Hiroshima anniversary yesterday

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
randomdude
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4609
Joined: Sat Aug 02, 2003 3:54 am 0

Hiroshima anniversary yesterday

Post by randomdude »

Just read on slashdot that its 60 years ago yesterday (6th Aug) that the first atom bomb was dropped.
Thought the least I could do was start a thread about it.

Its fairly interesting, if shocking. I feel these people should be remembered - although I'm sure worse things have happened in war that we do not remember.

So yeah. *bows head* To remember the hundreds of thousands.
I am both the king and the queen of cheese.
<Wife_of_Snake> Random the sugar rush fairy!
<}stinky_beast{> I'd do a zebra if it'd stand still
Matrixxx
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8282
Joined: Tue Feb 15, 2005 9:08 pm 0

Post by Matrixxx »

To be exposed momentarily to temperatures hotter than the surface of the sun - how on earth could anybody survive that. They say it was so hot the only thing that remained of people was their shadow... spooky. Dont know how true that is. I did see a picture of a step a few years back, a shadow on it where apparently an old man was sat at the time of the blast.

How dare the US demand other countries stop making nukes when they have an active WMD program of their own running, bloody hypocrites. :evil: Granted, it ended the conflict, but what a sob story the US would have made if they were on the recieving end of it, look at what they made of 9/11.

bombs on this scale suck, nobody should have access to them, least of all America IMHO.
User avatar
DutchLlama
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6038
Joined: Fri May 03, 2002 1:09 pm 0
Location: Fhloston Paradise with llovely Leeloo... Sweet! :)

Post by DutchLlama »

Matrix wrote:To be exposed momentarily to temperatures hotter than the surface of the sun - how on earth could anybody survive that. They say it was so hot the only thing that remained of people was their shadow... spooky. Dont know how true that is. I did see a picture of a step a few years back, a shadow on it where apparently an old man was sat at the time of the blast.

How dare the US demand other countries stop making nukes when they have an active WMD program of their own running, bloody hypocrites. :evil: Granted, it ended the conflict, but what a sob story the US would have made if they were on the recieving end of it, look at what they made of 9/11.

bombs on this scale suck, nobody should have access to them, least of all America IMHO.
Yes it would have been better if millions of soldiers and civilians would have died during a large scale invasion of the Japanese mainland. :roll:

Nukes are terrifying weapons but without them the war against Japan would have taken another bloody few years. That's the real tough part. :(
Boy: "Have you met monsters before?" The Doctor: "Yes."
Boy: "Are you scared of them?" The Doctor: "No, they are scared of me!"
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Post by zip accident »

Yeah, it was bad, as was Nagasaki.

I think Dresden was just about worse. Or maybe not, "The right of the Line" (John Terraine, Wordsworth Military Library (a reprint)) gives 25,000 killed, 35,000 missing at Dresden, which is less.

9/11? Until that happened, Pearl Harbour was the USA's main complaint, the original Battlestar Gallactica film's beginning was effectively a re-enactment of Pearl without the real causes. We'll be hearing about 9/11 for a hundred years.

<edit> Not fun to remember any of it. Sorry if it makes anyone sad or angry. :oops: :cry:
User avatar
punkrulesok
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2936
Joined: Sun Jun 09, 2002 9:17 am 0
Yahoo Messenger: punkrulesok@yahoo.com
Location: Wirral, UK.
Contact:

Post by punkrulesok »

Matrix wrote:bombs on this scale suck, nobody should have access to them, least of all America IMHO.
*Right* on! Unfortunately, man is not a peacefull entity, and I fear another world war will happen eventually, that will wipe out most of man kind.
User avatar
ElfQrin
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4384
Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2003 12:55 pm 0
Location: Italy
Contact:

Post by ElfQrin »

DutchLlama wrote: Yes it would have been better if millions of soldiers and civilians would have died during a large scale invasion of the Japanese mainland. :roll:

Nukes are terrifying weapons but without them the war against Japan would have taken another bloody few years. That's the real tough part. :(
Yet, if Nazis would have dropped the A-Bomb we would remember it today as one of the most inhumane, cruel, act ever perpetrated.

I'm somewhat convinced that if USA would be invaded by a foreign power and US citizens would explode themselves to fight such invaders they would be considered heroes, not terrorists... (in fact, suicide is the extreme sacrifice to save your country, in Hollywood movies).

Double standards, double standards... and History is written by winners.
User avatar
Rev. Stuart Campbell
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3995
Joined: Sun Jan 05, 2003 4:38 pm 0
Location: From Heck

Post by Rev. Stuart Campbell »

zip accident wrote:Yeah, it was bad, as was Nagasaki.

I think Dresden was just about worse. Or maybe not, "The right of the Line" (John Terraine, Wordsworth Military Library (a reprint)) gives 25,000 killed, 35,000 missing at Dresden, which is less.
The total number directly or indirectly killed by the firebombing of Dresden is widely held to be in the region of 200,000. I'll see if I can dig out my source for that. It's a matter of considerable dispute, with estimates ranging from 20,000 to 250,000. That's the trouble with firebombing - it's hard to count ashes.

And of course, more were killed by "conventional" firebombing raids on Tokyo than at Hiroshima or Nagasaki. It always disturbs me when people draw some kind of moral distinction between two nominally different ways of burning civilians to death. At least a lot of the Hiroshima victims didn't suffer.
http://wosland.podgamer.com
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
User avatar
Kemper_Boyd
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11967
Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0

Post by Kemper_Boyd »

http://users.erols.com/mwhite28/battles.htm
Dresden, Germany (air raid by UK & US: 13-14 Feb. 1945): 35 000
Houston Chronicle review of Dresden: Tuesday, February 13, 1945 by Frederick Taylor (2004)
"[C]asualty figures the German press put out -- 135,000 or 250,000 or even 400,000 dead.... nothing more than creative efforts of Nazi propagandists."
"[O]nly after the fall of the Soviet Union did records emerge that documented the true casualty figures -- 25,000 to 35,000 dead."
see also Palm Beach Post and NY Times reviews: 25,000-40,000
Martin Sorge, The Other Price of Hitler's War (1986): 35,000
Spartacus: "Recent research suggest that 35,000 were killed but some German sources have argued that it was over 100,000" [http://www.spartacus.schoolnet.co.uk/2WWdresden.htm]
Messenger, The Chronological Atlas of World War Two (1989): 50,000
Gilbert, History of the Twentieth Century: 39,773 bodies IDed. At least 20,000 missing. All told, as many as 80,000 d.
NOTE: The most commonly cited death toll is 135,000, but not among scholars.
Wikipedia: 135,000 ("Aerial bombing of cities" 5/04)
Johnson, Modern Times: 135,000
Irving: The Destruction of Dresden (1966): 135,000. See also Nizkor's discussion of this.
offyoutoddle
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2644
Joined: Sat Mar 19, 2005 2:16 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: awvc1@yahoo.co.uk
Location: London
Contact:

Post by offyoutoddle »

It gives me some hope for human nature though when you see how Hiroshima has dealt with the past - I find the flame that will burn as long a nuclear weapons are a threat a particularly touching symbol of hope. I want to believe that one day that flame will go out.
one joy scatters a thousand griefs
User avatar
Perkunas
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2058
Joined: Tue Apr 13, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Tokyo
Contact:

Post by Perkunas »

Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote: At least a lot of the Hiroshima victims didn't suffer.
Those that were instantly killed by the blast yes, but about half of the total amount of casualties came days/weeks/months/years later due to the lethal radioactive radiation. They did suffer alright... Some old Hiroshima/Nagasaki victims actually still suffer every day.
User avatar
Zen-Chan
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5499
Joined: Sun Apr 18, 2004 8:12 pm 0
Location: Glasgow, Scotland

Post by Zen-Chan »

Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote:At least a lot of the Hiroshima victims didn't suffer.
Well, the majority ones that were killed instantly didn't suffer - but the cancer rate for people that were alive in that area and born up to 10 years after is still unproportionally high to this day.

As you say, it's stupid to debate the pros and cons of different ways of killing thousands of people, but when one method leaves such a long term legacy over people who weren't even alive at the time of the bombing you have to wonder if a better option couldn't have been taken.
User avatar
Kemper_Boyd
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11967
Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0

Post by Kemper_Boyd »

ElfQrin wrote:Yet, if Nazis would have dropped the A-Bomb we would remember it today as one of the most inhumane, cruel, act ever perpetrated.
Yeah because Nazi Germany is so well regarded as it is.
User avatar
Gorecki
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5962
Joined: Sat Aug 31, 2002 1:39 am 0
Location: Essex, home of the Boy Racer

Post by Gorecki »

My knowledge of WW2 history is fairly basic so could somebody answer some questions for me.

What was the reasons for bombing Hiroshima and Nagasaki? Were they important military/industrial centres or was it just a case of terrorising the Japanese into surrendering? And if it was the latter, what was the reason behind dropping the second bomb, surely the first would have been enough?

How close was Japan to surrendering anyway? I've heard several left-wingers argue that Japan were on the brink of surrendering (some have even claimed that they actually did try to surrender but it was rejected by the US) and that dropping a nuclear bomb was just Americas way of showing off to the Russians.


There's a lot of talk about how nuclear weapons ended WW2 early but this is always stated as fact and rarely questioned or fully explained. A bit of background knowledge would be nice.
Tang Sou!
User avatar
DutchLlama
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6038
Joined: Fri May 03, 2002 1:09 pm 0
Location: Fhloston Paradise with llovely Leeloo... Sweet! :)

Post by DutchLlama »

ElfQrin wrote:
DutchLlama wrote: Yes it would have been better if millions of soldiers and civilians would have died during a large scale invasion of the Japanese mainland. :roll:

Nukes are terrifying weapons but without them the war against Japan would have taken another bloody few years. That's the real tough part. :(
Yet, if Nazis would have dropped the A-Bomb we would remember it today as one of the most inhumane, cruel, act ever perpetrated.

I'm somewhat convinced that if USA would be invaded by a foreign power and US citizens would explode themselves to fight such invaders they would be considered heroes, not terrorists... (in fact, suicide is the extreme sacrifice to save your country, in Hollywood movies).
Well yeah, the US shouldn't have attacked Germany then and left Hitler in power in Germany. :roll:

Don't we forget that both Germany and Japan (and Italy for that matter) attacked and occupied their neighbours? Or should we ignore that so we can go on with our hobby of mindless America bashing? :roll:
Boy: "Have you met monsters before?" The Doctor: "Yes."
Boy: "Are you scared of them?" The Doctor: "No, they are scared of me!"
User avatar
Kemper_Boyd
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11967
Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0

Post by Kemper_Boyd »

Gorecki wrote:What was the reasons for bombing Hiroshima and Nagasaki? Were they important military/industrial centres or was it just a case of terrorising the Japanese into surrendering? And if it was the latter, what was the reason behind dropping the second bomb, surely the first would have been enough?
That tends to depend upon the persons POV. The Army planners did
have both cities listed as militarily significant, and rejected Tokyo
and Osaka on the grounds of them being too costly in terms of civilian
deaths, with perhaps the risk of making Japan suicidely defiant. That
said it was most likely intended to end the war by a show of
overwhelming force, thus obtaining an unconditional surrender. The
dropping of the bomb on Nagasaki was due to the primary target
being obscured by cloud, so the secondary was attacked. Why Japan
didn't surrender immediatly after Hiroshima and why the US would
not wait any longer are open questions to this day.
Gorecki wrote: How close was Japan to surrendering anyway? I've heard several left-wingers argue that Japan were on the brink of surrendering (some have even claimed that they actually did try to surrender but it was rejected by the US) and that dropping a nuclear bomb was just Americas way of showing off to the Russians.
I find that explanation somewhat implausible as it makes most sense
in the context of the later cold war. Remember the allied powers were
still fighting alongside one another at this point, even if there were
mutual suspicions about their long term plans. There's no doubt that
Japan was militarily finished but the agreed terms (amongst the allies)
for Japan's surrender were not negotiable and the inclination of the
Japanese military was to reject such terms and fight in the homeland
at all costs, in a similar fashion to Hitler's insane every last man,
woman and child being expected to fend off the allies.
Gorecki wrote: There's a lot of talk about how nuclear weapons ended WW2 early but this is always stated as fact and rarely questioned or fully explained. A bit of background knowledge would be nice.
Well the US plan for the invasion of mainland Japan called for a first
assault at the end of 1945 (Kyushu) and a second invasion in 1946
(Honshu). So it's quite plausible that the war could have continued well
into 1946. FWIW the initial British plan called for an invasion in 1947!
Japan was in no position to threaten others by 1945, but the allies
demanded control of the country, so even in 1945 the war would
have continued if the Japanese would not surrender.

This is a good article on the allied and Japanese plans.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Downfall
Post Reply