WiteWulf wrote:
Don't listen to this if you're expecting to hear Primus covering Floyd, you'll be disappointed. It's a faithful, complete, play through of the whole album done by some extremely talented musicians.
I have to admit that I was a little disappointed by this when I first bought it sometime last year, precisely because of misplaced expectations along the lines you mentioned - I guess I was expecting a slappin', tappin' and twangin' "Primus-d up" version of the Floyd, which of course it isn't.
Because of that, I literally listened to it once, then stuck it on the shelf and promptly forgot about it.
In hindsight, this was of course, a bit of a mistake!
Having read your review, I decided to dig it out again, whacked it in iTunes on my work 'puter, and give it another go.
With a different set of expectations, and really giving it a fair go, I've now wound up listening to it a least once every day since.
What I love
is the faithfulness, along with just enough of the "gritty edge" you mentioned to differentiate it and make it a damn fine alternative to The Real Thing.
So thank ye kindly for helping me see the light!
