So VR. A gimmick?
- MattyP
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2905
- Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2003 10:23 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: CypherQ
- PSN: CypherQ
- Location: Hull, East Yorkshire
So VR. A gimmick?
I notice Sony have having a firesale on PSVR2 at the moment and its down from £529 to £349.
Looks like they just can't sell them. I have both an Oculus for the PC and picked up a PSVR2 not so long back to play with the Sony tech and enjoy both however mostly find that the games that work best with it are the ones where you are sat in something? So Flight Slim, Gran Turismo etc work really well and give the illusion of being there however I think this is mostly a limit because of the current implementation of the tech perhaps?
Other things can be a bit fiddly with the controls and can sometimes frustrate when you run up against th boundaries of what you can do in a 3D world with the controllers.
Personally love it and think its the next evolution of gaming - especially as it offers a immersive 3D environment and have been hugely impressed with PSVR2 but VR doesn't seem to be doing that well in general - Oculus / Meta are loosing a lot of money as they keep ploughing funds into its devices and now Sony are clearly struggling with PSVR2.
So is this a gimmick in terms of gaming? Personally think the tech needs a few more cycles before it gets more adoption - smaller headsets, controllerless use, using hand tracking etc. I can seriously see where it can go but at this rate I can also see companies bailing on the tech at some point. I doubt Sony will invest anything into another iteration of VR now (might be wrong). Meta will keep pouring money in for a while.
Any views on VR? Do you use it regularly... Do you see it as the future of interactive entertainment? Or just another faddy gimmick? Will we ever get to a state like demonstrated in Ready Player One or Jonny Johnny Mnemonic etc? What I do think it needs is that killer app. One which makes people sit up and think I *need* this. I expect this might eventually come through Meta/FB where you'd have virtual catchups etc and will be driven by improvements in the tech. Still think we are at least 5-10 years away though.
Looks like they just can't sell them. I have both an Oculus for the PC and picked up a PSVR2 not so long back to play with the Sony tech and enjoy both however mostly find that the games that work best with it are the ones where you are sat in something? So Flight Slim, Gran Turismo etc work really well and give the illusion of being there however I think this is mostly a limit because of the current implementation of the tech perhaps?
Other things can be a bit fiddly with the controls and can sometimes frustrate when you run up against th boundaries of what you can do in a 3D world with the controllers.
Personally love it and think its the next evolution of gaming - especially as it offers a immersive 3D environment and have been hugely impressed with PSVR2 but VR doesn't seem to be doing that well in general - Oculus / Meta are loosing a lot of money as they keep ploughing funds into its devices and now Sony are clearly struggling with PSVR2.
So is this a gimmick in terms of gaming? Personally think the tech needs a few more cycles before it gets more adoption - smaller headsets, controllerless use, using hand tracking etc. I can seriously see where it can go but at this rate I can also see companies bailing on the tech at some point. I doubt Sony will invest anything into another iteration of VR now (might be wrong). Meta will keep pouring money in for a while.
Any views on VR? Do you use it regularly... Do you see it as the future of interactive entertainment? Or just another faddy gimmick? Will we ever get to a state like demonstrated in Ready Player One or Jonny Johnny Mnemonic etc? What I do think it needs is that killer app. One which makes people sit up and think I *need* this. I expect this might eventually come through Meta/FB where you'd have virtual catchups etc and will be driven by improvements in the tech. Still think we are at least 5-10 years away though.
A light that burns twice as bright burns half as long.
Steam/Xbox/PSN User Name: CypherQ
Switch - 8177-9514-5116
Steam/Xbox/PSN User Name: CypherQ
Switch - 8177-9514-5116
- Little stoned kiwi
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4597
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
- Location: Christchurch
Re: So VR. A gimmick?
VR has been 5-10 years away for 30 years. It's the nuclear fusion or string theory of the entertainment domain.
I think expectations is one of the biggest barriers. No, it won't be like Ready Player One, Snow Crash, Minority Report - they are impractical imaginations not unlike the screenshot of an Arch Linux user's desktop. People would get over flailing their arms around very quickly.
On a non-technical tangent, those imaginations also present an open-environment with emergent properties that can't come about in corporate walled garden.
I think expectations is one of the biggest barriers. No, it won't be like Ready Player One, Snow Crash, Minority Report - they are impractical imaginations not unlike the screenshot of an Arch Linux user's desktop. People would get over flailing their arms around very quickly.
On a non-technical tangent, those imaginations also present an open-environment with emergent properties that can't come about in corporate walled garden.
If they think you're crude, go technical; if they think you're technical, go crude. I'm a very technical boy.
- Deckard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10747
- Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 11:27 pm 0
- Location: Falmouth, Cornwall, UK
Re: So VR. A gimmick?
Yeah feels like flying cars to me and i cant imagine the games I like - old school twin stick shooters will ever not make me feel sick in VR so no worries for me !
Now with a new Mac Mini Pro so dont judge me !
Re: So VR. A gimmick?
VR has the same "problem" as keyboards and mice; you can order online, but you can't really test it properly without getting hands-on and seeing for yourself what you think of it. Monitors are probably in the same category.
And it has a second "problem"; it is a 'personal' item, not a sharing item, so people might be more hesitant to walk up and try one if they come across one. If there is a clerk demoing it and doing sanity wipes then you would probably jump at it, but how often will that be the case?
And it has a second "problem"; it is a 'personal' item, not a sharing item, so people might be more hesitant to walk up and try one if they come across one. If there is a clerk demoing it and doing sanity wipes then you would probably jump at it, but how often will that be the case?
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: So VR. A gimmick?
I suspect Sturmovik has killed combat flight sims. It's huge, wonderful, and has a good quarter of all the aircraft in WW2. It's also ten years out of date, it used to do Track IR but I don't think it can do VR.
There have been flight sims since, half of them with the il*2 name and better flight models, but with only five or six aircraft types they can't compete.
MS flight sim seems to have done something similar with transports, I dunno how or why, I prefer combat sims and never got into any version of MS FS.
There have been flight sims since, half of them with the il*2 name and better flight models, but with only five or six aircraft types they can't compete.
MS flight sim seems to have done something similar with transports, I dunno how or why, I prefer combat sims and never got into any version of MS FS.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: So VR. A gimmick?
I bought a DK2 back when that was a thing, and I've got access to a Quest 2 but I've never felt comprehend to spend much time in either.
It's cool to be able to step into another world, but I just don't find it a comfortable place to be. I get a little motion sickness (actually lots of motion discomfort) but also a feeling of worrisome isolation. It's not something I want to go back to.
It's cool to be able to step into another world, but I just don't find it a comfortable place to be. I get a little motion sickness (actually lots of motion discomfort) but also a feeling of worrisome isolation. It's not something I want to go back to.
Re: So VR. A gimmick?
The problem with VR is the same as what happened to 3D TV. Everyone is doing it wrong.
People try to do the obvious things from jump scares to over the top experiences "you can only get in VR".
What they should be doing is just using it for subtle enhancement. Not directly coding specifically for VR.
The game should be good standalone and enhanced by VR. Look at the LLamasoft titles in VR, good on desktop, great in VR. You don't have to own VR to get a good game but it is better if you do.
Designing with a too specific set of criteria leads to similar, shallow and not very long games. You will tire of them quickly.
People try to do the obvious things from jump scares to over the top experiences "you can only get in VR".
What they should be doing is just using it for subtle enhancement. Not directly coding specifically for VR.
The game should be good standalone and enhanced by VR. Look at the LLamasoft titles in VR, good on desktop, great in VR. You don't have to own VR to get a good game but it is better if you do.
Designing with a too specific set of criteria leads to similar, shallow and not very long games. You will tire of them quickly.
- MattyP
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2905
- Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2003 10:23 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: CypherQ
- PSN: CypherQ
- Location: Hull, East Yorkshire
Re: So VR. A gimmick?
Great points!
Think VR being a personal thing makes it a difficult sell - not many demo pods around and post COVID there is probably more reluctance.
Also absolutely about games been designed to be great game from the ground up and enhanced for VR - although saying that it depends on the game type some lend themselves better to non VR and when VR is shoe-horned in it doesn't really work that well. Some of the LLamasoft games are perfect use cases for VR - it was almost as if they were designed for VR before it became more accessible. I am finding the LS games are great in VR as are games like Rez Infinite.
Played through the demo of Resident Evil Village last night. Very immersive however the controls felt a bit clunky and fiddly at times so I was feeling I was fighting with those as well as trying to kill a monster. Controls for me are still the main stumbling block to a degree - you have complex controllers with buttons etc to control an environment that needs simple controls so it breaks the imersion a bit when you have to drop out at times to work out where buttons are - case in point are things like playing MS flight sim with a multibuttoned yoke. Its not easy to just look down at the stick to find a button mid game. Although the pass through cameras and ease of access on the PSVR2 make things a bit easier.
Also it does isolate from the real world a bit too much perhaps for some people. Quite enjoy the detachment for a bit to be honest. Really feels like you are in another space.
Glad Sony and Meta are still tinkering with consumer level tech though and it makes it accessible. Nice to have some tech that tries to move things along over a flat 2D screen that is really designed for 2D games.
Think VR being a personal thing makes it a difficult sell - not many demo pods around and post COVID there is probably more reluctance.
Also absolutely about games been designed to be great game from the ground up and enhanced for VR - although saying that it depends on the game type some lend themselves better to non VR and when VR is shoe-horned in it doesn't really work that well. Some of the LLamasoft games are perfect use cases for VR - it was almost as if they were designed for VR before it became more accessible. I am finding the LS games are great in VR as are games like Rez Infinite.
Played through the demo of Resident Evil Village last night. Very immersive however the controls felt a bit clunky and fiddly at times so I was feeling I was fighting with those as well as trying to kill a monster. Controls for me are still the main stumbling block to a degree - you have complex controllers with buttons etc to control an environment that needs simple controls so it breaks the imersion a bit when you have to drop out at times to work out where buttons are - case in point are things like playing MS flight sim with a multibuttoned yoke. Its not easy to just look down at the stick to find a button mid game. Although the pass through cameras and ease of access on the PSVR2 make things a bit easier.
Also it does isolate from the real world a bit too much perhaps for some people. Quite enjoy the detachment for a bit to be honest. Really feels like you are in another space.
Glad Sony and Meta are still tinkering with consumer level tech though and it makes it accessible. Nice to have some tech that tries to move things along over a flat 2D screen that is really designed for 2D games.
A light that burns twice as bright burns half as long.
Steam/Xbox/PSN User Name: CypherQ
Switch - 8177-9514-5116
Steam/Xbox/PSN User Name: CypherQ
Switch - 8177-9514-5116
- Little stoned kiwi
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4597
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
- Location: Christchurch
Re: So VR. A gimmick?
If they think you're crude, go technical; if they think you're technical, go crude. I'm a very technical boy.
- Misfit
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10449
- Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 2:43 pm 0
- Location: Nottingham UK
- Contact:
Re: So VR. A gimmick?
Went to see Deadpool at the cinema on Sunday and was very surprised to see a Meta Quest advert.
Not surprised they were advertising it, but how they were. A young woman takes a ticket in a waiting room and it's a long wait, so she sits down, pulls out her Quest 3 and fires up Netflix to pass the time.
Obviously, this is bollocks and shows all the reasons VR doesn't work. Are you really going to sit in an open public place with a massive thing on your face and cut yourself off from everyone around you? Maybe in a controlled environment like a plane, but not the scenario shown. (Netflix had no passthrough last time I used it)
You can do the above much more discreetly today though, my Xreal AR specs connected to my phone only make me look slightly stupid and keep me in the room.
I use the Quest 3 a lot, fitness stuff and Walkabout golf with friends around the country is the main use. It's great and as long as the experiences are right then it has a lot to offer. I've sold a fair few Quests by showing people a few decent experiences, it is all about trying it.
A gimmick, but try the plank game and most people can't handle it. Even a lot of hardened VR users. It does show how effective things can be. Basically, you go up a skyscraper in a lift, it opens on the top floor and you are at the edge of the roof. Your task is to walk out the lift on a plank over the edge of the building. Sounds easy!
The mainstream needs the AR specs to merge with the VR headset, once we get the Quest in a pair of specs we have a hope of mainstream. It's coming, just taking it's time.
Not surprised they were advertising it, but how they were. A young woman takes a ticket in a waiting room and it's a long wait, so she sits down, pulls out her Quest 3 and fires up Netflix to pass the time.
Obviously, this is bollocks and shows all the reasons VR doesn't work. Are you really going to sit in an open public place with a massive thing on your face and cut yourself off from everyone around you? Maybe in a controlled environment like a plane, but not the scenario shown. (Netflix had no passthrough last time I used it)
You can do the above much more discreetly today though, my Xreal AR specs connected to my phone only make me look slightly stupid and keep me in the room.
I use the Quest 3 a lot, fitness stuff and Walkabout golf with friends around the country is the main use. It's great and as long as the experiences are right then it has a lot to offer. I've sold a fair few Quests by showing people a few decent experiences, it is all about trying it.
A gimmick, but try the plank game and most people can't handle it. Even a lot of hardened VR users. It does show how effective things can be. Basically, you go up a skyscraper in a lift, it opens on the top floor and you are at the edge of the roof. Your task is to walk out the lift on a plank over the edge of the building. Sounds easy!
The mainstream needs the AR specs to merge with the VR headset, once we get the Quest in a pair of specs we have a hope of mainstream. It's coming, just taking it's time.
- Misfit
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10449
- Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 2:43 pm 0
- Location: Nottingham UK
- Contact:
Re: So VR. A gimmick?
This was always going to happen. That's Pretty obvious if you can't even make me buy it!MattyP wrote:I notice Sony have having a firesale on PSVR2 at the moment and its down from £529 to £349.
Looks like they just can't sell them.
It's technically a great piece of kit, but you need a PS5 (yes I know that's obvious but it costs more than a standalone Quest), it did cost more than the console, and most importantly has minimal support to make you want it, plus it is wired so you need to be near your PS5, you can't underestimate the freedom of the wireless beauty of the Quest as you can use it anywhere. (I have very little space near my PS5)
- MattyP
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2905
- Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2003 10:23 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: CypherQ
- PSN: CypherQ
- Location: Hull, East Yorkshire
Re: So VR. A gimmick?
All good points and especially the tethering via.wire. I expect the Quest is good enough for most things however the PSVR2 with a PS5 driving it will have technically a better.experience however cost will certainly be the main issue for many.Misfit wrote:This was always going to happen. That's Pretty obvious if you can't even make me buy it!MattyP wrote:I notice Sony have having a firesale on PSVR2 at the moment and its down from £529 to £349.
Looks like they just can't sell them.![]()
It's technically a great piece of kit, but you need a PS5 (yes I know that's obvious but it costs more than a standalone Quest), it did cost more than the console, and most importantly has minimal support to make you want it, plus it is wired so you need to be near your PS5, you can't underestimate the freedom of the wireless beauty of the Quest as you can use it anywhere. (I have very little space near my PS5)
Saying all that PSVR2 is incredibly impressive for the the money even factoring in the PS5. Compared to say the Apple device or Valve Index (which needs a beefy PC) it's mid way between the Quest and those devices.
It will be interesting to see if the price drop has.any impact on what gets released in future. I do wonder if this is last attempt at consumer grade VR from Sony though.....
A light that burns twice as bright burns half as long.
Steam/Xbox/PSN User Name: CypherQ
Switch - 8177-9514-5116
Steam/Xbox/PSN User Name: CypherQ
Switch - 8177-9514-5116
- Misfit
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10449
- Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 2:43 pm 0
- Location: Nottingham UK
- Contact:
Re: So VR. A gimmick?
Absolutely right, it is impressive and good value and in our positions we can see that, just the public isn't ready for that kind of VR yet and there just isn't enough on the PS5 to sway them.MattyP wrote: All good points and especially the tethering via.wire. I expect the Quest is good enough for most things however the PSVR2 with a PS5 driving it will have technically a better.experience however cost will certainly be the main issue for many.
Saying all that PSVR2 is incredibly impressive for the the money even factoring in the PS5. Compared to say the Apple device or Valve Index (which needs a beefy PC) it's mid way between the Quest and those devices.
I'd pay that for one game if I wanted it enough, most people aren't that stupid!
You can obviously beat the Quest with a PS5 or good PC, but the Quest 3 is a good step up and like on the Switch, if the software is done well the raw power of the hardware isn't quite so important.
- MattyP
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2905
- Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2003 10:23 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: CypherQ
- PSN: CypherQ
- Location: Hull, East Yorkshire
Re: So VR. A gimmick?
Good point. Think the power race is probably less important than getting decent and fun content out there.... the more complex the games become the more expensive to develop and so longer to get out to market and make some money.Misfit wrote: You can obviously beat the Quest with a PS5 or good PC, but the Quest 3 is a good step up and like on the Switch, if the software is done well the raw power of the hardware isn't quite so important.
I guess even more so with fairly niche products like PSVR2 and Valve Index - the common baseline for VR is the Meta as its probably the most popular.
A light that burns twice as bright burns half as long.
Steam/Xbox/PSN User Name: CypherQ
Switch - 8177-9514-5116
Steam/Xbox/PSN User Name: CypherQ
Switch - 8177-9514-5116
Re: So VR. A gimmick?
NorthWay wrote:VR has the same "problem" as keyboards and mice; you can order online, but you can't really test it properly without getting hands-on and seeing for yourself what you think of it. Monitors are probably in the same category.
And it has a second "problem"; it is a 'personal' item, not a sharing item, so people might be more hesitant to walk up and try one if they come across one. If there is a clerk demoing it and doing sanity wipes then you would probably jump at it, but how often will that be the case?
Yeah, I've never seen one demoed in a shop so I never got to try it out, which, seeing what
they cost, has deterred me from taking the risk of buying one.
Also the puking factor is not a negligible shortcoming either.



