Roobarb wrote:I'm downloading Ubuntu and Fedora and whichever recognises more hardware and lets me configure the wireless LAN without screaming wins

Should be interesting: wireless can be a problem for just about any Linux system, depending on the chipset involved. Not a failing of Linux, as such, just down to certain vendors not wanting to reveal the "trade secrets".
Roobarb wrote:Dungeon-Dave wrote:I'd have thought that was a positive ADVANTAGE of Linux; you pick one that suits your purpose best... in the same way that you pick a certain platform of Windows.
Choice is good, but only if you can sensibly make a decision between the choices, and there are meaningful differences between them.
Yes, and there are too many different car manufacturers. They all seem to do roughly the same thing. How am I supposed to choose between them when there are no meaningful differences. If only they would all work together on just one car then by now I'd be able to drive at 500 miles per hour, and get a gazillion miles on a single teaspoon of sugar (with a little help from Mr. Fusion).
Sorry to be facetious, I do understand where you're coming from, but I'd rather have a little choice even if it does mean that there's some overlap between the different distros. They don't all do the same thing, and they don't all work the same way - it's just that the things that differentiate them aren't always obvious until you know a bit more about Linux (apt vs. yum, for example).
Having multiple vendors offering essentially the same thing isn't a bad thing at all. It leads to healthy competition. It lets them differentiate on more than just the basic software (what support is offered, whether they include proprietary software, etc.)
Roobarb wrote:a) hobby horses
Yes, there's a certain amount of this that goes on - but why shouldn't there be? If a developer wants to make their own distribution, then let them: if it doesn't offer anything new or interesting then it won't gain much "market share" and will remain the developer's niche toy. No harm done.
Roobarb wrote:b) getting popular and selling a pay-for business on 'enterprise versions'
Shock! Horror! Won't somebody think of the children! How dare these developers actually want to sell something.
FWIW not all distributions are aiming to get rich quick by selling "enterprise versions". This is one of the factors that differentiates between distributions.
Roobarb wrote:Anyway, i know many of the developers on these distros offer their services for free, and i don't want to knock that, but it just strikes me that Linux would be in a much better position to be a viable alternative to Windows on the desktop if they all just pulled in the same direction

Ah, the classic misunderstanding about Linux. Yes I'm sure that there are some developers who want to take over the desktop, but most of them just want the desktop to be good enough for their own use. If that means that installing codecs is a little fiddly, then so be it. Until everyone uses open formats for all their files (which will probably never happen) then there will always be legal hurdles which make it hard to have a "viable alternative to Windows" whilst also allowing free downloads.
If you want a legal Windows alternative, complete with a full range of codecs, then you have to accept that there is a licence fee to be paid on some of those codecs in many countries - most notably the USA. That's fine: some of the for-profit Linux distributions ship with the codecs in place for you.
But if you want to download a distribution free of charge, you have to accept that they can't afford to take the legal gamble of including non-free codecs. Sure, you can install them after the fact - but then it's you who's taking the legal gamble, not the Linux vendors.
The other problem with providing a "viable alternative to Windows" is, of course, hardware support. For this you can blame the manufacturers who won't release sufficient documentation for the developers to write their own drivers. Again, the Linux vendors can only go so-far to support undocumented hardware. The answer here is to (try to) buy hardware from Linux-friendly manufacturers, but if you want to download a free distro and use it with some arbitrary hardware that you just happen to have lying around then I think you can consider yourself lucky if the thing works at all.
But don't assume that every Linux developer is trying to create a "viable alternative to Windows" anyway. "Linux" isn't a single company with a single aim. Some groups within the Linux world want to produce a viable desktop offering. Others don't give a damn about the desktop. Yet others still want to produce a desktop but don't think the Windows GUI is the right option.
Getting all those developers, each with their different ideas, and trying to make them all work on a single Linux distribution would be a recipe for disaster and would probably slow development down considerably. Letting them split apart into different groups, to play, to try things out, and to share their results is a much better idea.