Selecting the right game engine...

Coders forum. Discuss techniques, swap code snippets, ask for help etc. relating to all forms of software development.
Post Reply
Trufun101
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 40
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2005 6:44 am 0
Contact:

Selecting the right game engine...

Post by Trufun101 »

My friends and I are designing a game, and we're trying to find the right game engine for the job. This is our first project together, so we'd like an engine thats "full-featured", so we can focus on the game itself, and not get caught up in all of the graphics / physics engine crapola.

We started with OgreDotNet, which was nice, but only a partially wrapped version of the regular Ogre SDK. Plus, it was more of a "graphics engine" vs. "game engine" -- there was still *very* much to be completed before actual game programming began.

We're now looking at Torque (the Tribes 2 engine). The indie license is dirt cheap and its got alot of nice features. You've pretty much got an FPS right out of the box. We're not creating an FPS, but I like how the graphics, sound, and network layers are already complete.

My question is...are we limiting ourselves too much by using such a "canned" product -- and are there any other inexpensive game engines worth looking at?

Thanks in advance :wink:
-Chris B.
User avatar
teamonkey
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12082
Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2002 1:07 am 0
XBL Gamertag: itsthetaste
PSN: teamonkey_ca
Contact:

Post by teamonkey »

Torque's alright. It doesn't have to be used for a FPS (c.f. Marble Blast Ultra on the Xbox 360) but it will require less modification (and therefore less work) if your game is a FPS, RTS or third-person game. The biggest strength of Torque is in its networking ability, which is excellent. What sort of game are you planning on doing?

I gather that the basic Torque engine (TGE) is being discontinued, that if you buy it now this will be the last major upgrade you'll get free. It's being superceded by the more expensive Torque Shader Engine (TSE) instead, which is what was used for Marble Blast Ultra and also the forthcoming Tribes-like game that's been mentioned in the news sites today.
Becky Rose
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 114
Joined: Thu Jul 28, 2005 12:44 pm 0

Post by Becky Rose »

I've seen people code great games in DarkBasic Professional, and 'expert' coders make utter rubbish in C++, i've played professional games I thought where sub-freeware in quality, and i've played freeware I would have paid for.

Having the right tools is essential, but at the same time they dont make half as much difference as the team behind the tools. Whatever tool you choose from the current indi crop you can use to make a commercial quality game - they've all been used for this purpose - even DarkBasic Professional which is considered the 'entry level' tool by most indies, and a laughable product by others, can and has produced professional quality results.

My personal choice is Blitz3D. I can find only a few minor faults with it in terms of what I develope: Lack of native forcefeedback support (although there is a 3rd party library); the vertice access commands don't return the right result when using mesh deformation animation, and it doesn't have support for DX9 shaders as it's a DX7 product.

Is it the best tool for the job? Well that's all down to opinion and subjectivity - personaly I like it, but more importantly i've been using it long enough to become quite good with it.

If you dive into a new set of tools don't expect to produce fully fledged high quality output on the first go - you can expect at least a year or two learning how to get the very most out of an engine before you are ready to produce something to a very high standard.

Whilst you are in the position that you cannot produce something to a very high standard - it doesn't really matter what tools you use: I'll be able to show you something written in DarkBasic that will be better than what any novice can produce in *any* tool, Mono and Duo being prime examples - the guy [ fog ] couldn't even draw and admits it, but i'd rather play one of those games than most of the so called shareware dross i've played over the years.
User avatar
failrate
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2354
Joined: Sun May 23, 2004 6:54 am 0
Location: Sandy Eggo
Contact:

Post by failrate »

I notice that you're focussing on 3D engines, innit? While I understand the attraction to 3D games and all, I would definitely advise against it for a first game. Simply put, 3D games are more than an order of magnitude more complex than 2D games. Not only is the rendering more complex than 2D, but collision and rigid-body systems are also much more complex.

On a related note: Simpleton is due for a whole version number upgrade in the next month :twisted:
Trufun101
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 40
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2005 6:44 am 0
Contact:

Post by Trufun101 »

failrate wrote:I notice that you're focussing on 3D engines, innit? While I understand the attraction to 3D games and all, I would definitely advise against it for a first game. Simply put, 3D games are more than an order of magnitude more complex than 2D games. Not only is the rendering more complex than 2D, but collision and rigid-body systems are also much more complex.

On a related note: Simpleton is due for a whole version number upgrade in the next month :twisted:
Thanks failrate. I've done my share of 2D games, so I'm ready for that leap into to 3D. I took an OpenGL class in college, so I've got at least the basics of 3D environments.

We made some simple games in OpenGL, but you had to do EVERYTHING from scratch, right down to mapping textures to each vertex -- which is why we're looking for a game engine that will allow us to focus on content, rather than struggling with 3D math, skinning, and collision detection. :?

So far Torque is looking good. It has its limitations, but is far more usable and "game ready" than Ogre3D.
-Chris B.
User avatar
PaulCunningham
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1218
Joined: Sun Jan 18, 2004 11:47 pm 0
Location: Walsall, England
Contact:

Post by PaulCunningham »

What about the Quake engines?
Cheers,
Paul Cunningham
Pumpkin Games
Trufun101
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 40
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2005 6:44 am 0
Contact:

Post by Trufun101 »

PaulCunningham wrote:What about the Quake engines?
Torque is probably gonna be pretty close to the Quake engines -- it was used for Tribes 2, plus they've got a new shader engine upgrade that beefs up the graphics.
-Chris B.
User avatar
failrate
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2354
Joined: Sun May 23, 2004 6:54 am 0
Location: Sandy Eggo
Contact:

Post by failrate »

Groovy, Trufun. I've been having a bit of fun arsing around with the Blender Game Engine. It's interesting practice, since you can link up logic blocks in sequence without having to write code, but can begin to implement code into your games without any real additional pain.

That said, it's only really good as a learning tool, as it does a few thing ass backwards (like not returning a handle to instantiated objects from it factory actuators... but you can have the object register itself on initialization). From there, it's fairly easy to move to Crystal Space.

However, since you're already opting for the Torque Engine, I'll only encourage you to go do that and report back to us on whether you like it or not. Garage Games are definitely making some moves. I'd like to know if those moves are going in the right direction.
ewok
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 420
Joined: Mon Jul 22, 2002 11:42 am 0
Location: Manchester

Post by ewok »

I've been using the early adopters version of T2D or TGB as it has recently been renamed. So far positive, nice community, fast response to issues and a nice little engine
Post Reply