Hiroshima anniversary yesterday

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
tufty
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12524
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 4:52 pm 0
Location: French Alps

Post by tufty »

Tetra Elemental wrote:The americans do overplay their part in the conflict but to say they were ultimately negligible is stupid.
Indeed.

Without the (admittedly paid for) logistics support the UK would have crumbled and fallen well before the 'merkins eventually joined in for real. And without their troops, the Normandy landings simply would not have happened.

No, they didn't exactly come galloping in on their white chargers, but without their intervention Europe would look very different today.

Simon
User avatar
Rev. Stuart Campbell
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3995
Joined: Sun Jan 05, 2003 4:38 pm 0
Location: From Heck

Post by Rev. Stuart Campbell »

Nobody's arguing with that. As I keep saying - without America the Nazis would still have been defeated. What that would have subsequently meant for France, Belgium, Holland etc would quite obviously have been a different matter. I agreed about a page and a half ago that what we ended up with is preferable to what the result of a Soviet-only victory would have been, and I've already said there probably wouldn't have been any Normandy landings without US troops. None of which alters the point I was making in the slightest. I do wish people would actually read what they imagine they're arguing against before they start angrily refuting claims that nobody made.
http://wosland.podgamer.com
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
User avatar
Rev. Stuart Campbell
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3995
Joined: Sun Jan 05, 2003 4:38 pm 0
Location: From Heck

Post by Rev. Stuart Campbell »

In fact, though, let's just play this one out and then we can hopefully get back to Hiroshima.

By June 1944, the Russians had already obliterated most of the Wehrmacht's fighting strength. The Germans were in full retreat, largely in disarray. Russia's enormous manufacturing might was in full flow, churning out tanks and planes and weapons at a rate the Third Reich couldn't even begin to compete with, all of which was accelerating the rate of the Soviet advance with every passing day. Red Army manpower was also effectively limitless - every German killed was irreplaceable, whereas there were 20 more waiting to take the place of every Russian killed (which explains the profligacy with which they attacked, concerned only with wiping the Germans out as fast as possible with no regard to their own losses).

The Russians reached Berlin in April 1945. The second-rate divisions stationed in the West would have delayed this date a little, but given the scenario detailed above, not by much. (Remember, many of them would have had to stay behind anyway, as forces of occupation.) In Berlin itself, the Wehrmacht was pretty much down to 14-year-old boys and pensioners armed with sharpened sticks by this point. So let's assume, with no D-Day landings, that the Soviet capture of the Reich Chancellery was held up until, ooh, July 1945. What now?

What you appear to be suggesting is that, with Germany surrendered and the war won, the Russians would have continued regardless into Holland and France et al, despite there being no justification whatsoever for them to do so in order to "liberate" these countries now that the war was over. This is such a fatuous notion that we'll dismiss it out of hand. Quite apart from anything else, we've seen how quickly the Americans could develop the A-bomb when they needed to. An East-West military conflict with only one side armed with atomic weaponry would have been short and ugly and bad news for the Russians.

What that leaves us with is the possibility of the USSR now exerting economic pressure on the nations of Western Europe, despite the fact that (because there were no D-Day landings and hence no fighting) these nations have survived the war more or less economically intact. Undoubtedly that's what the Soviets would have tried to do, but it's highly arguable that they could have managed it.

America was rich from the war, as was demonstrated by the Marshall Plan, which dealt with more or less the exact scenario we've just described - rebuilding Europe in order to make it a bulwark against Communism. With less rebuilding required, of course, the Plan would have been even more successful, reducing even further the USSR's chances of exerting economic pressure.

The chief difference - and it IS a substantial one - is that the whole of Germany would have remained a Soviet dominion after the war, which would have altered the economic balance of post-war Europe in quite a significant way, and might well have bolstered Communism to the extent that it would have survived longer than it did. But then, since the end of the Cold War is in reality (and with the benefit of hindsight, of course) the worst thing to have happened to Western civilisation in the last 20 years, it's debateable whether avoiding or delaying that is - ultimately - anything much to be shouting about.
Last edited by Rev. Stuart Campbell on Sun Aug 07, 2005 7:25 pm 0, edited 2 times in total.
http://wosland.podgamer.com
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
User avatar
DutchLlama
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6038
Joined: Fri May 03, 2002 1:09 pm 0
Location: Fhloston Paradise with llovely Leeloo... Sweet! :)

Post by DutchLlama »

Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote:
Tetra Elemental wrote:
Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote:
Tetra Elemental wrote: Without american intervention europe would have been totally under the boot of Hitler.
You know what you should do? Read some books.
Likewise.
See above. Your ignorance is breathtaking. Almost the entire burden of defeating the Nazis - certainly by the time the Americans got involved - was shouldered by the Soviets, who sacrificed ONE HUNDRED lives for every single American who died in WW2.
Well lets not forget that Stalin killed over half the Soviet population and troops who died during WWII. :?
Boy: "Have you met monsters before?" The Doctor: "Yes."
Boy: "Are you scared of them?" The Doctor: "No, they are scared of me!"
User avatar
Rev. Stuart Campbell
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3995
Joined: Sun Jan 05, 2003 4:38 pm 0
Location: From Heck

Post by Rev. Stuart Campbell »

DutchLlama wrote: Well lets not forget that Stalin killed over half the Soviet population and troops who died during WWII. :?
In what sense?
http://wosland.podgamer.com
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
User avatar
tufty
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12524
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 4:52 pm 0
Location: French Alps

Post by tufty »

Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote:
DutchLlama wrote: Well lets not forget that Stalin killed over half the Soviet population and troops who died during WWII. :?
In what sense?
In that between 1 and 20 million people were killed as a direct result of Stalin's orders between '35 and '39, I would think. Not to mention those that were killed by the NKVD /SMERSH on retreating. And the ones who died in the gulags after the war, having been directly transferred there from POW camps.

That doesn't cover the civilians who were left to starve / to the tender mercies of the advancing axis forces in the big slash and burn retreat of '41

There are basically two schools of thought when it comes to Stalin. The "big numbers" group estimate he was responsible for the deaths of about 50 million, and the "small numbers" group estimate 15 million or so.

Nice bloke, "Uncle Joe".

Simon
User avatar
Rev. Stuart Campbell
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3995
Joined: Sun Jan 05, 2003 4:38 pm 0
Location: From Heck

Post by Rev. Stuart Campbell »

tufty wrote: In that between 1 and 20 million people were killed as a direct result of Stalin's orders between '35 and '39, I would think.
Mm. Interesting definition of "during WW2", though, given that the USSR wasn't involved in WW2 until 1941. As far as Russia was concerned, these deaths weren't during The Great Patriotic War at all.
Last edited by Rev. Stuart Campbell on Sun Aug 07, 2005 8:33 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
http://wosland.podgamer.com
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
random
Baaaa!
Baaaa!
Posts: 725
Joined: Sat Sep 20, 2003 4:48 pm 0

Post by random »

Tetra Elemental wrote:
Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote:
Tetra Elemental wrote:
Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote:
Tetra Elemental wrote: Without american intervention europe would have been totally under the boot of Hitler.
You know what you should do? Read some books.
Likewise.
See above. Your ignorance is breathtaking. Almost the entire burden of defeating the Nazis - certainly by the time the Americans got involved - was shouldered by the Soviets, who sacrificed ONE HUNDRED lives for every single American who died in WW2. (And a large percentage of those Americans died fighting the Japanese, not the Nazis.) The ENORMOUS majority of Germans killed were killed on the Eastern Front.
For the record, I think your ignorance of warfare, specifically the set-up in europe during WWII, is laughable. War isn't about which side kills the most men, or which side loses the most men. If it was that easy the world map would look rather different throughout history. But I can't be arsed getting drawn into a long and pointless debate over it on here. The americans do overplay their part in the conflict but to say they were ultimately negligible is stupid. Any book on the history of WWII will tell you exactly the impact they had. Anti-american feeling wont make it go away. The rest is conjecture and there are plenty of books on that subject and all tell a different story.

Last post on this subject.
Dude, read what he actually wrote - not what you think he wrote.

The Rev is totally right in what he is saying that the Soviets were grinding down the Nazi's, and at the end the Allies were in a mad rush to stop the Soviets grabbing more of Europe.

Hitler committed suicide on 30 April 1945, while the unconditional surrender was on 7 May 1945. During this time Admiral Doenitz was basically moving as many units of the Nazi army as he could, as fast as he could, westward - so at least they would be captured by the non-Soviet Allies.

You might want to re-read your books Tetra Elemental :wink:

Back to the Hiroshama anniversary, I watched some of it live on Friday night, and spent a few moments of silence thinking. :cry:
User avatar
Rev. Stuart Campbell
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3995
Joined: Sun Jan 05, 2003 4:38 pm 0
Location: From Heck

Post by Rev. Stuart Campbell »

random wrote: You might want to re-read your books Tetra Elemental :wink:
I hope everyone with an interest is watching the second episode of Warlords (C4, not BBC2, sorry) right now, detailing exactly how hard Roosevelt tried NOT to get America involved in WW2.

And a reminder: the BBC's supposedly excellent drama-doc on Hiroshima starts in 10 minutes.
http://wosland.podgamer.com
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
User avatar
tufty
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12524
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 4:52 pm 0
Location: French Alps

Post by tufty »

Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote:
tufty wrote: In that between 1 and 20 million people were killed as a direct result of Stalin's orders between '35 and '39, I would think.
Mm. Interesting definition of "during WW2", though, given that the USSR wasn't involved in WW2 until 1941. As far as Russia was concerned, these deaths weren't during The Great Patriotic War at all.
I was working on the "over half the Soviet population" thing (which is of itself a little overambitious, he's only really thought to have presided over the deaths of 15-35% or so. I'd parsed out the "during WWII" thing as ambiguous grammar. 1935 to 1939 don't fall as "during WWII" in anybody's books.

Directly attributable military deaths on his own side are generally thought to be in the 1.5M bracket (half a million or so executed on the battlefield, and a million or so POWs shot on their happy homecoming, lucky chaps)

Overall WW2 deaths due to Uncle Joe according to http://users.erols.com/mwhite28/warstat1.htm, which site seems to provide a relatively balanced view on things around 4M, but potentially up to 17-18M depending on your source.

And then again, there's that nice Mr Mao...

Simon
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

Matrix wrote:To be exposed momentarily to temperatures hotter than the surface of the sun - how on earth could anybody survive that. They say it was so hot the only thing that remained of people was their shadow... spooky. Dont know how true that is. I did see a picture of a step a few years back, a shadow on it where apparently an old man was sat at the time of the blast.

How dare the US demand other countries stop making nukes when they have an active WMD program of their own running, bloody hypocrites. :evil: Granted, it ended the conflict, but what a sob story the US would have made if they were on the recieving end of it, look at what they made of 9/11.

bombs on this scale suck, nobody should have access to them, least of all America IMHO.


its no more certain that the yanks would have won, than us not winning the war against hitler if the pricks hadnt helped* us. and to NEVER have apologised for being the only country to have used such a disgusting weapon that still kills people of cancer TO THIS DAY and then have the cheek about concentration camps 8O

in this case, sorry but what the yanks done to the japs at that time in my mind is almost as bad as what hitler was doing. he was the bush of his day...cowardice thats all it was and dont dress up the dropping of the ONLY nukes on this planet in anger as anything else :?

charged us through the fucking nose*
User avatar
F-ZeroOne
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8208
Joined: Wed Sep 29, 2004 8:27 pm 0

Post by F-ZeroOne »

Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote:
Tetra Elemental wrote:
Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote:
Tetra Elemental wrote: Without american intervention europe would have been totally under the boot of Hitler.
You know what you should do? Read some books.
Likewise.
See above. Your ignorance is breathtaking. Almost the entire burden of defeating the Nazis - certainly by the time the Americans got involved - was shouldered by the Soviets, who sacrificed ONE HUNDRED lives for every single American who died in WW2. (And a large percentage of those Americans died fighting the Japanese, not the Nazis.)
It has been pointed out by some observers that part of the reason for this is that both the Nazis and the Russians were not quite as careful - by World War II standards - with their troops lives as the Allied forces. I believe (although I could be wrong) Hitler had the opportunity to pull his troops out of Stalingrad more than once. There are a lot of stories of Russian attacks being pressed at all costs.
Similar things happened in the Pacific; Japanese losses are in general much higher than US ones, although there are other factors that can be taken into account (e.g. the general decline in the quality of Japanese pilots from mid-war onwards... )
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Evilbeaver
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 35
Joined: Sat Dec 11, 2004 11:38 pm 0
Location: Middle Fucked Up America

Post by Evilbeaver »

[quote="Matrix"]How dare the US demand other countries stop making nukes when they have an active WMD program of their own running, bloody hypocrites. Granted, it ended the conflict, but what a sob story the US would have made if they were on the recieving end of it, look at what they made of 9/11. [quote]

Sure, I do agree that we need to scale back curtain military resources (WMDs) in order to get rouge nations to comply. However, I do think that the U.S. is a bit more accountable with nuclear weapons than North Korea, the former Soviet Union, and Iran (if they had them).

Don't get me wrong, I am as militant as they come when it comes to standing up against the U.S.'s current foreign policy, but I am not so delusional as to suggest that the U.S.'s advisories are close to being some sort of moral authority in this situation.
"All you need is ignorance and confidence; then success is sure."-Mark Twain
User avatar
Rev. Stuart Campbell
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3995
Joined: Sun Jan 05, 2003 4:38 pm 0
Location: From Heck

Post by Rev. Stuart Campbell »

F-ZeroOne wrote: It has been pointed out by some observers that part of the reason for this is that both the Nazis and the Russians were not quite as careful - by World War II standards - with their troops lives as the Allied forces. I believe (although I could be wrong) Hitler had the opportunity to pull his troops out of Stalingrad more than once.
No, that's absolutely true. A substantial portion of the German Sixth Army at Stalingrad could have been saved (or at least, their deaths postponed until later in the war) had Hitler allowed them to retreat. His refusal to allow retreat under almost any circumstances certainly increased the death toll, but not by the sort of margins I was quoting. And as I said, the USSR's main strategic advantage were its sheer reserves of manpower, so they were often profligate in attack, counting on overwhelming the Nazis with sheer numbers. Famously, at early points in the war, troops would be sent into battle with only one rifle for every two men, the idea being that the unlucky second guy would pick up a rifle from a corpse, quite possibly of the first guy.

Later in the war that policy was hard to defend because it was purely exercised to make sure the Soviets got to Berlin before the Americans and British, but early on it was the only desperate option the Red Army had available.
http://wosland.podgamer.com
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
User avatar
DutchLlama
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6038
Joined: Fri May 03, 2002 1:09 pm 0
Location: Fhloston Paradise with llovely Leeloo... Sweet! :)

Post by DutchLlama »

Old_but_still_a_kid wrote:in this case, sorry but what the yanks done to the japs at that time in my mind is almost as bad as what hitler was doing.
And of course all Japanese were innocent victims in this, riiiight? :roll:
Boy: "Have you met monsters before?" The Doctor: "Yes."
Boy: "Are you scared of them?" The Doctor: "No, they are scared of me!"
Post Reply