EA's dirty laundry
- HornedGod
- Baa!

- Posts: 41
- Joined: Thu Jul 03, 2003 3:11 pm 0
- Location: Home of the Chesapeake
- Contact:
EA's dirty laundry
A rather shocking account of work practices at EA's LA studios has been gathering quite a bit of attention over the last couple of days:
http://www.livejournal.com/users/ea_spouse/
I've done my fair share of crunch time working for game dev studios, but this just takes the piss.
Plenty of calls for developers to unionize, but I just don't see it happening any time soon myself.
http://www.livejournal.com/users/ea_spouse/
I've done my fair share of crunch time working for game dev studios, but this just takes the piss.
Plenty of calls for developers to unionize, but I just don't see it happening any time soon myself.
- p-saurus
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1282
- Joined: Wed Apr 24, 2002 8:56 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: p_saurus
- Location: Tucson, Arizona
- Contact:
I just came to post the exact same link. That sounds like a terrible way to live. Is that how the games industry is in general? Reading that makes me glad that I decided to study to be a teacher. The hours may be long and the salary bad in that profession too but it shouldn't be nearly as soul crippling as working for EA. 
Last edited by p-saurus on Thu Nov 11, 2004 7:51 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
TBh that doesn't shock me....
As the wife of a coder, I've sat alone for *many* hours waiting and wondering what time he is coming home/if he'll actually make it home...
He never got time back or paid overtime...
The first two and a half months of our marriage I was lucky if I saw him for a week in total.
Yes that is appauling the way EA are treating their staff but it does go on all over the place in the games industry, and probably always will....
As the wife of a coder, I've sat alone for *many* hours waiting and wondering what time he is coming home/if he'll actually make it home...
He never got time back or paid overtime...
The first two and a half months of our marriage I was lucky if I saw him for a week in total.
Yes that is appauling the way EA are treating their staff but it does go on all over the place in the games industry, and probably always will....
And though you're gone, you're with me every single day believe me
When someone you love becomes a memory, the memory becomes a treasure
(\ /)
( . .)
c('')('')
When someone you love becomes a memory, the memory becomes a treasure
(\ /)
( . .)
c('')('')
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
It's part of the package of working in the game industry. If it varies its with the length and intensity of the crunch time and the compensations for it. A well run company will limit to the last few months of a project, always keep at least a day off a week and offer weeks of extra leave to help people recover.Wife_Of_Snake wrote:Yes that is appauling the way EA are treating their staff but it does go on all over the place in the games industry, and probably always will....
Sadly it's easy to get this wrong and get away with it. You'll burn your staff out over a couple of projects but with many companies only completing one or two games before folding/being bought the company and managers don't last long enough to see the downside of such policies.
It should though get better. There will always be people willing to work under poor conditions because they love games, so it will always be poorly paid with long hours. But with games taking longer to develop, companies becoming more stable (at least the ones that survive) and the industry looking more and more like a regular industry treating employees like shit will become rarer, as it will cost too much in turnover and lost productivity.
It ain't all of these companies. I worked at High-Voltage, and they knew how to treat people right, or at least that's what I thought. They worked on a core hours system, which meant that everyone worked some of the same hours, but the other hours were completely flexible. This meant that a lot of people had convenient hours where they could run important errands, be with their families, hold Counter-Strike tourneys.
You know, the important things.
Even during the two crunches I worked through there (worked there only a short time as a lowly tester), my producers told the staff to go home to rest or take days off to take care of family.
So, not every game company is as batshit and villainous as EA.
You know, the important things.
Even during the two crunches I worked through there (worked there only a short time as a lowly tester), my producers told the staff to go home to rest or take days off to take care of family.
So, not every game company is as batshit and villainous as EA.
- HornedGod
- Baa!

- Posts: 41
- Joined: Thu Jul 03, 2003 3:11 pm 0
- Location: Home of the Chesapeake
- Contact:
I think the reason this is causing a bit of a storm is that this is EA we're talking about, the biggest publisher and developer in the world. Everyone knows it goes on to some extents in most development studios, but shouldn't EA really know better? It seems not. They rake in the cash, and still manage to treat their employees like shit.pogo wrote:It should though get better. There will always be people willing to work under poor conditions because they love games, so it will always be poorly paid with long hours. But with games taking longer to develop, companies becoming more stable (at least the ones that survive) and the industry looking more and more like a regular industry treating employees like shit will become rarer, as it will cost too much in turnover and lost productivity.
Other horror stories are sure to spring up, such as this one (from the comments of the original thread):
http://www.livejournal.com/users/joestraitiff
Luckily the developer I work at the moment seems to have their head screwed on about this sort of thing. We've just submitted to cert, and the only extra crunch time probably added up to an extra 10-15 hours per week over the last six weeks. While any crunch time is a royal pain, at least we get to spend this week lounging around playing Halo2 all day.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
.. ok .. let's say so, I think there are very few that work into coding that
did NOT live situations like that.
At the base of all this there's a "moral concept" that says "ok, it's ALL
wrong, it should NOT work this way".
Now let's analyze the whole thing under different aspects.
Well .. it's "common pratice" in the SW industry that you don't actually
sign a contract for a job paid hour-basis but rather for completition of
a project into an established amount of time and usually your
compensation is something decided since the beginning, usually
"once for all", that is paid you in some parts for the duration of
the work.
Usually these contracts do not talk about hours at all, it's generally
applied what we call "flexible worktime", nobody can tell you how
many hours a day you have to work and such, they pay for a job
started at day X, have maybe some milestones that have to be
completed at days Y,Z,W, and that is supposed to be completed at
day XX ...
"right/not right" .. eh .. it ALL depends what you signed in your
contract, what they clearly explained you when you accepted the job
and so on, if "they can do it or not" I suppose it all depends what you
accepted when you signed some papers.
In quite some places I worked overtime/bonuses/etc. were simply
not existent at all, but again this depends on the kind of contract I
had and the kind of agreement I had with the company.
Same about sick/vacation, when you work as "self employee" it's all
up to you, on the other side you can take holidays when you want and
how much you want .. but the company won't pay of course the time
you are away.
Thing change completely if you are (I speak about Italy) an employee.
Then yes, there's a worktime, there are some "rules" that both parts
have to respect, there's an overtime treatment and you can't -by law-
do more than a certain amount of overtime a month, there are some
bonuses that is your right to receive, any thing not respecting these
rules is simply going into the realm of the illegal.
But .. I think we all know what it means to sue a company .. BUT in
Italy especially NOW the situation is completely reversed compared to
past "work causes" are took into great consideration by courts and it's
quite likely you'll win if you start one for things like that.
As result (but not just for that of course yet this adds 'something' of it)
it's incredibly difficult to be hired as an "employee" in Italy, what they'll
always propose you is one of the other contracts above.
Now .. this let's say it's the "legal side" .. morally .. it's quite clear
enough from this letter (or so it appears) that there have been at least
a certain kind of "moral fraud" because situation and how the work might
develop into has been intentionatelly NOT clearly explained since
beginning.
A honest thing to say would have been "Listen, we can and we probably
will have projects that could required you to work from 9.am to 10.pm
seven days a week for some time that could be 'till completition',
hopefully not but we can't grant this won't happen .. " is it ok for you ?
What to say about all this ?
I can say only this, I spend about 9 years in SW developement living
for a certain time situations like this and .. I ended up in really *hating*
coding and such and looking for other kind of jobs very determined not
to be into coding again because, other "sad reality", after all I was able
to make money the same and even better doing other kind of less
stressfull jobs and more morally rewarding.
Not to mention the felling you get when working in such situations
you discover that the lady that comes 5 days a week from 3AM to
7AM to clean the office gets *more* money than you coder
But then something happened and so on ...
Just at "last thing" ..
.. 9AM till 10PM is pratically my everyday
working schedule .. it's flexible anyway and depends on what's going
on and the situation, if I have a goal I decided to nail down and
complete in the time I defined (or I need) this this is extended "as possible" ...
10 PM to 11 PM about is pub, then a bit of something then bed to get
possibly at least 6 hours of sleep.
I tell you .. only a coder can live a coder's life ...
did NOT live situations like that.
At the base of all this there's a "moral concept" that says "ok, it's ALL
wrong, it should NOT work this way".
Now let's analyze the whole thing under different aspects.
Well .. it's "common pratice" in the SW industry that you don't actually
sign a contract for a job paid hour-basis but rather for completition of
a project into an established amount of time and usually your
compensation is something decided since the beginning, usually
"once for all", that is paid you in some parts for the duration of
the work.
Usually these contracts do not talk about hours at all, it's generally
applied what we call "flexible worktime", nobody can tell you how
many hours a day you have to work and such, they pay for a job
started at day X, have maybe some milestones that have to be
completed at days Y,Z,W, and that is supposed to be completed at
day XX ...
"right/not right" .. eh .. it ALL depends what you signed in your
contract, what they clearly explained you when you accepted the job
and so on, if "they can do it or not" I suppose it all depends what you
accepted when you signed some papers.
In quite some places I worked overtime/bonuses/etc. were simply
not existent at all, but again this depends on the kind of contract I
had and the kind of agreement I had with the company.
Same about sick/vacation, when you work as "self employee" it's all
up to you, on the other side you can take holidays when you want and
how much you want .. but the company won't pay of course the time
you are away.
Thing change completely if you are (I speak about Italy) an employee.
Then yes, there's a worktime, there are some "rules" that both parts
have to respect, there's an overtime treatment and you can't -by law-
do more than a certain amount of overtime a month, there are some
bonuses that is your right to receive, any thing not respecting these
rules is simply going into the realm of the illegal.
But .. I think we all know what it means to sue a company .. BUT in
Italy especially NOW the situation is completely reversed compared to
past "work causes" are took into great consideration by courts and it's
quite likely you'll win if you start one for things like that.
As result (but not just for that of course yet this adds 'something' of it)
it's incredibly difficult to be hired as an "employee" in Italy, what they'll
always propose you is one of the other contracts above.
Now .. this let's say it's the "legal side" .. morally .. it's quite clear
enough from this letter (or so it appears) that there have been at least
a certain kind of "moral fraud" because situation and how the work might
develop into has been intentionatelly NOT clearly explained since
beginning.
A honest thing to say would have been "Listen, we can and we probably
will have projects that could required you to work from 9.am to 10.pm
seven days a week for some time that could be 'till completition',
hopefully not but we can't grant this won't happen .. " is it ok for you ?
What to say about all this ?
I can say only this, I spend about 9 years in SW developement living
for a certain time situations like this and .. I ended up in really *hating*
coding and such and looking for other kind of jobs very determined not
to be into coding again because, other "sad reality", after all I was able
to make money the same and even better doing other kind of less
stressfull jobs and more morally rewarding.
Not to mention the felling you get when working in such situations
you discover that the lady that comes 5 days a week from 3AM to
7AM to clean the office gets *more* money than you coder
But then something happened and so on ...
Just at "last thing" ..
working schedule .. it's flexible anyway and depends on what's going
on and the situation, if I have a goal I decided to nail down and
complete in the time I defined (or I need) this this is extended "as possible" ...
10 PM to 11 PM about is pub, then a bit of something then bed to get
possibly at least 6 hours of sleep.
I tell you .. only a coder can live a coder's life ...
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
- Kemper_Boyd
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11967
- Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0
Why should there be any crunch time? If crunch time was justHornedGod wrote: Other horror stories are sure to spring up, such as this one (from the comments of the original thread):
http://www.livejournal.com/users/joestraitiff
Luckily the developer I work at the moment seems to have their head screwed on about this sort of thing. We've just submitted to cert, and the only extra crunch time probably added up to an extra 10-15 hours per week over the last six weeks. While any crunch time is a royal pain, at least we get to spend this week lounging around playing Halo2 all day.
due to poor luck you'd expect to see an equal number of projects
finishing early, but you don't. The vast majority of software projects
overrun, and a big chunk fail. Quite simply fucking up is the industry
norm. Project manages consistently over promise and under deliver;
has no software company ever tried to break out of the continual
self delusion? Does any engineer ever admit to their weaknesses?
It makes me laugh when people talk about 'computer science'
of 'software engineering' when the industry is more like a
bunch of monkeys who can type.
I'd just love to see the management of any software project - games or other - be honest about it for a change. Say, "Here's how long you've got, here's how much money we can spend on it; just get in there and do the very best you can within those constraints." And then just leave the actual workers to get on with it, rather than continually fucking them about to justify their fat management salaries.Kemper_Boyd wrote:Why should there be any crunch time? If crunch time was just due to poor luck you'd expect to see an equal number of projects finishing early, but you don't. The vast majority of software projects overrun, and a big chunk fail. Quite simply fucking up is the industry norm. Project manages consistently over promise and under deliver; has no software company ever tried to break out of the continual self delusion? Does any engineer ever admit to their weaknesses?
It makes me laugh when people talk about 'computer science'
of 'software engineering' when the industry is more like a
bunch of monkeys who can type.
as long as the market supports it.Stone wrote:...as long as they can get away with it.Wife_Of_Snake wrote:it does go on all over the place in the games industry, and probably always will....
If EA are that shit employers how come they have employees? Do they pay more? Do they have better office locations? I don't know, but I do know that if it doesn't all pay off for everyone it won't work for long.
vi vi vi the text editor of the beast.
- Guru-Meditation
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4093
- Joined: Mon Jun 16, 2003 10:46 am 0
- Location: Bellevue near Seattle
- Contact:
At the company I work for you need to sign on the dotted line to work over 48 hours/week - and if you do work over that time your allowed time off each week etc to make up for it. This is the working law in the UK. If you feel that your overworked and not being allowed the time off you can actually get the company investigated - something I would advise you do if you are being treated like a code slave!
Personally if work is affecting your health, home life etc its time to kick back and make sure you know the law around working and use it to your advantage.
http://www.adviceguide.org.uk/index/lif ... and_safety
Personally if work is affecting your health, home life etc its time to kick back and make sure you know the law around working and use it to your advantage.
http://www.adviceguide.org.uk/index/lif ... and_safety
-= http://www.demonix.co.uk =-
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Two answers. First because the industry is competitive, and salaries are by far the main cost of developing a title, anything that lets a developer get the most bang for buck is done. And because the industry is full of idiots/enthusiasts willing to work long hours for less than they could get elsewhere companies can get away with agressive scheduling and crunch time. Heck, it's true of many other creative industries, from book publishing to Hollywood.Kemper_Boyd wrote:Why should there be any crunch time?
But the game industry is a young industry full of small, immature companies, some only as old as their last shipped game. They are often run by talented people who started the company to make games but who have no management experience or expertise. So they overcommit and underdeliver, driving themselves and their employees into the ground as they try and fail to complete the AAA title they thought they were working on.
And so the employees they've shat on quit to start their own company, and the cycle begins again. Thinking they won't make the same mistakes but they do.
It should be getting better. The size of a game project now means small startups have little chance to compete, so fewer doomed companies should be starting up. And the industry is no longer growing at a breakneck pace so there's less room for badly run companies which will struggle to survive if they can't keep their best staff.
But EA, the most successful company there is, are run like this ? As every games company wants either to be like EA or be bought out by EA there's maybe little hope for it.



