Hiroshima anniversary yesterday

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
ElfQrin
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4384
Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2003 12:55 pm 0
Location: Italy
Contact:

Post by ElfQrin »

DutchLlama wrote:
Old_but_still_a_kid wrote:in this case, sorry but what the yanks done to the japs at that time in my mind is almost as bad as what hitler was doing.
And of course all Japanese were innocent victims in this, riiiight? :roll:
The ones they nuked were all civilians, riiiight? (OK, incidentally it's probable that there were military among them too... :roll: )


On the other hand... up to WW2 it was normal to throw bombs wildly on cities over civilians. And it was normal to invade other countries without having to make up stories, you could just tell the truth "we are making our empire". And many other things that today the public opinion considers "wrong" were "normal" back to then.

Hans Magnus Enzensberger -- a German philosopher and writer -- said (I'm paraphrasing): "During the fascist years I didn't realize I was living in the fascist years".
As I've said winners write History, however may be one day we'll realize that today we are living in the "Bush/Blair years" with wars, restrictions of human and civil rights, and so on, and we'll understand how bad such years were.
User avatar
Kemper_Boyd
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11967
Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0

Post by Kemper_Boyd »

ElfQrin wrote:Hans Magnus Enzensberger -- a German philosopher and writer -- said (I'm paraphrasing): "During the fascist years I didn't realize I was living in the fascist years".
As I've said winners write History, however may be one day we'll realize that today we are living in the "Bush/Blair years" with wars, restrictions of human and civil rights, and so on, and we'll understand how bad such years were.
i.e. Jack shit in the grand scheme of things, unless you really are making
a comparison with the Nazis.
User avatar
ElfQrin
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4384
Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2003 12:55 pm 0
Location: Italy
Contact:

Post by ElfQrin »

Kemper_Boyd wrote:
ElfQrin wrote:Hans Magnus Enzensberger -- a German philosopher and writer -- said (I'm paraphrasing): "During the fascist years I didn't realize I was living in the fascist years".
As I've said winners write History, however may be one day we'll realize that today we are living in the "Bush/Blair years" with wars, restrictions of human and civil rights, and so on, and we'll understand how bad such years were.
i.e. Jack shit in the grand scheme of things, unless you really are making
a comparison with the Nazis.
No, otherwise I'd automatically lose due to the Godwin's Law :wink:

I'm saying that things we consider as normal today can be the greatest evil tomorrow.

And the distinction between "Good" and "Bad" is often made solely by the winners.
User avatar
phattslagg
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3578
Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
Location: Worcester, England

Post by phattslagg »

ElfQrin wrote:
DutchLlama wrote:
Old_but_still_a_kid wrote:in this case, sorry but what the yanks done to the japs at that time in my mind is almost as bad as what hitler was doing.
And of course all Japanese were innocent victims in this, riiiight? :roll:
The ones they nuked were all civilians, riiiight? (OK, incidentally it's probable that there were military among them too... :roll: )
Well, Hiroshima was effectively a 'military' city - there were thousands of soldiers stationed there. Thousands of civiians as well, of course.

My g/f watched a bit of the program about it with me tonight - she remarked that what the Americans did in that instance effectively amounted to terrorism..
Evilbeaver
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 35
Joined: Sat Dec 11, 2004 11:38 pm 0
Location: Middle Fucked Up America

Post by Evilbeaver »

ElfQrin wrote:On the other hand... up to WW2 it was normal to throw bombs wildly on cities over civilians. And it was normal to invade other countries without having to make up stories, you could just tell the truth "we are making our empire". And many other things that today the public opinion considers "wrong" were "normal" back to then.
Umm...didn't the Nazis tell the German citizens that the Polish invasion wasn't a preemptive strike, stating that Poland struck first? Didn't Hitler ask Norway and Denmark if he could peacefully occupy them for their protection?
"All you need is ignorance and confidence; then success is sure."-Mark Twain
User avatar
ElfQrin
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4384
Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2003 12:55 pm 0
Location: Italy
Contact:

Post by ElfQrin »

Evilbeaver wrote: Umm...didn't the Nazis tell the German citizens that the Polish invasion wasn't a preemptive strike, stating that Poland struck first? Didn't Hitler ask Norway and Denmark if he could peacefully occupy them for their protection?
OK, may be invading European countries required a bit more diplomacy than the rest of the world. But you surely didn't need to make up stories to invade African, Asian, or South American countries.

At least, Mussolini's speeches about the "Italian Empire" were very clear. And it wasn't different for UK, France, Spain, Portugal, Belgium...
User avatar
ElfQrin
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4384
Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2003 12:55 pm 0
Location: Italy
Contact:

Post by ElfQrin »

phattslagg wrote: Well, Hiroshima was effectively a 'military' city - there were thousands of soldiers stationed there. Thousands of civiians as well, of course.
Just a little note: Soldiers were everywhere, however Hiroshima and Nagasaki weren't chosen for any particular reason other than their size.

USA could have bombed a major city, including Tokyo itself, but they wouldn't have achieved the psychological effect of destroying a whole city with just one bomb.

phattslagg wrote: My g/f watched a bit of the program about it with me tonight - she remarked that what the Americans did in that instance effectively amounted to terrorism..
Well, according to the FBI definition of terrorism: "Terrorism is the unlawful use of force or violence against persons or property to intimidate or coerce a government, the civilian population, or any segment thereof, in furtherance of political or social objectives."
User avatar
Rev. Stuart Campbell
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3995
Joined: Sun Jan 05, 2003 4:38 pm 0
Location: From Heck

Post by Rev. Stuart Campbell »

ElfQrin wrote: Just a little note: Soldiers were everywhere, however Hiroshima and Nagasaki weren't chosen for any particular reason other than their size.

USA could have bombed a major city, including Tokyo itself, but they wouldn't have achieved the psychological effect of destroying a whole city with just one bomb.
As was detailed on last night's documentary, Hiroshima WAS heaving with soldiers, more so than most Japanese cities. Your second point is partly correct, though - Hiroshima was bombed because it hadn't been bombed before. Huge parts of Tokyo had already been burned to the ground, so it would have been a less effective demonstration of the bomb's power.
"Terrorism is the unlawful use of force or violence against persons or property to intimidate or coerce a government, the civilian population, or any segment thereof, in furtherance of political or social objectives."
There's nothing unlawful about dropping bombs on a nation that's launched an unprovoked attack on you, that you're at officially-declared war with. America IS a terrorist state, by any legal definition, but it wasn't in 1945.
http://wosland.podgamer.com
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
User avatar
Arv
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2274
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 3:46 pm 0
Location: Darkest Lancashire
Contact:

Post by Arv »

in this case, sorry but what the yanks done to the japs at that time in my mind is almost as bad as what hitler was doing.
Lovely people the japs, did you read about Nanking?
SYS 32592
"She's supposed to have transwarp." -- Sulu, "Aye. And if my grandmother had wheels, she'd be a wagon."

http://www.supermagi.com
User avatar
HGFB
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 23575
Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.

Post by HGFB »

Arv wrote:
in this case, sorry but what the yanks done to the japs at that time in my mind is almost as bad as what hitler was doing.
Lovely people the japs, did you read about Nanking?
Oh. I wish I hadn't looked that up now. Very unpleasant.
My bag is called Mr Shitface
User avatar
funkstar
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2069
Joined: Sun Aug 08, 2004 2:56 pm 0
Location: Copenhagen, Denmark

Post by funkstar »

Rev, I'm largely in agreement with your analysis, but I spot a hidden assumption, falsely belittling the american contribution. I agree that as the situation was in spring 1944 (and I'd say this could be drawn back to at least the middle of 1943), american participation in the European war did not have a determining effect on the outcome of the war.

However, I don't agree that we can conclude that the american effort was negligible from this analysis. Russian victory on the eastern front is not only determined by manpower, but also position, weather and supplies. In the case of the eastern front, the weather (most notably the rasputitsa), not manpower, may have played the decisive role. In the fall of 1941, the germans, having captured most of eastern Europe as quickly as they did westen Europe, are bogged down by the twice-yearly seasonal swamp and cannot reach Moscow, which is effectively unprotected in early fall 1941. The late launch of Barbarossa and the harsh rasputitsa of October 1941 both play a vital part in this, and a month more of blitz in both ends could have left the germans in control of Moscow, with an excellent view to having captured the Caucasus (which amounts to taking Stalingrad) by summer 1942. These events could have been achieved but with a delay of perhaps a year, but instead the germans chose (or are forced, I'm not entirely sure which is more correct) to ignore Moscow and head for Stalingrad, leaving themselves in a far more vulnerable situation than they need to, and making the Red Army's superior numbers far more of a advantage than was necessary. This never changes in the remaining course of the war. Thus, by winter 1943-1944, a succesful counteroffensive by the russians into eastern Europe is inevitable.

I think that poor decisions on part of the germans, as well as problematic weather played a far more decisive part in the Russian victory on the eastern front than any intrinsic advantage in manpower. As you said, the russians did not care about losses, but this didn't stop the germans standing at the gates (but a bit too far from) Moscow in fall 1941. Zhukov's famous defense relies crucially on the halting of the german advance in october, an entire month in which he amasses troops and supply them for winter battle (an impressive in any circumstances), both of which (proper reinforcement and equipment) are unavailable to the germans.

So, is the launch of Barbarossa delayed by Britain's unwillingness to be forced to surrender? I'd say so. Is the american supply lines to Britain a factor in this? Yes. It may not have been able to keep Britain unoccupied forever, but it certainly would have prolonged the effort. So in that respect, a 'small' american contribution can be seen to have been decisive.

Feel free to tear me to pieces, but it's all conjecture anyway. Any WW2 book recommendations, btw? I'm considering "The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich"...
User avatar
Rev. Stuart Campbell
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3995
Joined: Sun Jan 05, 2003 4:38 pm 0
Location: From Heck

Post by Rev. Stuart Campbell »

Well, Hitler never wanted to go to war with Britain at all. He was uninterested in the territory of the Empire and regarded the British as - more or less - part of the same Nordic race as the Germans, and sought for the Reich to co-exist with the (somewhat reduced) Empire. His plans to invade the UK were never serious, certainly not after the Battle Of Britain. However, he felt that Britain was investing her hopes in Russia - an enemy with whom he was committed to an ideological reckoning anyway - so defeating the Russians would force Britain to accept peace with the Reich without any further fighting in the West, which is what Hitler wanted both ideologically and militarily.

Undeniably, the Russian autumn and winter played a significant part in the failure to capture Stalingrad, Moscow and Leningrad, and to that end a far more significant event was the coup in Yugoslavia that delayed the start of Barbarossa by a month. But even if all three had been captured or destroyed, it's regarded as highly unlikely by most experts that it would have led to the psychological, political or military collapse of the USSR, which by that point was already considerably outstripping Germany in war production, as well as its advantage in manpower. Most Soviet resources had already been moved east of the Urals by then anyway.

The Germans had estimated at the start of Barbarossa that they faced a total of 160 Russian divisions in the East. By the time the advance ground to a halt outside Moscow, they calculated they'd already engaged roughly 360. The fact is, Barbarossa never stood any realistic chance of success, so massively had the Germans underestimated Russian strength. The impact of Britain and America on it, therefore, was minimal if any.

As for books - "Rise And Fall" is a daunting place to begin, weighing in at something around 2000 pages. I'd recommend something slightly less terrifying as a start point, probably either Martin Gilbert's "Descent Into Barbarism 1933-51", or the previously-mentioned "Hitler: Nemesis 1936-45" by Ian Kershaw. Both are magnificent, comprehensive and detailed works (and enormously depressing, obviously), which cover the entire period in (almost entirely) easy-to-follow chronological order, and are each a more manageable 800-1000 pages. (And if you want to go back a little further, there's the first part of Kershaw's (um) duology, "Hubris 1889-1936".)
http://wosland.podgamer.com
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
User avatar
funkstar
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2069
Joined: Sun Aug 08, 2004 2:56 pm 0
Location: Copenhagen, Denmark

Post by funkstar »

Ok, that seems very reasonable (especially Yogoslavia, which I had forgotten). Anyway, in your opinion, how could Germany have defeated the Soviets in WW2? Barbarossa may have been doomed, but could it have been done?

Thanks for the reading tips, too. Page count is not an issue, but I reckon I'll put off "Rise..." 'till a later time, though I've heard it to be excellent (and, as you say, depressing).

On a related note, I'm saddened to see that William Manchester didn't get to finish his Churchill biografy.
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Post by zip accident »

funkstar wrote:

Barbarossa may have been doomed, but could it have been done?
No.

The RAF was stronger in 1941 than in 1940, so there was no way to clear that flank.

If the war had been delayed until 1942-3, and Britain and France hadn't used the tiime for re-arming, and the Soviets hadn't re-armed either... but that's Fantasy, not Science Fiction.

More Fantasy:- if Germany had spent 1941 re-arming, with no attack on Russia, then went after Britain in 1942, having somehow talked Japan out of attacking the USA, capturing Britain (the government going into exile, probably to Canada). Then attacking Russia in 1943 might have been on, but even so probably not.

There were 2 or maybe, barely, 3 powers in WW2 that could have defeated the entire axis alone. The first two were the USA and USSR, the weakest the British Empire/commonwealth.

The Russians were arming the Chinese against Japan, before the start of WW2 in Europe. Russian planes and Japanese planes were virtually unknown in the west, but they had been used against each other in combat before the war was declared.

Japan chose not to annoy Russia, with good reason.
User avatar
Rev. Stuart Campbell
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3995
Joined: Sun Jan 05, 2003 4:38 pm 0
Location: From Heck

Post by Rev. Stuart Campbell »

zip accident wrote:
funkstar wrote:

Barbarossa may have been doomed, but could it have been done?
No.

The RAF was stronger in 1941 than in 1940, so there was no way to clear that flank.

If the war had been delayed until 1942-3, and Britain and France hadn't used the tiime for re-arming, and the Soviets hadn't re-armed either...
I don't think Barbarossa could have succeeded either, but it's doubtful that the "flank" represented by the Western front (which was basically non-existent from 1941 to 1944 anyway) had any significant bearing on that. As I said earlier, the German deployment there was a pretty small percentage of their fighting strength, and the truth is that they were so massively outnumbered by the Soviets that if moved to the East they would have been a drop in the ocean, chewed up in a matter of weeks.

I used to think that Britain's defiance might have made a crucial difference in late 1941, since the Nazis came so close to capturing (particularly) Stalingrad, and a few more divisions released from the West might have given them it. But the more you look into it, the more you realise how little that would have changed the situation war strategically. Russia's land spaces are so great, and its population so numerous, that there's simply no realistic chance of a nation the size of Germany ever conquering it, given the implacable will to resist of the Russian people and leadership.

As I said, even in late 1941 the Russians were producing tanks and aircraft faster than the Germans, and replacing lost troops much more easily. Factor in the supply difficulties, and the appalling lack of preparation of the German army for the Russian winter, and so on, and it becomes clear just what an impossible task it was. The Nazi war machine was based on speed, and the primitive infrastructure of 1940s Russia - poor dirt roads, bad communication, even the railways were a different gauge to Germany's - was completely at odds with that. The further the Germans got into the country, the longer their supply lines became, the weaker they got.
http://wosland.podgamer.com
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
Post Reply