Ukraine updates
Re: Ukraine updates
Just a bit of trivia.
We were duly informed by our TV news last night that we are far from prepared for a nuclear war.
We only have 3 nuke protected bunkers and they are military.
Actually 2 of them happen to be in my municipality. They even showed the location of one them, like we didn't all know about.
They think we need to get better prepared for the future even though they also said that for the situation now we should be OK because we are are one of the (European) countries further away fm the Ukraine.
Ow, and coincidentally we already have a company making bunkers for private homes.
Note: there was some fm the 1950s and early 60s in the Bay Area. I saw one of them.
We were duly informed by our TV news last night that we are far from prepared for a nuclear war.
We only have 3 nuke protected bunkers and they are military.
Actually 2 of them happen to be in my municipality. They even showed the location of one them, like we didn't all know about.
They think we need to get better prepared for the future even though they also said that for the situation now we should be OK because we are are one of the (European) countries further away fm the Ukraine.
Ow, and coincidentally we already have a company making bunkers for private homes.
Note: there was some fm the 1950s and early 60s in the Bay Area. I saw one of them.
Re: Ukraine updates
There is no 'protecting' from a nuclear war. It guarantees the end of all modern society. The purpose of any nuclear "defensive" positions is to try to make time for your own nuclear resources to respond. If you don't have nuclear missiles yourself, there is absolutely zero purpose of any of it.
Re: Ukraine updates
The thing I don't get is that "Putin wants Ukraine" and if he nukes it then does he have some magic potion that makes the nuked areas habitable for Russians?
It seems totally counter-intuitive to me: If he wants it then he can't really nuke it to get any value from it?
It seems totally counter-intuitive to me: If he wants it then he can't really nuke it to get any value from it?
Re: Ukraine updates
Again, thinking of it in those terms is a domain error. Using nuclear weapons at all revolves around the considerations of the end of the world, not such trivialities.
Re: Ukraine updates
For you. Maybe not for people like Putin, who might see a dead world called Greater Russia as a better outcome that a living one without any Russia at all.Dio wrote:Again, thinking of it in those terms is a domain error. Using nuclear weapons at all revolves around the considerations of the end of the world, not such trivialities.
Re: Ukraine updates
That's not what Putin's doing here. He has no fear of external warfare. He has nuclear weapons. The safety of Russia itself is guaranteed. (As, ironically, was the safety of Ukraine, until they gave up their nuclear weapons; the one lesson everyone can write down from this is "nuclear weapons aren't optional". Any concept of nuclear non-proliferation or disarmament has regrettably been forever buried by this).
If you phrased it in terms of "Not wanting Russian speaking people on his border who can tell people inside his border that life without a dictator is better place than with one" then you might have at least some semblance of a point.
But either way, it's still not a counter to my response to NW': he said "what's the value of Ukraine after a nuclear war?" and I said "Nothing, along with the rest of the world" in reply.
If you phrased it in terms of "Not wanting Russian speaking people on his border who can tell people inside his border that life without a dictator is better place than with one" then you might have at least some semblance of a point.
But either way, it's still not a counter to my response to NW': he said "what's the value of Ukraine after a nuclear war?" and I said "Nothing, along with the rest of the world" in reply.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Ukraine updates
For five hundred years at a guess. Which is a very long time, but it's not forever.Dio wrote:There is no 'protecting' from a nuclear war. It guarantees the end of all modern society.
I believe humans would probably survive, but if not rats, cockroaches or ants almost certainly would. Earth the rock wouldn't even notice.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: Ukraine updates
Now that really doesn't make me feel any better, frankly.
- Little stoned kiwi
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4598
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
- Location: Christchurch
Re: Ukraine updates
If Russia loses badly, Putin has nothing to lose by nuking the Ukraine. The threat is enough to make his opponents prefer a statement.
If they think you're crude, go technical; if they think you're technical, go crude. I'm a very technical boy.
Re: Ukraine updates
https://www.twz.com/news-features/russi ... one-attack
Holy crap! As ever, its going to be a while before the true extent of the damage is known, but in footage of the attack at least one Tu-95 appears to lose a wing. Tu-95s are four engined turboprop heavy bombers dating back to the 50s, and as they were all built during the Soviet era, each one lost is literally irreplaceable.
Holy crap! As ever, its going to be a while before the true extent of the damage is known, but in footage of the attack at least one Tu-95 appears to lose a wing. Tu-95s are four engined turboprop heavy bombers dating back to the 50s, and as they were all built during the Soviet era, each one lost is literally irreplaceable.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: Ukraine updates
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/cr58e9yr2ezt
At this point I'm beginning to think Ukraine knows who the next Bond is, and they've hired them before Amazon could.
At this point I'm beginning to think Ukraine knows who the next Bond is, and they've hired them before Amazon could.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: Ukraine updates
So as I'm sure we all know, Russia recently sent some MiG-31s to poke NATO a bit in Estonian aerospace. And theres something I've noticed from the images released that doesn't seem to have been picked up on.
First, a little context for the non-aerosexuals. The MiG-31 is often described as a "fighter", but what it really is an "interceptor" - a slightly different beast. Its job is to either get somewhere fast and shoot down a threat from far away with long range air-to-air missiles, or pursue a threat at high speed and shoot it down with long range air-to-air missiles (the MiG-31 can be used for other roles, including recon, strike and suppressing air defences, but its primary design role was interceptor). Compared to other "fighters", its pretty fast but also not overly agile. Its a drag racer in a world largely made of track cars.
So what caught my eye is at least one of the MiG-31s, and probably all of them, were carrying only three short range air-to-air missiles under each wing (the MiG-31 has under-fuselage hardpoints for the bigger, long range missiles, but these can also be carried underwing). There could be a number of reasons for this; the prime one probably being that if a malfunction happened and a MiG-31 went down over NATO territory NATO wouldn't then acquires examples of the long range missiles.
But it does also mean that if Russia was expecting some kind of hostile response from NATO, other than sheer speed, the MiG-31 pilots would have had only limited means to defend themselves. Most NATO aircraft they would encounter would almost certainly be carrying longer-ranged missiles. The number carried is also a bit odd; it might suggest that theres some kind of supply issue for certain types of these missiles.
First, a little context for the non-aerosexuals. The MiG-31 is often described as a "fighter", but what it really is an "interceptor" - a slightly different beast. Its job is to either get somewhere fast and shoot down a threat from far away with long range air-to-air missiles, or pursue a threat at high speed and shoot it down with long range air-to-air missiles (the MiG-31 can be used for other roles, including recon, strike and suppressing air defences, but its primary design role was interceptor). Compared to other "fighters", its pretty fast but also not overly agile. Its a drag racer in a world largely made of track cars.
So what caught my eye is at least one of the MiG-31s, and probably all of them, were carrying only three short range air-to-air missiles under each wing (the MiG-31 has under-fuselage hardpoints for the bigger, long range missiles, but these can also be carried underwing). There could be a number of reasons for this; the prime one probably being that if a malfunction happened and a MiG-31 went down over NATO territory NATO wouldn't then acquires examples of the long range missiles.
But it does also mean that if Russia was expecting some kind of hostile response from NATO, other than sheer speed, the MiG-31 pilots would have had only limited means to defend themselves. Most NATO aircraft they would encounter would almost certainly be carrying longer-ranged missiles. The number carried is also a bit odd; it might suggest that theres some kind of supply issue for certain types of these missiles.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Ukraine updates
It's even more specialised than that, it was designed as an attempt to stop the Sr 71, never caught one, but probably flew over secret sites to keep Sr 71s away. With the Sr71 mothballed, it's a very fast, very high altitude plane with almost no competion. The 12 minute flight time was probably crossing Estonia by the longest possible straight line route.F-ZeroOne wrote:So as I'm sure we all know, Russia recently sent some MiG-31s to poke NATO a bit in Estonian aerospace. And theres something I've noticed from the images released that doesn't seem to have been picked up on.
The MiG-31 is often described as a "fighter", but what it really is an "interceptor" - a slightly different beast. Its job is to either get somewhere fast and shoot down a threat from far away with long range air-to-air missiles, or pursue a threat at high speed and shoot it down with long range air-to-air missiles (the MiG-31 can be used for other roles, including recon, strike and suppressing air defences, but its primary design role was interceptor). Compared to other "fighters", its pretty fast but also not overly agile. Its a drag racer in a world largely made of track cars.
There are photos? The Beeb used stock photos. It would be hard to get photos showing any details such as missiles at the height and speed they were probably flying.So what caught my eye is at least one of the MiG-31s, and probably all of them, were carrying only three short range air-to-air missiles under each wing.
Interception without advanced warning would be impossible, and with warning I'm not sure there's anything that could fly high enough. This flight doesn't mean anything at all, but a recurrence probably can't be stopped.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: Ukraine updates
The photos are I saw were the same ones as in this article (regards the BBC, the initial report they did used a photo of what I think was an inverted Su-27 (or variant), whilst captioning it as a MiG-31! They corrected it later):
https://en.defence-ua.com/news/photo_of ... 15889.html
The article also raises some of the same questions I did about the load-out.
The MiG-31s clearly weren't flying at the full extent of their capabilities, though its not entirely clear from the article if the photos were taken while they were still in Estonian airspace or not; for one thing, three Russian fighter jets heading in at Mach 2 plus and not responding to hails would probably would have sent even more alarm bells ringing at NATO. They were reportedly intercepted (perhaps "responded to" would be more accurate) by JAS39 Gripens, which while not exactly slow, don't have the same sheer engine power. However, they can carry Meteor missiles, which would level the playing field a fair bit if necessary.
https://en.defence-ua.com/news/photo_of ... 15889.html
The article also raises some of the same questions I did about the load-out.
The MiG-31s clearly weren't flying at the full extent of their capabilities, though its not entirely clear from the article if the photos were taken while they were still in Estonian airspace or not; for one thing, three Russian fighter jets heading in at Mach 2 plus and not responding to hails would probably would have sent even more alarm bells ringing at NATO. They were reportedly intercepted (perhaps "responded to" would be more accurate) by JAS39 Gripens, which while not exactly slow, don't have the same sheer engine power. However, they can carry Meteor missiles, which would level the playing field a fair bit if necessary.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: Ukraine updates
I know we can't. Because nukes.
But in his invasion of Ukraine, Putin's demonstrated just how weak the Russian army actually is.
Prior to the invasion, the world imagined that the Russian Federation's military strength was basically an extension of the former Soviet Union - which was a formidable force to be worried about - but he attempted a "Blitzkrieg" on Kiyv and his tanks got stuck in the mud and he had to abort.
(Tanks which Ukraine has captured since. They're ancient Soviet tech, that's been patched up weakly in the intervening decades and they're actually genuinely rusting. Like, Ukraine actually has these and they're on display for the public to view - they're not remotely in good shape, which is why they failed so miserably to even get to Kiyv in the first place, let alone contemplate taking that city.)
Putin clearly originally believed the same hype about the Russian army as everyone else did, prior to this invasion, to think he actually stood a chance of pulling off a "blitzkrieg" on Kyiv to take Ukraine in days. But he absolutely couldn't. Nowhere near. Had to retreat out embarrassment that the tanks couldn't even get to the city.
Three years of fighting and it's been pretty much a stalemate. Because this is the Goliath of Russia versus the David of Ukraine - there should, on paper, be no contest.
Russia's territorial gains mostly are in the Russian-friendly South where they actually welcome Russia's rule. And Russia is definitely trying - it's so blatantly just bombing civilians directly. Not even the pretence of anything less than "total war" against everyone. They're not holding back in the slightest. And even if he were holding back then after 3 years of being made to look stupid, he would have ordered them in to finish the job, to not look so embarrassingly pathetic - but, no, he can't do that, because Russia really, really, really is trying its best and holding nothing back. This is the extent of their capacity.
Putin made a horrendous mistake in invading Ukraine. He's shattered the myths and legends about Russian military strength and revealed to the world that the Russian army really isn't impressive in the slightest anymore.
They can't cope with Ukraine. The idea that they stand any chance whatsoever to take on a united NATO of 32 countries is laughable.
Be thankful for those nukes and that, yes, the West loves its children too. Or you'd be crushed without even blinking, based on your apparent conventional military strength.
Next time this happens, blow those Migs and drones out of the air. Set up a missile "wall" that instantly annihilates anything that crosses even a millimetre over the borders. And just speak the truth: "Come and have a go, if you think you're hard enough. We could wipe you out, without breaking a sweat".
Stop playing up to the obvious bullshit mythology. If Russia was a true threat, then it would have taken Ukraine in days, as originally planned. It's years later, and they've thrown everything at them, just to reach a standstill. There's no way they could pose NATO, united, any genuine threat, and certainly not at the same time as they're wasting all their resources to go nowhere in Ukraine.
We call your bluff, Mr. Putin. You're just a sad old man, with delusions of grandeur, who rudely discovered that the mighty Russian army was not mighty in the slightest, when it can't even take a de-fanged Ukraine.
Because, yes, in the interests of peace, Ukraine was "de-fanged" - it gave up its nuclear arsenal and other defences to appease Putin - and we asked them to disarm. A much smaller country, that gave up its defences in the interests of international relations and you still can't take it years later, even going full-on "total war" to just blanket bomb civilians and civilian infrastructure (which is a war crime).
It's the old joke: "Best to keep quiet and let people think you're a fool, than to open your mouth and remove all doubt". In invading Ukraine, we can see the actual truth of your conventional military strength and it's floundering badly on what's supposed to be the "easiest" target of your world domination plans.
We need to stop pandering to this tyrant. He's out of his depth and bluffing real badly here. He ain't got shit.
But in his invasion of Ukraine, Putin's demonstrated just how weak the Russian army actually is.
Prior to the invasion, the world imagined that the Russian Federation's military strength was basically an extension of the former Soviet Union - which was a formidable force to be worried about - but he attempted a "Blitzkrieg" on Kiyv and his tanks got stuck in the mud and he had to abort.
(Tanks which Ukraine has captured since. They're ancient Soviet tech, that's been patched up weakly in the intervening decades and they're actually genuinely rusting. Like, Ukraine actually has these and they're on display for the public to view - they're not remotely in good shape, which is why they failed so miserably to even get to Kiyv in the first place, let alone contemplate taking that city.)
Putin clearly originally believed the same hype about the Russian army as everyone else did, prior to this invasion, to think he actually stood a chance of pulling off a "blitzkrieg" on Kyiv to take Ukraine in days. But he absolutely couldn't. Nowhere near. Had to retreat out embarrassment that the tanks couldn't even get to the city.
Three years of fighting and it's been pretty much a stalemate. Because this is the Goliath of Russia versus the David of Ukraine - there should, on paper, be no contest.
Russia's territorial gains mostly are in the Russian-friendly South where they actually welcome Russia's rule. And Russia is definitely trying - it's so blatantly just bombing civilians directly. Not even the pretence of anything less than "total war" against everyone. They're not holding back in the slightest. And even if he were holding back then after 3 years of being made to look stupid, he would have ordered them in to finish the job, to not look so embarrassingly pathetic - but, no, he can't do that, because Russia really, really, really is trying its best and holding nothing back. This is the extent of their capacity.
Putin made a horrendous mistake in invading Ukraine. He's shattered the myths and legends about Russian military strength and revealed to the world that the Russian army really isn't impressive in the slightest anymore.
They can't cope with Ukraine. The idea that they stand any chance whatsoever to take on a united NATO of 32 countries is laughable.
Be thankful for those nukes and that, yes, the West loves its children too. Or you'd be crushed without even blinking, based on your apparent conventional military strength.
Next time this happens, blow those Migs and drones out of the air. Set up a missile "wall" that instantly annihilates anything that crosses even a millimetre over the borders. And just speak the truth: "Come and have a go, if you think you're hard enough. We could wipe you out, without breaking a sweat".
Stop playing up to the obvious bullshit mythology. If Russia was a true threat, then it would have taken Ukraine in days, as originally planned. It's years later, and they've thrown everything at them, just to reach a standstill. There's no way they could pose NATO, united, any genuine threat, and certainly not at the same time as they're wasting all their resources to go nowhere in Ukraine.
We call your bluff, Mr. Putin. You're just a sad old man, with delusions of grandeur, who rudely discovered that the mighty Russian army was not mighty in the slightest, when it can't even take a de-fanged Ukraine.
Because, yes, in the interests of peace, Ukraine was "de-fanged" - it gave up its nuclear arsenal and other defences to appease Putin - and we asked them to disarm. A much smaller country, that gave up its defences in the interests of international relations and you still can't take it years later, even going full-on "total war" to just blanket bomb civilians and civilian infrastructure (which is a war crime).
It's the old joke: "Best to keep quiet and let people think you're a fool, than to open your mouth and remove all doubt". In invading Ukraine, we can see the actual truth of your conventional military strength and it's floundering badly on what's supposed to be the "easiest" target of your world domination plans.
We need to stop pandering to this tyrant. He's out of his depth and bluffing real badly here. He ain't got shit.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes


