Cloudane wrote:RTD has said he won't retcon the Timeless Child, as Chibnall is his friend.
Aye, I read that online as well.
Andrew Cartmel, though, hates it as a version of his "Cartmel Masterplan" because it does the opposite of his original intent - he wanted to bring mystery back to the character, but feels Chibnall has put in far too much detail and specifics, to have basically done the complete opposite.
https://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/andrew-ca ... -93918.htm
In fairness, in the right hands, you could make it work.
It's not so much the "not really a Gallifreyan, but some unknown alien from another universe, and that's actually where the Gallifreyans got their regeneration from" concept itself, but the very cack-handed "tell, don't show" way Chibnall just "info dumped" it on us all. Other than the Fugitive Doctor "hint" a few episodes earlier, it just all instantly appeared in a single episode, and was just spelt out to us by the Master.
No mystery, no gradual build up. Just "the Timelords are all dead and wiped out now, by the way. Oh, and the Doctor was never really a Timelord anyway". Just an instant "old canon is gone, here's the new canon" info dump.
Like, Moffat and RTD have had their faults too, of course. But they would have at least built up to this and written it better.
Indeed, having the Fugitive Doctor earlier in the series would tee it off perfectly. Like, having a new Doctor we've never seen before show up. And then establish that this is a previous Doctor, not a new one. Ooh, now there's a mystery. So Hartnell wasn't the first? The Brain of Morbius sequence is canon? Ooh, that's interesting.
Then you could have the Doctor be intrigued by this revelation in their past that they just can't remember, and then goes on a quest to work it all out. Go and visit the Timelords, and not get any straight answers but get hints that, hmm, this shit might actually be true and why are they so off with me for asking? And it can be revealed, hint by hint, until the final revelation.
For me, it's not so much the change of canon. It's the really shit way it was done. So, maybe in better hands, it can be made to work. We'll see.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes