Gay?

Every now and then a Llamasoftie will say something interesting. Honestly! This is where we will keep these topics so that they don't get deleted.
User avatar
Yak
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 20266
Joined: Wed Apr 17, 2002 10:22 am 0
Location: Wales
Contact:

Post by Yak »

koworld wrote:
Yak wrote:I think "love at first sight" is basically a physiological response, some vestige left over from presentient times. Of course it can feel powerful (I speak theoretically here, having never been prone to such responses with humans) and it can lead to infatuation, which often *is* mistaken for "love". Which is not to say that such a state cannot lead to what Trolley so appropriately calls Unity - if the underlying informational congruences are there to back up the initial physiological response, then sure, it could happen. The danger of course is that people sometimes don't bother doing the necessary communication to establish that.
That's an interesting perspective but not one I share. I know the difference between infatuation, lust and love that grows, and love that is instant. I'm not saying that a deep instant love is indestrucable though. The forces you mention can break any realationship.
You simply have to consider how much information is acquired before the emotional response kicks in to identify the nature of what you are feeling. Mating in presentient times was almost entirely predicated on physical characteristics, and so when this occurs in humans it is overwhelmingly likely that it is that vestigial response at work. Certainly it may well be slightly elevated from that - after all we can work out quite a bit about someone's lifestyle and attitudes from how they present and comport themselves - but it is still purely an initial response which, without being backed up by the "due diligence" of deep communication, is too frail to sustain anything serious. And as I said, that initial response may well serve to effect a communication process that leads to Trolley's Unity - but it should be recognised for what it is.

We are, after all, primarily creatures of information, and physiological aspects change over time. It is only sensible therefore to base our relationships upon information exchange. And in an initial meeting there may well be the desire to communicate further - but it is that communication that makes the Unity; it does not pre-exist in the initial response.

\
(:-) - Yak
/
Justified and Ancient.
koworld
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13130
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2002 6:14 pm 0

Post by koworld »

Yak wrote: And as I said, that initial response may well serve to effect a communication process that leads to Trolley's Unity - but it should be recognised for what it is.
I still disagree. I'm convinced that 'love' is one of those areas of emotional response where neither logic, philosophy, neurology, or instinctive/physical criteria hold the answers. Its one of the gaps between understandings that provide places in this world for magic to live.

And I'm very content to remain convinced of that. I'd rather let the magic live than see the process reduced to numbers.
User avatar
Yak
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 20266
Joined: Wed Apr 17, 2002 10:22 am 0
Location: Wales
Contact:

Post by Yak »

koworld wrote:
Yak wrote: And as I said, that initial response may well serve to effect a communication process that leads to Trolley's Unity - but it should be recognised for what it is.
I still disagree. I'm convinced that 'love' is one of those areas of emotional response where neither logic, philosophy, neurology, or instinctive/physical criteria hold the answers. Its one of the gaps between understandings that provide places in this world for magic to live.
And I still believe that there is a potential world of hurt in declaring "love" on the basis of almost zero data, and I'll live by that :).

We must therefore agree to disagree on this one :).

\
(:-) - Yak
/
Justified and Ancient.
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Post by gilesgoat »

Bluey wrote: Ever get told by someone that they love you? and then not known what to do about it?
I dare to say that "is very simple", if someone says you that and
you don't know "what to do" you don't love him ...

I mean "love" for sure can't be a "monodirectional thing" or
an expression you simply "drop there" to someone.

It's a deep thing .. meaning a complete form of mutual understanding,
closeness, trustenss, same point of view in many aspects and .. the
need to be togheter ..

If you have "doubts", if you have things or something you maybe wished
to know/ask and you never did .. if to hear this word it seems to you
"I don't know what to do" ..

Well .. it's not "real" love ... maybe it would like to be but at the moment
it's not.

This 4 letters word is a terribly deep thing and .. I'd dare to say it's
a word that two persons should say each other together .. the same
time .. so .. this way it probably would mean "we both feel the same".
Bluey wrote: I have the same view on 'Love' - its something that takes time, you cannot possibly be completely 'in love' with someone unless you know them - and know them well.
Yes, it takes TIME to understand what/how the persons involved feel.

It's not only a matter of understanding "who is the person in front of
you and what you feel for him/her" .. it's also a matter of what *I*
feel for him/her .. sometime it's not clear and during this phase the
most important thing is honest and clear communication :)
Bluey wrote: Yet there have been times when I have felt something perhaps akin to 'love' - an overwhelming closeness or connection with someone, while
I didn't know them that well...
Closeness is a bit a different thing, we can feel closeness to someone
when we feel and see that someone is able to understand/accept
something of us that we maybe would like to speak/share with
someone else but that we are not able to ...

We look for some understanding ... and we are not able to find it
till we find someone able to.

This form of closeness is basically what I'd say a deep friendship, be
friends and be helpful, honest and caring of friends IS "closeness".

We feel bad when a friend feels bad, we wish to be helpful when we can,
we like to share moments of happiness and joy and sometime pain
too ...

We are close ..

Now .. I'd say that the difference between "closeness" and "love" is
that "love" is a closeness that applies in "every level/aspect of a person"
I mean when this kind of closeness is reciprocal and applies in what
are all the "basic life aspects" of a person.

Maybe ... it's easy and not easy anyway to say when closeness starts
to be something more than this but I am sure of one thing, so I believe,
while closeness can be felt among different persons, "love" "belongs"
only to two persons.

... and cannot be shared .. while closeness can :oops:

We need closeness sure otherwise our lives would be pretty much
"just us" .. and I think the good thing about closeness is that is really
a feeling that can be shown and understood among many people,
well .. maybe not so many .. maybe not with everybody at the same
level but it can be ...
Bluey wrote: But then, I think there's a distinction between loving someone and being in love with someone...
NO, here I disagree ...

Explain me what you mean then between "to love someone" and
"being in love" ... unless you are quoting two different meanings and
"misusing" the word "love" ...

In this way, I'd interpret it this way: "to love someone" = "I feel some
kind of affection for" ... "to be in love" = "love" (the "real" way) reciprocal
thing.

I'd say .. "better do not mix so 'easely' the two things .. "

There is a distinction .. can't be the same thing really ...

In my opinion and personally feelings, you can love or, to even
better say like Trolley says, feel Unity only for one person.

I can be wrong but that' how *I* feel ... and I can't understand/accept
different, but that's "my limit" I know :oops: not all the people think
like me.

Life is good also because we are all different, yet we can fit more or
less well together :wink:

(... and after said this he started to throw broken dishes and pots
to his/her mate ... *blam* *crash* *blam* ... :mrgreen: )

Last sentence is just silly I know :mrgreen: forgieve me :mrgreen: ...
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
koworld
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13130
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2002 6:14 pm 0

Post by koworld »

Yak wrote:
koworld wrote: And I still believe that there is a potential world of hurt in declaring "love" on the basis of almost zero data, and I'll live by that :).
Ahh, I see what you're getting at there. Well christ that's the key to all worthwhile human relationships, isn't it:

Initial risk.
User avatar
Bluey
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1713
Joined: Mon Mar 24, 2003 11:14 am 0
Location: Taunton

Post by Bluey »

koworld wrote: That's an interesting perspective but not one I share. I know the difference between infatuation, lust and love that grows, and love that is instant. I'm not saying that a deep instant love is indestrucable though. The forces you mention can break any realationship.

Not everything in life is down to the numbers. Sometimes magic just happens.
I do know what you mean - I believe what you've described has happened to me too - but (and I don't want to ruin any magic for you) the two times its happened to me its ended in tears... A part of me still 'loves' the people involved, but one I hope I never see again and the other remains a friend... I don't think emotions can be easilly explained, and everyone not only has different experiences regarding love, but also different perspectives/reflections and their own unique way of... 'feeling' them.

I'm glad you believe the magic - life would be so cold and calculated if everything could be explained...

*hugs*
Mmmm. Yes. Possibly.
User avatar
Jimaroid
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5146
Joined: Fri May 09, 2003 12:21 pm 0
Location: Dundee

Post by Jimaroid »

Yak wrote:
koworld wrote:
I still disagree. ...
...
We must therefore agree to disagree on this one :).
Sounds like the end of a lovers tiff to me. ;)
koworld
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13130
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2002 6:14 pm 0

Post by koworld »

Bluey wrote:
I do know what you mean - I believe what you've described has happened to me too - but (and I don't want to ruin any magic for you) the two times its happened to me its ended in tears...
Oh absolutely. But I'll bet the ride, while it was happening, made you feel alive? Love, adventure, hightened emotional states; all these things are pin-pricks to the soul.

It may well end in tears with me and Sarah, or we might be together for ever, either way this is something worth being a part of.

:D
User avatar
shobet_mawr
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2784
Joined: Thu Sep 12, 2002 9:34 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: huw1970
Location: Hiking in my Altix

Post by shobet_mawr »

Isn't love like a box of quality street?
Everybody likes the nice ones, but don't want the hard ones stuck to their teeth.
Or something like that

Anyway Image is gay
:dragon: Made in Wales! :dragon:

Beware SHOB the thread killer!

I'm fucking evil me, grrrr, see or teh EVIL see

P.S. I know where you live etc.
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Post by gravy »

koworld wrote:
Yak wrote: And as I said, that initial response may well serve to effect a communication process that leads to Trolley's Unity - but it should be recognised for what it is.
I still disagree. I'm convinced that 'love' is one of those areas of emotional response where neither logic, philosophy, neurology, or instinctive/physical criteria hold the answers. Its one of the gaps between understandings that provide places in this world for magic to live.

And I'm very content to remain convinced of that. I'd rather let the magic live than see the process reduced to numbers.
I'm with KW on this. Sometimes you just *know* and talking about it is just redcutive, a clumsy filter, like trying to explain nuclear physics through pottery.

Yak's right as well, you do need a lot of data to make that call but sometimes it can be incredibly high bandwidth and completely unspoken.

big hug to biscs :D :D :D
User avatar
Sickboy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13819
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 4:31 pm 0
Location: London

Post by Sickboy »

koworld wrote:
Bluey wrote:
I do know what you mean - I believe what you've described has happened to me too - but (and I don't want to ruin any magic for you) the two times its happened to me its ended in tears...
Oh absolutely. But I'll bet the ride, while it was happening, made you feel alive? Love, adventure, hightened emotional states; all these things are pin-pricks to the soul.

It may well end in tears with me and Sarah, or we might be together for ever, either way this is something worth being a part of.

:D
I had a mental time a few years ago where I was involved with three people for three different reasons (love, lust, bit of both). As you say (koworld), it was like living in a higher state - like a twisted version of The Diceman (as if there were three versions of me and my life was based on switching from one to another).

From a cowardly perspective, I was keeping my options open and having a damned good time - dismissing everyone else's feelings. All I really achieved was an increasing alienation from who the hell I really was and what exactly I was hoping to get out of it all.

Eventually, like some cheap film, the answer came from the place I least expected - and from someone who made me realise that the 'love' I thought I'd felt (and expressed) was just a strange form of inter-dependancy.

I guess there's also an ageing issue. It's your job when you're young and thrusting to sample as much fun and variety as possible - where the thrill of the risk is almost all of the thrill.

But, as I creep towards middle age, I'm glad that I did all of that once, and even gladder that I'm not still doing it.

There's a great quote from psychologist Adam Phillips - "At its best, monogamy may be the wish to find someone to die with. At worse, it's a cure for the terrors of aliveness. They are easily confused".

Well, that's love to me - whatever the flavour (first-sight, unrequited, monogamous, duplicitious, whatever), it makes you feel alive.
User avatar
shobet_mawr
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2784
Joined: Thu Sep 12, 2002 9:34 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: huw1970
Location: Hiking in my Altix

Post by shobet_mawr »

Alive it's alive

Image

Can I have my lolly now?
:dragon: Made in Wales! :dragon:

Beware SHOB the thread killer!

I'm fucking evil me, grrrr, see or teh EVIL see

P.S. I know where you live etc.
Dave
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8035
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 6:35 pm 0

Post by Dave »

Sorry these are images, but I need to delete them eventually. They are notes I had from a class. Obviously, you won't have the textbook. ;) But, it does help you form differences between different types of love:

Image

Image
Image

Image
Image
Image
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Post by gilesgoat »

Bluey wrote:
koworld wrote: That's an interesting perspective but not one I share. I know the difference between infatuation, lust and love that grows, and love that is instant. I'm not saying that a deep instant love is indestrucable though. The forces you mention can break any realationship.

Not everything in life is down to the numbers. Sometimes magic just happens.
I do know what you mean - I believe what you've described has happened to me too - but (and I don't want to ruin any magic for you) the two times its happened to me its ended in tears... A part of me still 'loves' the people involved, but one I hope I never see again and the other remains a friend... I don't think emotions can be easilly explained, and everyone not only has different experiences regarding love, but also different perspectives/reflections and their own unique way of... 'feeling' them.

I'm glad you believe the magic - life would be so cold and calculated if everything could be explained...

*hugs*
Well .. as Bluey says nodoby wants to spoil the magic and surely some
things maybe some time are "felt at instant" ...

Anyway, it's exactly here at this point where "time" and "talking"
enters in, to see exactly how/till which level some "instant feelings"
are really "inside".

I can tell you I had quite some experiences .. and one thing I learnt
from sure, there's a HUGE difference between "emotions felt" and
"a life togheter".

Some emotions can really be "instantly felt without prior knowledge"
because ... in some way or another we maybe start to feel them ..

BUT .. this is really not enough to build a life over it, not a last longing
life if emotions are not really "understood" and "explored".

I say this, because I passed myself throught situations where I was
feeling something thinking that the other was feeling the same about
me .. and because all this was "so good" and nobody wanted to spoil
this "magic" "living the moment" .. converstation was kept "at the
minimum required".

The moment, the feelings the emotions were "so good" that the FEAR
to loose all that was preventing the "real communication".

Well .. I tell you, this won't last forever ... as you feel emotions this
way for someone it may happen a day you, or the other one could
start feeling same kind of emotions for someone different and this
thing "start again" with someone other.

I'd say that life and especially "love" means to be able to look into
our fears and work them out ... and .. also be ready to know and
handle that something could really NOT work out.

That's the only way I think to find "the real thing", is not a matter of
"calculating/explaining the life" .. but is "to be honest" .. FIRST with
OURSELVES .. and if you really think you love someone then you
really OWE honesty .. so it's a "must" to understand and communicate
exactly what/how one feels.

That's my opinion ...

Koworld says "it does not matter how it could end, tears or sadness
all that is worth" ... hmmmmm ... that's *your* opinion ... does your
mate thinks the same about it ? ..

Are you sure you can really say is really worth ?

I'd say "it is" if you really been honest and you can honestly say
yourself "I tried to be/show what I am, it did not work because someone
other did not like much what I am" ..

So nobody can complain and there's no "fault" and no "bad" in no side.

Hey .. life is this too .. we can be "accepted" we can be not .. we can't
blame people that do not like us ..

But .. if you live in a dream and you know ...

When the dream ends, and could end bad too ... well .. sorry to say
... but "it's all your fault" ... :(

It's hard to accept I know, but to live means NOT to live inside dreams
when we start to realize that it's just a dream and not really more.

It's reasonable not to realize this ... is not reasonable when you start to
realize this and you don't want to accept it ...

*hugs* and best wishes to everybody of course :)
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Tmuk
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7598
Joined: Tue Apr 30, 2002 11:42 am 0
Location: London
Contact:

Post by Tmuk »

I'm not realy sure where I stand on love. When I was 19 I fell in love with a 22 year old girl, and she fell in love with me.
For a few weeks is felt amazing. I walked around like I was 10ft tall, and all I did was think about her. Then, suddenly it changed. The thought of being separated from her, of being dumped took over completely. For th next 4 months I was fucking terrified of how I would feel when we eventually split up. Did I want to spend the rest of my life with this girl? No. But did I want to split up? No. It was a terrifying situation for me and when she eventually left me for someone else (older, wiser, better looking presumably) it took me a year to get over her. I'd never felt pain like it.

So now, when I find myself seemingly starting a relationship with a lovely girl - beautiful, great fun, likes many of the things I like - I don't know what to do.
Do I let myself free-fall into the same old situation again or block out my emotions and finish it with her? Maybe it's my age. At 21, I'm suddenly an adult. If I look backwards, there's my childhood, not all that far away. Or I look forwards there's the great un-known...the possibility of being married with kids in less than a decade, which is a terrifying prospect, to be honest.

Love doesn't make much sense at the moment. I don't want to settle down yet so what would be the point of having any kind of emotional relationship with a girl? I suppose I'm just afraid of life running away with me and dumping me in a situation where I don't want to be...
Locked