If You Believe We Put A Man On The Moon
If You Believe We Put A Man On The Moon
... then nothing is cool?
Just finished reading MOONDUST by Andrew Smith. Really enjoyed it. It basically starts with the premise that only 12 men walked on the moon, and only 9 are left now - soon there will be none. So the author sets out to interview them all and see how their journey affected them.
Without giving too much away, it explores the hoax theories, and two moments of note for me:
1. Bart Sibrel, an arch hoax believer, has been trying to get all nine moonwalkers to swear on the bible that they actually went. He is quite aggressive about this, and when he tries it with Buzz Aldrin, gets a smack in the mouth for his troubles.
2. The hoaxists believe that the "films" were directed on behalf of NASA by Stanley Kubrick, whose last film was "Eyes Wide Shut". Kubrick died before it was released, but had it written into the contract that the film would be released exactly 30 years to the day since the first moon landing. Wierd, huh?
So, inspired by a certain other conspiracy thread, I thought that I would ask you lot - Do you believe, we put a man (well, actually, 12) on the moon? Michael Stipe doesn't seem to think so!
For me - certainly. I love Apollo, and the thing that swings it for me is that the whole Apollo programme was designed to humiliate the Soviets. If Apollo just remained in low orbit, why did the Russians keep quiet for 30 years?
Just finished reading MOONDUST by Andrew Smith. Really enjoyed it. It basically starts with the premise that only 12 men walked on the moon, and only 9 are left now - soon there will be none. So the author sets out to interview them all and see how their journey affected them.
Without giving too much away, it explores the hoax theories, and two moments of note for me:
1. Bart Sibrel, an arch hoax believer, has been trying to get all nine moonwalkers to swear on the bible that they actually went. He is quite aggressive about this, and when he tries it with Buzz Aldrin, gets a smack in the mouth for his troubles.
2. The hoaxists believe that the "films" were directed on behalf of NASA by Stanley Kubrick, whose last film was "Eyes Wide Shut". Kubrick died before it was released, but had it written into the contract that the film would be released exactly 30 years to the day since the first moon landing. Wierd, huh?
So, inspired by a certain other conspiracy thread, I thought that I would ask you lot - Do you believe, we put a man (well, actually, 12) on the moon? Michael Stipe doesn't seem to think so!
For me - certainly. I love Apollo, and the thing that swings it for me is that the whole Apollo programme was designed to humiliate the Soviets. If Apollo just remained in low orbit, why did the Russians keep quiet for 30 years?
Re: If You Believe We Put A Man On The Moon
It's like using a cross against a vampire: it only works if he's Christian.Zoot wrote: 1. Bart Sibrel, an arch hoax believer, has been trying to get all nine moonwalkers to swear on the bible that they actually went.
Of course they are fake, have you seen the pictures?
http://www.stuffucanuse.com/fake_moon_l ... ndings.htm
http://www.stuffucanuse.com/fake_moon_l ... ndings.htm
Been round this road so many times
Feel like it's skin is part of mine
This taste of milk is almost gone
Still got my shame, but not for long
Been wrong so many times before
But never quite like this
Heard all, in the rain
But the rain all turned to piss
Feel like it's skin is part of mine
This taste of milk is almost gone
Still got my shame, but not for long
Been wrong so many times before
But never quite like this
Heard all, in the rain
But the rain all turned to piss
- RedOktober
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4788
- Joined: Sun Sep 04, 2005 11:15 pm 0
- Location: Stalin's Organ
- Contact:
Clangers!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Nuff sed
Nuff sed
Commit acts of random kindness and senseless beauty.
Avatar: Autumn Magic
http://www.amybrownart.com/
Avatar: Autumn Magic
http://www.amybrownart.com/
The hoaxists claim that shadows are falling in the wrong direction in relation to the sun. In fact, light hits the moon directly from the sun, and is also reflected back from Earth. Also, there are some big fuck-off mountains on the moon (3 miles high) that can do strange things with light.Spoongod wrote:I don't caer, I just like the idea that we did and hope to fuck it's true despite the inconsitancies. I've not idea how extra terrestrial light would fall and the wossname radiation belt i a big maybe but I'd like a moon-base please so I'm hoping it's real...
http://www.badastronomy.com/bad/tv/foxapollo.html

Edit: oh, sorry, yes: Moondust is a wonderful book.
Edit: oh, sorry, yes: Moondust is a wonderful book.
Last edited by F-ZeroOne on Mon May 22, 2006 6:41 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Actually, I believe he tried to sue Aldrin. The judge dismissed the claim fairly sharpish.Zoot wrote:Indeed - I did tooYak wrote:I read that book on the way to e3, and I did a LOL when I got to the bit about Buzz chinning that nutter.
Fair do's to the Sibrel guy, mind, for taking his medicine and not moaning.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Oh, I've just noticed we were asked if we believe in the Moon landings. Yes, I do. Theres all kinds of arguments that could be made - the link I posted earlier has several - but my personal one is that, to the best of my knowledge, no-one has ever tried to claim that a Saturn-V launch was faked.
Even if you believe the Lunar module was made out of a tin-foil covered washing-up bottle, the Saturn V was the most complicated machine humankind has probably ever built (it had so many parts that even with a 99% reliabilty rate, that still meant any of 10,000 things could go wrong), and once one was launched - compared to the overall cost of building the things in the first place - you are effectively not spending money anymore.
Even if you believe the Lunar module was made out of a tin-foil covered washing-up bottle, the Saturn V was the most complicated machine humankind has probably ever built (it had so many parts that even with a 99% reliabilty rate, that still meant any of 10,000 things could go wrong), and once one was launched - compared to the overall cost of building the things in the first place - you are effectively not spending money anymore.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.






