Just watched HHGTTG (the film)
Just watched HHGTTG (the film)
Hey, this isn't bad at all! It's even quite funny!
I even like Marvin, and that spaceship's funky, and
THE END.
Oh.
I don't remember the first book ending so suddenly. I felt as though I was halfway through the film when it ended.
I even like Marvin, and that spaceship's funky, and
THE END.
Oh.
I don't remember the first book ending so suddenly. I felt as though I was halfway through the film when it ended.
Last edited by Oaf on Sun Apr 16, 2006 7:50 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
- Secret Vampire
- Baaa!

- Posts: 493
- Joined: Wed Nov 09, 2005 12:32 pm 0
- Location: Birmingham
it's worth reading the introduction to the trilogy in 4 (or 5 now, probably) parts for an insight into why it ends so suddenly, the Radio, book and TV versions don't all follow the same timeline, and the film is different again.
That said, the film, though well done, wasn't ideal, it definitely cries out for a sequel, but I doubt we'll see one without any kind of input from DNA.
Right about now, I'm thinking that the Dirk Gently books could make for an excellent couple of films, but I suspect there's even less chance of seeing those.
That said, the film, though well done, wasn't ideal, it definitely cries out for a sequel, but I doubt we'll see one without any kind of input from DNA.
Right about now, I'm thinking that the Dirk Gently books could make for an excellent couple of films, but I suspect there's even less chance of seeing those.
- matt303
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4219
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 3:37 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: matt303uk
- Location: Derbyshire
I just found that most of the film completely lacked comedy timing, most scenes just felt like the actors rattling off their lines. The worst part of this is when deep thought gives the answer, completely under played that. I wonder how much of the comedy timing ended up on the cutting room floor (well computers trash can) in a desperate attempt to keep it to 90mins. I've got it on DVD but haven't been able to bring myself to watch it a second time.
In fact thinking about it the story is about what they covered in 3 episodes in the BBC series so with a cleaner story line (drop the John Malkovich stuff) and directors that understand comedy it could have been good. Thank goodness they are NOT making another.
In fact thinking about it the story is about what they covered in 3 episodes in the BBC series so with a cleaner story line (drop the John Malkovich stuff) and directors that understand comedy it could have been good. Thank goodness they are NOT making another.
It does wind me up that poor old Douglas Adams spent a large chunk of his life trying to get a film version of THHGTTG made, then as soon as he pops his clogs they go and make this half-baked effort. 
"I am a very considerate person. If I want to go out all night on my miniature golf course and shoot lizards, well, no reason to keep the neighbours awake..."
...it was interesting to sit through the credits, and see the various things they give credit to. the douglas adams (head) shaped planet is from a computer game I seem to recall.
It wasn't a bad film, sure the comic timing was off a little, but then i'm sure there's people who said the TV show wasn't a patch on the radio show...and the radio show wasn' as good as the books etc.
I've never heard the radio show, but I think the TV show would have always taken some beating.
At least they did the improbability drive justice. Bill Bailey voicing the whale was funny too...
It wasn't a bad film, sure the comic timing was off a little, but then i'm sure there's people who said the TV show wasn't a patch on the radio show...and the radio show wasn' as good as the books etc.
I've never heard the radio show, but I think the TV show would have always taken some beating.
At least they did the improbability drive justice. Bill Bailey voicing the whale was funny too...
It was rushed, and certainly patchy. Budget issues I think.
But still I found it a fantastic film overall and not the travesty some called it. It comes accross as exactly what it is too me;
A half-made piece of Adams finnished by lesser skilled hands.
Btw, heres a nice flash animation someone did;
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/305260
But still I found it a fantastic film overall and not the travesty some called it. It comes accross as exactly what it is too me;
A half-made piece of Adams finnished by lesser skilled hands.
Btw, heres a nice flash animation someone did;
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/305260
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- cyric100
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2316
- Joined: Thu Apr 25, 2002 5:51 pm 0
- Location: My underwater lair at Monterey bay
I think the timing is only part of it. I watched most of it again the other week and found myself thinking that the script really wasn't as bad as I'd first thought, but the delivery of some lines was wrong. Timing was part of that but also the intonation and emotion seemed wrong for the lines themselves and detracted from the intrinsic humour within.Waler wrote: It wasn't a bad film, sure the comic timing was off a little
I find myself blaming the director for not making as much of the movie as they could. As though they didn't understand why the line was funny in the context of the person giving it. Could be just me though...
Still, pleasant enough to watch but not a classic by any means.
No time for heartache, no time to run and hide,
no time for breaking down, no time to cry.
no time for breaking down, no time to cry.




