hospitals, folks giving away their fortunes to animal sanctuaries and devoting and dedicating their study and lives to veterinary practice.
The Industrial Revolution was extraordinarily successful in exponentially raising the standard of living and extending life expectancy. I've emphasised the point before, but the historical past was a living hellscape. Truly fucking awful to levels we might struggle to comprehend. Infant mortality levels where, even as recently as the Victorian era, 1-in-3 - moving to 1-in-2 or 50% for the inner city slums - children never made it to the age of 5. Disease and pandemics were a constant feature. Without modern medicine, vast numbers of folks condemned to be crippled or in pain for all of their short lives. Slavery, the perpetual subsistence farming of serfdom - the guarantee of living under some god-awful tyranny.
But, yet, for all this tremendous success, we do have to acknowledge William Blake's "dark satanic mills". Because, yup, the big cock-up of all this tremendous progress - which, you know, also afforded humanity enough space to abolish slavery and improve civil rights, through women's rights and, more recently, gay rights and beyond, as the economic advantage permits the social progress to occur, when we have time and space to deal with this, and don't have to impose "baby factory" religious ethics on everything to keep raising the population to fight against the awful infant mortality rates.
(For those who ain't noticed, all of God's sexual "morals"? All focused on "go forth and multiply". In keeping the population numbers up. Gays don't naturally increase the population - abomination! Women having a mind of their own? Can't afford that, as they need to be constantly pumping out babies. In antiquity, when your "city" was only thousands of people and your neighbours were war-like conquerors - themselves worried about also going extinct, so driven to conquer to survive - then population numbers mattered to keep your culture alive. The Abrahamic God is not alone in this message of "produce more babies", as every culture needed its armies - it's cannon fodder - to keep existing.
The story of Onan is often held up as "God does not want you masturbating" - or "onanism" as it's also alternatively called - but, if you read it, then what's actually going on is that Onan's brother dies. And, in that culture, there's the notion that Onan must now take his brother's wife as his wife, and complete the "duty" to impregnate her. He must take his brother's wife and carry on the baby-making process. Such was this notion of keeping the population numbers up in antiquity, that's how it worked. If a "soldier" falls, then his brother has to do "double duty" and now make babies with both his own wife and his brother's wife. We can also note, yes, that there's nothing in this about seeing if his brother's wife actually wants to do this - that's not a consideration, because women having opinions of their own could lead to them saying "no" and making babies is more important than worrying about their consent to do so.
Onan's terrible "sin" in the eyes of God is that, yup, he takes on his brother's wife and has sex with her. But then, at the last minute, he pulls out and "spills his seed" on the ground. So he's just enjoying the sex and avoiding the baby making. And that's his terrible "sin" before God. The story itself is not actually about masturbation - that's just an extension of the idea of "don't spill your seed". Like, such is the cultural drive for baby-making here, there's the notion that God wants every ejaculation to be impregnating someone or you're doing it wrong.)
In fact, I could point to the fact that such mad notions even exist in the historical past itself points to what a living hell it all was. This, somehow, all made perfect sense back then, as reasonable behaviour. Indeed, it was necessary for cultural survival. Natural disasters and diseases happened - you had to be actively fighting against extinction to win, it was not sufficient to just let it all happen naturally.
Now, moving onto environmentalism, you probably all know that I have an interest in this myself, with my "future of energy" thread and advocacy of renewables and batteries and such.
But I don't blame humanity for it all. At least, my beef is that we do now know better and we should raise our game to meet the challenge. But I totally see how we ended up in this shit hole of a problem in the first place, and it was not any "inherent evil" involved.
As mentioned, the first cars were electric vehicles, before the internal combustion engine showed up. More over, as I've pointed out, where the electric motors is often 90+% efficient - basically, as efficient as entropy allows anything to be - the internal combustion engine is, at its very best, nudging on only 30% efficient. Most of the fuel - over 70% - you pay for doesn't actually go towards the forward motion of your vehicle. This is horridly inefficient.
But, ah, the wonder of fossil fuels is that they have such immense energy density, that even when you're throwing most of it away - and, in any application that's not heating, that is exactly what you're always doing - we can all still easily power massive vehicles, weighing several tons, to 90mph down the motorway for hundreds and hundreds of miles, no problem.
The energy density of fossil fuels is insane, basically. And that's why, upon the discovery of this amazing "shortcut", it came to dominate absolutely everything. And, of course, a very useful facet of fossil fuels over solar or wind or hydro is that you can burn it any time you like. No need to worry about energy storage or intermittent power sources. Whenever you need it, just throw another lump of coal on the fire.
Slight problem. This release CO2 into the atmosphere. And because there's 8 billion of us now - yeah, there's no longer any "baby-making" problems anymore (quite the opposite) - then we're pumping out this shit at a rate that cannot be sustained. I mean, quite literally. It's all going to run out within decades. Which is one of my primary points about going renewable - we're soon going to have zero choices in the matter anyway, so getting out ahead on this, ensures the tech and infrastructure is good enough for when that happens.
Whilst I have immense disappointment in the reaction of the fossil fuel industry - because they realised what they were doing decades before it became public, and just like the tobacco industry, reacted by just spending billions upon billions in keeping it quiet, inventing a "debate" that does not scientifically exist, pay for the bullshit headlines about EVs you're seeing in the Murdoch newspapers recently and bribing politicians to do their bidding - I can't be disappointed in the general human reaction.
Because, as these issues have come to public light, we have folks happily recycling. We have Extinction Rebellion and Insulate Britain. We've had stupid Hollywood movies ("the Day after Tomorrow") and good ones, satirising our stupidity, like "Don't Look Up".
Most people, most of the time, are totally on board with fixing this problem. If we could have a global referendum and the result of the vote was instantly and fully implemented, the problem would be over and done with already. Unfortunately, the fossil fuel industry has immense money and it's still in its "deny, deny, deny" mode - like the tobacco industry - to concerned for maintaining its gravy train, and they really do have all the politicians bought and paid for.
Indeed, the amount of money that these parasites are unnecessarily stealing from us, you'll be amazed at just how rich the whole planet could get when we're all getting a big chunk of our energy from the cheapest sources - of solar and wind - for free. Our economy is down the toilet bowl, because we're clinging onto an ever-more-expensive dead-end technology that's dying right in front of us.
The pandemic started the problem, because fossil fuels are a physical thing that needs to be transported around, so closing all the world's borders and stopping people moving around had a serious impact (meanwhile, in the solar and wind farms, absolutely nothing happened). Then Putin's war has sent shit stratospheric, as he made the supply problems worse, not least because Russia supplies a lot of Europe's gas and oil. This is causing the "cost of living" crisis. And because the cost of living is now through the roof, that's why there's all these NHS and transport strikes, as folks really do need wage increases to avoid their lives get so much more horribly worse.
Ergo, as I say, if we'd all started going solar and wind back in the '90s - when there was popular mainstream consensus in the public that something needed to be done and, therefore, we can imagine that the politicians actually listened, rather than took their fossil fuel bribes, to really do something useful - then there not only wouldn't be a cost of living crisis right now, there couldn't be one (at least caused by energy costs) ever again.
It ain't just cheaper. It's more economically stable. The Sun rises and sets every day. The tides go in and out twice a day. We can come back to this in a few million years, and those statements will still remain true. Basing your economy on a stable reality like that will avoid it "boom and bust"-ing every 2 seconds.
Humans are not "inherent evil". The fact that there's even the question asked actually proves that couldn't be the case. We do have the solutions and most people, most of the time, absolutely want to pursue them post-haste.
There's a broken logic to "the planet would be better off without us". Sure, I won't dispute that, on a certain level, that's not untrue. But what would be the fucking point of a "perfect planet" - and I quote that, because, of course, nature is "red in tooth and claw", not actually perfect loveliness, if you actually pay attention - if there's no sufficient self-aware creature left to appreciate it?
It's a bit like this. I know how to create a 100% perfect crime-free Utopia. All we have to do is kill off all the human beings. No human beings, no crime. Cool. Except, of course, the rather massive problem that what's the point of your crime-free Utopia, if there's no-one left to enjoy it? And, heck, we're bending our notions of "crime" here, as it's not as if animals won't be murdering each other to eat and survive. It's only "crime-free" in the sense that human law only allows humans to be guilty of crimes. There's still plenty of sheer fucking evil going on. Indeed, truth is, humans are the ones who impose some kind of order and standards to try to reduce the amount of evil that's naturally going on.
It's a dumb solution. It doesn't make any sense, if you think about it.
You can simplistically say "humans commit crime" Therefore, no humans and there's no crime. Therefore, commit genocide of all humans. Well, you've clearly gone wrong there, as you've somehow rationalised that committing THE WORST CRIME IMAGINABLE - mass-murdering everyone on the planet - is morally good.
As I say, there isn't really such things as "evil". It's not, like, an actual physical entity that's going around "infecting" people to do bad. It's people having these horrid misunderstandings of reality that fool them into thinking that doing absolutely the wrong thing is actually doing the right thing. And then, filled with conviction that, say, killing off all the prostitutes will restore the moral fibre of society, you've just convinced yourself into becoming Jack the Ripper and you're now a serial killer. Or you're so filled with love for God that you've flown a plane into a building and murdered thousands of people... for what's actually no good reason whatsoever, as you've actually done nothing to help anyone there. You've just killed people and the world didn't improve a single inch, did it? Actually, it got vastly worse there for a while. Then it returned to "business as usual". Which it will always do, you stupid idiot.
But, yes, there's totally this strange quirk in the human psyche.
A big ironic quirk of "perfectionism" that we grossly over-self-flagellate over our faults and mistakes, telling ourselves how fucking "evil" and "guilty" we are, often to the point of almost suicidal fatalism where we're convincing ourselves that genocide - wiping out all of humanity - would actually be a better result.
Which is oozing with irony, because if we were "inherent evil" then we wouldn't care. The fact we beat ourselves up about this constantly proves it's just not true. We are capable of evil, sure, but we are not inherently so - because if it were inherent, then it wouldn't be in our nature to be so reviled and self-flagellating about such evil, when it does happen. The fact we even ask the question proves that it's not actually true.
There's a thing in English. We say "I am right". The auxiliary verb is "to be" - am, is, etc. - and this creates the notion that people are inherently good or bad. In their very being.
But, in German, the auxiliary verb is "to have". You say "Ich habe recht", "du hast recht", "sie haben recht", etc. and I prefer that way of thinking. That "right" and "wrong" is not a thing you are, in your being. It's an external object that you can possess or not possess.
You are just you. Not inherently anything. But if you pick up "the right thing to do" - an external object that you can possess - then "you have right". It is currently in your possession. And note that, by this model, you could also temporarily lose possession of "right" - you had right for this and you had right for that but, ah, you've not picked up "right" for this one, I'm afraid. Possession is inherently a temporary concept.
Whereas, the phrase "I am right" is suggesting that you are not only right in your very being, but it's implicitly going on to suggest that, as a state of being, you're always right about everything. All the time, forever more. "I am right" also lacks a temporal component. It's not "I am right, temporally in this moment, about this one subject", it's implying that "right" is like a permanent state of being.
I mean, don't get me wrong. Germans also make these same mistakes - after all, there's that very big obvious example of the Germans getting it most horribly wrong, like no-one else has ever done before or since - so, sure, the theory of "linguistical determinism" is far from the whole story.
But it helps to see things from a different perspective - try using "to have" as the auxiliary verb for "right" and "wrong" for a while, to try out this different way of thinking - to help spot where you're assuming things that actually shouldn't really be automatically assumed at all.
Indeed, it has been shown, in the research, that bilingualism strengthens a broad range of cognitive capabilities, as you inherently carry around more than one way of looking at things.
But, yeah, humans are not "inherent evil" and it really wouldn't help anything to wipe us out.
Because, after all, if we're not around, who's the beneficiary here?
And, indeed, there's absolutely no guarantees that evolution would conjure up a new intelligent species - it took most of 4.5 billion years to get to us in the first place (and if it takes that long again, then the Sun will have killed off this planet before then, so it wouldn't happen) - and there's nothing that prevents them being just as bad, or even worse, than us.
Though the inherent racism of Star Trek annoys me sometimes - Picard lecturing aliens about humanity, and Spock is totally racist about humans all the time (which is self-hatred, considering he's half-human - indeed, some other Vulcans seem to have much less of a problem with humans, so one wonders if this self-hatred is just Spock's own identity crisis) - it might be actually true that all the other aliens out there are violent or greedy bastards, and it turns out we're actually among the best of them.
We might actually be the best that the universe has ever thrown up, for all we know. Indeed, right now, we don't know that we're not the ONLY thing that the universe has thrown up and there are no other intelligent beings of our calibre out there at all. Or, indeed, as Brian Cox has argued, the statistics might mean that, on average, there's maybe only one or two intelligent species per galaxy, say - and, as I've covered before, galaxies and the universe is so vast, this effectively means we're on our own, because - short of "stargate" wormholes everywhere - you're not getting to another galaxy in any reasonable time, even with x1000 lightspeed FTL drives.
Indeed, I do find it ironic. We're so hard on ourselves, as a general rule, because we have a conscience and want to get things right. We hold ourselves to an unattainable perfectionism, and then start whipping ourselves on the back for our comparatively trivial failings to reach the impossible standard.
That, to me, is absolutely NOT an "inherently evil" being. Not at all. Quite the opposite. it's an imperfect being, full of regrets, trying its damnedest to be better and being far too hard on itself when it fails to quite live up to that.
I'm a humanist and that pretty much explains why, and how I see humans. And, indeed, part of my humanism is an acceptance that humans are not, and cannot be, perfect. I consider "the Human Condition" and "to err is to be human" as all part and parcel of what it is to be human.
Like, Neil Armstrong landing on the Moon. His scripted line was actually "One small step for A man, one giant leap for mankind". At the most significant historical moment for humanity, after such immense effort to get to the Moon, he fucks it up.
(Actually, fair play to NASA, that's their footage and they actually do acknowledge the mistake in the subtitles, as it has "one small step for [a] man" written there. I do also like the long pause. Like Neil says "one small step for man, one..." and there's an awkward pause, as he just realises he said it wrong. But then, ah, fuck it, it's too late now. And he just finishes it off.
Close enough. That'll do.
And that's my understanding of humans and humanism. At the height of our achievement, we slightly screw up the historical scripted line. In the words of Sting, "that's my soul up there" in that awkward pause by Neil, as he realises he messed it up. But, also, you know, fuck it, he's standing on the Moon. Don't get so hung up on the fluffed line, while you're actually standing on Earth's satellite that took such immense ingenuity and effort to reach. Like, don't sweat the small stuff. Focus on the bit that matters.)
We're forever beating ourselves up about our own failings, acting as if we're an inherently evil species, without noticing the obvious.
It's found in religions.
The Abrahamic thing that we're "born sinners". Christian hymns are full of "Oh, God, you are so awesome, while we're such scum, we're like shit upon on your shoes, unworthy to even contemplate your majesty" doing-oneself-down nonsense. Whilst Buddhism is less directly self-insulting, it's still totally your fault that you're still here, in the realm of "life is suffering", because of anything less than absolutely perfect karma (one tiny karmic mistake and, yup, you're doing yet another lap of existence all over again - and, presumably, before Buddha solved the problem of how to obtain Nirvana, folks were doomed to an infinite repeat of existence forever, except by an "infinite monkeys on infinite typewriters" coincidence, that you got it all 100% perfect by random coincidence).
You find it in Victorian notions of "all things bright and beautiful". Nature is God's wonderful theme park of perfection, and we're the fucking scum what ruined it all.
A meme repeated throughout culture, from the human hunters in Bambi being "inherent evil" whenever they show up, or the same in the innumerable "nature good, man evil" tropes, such as, you know, in Avatar.
And this is found in the environmental movement too. Or leftist notions about the purity of our foods, having "no artificial colours or preservatives" - organic is awesome, but man-made is scum (even though, strictly, what the word "organic" actually means in science is that it's carbon-based. "Organic chemistry" basically means "the chemistry of carbon").
It's the Catholic guilt trip. Constantly self-flagellating that we're evil and terrible and unworthy scum. Like, the Catholics actually make a fetish out of that, but it's not as if all of humanity, in general, isn't forever doing this.
But I mentioned that we fail to notice the obvious. And what I mean by that is that an actually "inherently evil" creature would not actually constantly beat themselves up about their mistakes and failures all the time like this.
The fact that we're so obsessed with saying that we're "inherent evil" actually proves that we're not inherently evil at all, if you think about it.
The truly evil creature - that has evil inherently within their nature - would just commit evil and have no remorse nor regrets of any kind whatsoever. Now THAT would be "inherent evil", because that's literally what "inherent" means, right?
But, nah, what we've actually got is limited beings - because we're not omniscient, and don't know the future at all, so we're always operating in an environment of imperfect information - who're making cock-ups, honest mistakes, misinterpretations and then, upon realising we've fucked shit up, start self-flagellating with great enthusiasm.
Which, indeed, does reach fatalistic, almost suicidal, levels of "well, nature would be better off, if humanity was just wiped out completely".
Okay, sure, except nature is, of course, not remotely perfect - "red in tooth and claw" - and most animals live an utterly torturous life in the wild, and what's the fucking point of any of this, if you haven't got a sufficient self-aware species left to appreciate how fucking awesome everything supposedly is (which it actually isn't, see point one)?
The hilarious paradox that, in pursuit of an unattainable moral perfection, we've somehow found ourselves praying for GENOCIDE, for pity's sake.
And this is the real point about "good" and "evil", of course. No-one wakes up of a morning and thinks "how can I be really evil today?". No, the mad bastard who goes on a shotgun rampage or kamakazis a plane into a building thinks that they hear God in their heads, giving them an existential "mission" to save everyone's soul or something. The neo-Nazi eugenicist reckons he's "preserving our genetics" and just increasing the "Lebensraum" for all these supposedly "perfect" Aryan people.
"Evil" is not an actual thing. It's not some entity that floats around and "infects" people to do bad, like a disease you can catch.
It's a misunderstanding of reality that leads you to think that you're doing the correct thing, while you are, in fact, doing absolutely the wrong thing.
The 9/11 kamakazi pilots reckoned they were doing Allah's work to prevent Western "Jahiliyyah" (a state of ignorance of God) from spreading into the Islamic hearts, through the medium of Hollywood blockbusters, Levi jeans and folks drinking Pepsi. Jack the Ripper murdered prostitutes - we can't know for sure, as we still don't know who it actually was, but there seems very clearly to be some Victorian / Abrahamic "sex negative" morality motivating it all, that they felt they were "purging" these sex workers from "infecting" the populous or something like that.
You get the gist. And, indeed, ironically, the true "evil" - if we can say that such a thing exists - here is the level of supreme confidence with which these people hold the conviction that they're doing a good thing. They're so convinced, they're actually defying natural human instincts to not go around murdering people in pursuit of some ideal of "perfection" that cannot possibly exist.
To provide the counter-arguments, humans have pets - animals that provide us no genetic advantage to preserve - as genuine family members. We have animal hospitals, folks giving away their fortunes to animal sanctuaries and devoting and dedicating their study and lives to veterinary practice.
The Industrial Revolution was extraordinarily successful in exponentially raising the standard of living and extending life expectancy. I've emphasised the point before, but the historical past was a living hellscape. Truly fucking awful to levels we might struggle to comprehend. Infant mortality levels where, even as recently as the Victorian era, 1-in-3 - moving to 1-in-2 or 50% for the inner city slums - children never made it to the age of 5. Disease and pandemics were a constant feature. Without modern medicine, vast numbers of folks condemned to be crippled or in pain for all of their short lives. Slavery, the perpetual subsistence farming of serfdom - the guarantee of living under some god-awful tyranny.
But, yet, for all this tremendous success, we do have to acknowledge William Blake's "dark satanic mills". Because, yup, the big cock-up of all this tremendous progress - which, you know, also afforded humanity enough space to abolish slavery and improve civil rights, through women's rights and, more recently, gay rights and beyond, as the economic advantage permits the social progress to occur, when we have time and space to deal with this, and don't have to impose "baby factory" religious ethics on everything to keep raising the population to fight against the awful infant mortality rates.
(For those who ain't noticed, all of God's sexual "morals"? All focused on "go forth and multiply". In keeping the population numbers up. Gays don't naturally increase the population - abomination! Women having a mind of their own? Can't afford that, as they need to be constantly pumping out babies. In antiquity, when your "city" was only thousands of people and your neighbours were war-like conquerors - themselves worried about also going extinct, so driven to conquer to survive - then population numbers mattered to keep your culture alive. The Abrahamic God is not alone in this message of "produce more babies", as every culture needed its armies - it's cannon fodder - to keep existing.
The story of Onan is often held up as "God does not want you masturbating" - or "onanism" as it's also alternatively called - but, if you read it, then what's actually going on is that Onan's brother dies. And, in that culture, there's the notion that Onan must now take his brother's wife as his wife, and complete the "duty" to impregnate her. He must take his brother's wife and carry on the baby-making process. Such was this notion of keeping the population numbers up in antiquity, that's how it worked. If a "soldier" falls, then his brother has to do "double duty" and now make babies with both his own wife and his brother's wife. We can also note, yes, that there's nothing in this about seeing if his brother's wife actually wants to do this - that's not a consideration, because women having opinions of their own could lead to them saying "no" and making babies is more important than worrying about their consent to do so.
Onan's terrible "sin" in the eyes of God is that, yup, he takes on his brother's wife and has sex with her. But then, at the last minute, he pulls out and "spills his seed" on the ground. So he's just enjoying the sex and avoiding the baby making. And that's his terrible "sin" before God. The story itself is not actually about masturbation - that's just an extension of the idea of "don't spill your seed". Like, such is the cultural drive for baby-making here, there's the notion that God wants every ejaculation to be impregnating someone or you're doing it wrong.)
In fact, I could point to the fact that such mad notions even exist in the historical past itself points to what a living hell it all was. This, somehow, all made perfect sense back then, as reasonable behaviour. Indeed, it was necessary for cultural survival. Natural disasters and diseases happened - you had to be actively fighting against extinction to win, it was not sufficient to just let it all happen naturally.
Now, moving onto environmentalism, you probably all know that I have an interest in this myself, with my "future of energy" thread and advocacy of renewables and batteries and such.
But I don't blame humanity for it all. At least, my beef is that we do now know better and we should raise our game to meet the challenge. But I totally see how we ended up in this shit hole of a problem in the first place, and it was not any "inherent evil" involved.
As mentioned, the first cars were electric vehicles, before the internal combustion engine showed up. More over, as I've pointed out, where the electric motors is often 90+% efficient - basically, as efficient as entropy allows anything to be - the internal combustion engine is, at its very best, nudging on only 30% efficient. Most of the fuel - over 70% - you pay for doesn't actually go towards the forward motion of your vehicle. This is horridly inefficient.
But, ah, the wonder of fossil fuels is that they have such immense energy density, that even when you're throwing most of it away - and, in any application that's not heating, that is exactly what you're always doing - we can all still easily power massive vehicles, weighing several tons, to 90mph down the motorway for hundreds and hundreds of miles, no problem.
The energy density of fossil fuels is insane, basically. And that's why, upon the discovery of this amazing "shortcut", it came to dominate absolutely everything. And, of course, a very useful facet of fossil fuels over solar or wind or hydro is that you can burn it any time you like. No need to worry about energy storage or intermittent power sources. Whenever you need it, just throw another lump of coal on the fire.
Slight problem. This release CO2 into the atmosphere. And because there's 8 billion of us now - yeah, there's no longer any "baby-making" problems anymore (quite the opposite) - then we're pumping out this shit at a rate that cannot be sustained. I mean, quite literally. It's all going to run out within decades. Which is one of my primary points about going renewable - we're soon going to have zero choices in the matter anyway, so getting out ahead on this, ensures the tech and infrastructure is good enough for when that happens.
Whilst I have immense disappointment in the reaction of the fossil fuel industry - because they realised what they were doing decades before it became public, and just like the tobacco industry, reacted by just spending billions upon billions in keeping it quiet, inventing a "debate" that does not scientifically exist, pay for the bullshit headlines about EVs you're seeing in the Murdoch newspapers recently and bribing politicians to do their bidding - I can't be disappointed in the general human reaction.
Because, as these issues have come to public light, we have folks happily recycling. We have Extinction Rebellion and Insulate Britain. We've had stupid Hollywood movies ("the Day after Tomorrow") and good ones, satirising our stupidity, like "Don't Look Up".
Most people, most of the time, are totally on board with fixing this problem. If we could have a global referendum and the result of the vote was instantly and fully implemented, the problem would be over and done with already. Unfortunately, the fossil fuel industry has immense money and it's still in its "deny, deny, deny" mode - like the tobacco industry - to concerned for maintaining its gravy train, and they really do have all the politicians bought and paid for.
Indeed, the amount of money that these parasites are unnecessarily stealing from us, you'll be amazed at just how rich the whole planet could get when we're all getting a big chunk of our energy from the cheapest sources - of solar and wind - for free. Our economy is down the toilet bowl, because we're clinging onto an ever-more-expensive dead-end technology that's dying right in front of us.
The pandemic started the problem, because fossil fuels are a physical thing that needs to be transported around, so closing all the world's borders and stopping people moving around had a serious impact (meanwhile, in the solar and wind farms, absolutely nothing happened). Then Putin's war has sent shit stratospheric, as he made the supply problems worse, not least because Russia supplies a lot of Europe's gas and oil. This is causing the "cost of living" crisis. And because the cost of living is now through the roof, that's why there's all these NHS and transport strikes, as folks really do need wage increases to avoid their lives get so much more horribly worse.
Ergo, as I say, if we'd all started going solar and wind back in the '90s - when there was popular mainstream consensus in the public that something needed to be done and, therefore, we can imagine that the politicians actually listened, rather than took their fossil fuel bribes, to really do something useful - then there not only wouldn't be a cost of living crisis right now, there couldn't be one (at least caused by energy costs) ever again.
It ain't just cheaper. It's more economically stable. The Sun rises and sets every day. The tides go in and out twice a day. We can come back to this in a few million years, and those statements will still remain true. Basing your economy on a stable reality like that will avoid it "boom and bust"-ing every 2 seconds.
Humans are not "inherent evil". The fact that there's even the question asked actually proves that couldn't be the case. We do have the solutions and most people, most of the time, absolutely want to pursue them post-haste.
There's a broken logic to "the planet would be better off without us". Sure, I won't dispute that, on a certain level, that's not untrue. But what would be the fucking point of a "perfect planet" - and I quote that, because, of course, nature is "red in tooth and claw", not actually perfect loveliness, if you actually pay attention - if there's no sufficient self-aware creature left to appreciate it?
It's a bit like this. I know how to create a 100% perfect crime-free Utopia. All we have to do is kill off all the human beings. No human beings, no crime. Cool. Except, of course, the rather massive problem that what's the point of your crime-free Utopia, if there's no-one left to enjoy it? And, heck, we're bending our notions of "crime" here, as it's not as if animals won't be murdering each other to eat and survive. It's only "crime-free" in the sense that human law only allows humans to be guilty of crimes. There's still plenty of sheer fucking evil going on. Indeed, truth is, humans are the ones who impose some kind of order and standards to try to reduce the amount of evil that's naturally going on.
It's a dumb solution. It doesn't make any sense, if you think about it.
You can simplistically say "humans commit crime" Therefore, no humans and there's no crime. Therefore, commit genocide of all humans. Well, you've clearly gone wrong there, as you've somehow rationalised that committing THE WORST CRIME IMAGINABLE - mass-murdering everyone on the planet - is morally good.
As I say, there isn't really such things as "evil". It's not, like, an actual physical entity that's going around "infecting" people to do bad. It's people having these horrid misunderstandings of reality that fool them into thinking that doing absolutely the wrong thing is actually doing the right thing. And then, filled with conviction that, say, killing off all the prostitutes will restore the moral fibre of society, you've just convinced yourself into becoming Jack the Ripper and you're now a serial killer. Or you're so filled with love for God that you've flown a plane into a building and murdered thousands of people... for what's actually no good reason whatsoever, as you've actually done nothing to help anyone there. You've just killed people and the world didn't improve a single inch, did it? Actually, it got vastly worse there for a while. Then it returned to "business as usual". Which it will always do, you stupid idiot.
But, yes, there's totally this strange quirk in the human psyche.
A big ironic quirk of "perfectionism" that we grossly over-self-flagellate over our faults and mistakes, telling ourselves how fucking "evil" and "guilty" we are, often to the point of almost suicidal fatalism where we're convincing ourselves that genocide - wiping out all of humanity - would actually be a better result.
Which is oozing with irony, because if we were "inherent evil" then we wouldn't care. The fact we beat ourselves up about this constantly proves it's just not true. We are capable of evil, sure, but we are not inherently so - because if it were inherent, then it wouldn't be in our nature to be so reviled and self-flagellating about such evil, when it does happen. The fact we even ask the question proves that it's not actually true.
There's a thing in English. We say "I am right". The auxiliary verb is "to be" - am, is, etc. - and this creates the notion that people are inherently good or bad. In their very being.
But, in German, the auxiliary verb is "to have". You say "Ich habe recht", "du hast recht", "sie haben recht", etc. and I prefer that way of thinking. That "right" and "wrong" is not a thing you are, in your being. It's an external object that you can possess or not possess.
You are just you. Not inherently anything. But if you pick up "the right thing to do" - an external object that you can possess - then "you have right". It is currently in your possession. And note that, by this model, you could also temporarily lose possession of "right" - you had right for this and you had right for that but, ah, you've not picked up "right" for this one, I'm afraid. Possession is inherently a temporary concept.
Whereas, the phrase "I am right" is suggesting that you are not only right in your very being, but it's implicitly going on to suggest that, as a state of being, you're always right about everything. All the time, forever more. "I am right" also lacks a temporal component. It's not "I am right, temporally in this moment, about this one subject", it's implying that "right" is like a permanent state of being.
I mean, don't get me wrong. Germans also make these same mistakes - after all, there's that very big obvious example of the Germans getting it most horribly wrong, like no-one else has ever done before or since - so, sure, the theory of "linguistical determinism" is far from the whole story.
But it helps to see things from a different perspective - try using "to have" as the auxiliary verb for "right" and "wrong" for a while, to try out this different way of thinking - to help spot where you're assuming things that actually shouldn't really be automatically assumed at all.
Indeed, it has been shown, in the research, that bilingualism strengthens a broad range of cognitive capabilities, as you inherently carry around more than one way of looking at things.
But, yeah, humans are not "inherent evil" and it really wouldn't help anything to wipe us out.
Because, after all, if we're not around, who's the beneficiary here?
And, indeed, there's absolutely no guarantees that evolution would conjure up a new intelligent species - it took most of 4.5 billion years to get to us in the first place (and if it takes that long again, then the Sun will have killed off this planet before then, so it wouldn't happen) - and there's nothing that prevents them being just as bad, or even worse, than us.
Though the inherent racism of Star Trek annoys me sometimes - Picard lecturing aliens about humanity, and Spock is totally racist about humans all the time (which is self-hatred, considering he's half-human - indeed, some other Vulcans seem to have much less of a problem with humans, so one wonders if this self-hatred is just Spock's own identity crisis) - it might be actually true that all the other aliens out there are violent or greedy bastards, and it turns out we're actually among the best of them.
We might actually be the best that the universe has ever thrown up, for all we know. Indeed, right now, we don't know that we're not the ONLY thing that the universe has thrown up and there are no other intelligent beings of our calibre out there at all. Or, indeed, as Brian Cox has argued, the statistics might mean that, on average, there's maybe only one or two intelligent species per galaxy, say - and, as I've covered before, galaxies and the universe is so vast, this effectively means we're on our own, because - short of "stargate" wormholes everywhere - you're not getting to another galaxy in any reasonable time, even with x1000 lightspeed FTL drives.
Indeed, I do find it ironic. We're so hard on ourselves, as a general rule, because we have a conscience and want to get things right. We hold ourselves to an unattainable perfectionism, and then start whipping ourselves on the back for our comparatively trivial failings to reach the impossible standard.
That, to me, is absolutely NOT an "inherently evil" being. Not at all. Quite the opposite. it's an imperfect being, full of regrets, trying its damnedest to be better and being far too hard on itself when it fails to quite live up to that.
I'm a humanist and that pretty much explains why, and how I see humans. And, indeed, part of my humanism is an acceptance that humans are not, and cannot be, perfect. I consider "the Human Condition" and "to err is to be human" as all part and parcel of what it is to be human.
Like, Neil Armstrong landing on the Moon. His scripted line was actually "One small step for A man, one giant leap for mankind". At the most significant historical moment for humanity, after such immense effort to get to the Moon, he fucks it up.
(Actually, fair play to NASA, that's their footage and they actually do acknowledge the mistake in the subtitles, as it has "one small step for [a] man" written there. I do also like the long pause. Like Neil says "one small step for man, one..." and there's an awkward pause, as he just realises he said it wrong. But then, ah, fuck it, it's too late now. And he just finishes it off.
Close enough. That'll do.
And that's my understanding of humans and humanism. At the height of our achievement, we slightly screw up the historical scripted line. In the words of Sting, "that's my soul up there" in that awkward pause by Neil, as he realises he messed it up. But, also, you know, fuck it, he's standing on the Moon. Don't get so hung up on the fluffed line, while you're actually standing on Earth's satellite that took such immense ingenuity and effort to reach. Like, don't sweat the small stuff. Focus on the bit that matters.)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Are anti-survivalists a big thing?
Regards capitalism vs. communism, as I've covered before, I'm a "third way" kind of person and think that the real point is reaching a Star Trek "Age of Abundance" where such shit no longer even matters.
I feel that public services would actually remain safer not in government or corporate hands, but in "not-for-profit" community hands.
I've given the example before, but the system that the NHS was modelled after was from the Miners hospitals.
It's become a NHS facility now, appropriately enough, but here's "Caerphilly District Miners Hospital":

Coal mining is a dangerous job. Even more so back then.
And, in the early Industrial Revolution, there were no health and safety laws, there were no employment laws. Basically, a worker was on their own.
If an accident happened in the mine and left you unable to work then, sorry, no compensation. You can't work? Then you've lost your job. Because no employment laws or tribunals. You were killed? Ah, well, your family is now fucked.
Neither the corporate employer nor the State gave a fuck back then. These coal miners were on their own, in a dangerous job that injured and killed lots of them, and was always gradually eroding their physical health, as it's not a reasonable working environment, really, for human beings.
And the miners did something remarkable. They got together and contributed a small amount, from their pay packet, to a collective fund and then raised enough to buy a hospital, like the building you see in the picture. And, from their contributions, they hired doctors and nurses and filled the building with medical equipment.
Because all of the miners actually collectively owned the hospital - they were all "part-owners" in this enterprise - then they (and their families) could, of course, make use of the hospital "free at the point of use".
No-one was helping them, so the miners helped themselves.
And, of course, Aneurin Bevan - the founder of the NHS - was a Welshman who grew up seeing these "miners hospital" buildings. He was familiar with this system and rightly thought "everyone should have this".
Then used the power of the State - as Labour were in power - to make that happen, setting up the NHS. Following a similar idea that folks make "contributions" from their pay to fund hospitals, doctors, nurses, medical equipment that then anyone can make use of, "free at the point of use". Because, well, you collectively own that hospital, you collectively pay the doctors' and nurses' wages.
Thing is, we see the problem with the State running it. Because "the State" is now the Tories, who hate the idea of the plebs running things for their own benefit, where there's no profit for them to be lording it over the riff-raff. So the Tories are running the NHS into the ground, just waiting for it to collapse sufficiently that they can sell it all off to the Americans.
If we still had the worker-owned Miners Hospital system - a not-for-profit community-run system - then it'd be safe from both corporate greed and Tory ideology.
Because "sorry, this is a privately-owned business and, so long as we obey the law, then the State has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with us. Please go away".
But, you know, it's a not-for-profit business. It's people owning their own hospitals for their own treatment. They run it for their own benefit. Indeed, they are both the owners and the patrons of this hospital, if they put up prices for profit, then they're just pointlessly paying more in contributions. It just doesn't make sense under this system.
This is a bit of a Welsh thing.
Because, when the government privatised water supply, Wales has "Welsh Water / Dwr Cymru" that is run as a not-for-profit public service. In England, water supply pricing has been going up, but Welsh Water isn't there to make a profit and any profit should all go back into running the system (not that prices haven't gone up, but that's because things are costing more in this "cost of living" crisis, with energy costs, not because some rich bastard wants a new Bugatti or a pony for their daughter).
And then there's the story of Tower colliery. As we all know, Maggie wanted to smash the unions and shut down the coal mines.
The Coal Board declared Tower Colliery to be "unprofitable" and shut it down. But the coal miners took their redundancy pay and collectively bought the mine.
In fairness, John Redwood has said that the reason he supported letting the miners buy the coal mine was that he was suspicious that the Coal Board was talking nonsense about profitability, and also there is - ironically enough - some Conservative ideology to the idea of the workers "lifting themselves up by their own bootstraps" and becoming entrepreneurial owners of their own businesses.
(This is also why I consider this sort of thing to be a "third way" in the middle, because while you can see the workers taking collective action is "socialism", you can also see them becoming self-employed business owners of a privately-run business to be very "Tory" as well. Redwood was happy to let them try, ironically enough, because he's a Tory and seemingly is one of the few who isn't lying when they say that they believe in conservative ideology.)
Tower Colliery was owned by all the workers. They had democratic meetings and voted on the big decisions.
The pit was able to make a profit - despite what the Coal Board had said - every single year of its operation (even when there was a quite expensive mine collapse, at one point, that needed to be dealt with). The only reason it closed, by the way, was because the coal seam itself run out. No more to be mined there.
So, personally, I'm not waving any flags for nationalisation or privatisation. I would rather see public services all go towards this employee-owned not-for-profit model. The community would collectively own its own water supply, energy supply, run its own hospitals, etc. for its own benefit.
It'd be safe from corporate greed AND state control - as the owners are the customers, and the customers are the owners - because we can see the problem of nationalisation with the NHS. It won't always be Labour in power, and when the Tories (or Blair's "pseudo-Tories") gain control, they'll deliberately run it into the ground and sell it off. For profit.
Decentralise it all.
Homes with solar panels and batteries, looking after their own needs. Hooked into community grids, where collectively-owned wind turbines and tidal lagoons supplement the solar. Maybe some geothermal heating for the area (re-using one of those abandoned coal mines, perhaps). Not-for-profit energy. Not-for-profit water supply. Not-for-profit local bus travel (which can be electric buses, so they can be renewably powered at the depot - so cheap fares because there's no fuel costs and it's all not-for-profit, so you're being charged enough to pay for it all and pay the bus driver wagegs, but no more than that).
We have the technologies and capabilities to reasonably do this sort of thing now. We should move to a decentralised not-for-profit model and remove the artificial "throttling" of resources. Because the for-profit corporations are all quite deliberately about throttling supply off, charging by usage and extracting the most profit out of it all.
Basically, as we have "closed source" and "open source" in software, let's move towards "open source" public services. Not-for-profit collective community ownership of the public services that that community needs. And because it's the community running its own services, then it'll always naturally be serving its community first and foremost. That's its only interest. And there is no profiteering, because if you raise prices then that just means you pay more contributions - why would you want that? - which you get back anyway - so what's the point?
But these are privately-owned businesses, in a legal sense, so if the Tories want to run it down or sell it off, they can fuck off. Nothing to do with the State. Privately-run business. Go away.
Local public services for local people.
I'm dubious of both capitalism - I mean, right now, all of us can see why, as it's not doing a very good job, is it? - but also of communism. And our communist advocates will no doubt remind us, not incorrectly, that no actual real world implementation of communism was "real communism". But, come on, that's a touch of "no true Scotsman", isn't it? And, well, sorry, but that's a logistical problem unto itself. There's no point having this perfect ideal Marxist theory, if no-one is ever able to actually make it work in the real world. So the fact that, yes, no-one's ever truly implemented communism properly is true but that is a problem in itself, if it seemingly can't actually be done for real anywhere.
(And, of course, another counter-argument is that capitalism has never really been implemented properly either. Even in America and the UK, there are anti-trust and monopoly authorities, there are taxes to pay for public services. There's welfare systems. Yes, communism has never been properly implemented. But, equally, neither has out-and-out "dog eat dog" capitalism either. Though, granted, right now it feels like the capitalists are trying real hard to do so.)
So I'm all for this "third way", which is not-for-profit community-owned services. Decentralisation, so it's out of the hands of governments and corrupt politicians, with communities running their services for their own benefit. A solution moving towards "the Age of Abundance", with resilience and economic stability built-in.
Like the Internet, no-one "owns" it. We all collectively contribute our own little bits to it, and "share the wealth" between us.
We previously built things big because that was the only way to feasibly do it. But with renewables, ubiquitous computing, automation and AI, we can begin to decentralise the whole thing and do everything more and more locally. For the benefit of that community. Of the people, for the people.
You get the gist. We can actually now start moving away from the big corporate model, with large centralised governments, and have more localism, more direct democracy. And the additional beauty of it of all is that this moves us further and further away from tyranny ever being possible.
Towards an "Age of Abundance" / "Age of Automation" where we're moving towards that Star Trek "no money" future. As Picard said, these community-run not-for-profits are not about making money, they're about being the best that we can be, for our own mutual benefit. Cheaper the better.
I mean, I'm a pragmatist at heart and not naive that this'll all magically happen, without any major problems or even the odd catastrophe, and it will definitely need to be fought for, against the old people with their old force-of-habit ways ("new ideas do not succeed - they just wait for the old ways to die"). But it's all now becoming very much technologically possible, and I feel, socially, it's what most humanity is crying out for. It can be made to work, and I feel we should endeavour to make it work.
I'd rather do it without needing to chop off any aristocratic heads, I stress, but I also cannot control the mob either, so I'd advise "the elites" to capitulate willingly - and find a new comfortable place for themselves - as, whatever I personally feel, the mob can be quite the "unstoppable force". As I challenge that Brutus was making no threats, just stating facts, I would also just say "Sic Semper Tyrannis" too, as a polite warning.
I feel that public services would actually remain safer not in government or corporate hands, but in "not-for-profit" community hands.
I've given the example before, but the system that the NHS was modelled after was from the Miners hospitals.
It's become a NHS facility now, appropriately enough, but here's "Caerphilly District Miners Hospital":

Coal mining is a dangerous job. Even more so back then.
And, in the early Industrial Revolution, there were no health and safety laws, there were no employment laws. Basically, a worker was on their own.
If an accident happened in the mine and left you unable to work then, sorry, no compensation. You can't work? Then you've lost your job. Because no employment laws or tribunals. You were killed? Ah, well, your family is now fucked.
Neither the corporate employer nor the State gave a fuck back then. These coal miners were on their own, in a dangerous job that injured and killed lots of them, and was always gradually eroding their physical health, as it's not a reasonable working environment, really, for human beings.
And the miners did something remarkable. They got together and contributed a small amount, from their pay packet, to a collective fund and then raised enough to buy a hospital, like the building you see in the picture. And, from their contributions, they hired doctors and nurses and filled the building with medical equipment.
Because all of the miners actually collectively owned the hospital - they were all "part-owners" in this enterprise - then they (and their families) could, of course, make use of the hospital "free at the point of use".
No-one was helping them, so the miners helped themselves.
And, of course, Aneurin Bevan - the founder of the NHS - was a Welshman who grew up seeing these "miners hospital" buildings. He was familiar with this system and rightly thought "everyone should have this".
Then used the power of the State - as Labour were in power - to make that happen, setting up the NHS. Following a similar idea that folks make "contributions" from their pay to fund hospitals, doctors, nurses, medical equipment that then anyone can make use of, "free at the point of use". Because, well, you collectively own that hospital, you collectively pay the doctors' and nurses' wages.
Thing is, we see the problem with the State running it. Because "the State" is now the Tories, who hate the idea of the plebs running things for their own benefit, where there's no profit for them to be lording it over the riff-raff. So the Tories are running the NHS into the ground, just waiting for it to collapse sufficiently that they can sell it all off to the Americans.
If we still had the worker-owned Miners Hospital system - a not-for-profit community-run system - then it'd be safe from both corporate greed and Tory ideology.
Because "sorry, this is a privately-owned business and, so long as we obey the law, then the State has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with us. Please go away".
But, you know, it's a not-for-profit business. It's people owning their own hospitals for their own treatment. They run it for their own benefit. Indeed, they are both the owners and the patrons of this hospital, if they put up prices for profit, then they're just pointlessly paying more in contributions. It just doesn't make sense under this system.
This is a bit of a Welsh thing.
Because, when the government privatised water supply, Wales has "Welsh Water / Dwr Cymru" that is run as a not-for-profit public service. In England, water supply pricing has been going up, but Welsh Water isn't there to make a profit and any profit should all go back into running the system (not that prices haven't gone up, but that's because things are costing more in this "cost of living" crisis, with energy costs, not because some rich bastard wants a new Bugatti or a pony for their daughter).
And then there's the story of Tower colliery. As we all know, Maggie wanted to smash the unions and shut down the coal mines.
The Coal Board declared Tower Colliery to be "unprofitable" and shut it down. But the coal miners took their redundancy pay and collectively bought the mine.
In fairness, John Redwood has said that the reason he supported letting the miners buy the coal mine was that he was suspicious that the Coal Board was talking nonsense about profitability, and also there is - ironically enough - some Conservative ideology to the idea of the workers "lifting themselves up by their own bootstraps" and becoming entrepreneurial owners of their own businesses.
(This is also why I consider this sort of thing to be a "third way" in the middle, because while you can see the workers taking collective action is "socialism", you can also see them becoming self-employed business owners of a privately-run business to be very "Tory" as well. Redwood was happy to let them try, ironically enough, because he's a Tory and seemingly is one of the few who isn't lying when they say that they believe in conservative ideology.)
Tower Colliery was owned by all the workers. They had democratic meetings and voted on the big decisions.
The pit was able to make a profit - despite what the Coal Board had said - every single year of its operation (even when there was a quite expensive mine collapse, at one point, that needed to be dealt with). The only reason it closed, by the way, was because the coal seam itself run out. No more to be mined there.
So, personally, I'm not waving any flags for nationalisation or privatisation. I would rather see public services all go towards this employee-owned not-for-profit model. The community would collectively own its own water supply, energy supply, run its own hospitals, etc. for its own benefit.
It'd be safe from corporate greed AND state control - as the owners are the customers, and the customers are the owners - because we can see the problem of nationalisation with the NHS. It won't always be Labour in power, and when the Tories (or Blair's "pseudo-Tories") gain control, they'll deliberately run it into the ground and sell it off. For profit.
Decentralise it all.
Homes with solar panels and batteries, looking after their own needs. Hooked into community grids, where collectively-owned wind turbines and tidal lagoons supplement the solar. Maybe some geothermal heating for the area (re-using one of those abandoned coal mines, perhaps). Not-for-profit energy. Not-for-profit water supply. Not-for-profit local bus travel (which can be electric buses, so they can be renewably powered at the depot - so cheap fares because there's no fuel costs and it's all not-for-profit, so you're being charged enough to pay for it all and pay the bus driver wagegs, but no more than that).
We have the technologies and capabilities to reasonably do this sort of thing now. We should move to a decentralised not-for-profit model and remove the artificial "throttling" of resources. Because the for-profit corporations are all quite deliberately about throttling supply off, charging by usage and extracting the most profit out of it all.
Basically, as we have "closed source" and "open source" in software, let's move towards "open source" public services. Not-for-profit collective community ownership of the public services that that community needs. And because it's the community running its own services, then it'll always naturally be serving its community first and foremost. That's its only interest. And there is no profiteering, because if you raise prices then that just means you pay more contributions - why would you want that? - which you get back anyway - so what's the point?
But these are privately-owned businesses, in a legal sense, so if the Tories want to run it down or sell it off, they can fuck off. Nothing to do with the State. Privately-run business. Go away.
Local public services for local people.
I'm dubious of both capitalism - I mean, right now, all of us can see why, as it's not doing a very good job, is it? - but also of communism. And our communist advocates will no doubt remind us, not incorrectly, that no actual real world implementation of communism was "real communism". But, come on, that's a touch of "no true Scotsman", isn't it? And, well, sorry, but that's a logistical problem unto itself. There's no point having this perfect ideal Marxist theory, if no-one is ever able to actually make it work in the real world. So the fact that, yes, no-one's ever truly implemented communism properly is true but that is a problem in itself, if it seemingly can't actually be done for real anywhere.
(And, of course, another counter-argument is that capitalism has never really been implemented properly either. Even in America and the UK, there are anti-trust and monopoly authorities, there are taxes to pay for public services. There's welfare systems. Yes, communism has never been properly implemented. But, equally, neither has out-and-out "dog eat dog" capitalism either. Though, granted, right now it feels like the capitalists are trying real hard to do so.)
So I'm all for this "third way", which is not-for-profit community-owned services. Decentralisation, so it's out of the hands of governments and corrupt politicians, with communities running their services for their own benefit. A solution moving towards "the Age of Abundance", with resilience and economic stability built-in.
Like the Internet, no-one "owns" it. We all collectively contribute our own little bits to it, and "share the wealth" between us.
We previously built things big because that was the only way to feasibly do it. But with renewables, ubiquitous computing, automation and AI, we can begin to decentralise the whole thing and do everything more and more locally. For the benefit of that community. Of the people, for the people.
You get the gist. We can actually now start moving away from the big corporate model, with large centralised governments, and have more localism, more direct democracy. And the additional beauty of it of all is that this moves us further and further away from tyranny ever being possible.
Towards an "Age of Abundance" / "Age of Automation" where we're moving towards that Star Trek "no money" future. As Picard said, these community-run not-for-profits are not about making money, they're about being the best that we can be, for our own mutual benefit. Cheaper the better.
I mean, I'm a pragmatist at heart and not naive that this'll all magically happen, without any major problems or even the odd catastrophe, and it will definitely need to be fought for, against the old people with their old force-of-habit ways ("new ideas do not succeed - they just wait for the old ways to die"). But it's all now becoming very much technologically possible, and I feel, socially, it's what most humanity is crying out for. It can be made to work, and I feel we should endeavour to make it work.
I'd rather do it without needing to chop off any aristocratic heads, I stress, but I also cannot control the mob either, so I'd advise "the elites" to capitulate willingly - and find a new comfortable place for themselves - as, whatever I personally feel, the mob can be quite the "unstoppable force". As I challenge that Brutus was making no threats, just stating facts, I would also just say "Sic Semper Tyrannis" too, as a polite warning.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Are anti-survivalists a big thing?
NO, has NOTHING TO DO with "religion" or "morale" .. it's PLAIN SIMPLE this factors :This is an interesting quirk of the human psyche.
We're forever beating ourselves up about our own failings, acting as if we're an inherently evil species, without noticing the obvious.
It's found in religions.
- fear
- greed
- will for "power" over others
- limited or non-exhistent empathy ( i.e. I don't care what my actions do on others as long as they benefit me ) i.e. selfishness
Overall "will to do whatever it takes for personal gain without considering too much the larger consequences of the actions as long as I can keep doing them in my own lifetime and guarantee ME all the benefits" ( i.e. it won't be my problem it will be somebody's else problem ).
If nothing else, I think, religions/morale TRY to "establish an order" to mitigate/avoid the overall "innate feelings" and avoid "the total collapse". If they succeed/is the best method that's up for debate.
I think even "experimentally" ( again we could discuss this ) in simulations/etc. without a "mana" ( moral / rules / bad consequences ) "the more asshole/selfish one acts, the more it gains" ( sure at the expense of destroying a lot but if resources are many compared to what the person really needs can keep working until its lifetime ) even if some other simulations seems to prove the contrary I am convinced that "is true".
And this "naturally brings" to "the law of the strongest" "the most evil" and such, and also "minimal effor maximal gain".
I am sure it's been scientifically proven that cause some genes some people ARE really "more evil inclined than others" or "more inclined to certain behaviours than other people" and that IS really genetic, that we as humans "with brain and will" we can "overcome such things" is a fact but I think it's also a fact that there are some "tendecies" that we can inherit in bad and good.
And then there's influence, education, society models, etc. .. all things that will shape "the way we think and feel and perceive" again in good and bad.
But yeah "natural instincts" have nothing to do with religion, they are there.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"


