Other DVD Players with VLM except Nuon?

My God...It's full of stars - Neon, Psychedelia, Colourspace, Trip-a-Tron and all flavours of VLM...
Post Reply
User avatar
Interceptor
Posts: 6
Joined: Sat Feb 28, 2004 2:53 pm 0

Other DVD Players with VLM except Nuon?

Post by Interceptor »

Are there other (good) DVD players with VLM functions except the Nuons?
Image
just my 2 cents
matt
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14826
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 4:07 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: gingerbeardman
PSN: wirehang
Location: here && there
Contact:

Post by matt »

Slight confusion here.

VLM2 capability requires the NUON chip. VLM1 is on the Atari Jaguar CD, VLM3+ within Unity.

So, what is your real question? ;)

matt
User avatar
overand
Posts: 9
Joined: Fri Feb 27, 2004 2:40 pm 0
Location: Northeast USA
Contact:

Post by overand »

I think his question is "Are there any other DVD players with integrated lightsynths."

I'd say that there probably aren't any non-DVD players with lightsynths that are worth it. The 3DO had an interesting lightsynth, that was decent for the time, and the demo CD that the 3DO came with had an app that let you interact with it, but I think the regular music-playing-lightsynth was essentailly non-interactive.

If you can't get a NUON player, your best bet is probably to go for any of the various PC lightsynths. I'm partial to AVS and Milkdrop within Winamp, but I'm sure some of the forum vets here have some other suggestions. =] Browse the lightsynths forum!
overand.com
quasi-experimental electronic music
User avatar
zbandito
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2916
Joined: Sat May 18, 2002 10:00 pm 0
Location: Portland, Oregon
Contact:

Post by zbandito »

milkdrop is great but afaik it's noninteractive. VLM3 on the cube will pretty much be the best lightsynth available when it is released. but of course the cube doesn't play DVD. but a cheap dvd player is like $30 if you wait for a sale price
User avatar
overand
Posts: 9
Joined: Fri Feb 27, 2004 2:40 pm 0
Location: Northeast USA
Contact:

Post by overand »

Milkdrop is noninteractive as far as I know as well. AVS however has some interactivity. Unfortunately, the 'beat detection' in AVS is fairly bad. For an interesting preset that has interactivity, check around for 'Don't Trip And Drive,' for AVS, from a back called i *think* 'final hack' fromt he Whacko AVS series by I THINK 'Uconed'. yep, this is right, at least partially:

http://www.acko.net

--edit--

I wouldn't even really call this much of a 'lightsynth' preset, I cite it simply because it showcases potential interactivity in AVS. Still not VLM though!
overand.com
quasi-experimental electronic music
User avatar
5th Earth
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2091
Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2004 12:51 am 0
Location: San Jose, California

Post by 5th Earth »

Milkdrop is as interactive as AVS, if not slightly more, in my experience. It's just that most people don't know how to interact with it--it's not as user-friendly. Dig out the documentation from the Winamp folder or the website. and you'll see. Heck, most people don't even know they can make their own presets in Milkdrop (and that it's not totally random).

I assume by interactivity you mean the usual trigger preset (with fade/hardcut), spawn sprite/text/image, and that sort of thing. Nothing like VLM control. If that's what you mean, I'd like to know how to do that in AVS myself 'cos I sure don't know how.
It seemed like a good idea at the time.
User avatar
overand
Posts: 9
Joined: Fri Feb 27, 2004 2:40 pm 0
Location: Northeast USA
Contact:

Post by overand »

No, by interactive I mean that you can control what's on-screen using the mouse. The "Don't Trip And Drive" preset lets you control the onscreen action with your mouse. THis is an exceptional (both unusual and well put together) AVS preset, and doesn't show what AVS is usually like at all. In fact, I don't know of any other AVS presets that support user input like this. And yes, I've made some milkdrop presets, but never anything particularly amazing (or original), usually I end up modifying exisitg presets, removing some of the 'slowly alter this parameter over time' stuff that some people seem to like having. Usually I do this while... er... addled, so I think that's a good indication of the ease of editing within milkdrop. Milkdrop is just fine, as is AVS (though AVS is a real CPU hog, it'll eat whatever you throw at it, and on a complex preset, you can't expectm uch above 20fps at anything like 640x480. Usually my AVS gets set to something around 400x300, on my P4 2.4 And please, please don't ask 'what's your video card!' AVS is almost entirely CPU bound, unless you count the time it takes to make the 2d DirectX writes.

(Sorry, have had too many arguments with people lately who think they need monster video cards to use 3DS Max. Yeah, if you want your preview window to be nicer, which is a real issue... but... heh. It's not gonna help your render time. Not a lot of rendering apps can offload work to your 3d card, though that's changing slowly.)
overand.com
quasi-experimental electronic music
Rovastar
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 58
Joined: Mon Oct 13, 2003 12:52 am 0
Location: Derby/London, England
Contact:

Post by Rovastar »

No real 'interaction' on either MilkDrop or AVS. It is not something that is often requested to be honest.

Mouse interaction has however been experimented in Geiss II Ryan's last peice of work for Nullsoft.

Interaction is something that I might intergrate in future visualization projects (maybe in future devolpment of R4) VJ software route and visualizations have always been about automatation moving to the music

Also each scene will have to be re-written to account for the additional parameters from the mouse and/or joystick. But often I find that if I want to change a parameter I would use a element of the sound, bass, treble, beat, rate of change, etc.
User avatar
overand
Posts: 9
Joined: Fri Feb 27, 2004 2:40 pm 0
Location: Northeast USA
Contact:

Post by overand »

Rovastar, you may be a lightsynth god, but you're wrong about AVS. The interaction *is* there. Did you read my post? Try the preset yourself. Yeah, it appears to be quite the kludge, but it's there- mouse control of the action in the preset. Well, whatever, don't want to turn this into an argument.
overand.com
quasi-experimental electronic music
Post Reply