Intel vs AMD
Intel vs AMD
This is a serious post, not an attempt at trolling, honest.
There's another thread I've started about recommending a graphics card, which has mentioned an AMD processor/mobo combination. I had got my mind set on an Intel P4 processor.
Now you people on here (well most of you) seem fairly pleasant, and knowledgeable, and I'd like to pick your brains.
The question is: Should I go for a P4 or an AMD? And why?
The 'puter will be used mainly for programming, surfing etc, but I do occasionally run the odd game.
Rest of the spec I want. Dual channel memory (512 meg) and Raptor SATA drive etc etc. BUT I don't want to spend more than about £700 including a flatscreen monitor AND a proper licensed copy of XP Pro (£92 quid from Scan). I've budgeted about £250-£300 on a mobo, memory, and processor, so nothing too expensive eh?
Thanks,
Potts
There's another thread I've started about recommending a graphics card, which has mentioned an AMD processor/mobo combination. I had got my mind set on an Intel P4 processor.
Now you people on here (well most of you) seem fairly pleasant, and knowledgeable, and I'd like to pick your brains.
The question is: Should I go for a P4 or an AMD? And why?
The 'puter will be used mainly for programming, surfing etc, but I do occasionally run the odd game.
Rest of the spec I want. Dual channel memory (512 meg) and Raptor SATA drive etc etc. BUT I don't want to spend more than about £700 including a flatscreen monitor AND a proper licensed copy of XP Pro (£92 quid from Scan). I've budgeted about £250-£300 on a mobo, memory, and processor, so nothing too expensive eh?
Thanks,
Potts
- Kemper_Boyd
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11967
- Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0
AMD. Got a Duron 1600 myself, and accidentally overclocked it to 2GHz, yet there's no significant temperature rise due to it. I'm always around 30°C CPU temperature, which rises to 35°C during hot summer days. Could even overclock it to 2,4 GHz without any significant temperature rise, yet it cost me 34 euros, while the same chip from Intel (Intel P4 1,6 GHz... something around that), would've been more, even if it were a celery.
...
Or was that 34 euros my mobo... should have to check my bills. I know I didn't pay more than 60 for both together, so it can't be more than 34.
In short: AMD's got awesome price-quality, if you keep your eyes peeled
...
Or was that 34 euros my mobo... should have to check my bills. I know I didn't pay more than 60 for both together, so it can't be more than 34.
In short: AMD's got awesome price-quality, if you keep your eyes peeled
- chris4500uk
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1158
- Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2004 3:05 am 0
- Location: Middlesbrough, UK
- Contact:
-
Kronos
not p4 but celeron = duron equivalentKon-Tiki wrote:AMD. Got a Duron 1600 myself, and accidentally overclocked it to 2GHz, yet there's no significant temperature rise due to it. I'm always around 30°C CPU temperature, which rises to 35°C during hot summer days. Could even overclock it to 2,4 GHz without any significant temperature rise, yet it cost me 34 euros, while the same chip from Intel (Intel P4 1,6 GHz... something around that), would've been more, even if it were a celery.
...
Or was that 34 euros my mobo... should have to check my bills. I know I didn't pay more than 60 for both together, so it can't be more than 34.
In short: AMD's got awesome price-quality, if you keep your eyes peeled
athlons are terrible for overclocking in my experience
- hairy_pete
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 7217
- Joined: Mon May 27, 2002 8:10 pm 0
- Location: A Tiny Village in Bavaria
Re: Intel vs AMD
P4Potts wrote:The question is: Should I go for a P4 or an AMD?
Compatibilty and stability.Potts wrote:And why?
The 'puter will be used mainly for programming, surfing etc,
AMD will give you more bang for yer buck and is a great processor, but the chipsets and drivers are, for want of a better word, fussy. They can always be made to work, but it ain't worth the effort IMO.
Intel stuff can be well abused and still work, not as optimally maybe, but Intel are still way ahead of the chuck it in, it'll work game.
vi vi vi the text editor of the beast.
- hairy_pete
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 7217
- Joined: Mon May 27, 2002 8:10 pm 0
- Location: A Tiny Village in Bavaria
- Kemper_Boyd
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11967
- Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0
I know that. I never said best. I said generally more compatible, and better supported by third party drivers, and I've done enough field work to stand by that.hairy_pete wrote: The "Intel makes the best chipsets" thing is a myth.
You might get a better computer with AMD but you get a better Computer exerience with Intel. (Linux users need not apply
vi vi vi the text editor of the beast.
Re: Intel vs AMD
This was my original thinking. Until a couple of comments on the graphics card thread I'd not considered AMD.mattley wrote:P4Potts wrote:The question is: Should I go for a P4 or an AMD?
Compatibilty and stability.Potts wrote:And why?
The 'puter will be used mainly for programming, surfing etc,
AMD will give you more bang for yer buck and is a great processor, but the chipsets and drivers are, for want of a better word, fussy. They can always be made to work, but it ain't worth the effort IMO.
Intel stuff can be well abused and still work, not as optimally maybe, but Intel are still way ahead of the chuck it in, it'll work game.
If I'd more experience of building PC's I might 'take a chance' on an AMD, but to be honest, it's a big investment for me at the moment and I can't afford to be wrong.
Potts

