Recommend a Linux distribution for a non-techie?

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
User avatar
Roobarb
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1451
Joined: Mon Nov 14, 2005 2:37 pm 0
Location: Blighty

Post by Roobarb »

Like i said earlier:
Anyway, i know many of the developers on these distros offer their services for free, and i don't want to knock that, but it just strikes me that Linux would be in a much better position to be a viable alternative to Windows on the desktop if they all just pulled in the same direction.
If my rant came across as nasty, i apologise. I have a great deal of admiration for the developers who offer their time on OSS projects. It's fundamentally just a little venting of spleen that a lot of that work seems to ignore areas where OSS could really make a difference to more than a select community of technically minded people.
User avatar
Acronym
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3982
Joined: Wed Feb 19, 2003 8:18 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: andrew_walkingshaw
Contact:

Post by Acronym »

Roobarb wrote:Like i said earlier:
Anyway, i know many of the developers on these distros offer their services for free, and i don't want to knock that, but it just strikes me that Linux would be in a much better position to be a viable alternative to Windows on the desktop if they all just pulled in the same direction.
If my rant came across as nasty, i apologise. I have a great deal of admiration for the developers who offer their time on OSS projects. It's fundamentally just a little venting of spleen that a lot of that work seems to ignore areas where OSS could really make a difference to more than a select community of technically minded people.
Unless you pay people, they'll write code for their own ends and interests, and even then it's a management issue. Ubuntu is the best of a bad lot in this regard.
User avatar
tufty
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12524
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 4:52 pm 0
Location: French Alps

Post by tufty »

Roobarb wrote:They've also made sure that their customers don't need to read a Haynes manual for them to use the thing properly, they keep the steering wheel and pedals in the same place, and they don't require you to refine your own sodding custom petrol formulation to make the thing go.
Sure. On the other hand, you are generally expected to know how to drive your vehicle before taking it on the road. There is what I consider an unrealistic expectation that you should be able to just take a computer and make it do magical things without knowing a blind thing about it. This is patently not the case when this, largely techie, forum has almost daily "Hayyyyylp! How do I make (insert OS) do this?" threads.

So yes, Windows might be an "easier" system for a complete newbie to use. But it's only hiding the complexities that we all know lurk just beneath the surface. Linux et al don't hide that complexity as well, making the initial step a daunting one - hell when I first used unix (back in - umm - 1986 or so, well before this "linux" thing was even thought of, we had a week's "using unix" training, and this was for people who were already programmers). Once you get to grips with a unix-alike system, though, you'll be able to do more and faster than you ever could with the dumbed down interface that Windows provides.

Still, hey, I'm a geek, and a :macwanker: to boot, so what do I know?
The success of the LAMP solution stack clearly shows the benefits of having a de facto standard.
Hah. Hah. Hah. Benefits my big hairy cock.

LAMP consists of:
  • Linux - Okay, a relatively stable kernel as long as you get a "good" one for your particular hardware mix, but it's hardly the most secure of beasts, despite the hype, particularly because most distros seem to intall everything under the sun "in case you need it" (although this is getting somewhat better, at least they don't tend to have telnet connections by default these days)
  • Apache - pretty good, pretty secure, but getting a bit fat and slow these days. Tuning apache is a black art in of itself.
  • MySQL - Toy RDBMS. Shit on this from a great height.
  • PHP - It's a bit like a programming language, I suppose. In the same way that MySQL is a bit like a RDBMS.
So, what we actually have in that particular de-facto standard is two bits of stuff that are pretty good but not best-of-breed and two bits of candied-shit-on-a-stick that are prevalent "because everyone uses them". No real design has gone into making these things work together. It can be made to work well, but there's an awful lot of gotchas - phpBB is arguably the poster-boy for (at least the MP part of) the LAMP "stack", but it's well known for being full of security holes, and if I'm not wrong is a bit of a bitch to administer.

I would argue that a better "stack" for an application server would be:
  • (open|free|net)BSD (more secure, more stable, less crap installed by default, easier to sysadmin)
  • lighttpd (faster and less "hungry" than apache, easier to set up for https, just as capable for most things)
  • postgresql (it's a real RDBMS)
  • Anything but PHP (Ruby on Rails is my current favourite, but Perl is good and at least as object oriented as PHP, there's good stuff being done in python, etc)
Of course it's not directly relevant to the "desktop" argument, of course, but choice is always a good thing. Choice drives competition drives innovation. The "de facto standard" is not always the best.

On the other hand, you're right that the linux market is fractured, almost terminally so - there's too many distributions that are not quite compatible with each other, hell, I ran Suse for a while and never worked out why kernel.org kernels wouldn't work properly with the Suse runtime. there's 2 major desktop environments, whose development teams are seemingly at each other's throats over trivia, that doesn't help. Frankly I hated them both with a vengeance, way too lardy, but I come from a "raw X" background and tend to run linux/bsd on stuff that's frankly underpowered by today's standards, so that's to be expected.

It's also way overhyped as a "windows killer". It's not, because it hasn't dumbed down to the requisite level yet.

So, yeah, go ahead. Pay Redmond your eejit tax, install Windows and settle yourself in for a lifetime of panicked "Can you come and sort out the 200 viruses I've got on my machine" and "Windows doesn't recognise my hard drive any more" calls. Or teach the person concerned a little about what a computer is for, how it works, and how to ask the questions they need to ask to know when they are having problems, then install them a relatively light Linux.

"Give a man a fish, you have fed him for today. Teach him to fish, and the bastard'll be poaching the koi out of your pond as soon as your back's turned."

Oh, hang on. That's not right.

Simon
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
User avatar
Acronym
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3982
Joined: Wed Feb 19, 2003 8:18 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: andrew_walkingshaw
Contact:

Post by Acronym »

I know this crops up in every thread, but there's a reason you see so many Macs around heavyweight Unix folks these days, and it's the sheer cussedness of Linux as a desktop OS.

It's been 'not ready for primetime' since 1998. :)
Will
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 115
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 1:20 pm 0

Post by Will »

Roobarb wrote: After spending a short amount of time with Ubuntu, that's the conclusion i came to as well.
Hardly the basis of a fair comparison is it? It took weeks for me to adjust to Mac OS X. It felt awkward and counter intuitive, but that was only because of the fact I was more used to Windows and Linux. Now I love it and find it the easiest to use.
Roobarb wrote:.Then i had a look to see what steps she'd have to go to to install software: "Open a terminal window and type in: sudo apt-get install <package>". Not exactly point and click, and how's she supposed to know what packages are available? What if she wants to install something that isn't an ubuntu package? I'm sure it's all possible, but it's not user-friendly.
Acutally, there is a point and click way of installing software. It alllows you to search for packages by name and description. You can also browse through categories. Tick the software you want installed and away you go. A very quick and easy way to find and install all sorts of software for free. All there in the default menus, if you had bothered to take the time to look.
Roobarb wrote: So basically Linux is created by geeks for geeks. Well that's great for geeks, but fuck all use to the vast majority of PC users in this world.
Thats very unfair, there's a lot of people working very hard to deliver a Linux desktop usable for Joe Bloggs. It may not be there yet, but it ain't exactly a small task either. Abd its certainly a lot better than "fuck all use".
Roobarb wrote: If Linux developers want more hardware manufacturer involvement, then the solution is simple: make your software more appealing to the mass market who are actually going to make it worthwhile for the hardware manufacturers by buying enough units.
Of course, part of making software more appealling is getting better hardware support. Its chicken and egg I'm afraid. Writing drivers without the specs isn't easy.

I'll certainly agree that if Linux doesn't support all your hardware, it can be a total pain in the arse. But if it all works out of the box, and mine does, then I find Linux a lot easier to use than Windows.

I'm sure for a lot of people Windows is the better choice. But a large percentage of the percieved superior usability simply comes from the fact people are more used to the Microsoft OS. Sure, criticise Linux, but make sure your criticism is fair.
User avatar
tufty
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12524
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 4:52 pm 0
Location: French Alps

Post by tufty »

Acronym wrote:I know this crops up in every thread, but there's a reason you see so many Macs around heavyweight Unix folks these days, and it's the sheer cussedness of Linux as a desktop OS.

It's been 'not ready for primetime' since 1998. :)
True, but it is an awful lot closer in many respects than it was back then. Let's look at what was being bitched about:
. For some reason the default volume control seems to have been configured by Spinal Tap. Turn volume down? No idea. There's a sound control applet, but it doesn't seem to include a volume setting.
That's sucky. I'll admit that, it's probably an OSS drivers verses ALSA drivers issue or something equally cock.
Install a wireless LAN card? Fat chance! Looking into it, getting linux drivers from many manufacturers is pretty tough. I could apparently pay $20 for some third party software that allows you to use Windows device drivers, or mess around with some free NDIS wrapper. I decided at that point i had better things to do with my time.
Ummm. Largely speaking, I've found this to be untrue. It may be a "bit tricky" to find the drivers (often you have to go back to the chipset manufacturer rather than the vendor itself), but I've yet to find a wireless card that didn't have linux drivers. Not so for OSX, oddly enough, although that's getting better these days. NDISWrapper is pretty easy to set up if you can't find the drivers, and works well enough.
Install a printer or camera: same story.
The gutenprint stuff supports pretty much every printer out there with the exception of a few windows-only printers and some oddballs (like the Dell ones we were discussing last week). Cameras show up as USB mass storage devices unless they are deliberately crippled not to do so - I've not seen a digital camera that wouldn't talk to linux yet.
Then i had a look to see what steps she'd have to go to to install software: "Open a terminal window and type in: sudo apt-get install <package>". Not exactly point and click, and how's she supposed to know what packages are available? What if she wants to install something that isn't an ubuntu package? I'm sure it's all possible, but it's not user-friendly.
That's a "read the fucking recommendations" issue, ISTR there being a link to a graphical package installer for ubuntu in this very thread.

So. One bug which is probably a misconfiguration, but admittedly annoying.
One "have to hunt around a bit for drivers", or actually do something to make them work.
And then "fuckit, I give up".

Like I said before, though, I'm a macwanker and proud of it, and haven't used linux on the desktop since 2001. And my few remaining linux driven servers are being EOLed and replaced by netras running freeBSD. I don't overly like administering linux. But that's me.

Simon
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
User avatar
xav
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2455
Joined: Thu Jun 06, 2002 5:32 pm 0
Location: Bucks, UK
Contact:

Post by xav »

I know I shouldn't bite, but I guess I'm a sucker for punishment...
Roobarb wrote:It installed OK, but went downhill from there:
. For some reason the default volume control seems to have been configured by Spinal Tap. Turn volume down? No idea. There's a sound control applet, but it doesn't seem to include a volume setting.
Applications=>Sound & Video=>Volume Control (on the Ubuntu 5.10 install I'm using at the moment)

Alternatively there's a volume applet on my menu bar. I can't recall if I added that myself or not, but I think it was already there by default. It looks like a speaker. Click on it for the volume control, right-click for options.

Roobarb wrote:Install a wireless LAN card? Fat chance! Looking into it, getting linux drivers from many manufacturers is pretty tough. I could apparently pay $20 for some third party software that allows you to use Windows device drivers, or mess around with some free NDIS wrapper. I decided at that point i had better things to do with my time.
Fair enough, I suspected this would be where you would fall down. I blame the manufacturers for not releasing documentation, but I gather from the rest of your post that you don't.
Roobarb wrote:Install a printer or camera: same story.
My printer is on my network. I just had to enter its IP and choose the printer manufacturer and model. I've also installed various USB and parallel printers by just plugging them in and letting the printer configuration program auto-detect them. I've only come across one printer that I couldn't get to work, so far.

My camera was plugged into the USB socket, and worked immediately.

That's not to say that it's always easy, I'll grant you - but from experience I know that it's not always easy with Windows or MacOS either.
Roobarb wrote:Then i had a look to see what steps she'd have to go to to install software: "Open a terminal window and type in: sudo apt-get install <package>". Not exactly point and click,
I go to Applications=>Add Applications, and choose them (by pointing and clicking) from the long list that's there. I think this has been renamed in 6.06 to "Add/Remove Software" or something similar.

If I want some software that's not in the list then I choose the "Advanced" option to open "Synaptic". It's a more powerful package manager, but I still point and click with the mouse.

Very, very rarely do I need to open a terminal to install new software - and that tends to be more advanced stuff that your everyday user wouldn't be adding anyway. (As an aside, I know that steps are being made to remove the need for the terminal, even for adding packages that aren't officially supported; unfortunately the UI for that work didn't make it to the 6.06 release, but should be present in the next version)
Roobarb wrote:and how's she supposed to know what packages are available?
How do you know what Windows software is available? Or MacOS? With Ubuntu you do get a list of the software in the official repositories, and can install them with a couple of clicks of the mouse. I've never seen such a list for Windows at all.
Roobarb wrote:What if she wants to install something that isn't an ubuntu package? I'm sure it's all possible, but it's not user-friendly.
I've enabled the semi-official repositories on my copy of Ubuntu (requires a few mouse clicks, that's all). Synaptic now lists over 17,000 packages. Believe me, that covers most of the main programs that a user would want to install.

As for any other software - well, the same is true in the Windows world. Not every program has a friendly installer (let alone an uninstaller), but the ones that don't tend to be niche products that most users wouldn't be installing anyway.
Roobarb wrote:
xav wrote:Ah, the classic misunderstanding about Linux. Yes I'm sure that there are some developers who want to take over the desktop, but most of them just want the desktop to be good enough for their own use. If that means that installing codecs is a little fiddly, then so be it.
So basically Linux is created by geeks for geeks. Well that's great for geeks, but fuck all use to the vast majority of PC users in this world.
That's not what I was saying at all. I was simply pointing out that just because you want it to be everything that Windows is, plus a little bit more, doesn't necessarily make it so. It is good enough for a lot of people - and they're not necessarily all geeks (I've had a lot of success installing it for non-geeks who just want to write emails and surf the web without having to worry about viruses'n'shit). It might not be good enough for you, or your friend, or your mother's postman's aunt, but that doesn't necessarily reflect a failing in Linux, just a mismatch between what it does and what you want it to do.

Roobarb wrote:
xav wrote:The other problem with providing a "viable alternative to Windows" is, of course, hardware support. . For this you can blame the manufacturers who won't release sufficient documentation for the developers to write their own drivers
Actually, no, i'll blame the same people who are only interested in creating an OS for their own purposes. I think it's perfectly reasonable for a hardware manufacturer to be very circumspect about god knows who writing drivers for their hardware with no formal QA in place.
You started this thread by asking which version of Linux you should use. You didn't start it by asking which vendors' products you should buy to get the best Linux support.

If a product won't work under Linux due to lack of documentation, then I blame the vendors. It's their right to do that, of course, but in that case they probably wouldn't be recommended as a good vendor for a Linux system.

However if you start with the premise of "I've got some hardware already" then the question of whether or not it will run under Linux is largely down to the amount of documentation the vendor supplies.
Roobarb wrote:If Linux developers want more hardware manufacturer involvement, then the solution is simple: make your software more appealing to the mass market who are actually going to make it worthwhile for the hardware manufacturers by buying enough units.
Catch-22. Without hardware support it will never be more appealing to the mass market, in which case by your argument it doesn't deserve to get hardware support.

The solution to this isn't for manufacturers to write drivers for Linux - because then the BSD people will complain, or the Amiga people, or whatever. The solution is for them to provide sufficient documentation for the Open Source community to provide their own drivers.

Roobarb wrote:Modern car manufacturers may not be producing cars running at 500 miles per hour on a teaspoon of sugar, but they are producing more reliable, less polluting, more efficient, more comfortable, more spacious, safer, more secure cars with a great deal more electronic entertainment and convenience features than ever before, so i'd say it's been a pretty successful way of doing things.
Modern Open Source programmers may not be producing software that matches Windows in some areas, but they are producing less virus-prone, faster, more powerful operating systems which improve on an almost daily basis, so I'd say it's been a pretty successful way of doing things.

The point being that getting all the car manufacturers to work together is no more likely to get you a supercar than getting all the Open Source programmers to work together will get you a direct replacement for Windows.

The improvements to cars haven't all come from the same company: diversity and competition is a good thing for driving innovation. The same applies in the programming world. You might not like the diversity, but as a Gnome user I'd be annoyed if I had to do things the KDE way, and vice versa. There are so many choices because there's a demand for so much choice amongst the existing user base. It might not be the best way to attract new users, but I'd argue that hanging on to the ones you've already got is just as important, if not moreso because in this case they're also the people developing the stuff.

Roobarb wrote:Your average person is prepared to spare a bit of thought on their new car as it represents a significant purchase for them both cost-wise and lifestyle-wise. On the other hand, they don't give a stuff about the niceties of computer operating systems, so all those (non-commercial) distros are purely for the benefit of Linux fanboys.
Or more likely they don't give a stuff about niceties of computer operating systems so they use whatever came with the box when they bought it. All those distros, commercial or not, are for the benefit of people who have gone looking for them - which implies that they do give a stuff about their operating system (or that they're not prepared to drop the cash for Windows, but are more than happy to moan when the software they've paid nothing for doesn't work in exactly the way they think it should).

Roobarb wrote:I have no problem with fanboys doing whatever turns them on, and ignoring the needs of the mass market, but in that case they should quit moaning about the lack of hardware manufacturer support
See my comments above: I wasn't moaning about the lack of hardware manufacturer support, I was just pointing out that your arbitrary hardware may not work due to lack of documentation. If you want all the hardware to work 100% then you should buy it from manufacturers who support Open Source with suitable documentation - but that's not how this thread started, is it.
Roobarb wrote:and stop trying to hype 'Linux' as an alternative to Windows for the average PC user
Erm... you asked us, remember? I don't think any of us tried to hype 'Linux' as an alternative to Windows for the average PC user - in fact I think we were quite honest about its shortcomings.
Co-creator of The Greys, Monsters, Inked & Elvie webcomics
• Web Site • Twitter • Patreon •
User avatar
Dungeon-Dave
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3925
Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2005 12:01 pm 0
Location: UK
Contact:

Post by Dungeon-Dave »

Roobarb wrote:So basically Linux is created by geeks for geeks. Well that's great for geeks, but fuck all use to the vast majority of PC users in this world.
I hear this a lot on IRC: the Windows people telling me that Linux has no place, that they'd never use it, that it's provides nothing that Windows doesn't etc...

It's really ironic that they're connecting to an IRC network run on Linux servers (we won't allow a Windows-based IRC server to link). Factor in that their websites are running off Apache under Linux, and their email is filtered and delivered using postfix and sendmail, plus the Unreal Tournament servers are all running Linux - yet none of these are fuck all use to the windows-installed PC owners...

I honestly believe that nobody *really* opted to use Windows. The vast majority of PC users bought a PC, and found Windows installed on it, and just grew accustomed to it, learning differences with newer releases. If a store started dropping some Linux distro onto their PCs and people had never experienced Windows, they'd grow just as accustomed.

Coming from a Unix background, I found Windows very limited (and still do). Coming from a Windows background, others will find Unix harsh and not as idiot-friendly as Windows. It is simply two different mind-sets.
I have no problem with fanboys doing whatever turns them on, and ignoring the needs of the mass market, but in that case they should quit moaning about the lack of hardware manufacturer support, and stop trying to hype 'Linux' as an alternative to Windows for the average PC user. And quit telling me Open Source is for the good of (wo)mankind.
Agreed. Although I'm a *nix geek, I despise the fanboyism amongst the *nix camps almost as bad as the Winfans. It's an OS, for ${deity}'s sake. Just USE the fucking thing, and stop audiowanking into my MP3space. I know how good and how shite they are in equal measures: verbal masturbation doesn't improve my opinion.
Acronym wrote:ASR? Get out more, man. :)
What's your forum account? *clickety-click*
User avatar
Bubba
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10013
Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2003 12:52 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: BubbaFatAss
PSN: BubbaFatAs
Location: Cambridge

Post by Bubba »

Dungeon-Dave wrote:I hear this a lot on IRC: the Windows people telling me that Linux has no place, that they'd never use it, that it's provides nothing that Windows doesn't etc...

It's really ironic that they're connecting to an IRC network run on Linux servers (we won't allow a Windows-based IRC server to link). Factor in that their websites are running off Apache under Linux, and their email is filtered and delivered using postfix and sendmail, plus the Unreal Tournament servers are all running Linux - yet none of these are fuck all use to the windows-installed PC owners...
Thing is, it's quite different from an end user using Linux as an operating system, or the services that are provided by Linux. I have pretty much no desire or reason to use Linux. I'm quite happy with Windows on my desktop for coding with, and when I need to dip into the world of unix I can use mac os :). Like linux but end user friendly :). Linux distributions are getting better and better, especially things like Ubuntu. Yet I still find myself coming back to Windows / Mac OS every time. It just does everything I need it to, including many things on your list up there ;). Maybe that makes me "the idiot brigade", but I've fiddled with Linux a fair bit for many years and have yet to jump ship :).
Dungeon-Dave wrote:I honestly believe that nobody *really* opted to use Windows. The vast majority of PC users bought a PC, and found Windows installed on it, and just grew accustomed to it, learning differences with newer releases. If a store started dropping some Linux distro onto their PCs and people had never experienced Windows, they'd grow just as accustomed.
Yeah, I think it's fair to say that this is gradually becoming true with friendly distros like Ubuntu. However, one thing that really kicks end users is the sheer amount of releases. Looking at something like Ubuntu there seems to be new releases quite frequently. Does anyone happen to know if there's an option to enable autoupdates, Windows style that'll check for new releases and apply them automatically. IMHO it's these kind of features that separate Windows from Linux when it comes to end users...

Now some smart arse will point out that this features been in Ubuntu for ever or something :D

Cheers

Bubba
||Work || Flickr||
User avatar
xav
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2455
Joined: Thu Jun 06, 2002 5:32 pm 0
Location: Bucks, UK
Contact:

Post by xav »

Bubba wrote:Does anyone happen to know if there's an option to enable autoupdates, Windows style that'll check for new releases and apply them automatically. IMHO it's these kind of features that separate Windows from Linux when it comes to end users...

Now some smart arse will point out that this features been in Ubuntu for ever or something :D
This feature has been in Ubuntu for ever (well, at the very least for the past couple of releases).

It automatically prompts you when there are updates to your current system, with the option for security updates to take place automatically in the background without prompting you. It's similar to Windows Update, except that it covers everything in the Ubuntu repositories (and any others you've added), so it's like Windows Update if WU also updated Firefox, OpenOffice, The GIMP, and most of the other non-Microsoft programs you might have installed.

In the past upgrading to new releases of Ubuntu (the equivalent of upgrading from Win95 to 98, or 2000 to XP) required you to point the update tool at the new repositories. The easiest way to do this was to replace the repository name wherever it occurred in the configuration file - it was as simple as a search and replace to put "dapper" in place of "breezy", for example.

With the latest version, however, upgrading to a new release is also handled by the update manager. When the new release goes live an additional button will appear in the GUI: pressing it will perform the upgrade.

For more details, see this blog entry, although note that step 1 is only required because the new version isn't out yet (the -d switch lets the update manager also consider development releases). I believe that when the new release is out this button will appear without the need to do that.

Something tells me that upgrading XP to Vista will require a little more than clicking a single button :wink:
Co-creator of The Greys, Monsters, Inked & Elvie webcomics
• Web Site • Twitter • Patreon •
User avatar
Roobarb
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1451
Joined: Mon Nov 14, 2005 2:37 pm 0
Location: Blighty

Post by Roobarb »

xav wrote:Erm... you asked us, remember? I don't think any of us tried to hype 'Linux' as an alternative to Windows for the average PC user - in fact I think we were quite honest about its shortcomings.
Yes that's very true, and i've undoubtedly come across as an ungrateful git. So, er sorry about that :(

With the last paragraph of that rant i was thinking of the 'linux rocks. windows sucks. we should all use linux. Support linux now!!" type of comments that you tend to see in a lot of letters pages and comments sections shortly after another windows vulnerability is reported. It wasn't aimed at anyone kind enough to contribute to this thread. Like you say, everyone was very upfront about the pros and cons. I wasn't clear at all there really.

As to my mini trial with ubuntu, my main aim was to assess its suitability for someone who is familiar with windows, given that they use it at work, but not interested in technology for it's own sake. They're not going to be interested in spending hours working out what widget's moved where from what they're used to, and hunting for drivers, let alone choosing hardware based on driver support, so i was deliberately impatient. I agree, as Will pointed out, it wasn't very fair to criticise it for not working like Windows, but it was a very important factor here. If i was evaluating the OS for myself, as someone is prepared to spend some time learning yet another way of doing things just to find out more about it, it would have been a different answer.

As you and Tufty pointed out, the volume control is there, just not where a Windows user would expect it to be.
Adding applications, yes i totally missed it, but then the help file was hardly very useful either. I just googled ubuntu install application and must have got the pre 5.10 way or doing it. The new installer does indeed look slick.

None of it's particularly a killer for someone actually prepared to put some time in to learn a new GUI. I know she'd just rather the pay the money for something she's familiar with instead.

It did leave me wondering though, given that OpenOffice goes to the trouble of making the user experience pretty close to what an MS office user would expect, why does there seem to be this aversion to making a desktop skin that sticks things in the same place as Windows? Or maybe there is a distribution that has? I don't know, it's like trying to find a needle in a haystack. I mean when i tried the Distro Quiz linked to on the Linux wikipedia entry, i got a total of 18 distribution recommendations, and that was after answering a page full of questions. What possible use is that to someone who doesn't already know what they're looking for?!

The hardware support was the real clincher though. I can't exactly tell her she needs to check that her next printer or camera purchase will work with Ubuntu, when there's no easy way for her to find that out without significant technical knowledge, let alone try to install it herself when i'm not around. My bet is it will be more cost effective for her to buy a copy of windows and have the choice of whatever the best hardware bargain is available at the time.
xav wrote:That's not what I was saying at all. I was simply pointing out that just because you want it to be everything that Windows is, plus a little bit more, doesn't necessarily make it so. It is good enough for a lot of people - and they're not necessarily all geeks (I've had a lot of success installing it for non-geeks who just want to write emails and surf the web without having to worry about viruses'n'shit). It might not be good enough for you, or your friend, or your mother's postman's aunt, but that doesn't necessarily reflect a failing in Linux, just a mismatch between what it does and what you want it to do.
That's fair enough, i misunderstood what you were saying. I'd interpreted it as "linux developers are only interested in creating an OS that meets their own needs". It didn't really seem to reflect the spirit of Richard Stallman's original GNU Manifesto.
Dungeon-Dave wrote:I honestly believe that nobody *really* opted to use Windows. The vast majority of PC users bought a PC, and found Windows installed on it, and just grew accustomed to it, learning differences with newer releases. If a store started dropping some Linux distro onto their PCs and people had never experienced Windows, they'd grow just as accustomed.
Oh I absolutely agree 100%. The thing is though, the overwhelming majority of people who have ever used a PC *are* used to Windows. Why force them to learn yet another way of doing things? If greater adoption of Linux is an aim of Linux developers, and from all the feedback i've had, it's clear that it is, then why not provide a GUI option that is close to what they are used to, and how about promoting a single Distro as a Windows alternative? It's worked wonders for Firefox. Latest i heard it was around 12% market share. Start getting anywhere near that kind of figure for Linux desktop and there'll be a heck of a lot more hardware support and, as with chickens and eggs, the flock will grow.
xav wrote:Catch-22. Without hardware support it will never be more appealing to the mass market, in which case by your argument it doesn't deserve to get hardware support.
Well to clarify my point, it is rather that someone's got to start the ball rolling, and it ain't going to be hardware manufacturers who are commercial entities paying peoples wages with sod all margin as it is. It's not just a question of 'providing good documentation'. What guarantee does the manufacturer have that the device driver writer doesn't just release a buggy PoS that will up their support calls to the point of unprofitabilitly? Maybe there is a suitable QA procedure for linux driver release, but if there isn't, there's a process problem here that needs to be fixed first. It's also a fact of life that consumers expect drivers to be shipped with the product (or at the very least be advised on where/what versions to download), so like it or not the hardware manufacturer has to get involved.
xav wrote:The improvements to cars haven't all come from the same company: diversity and competition is a good thing for driving innovation. The same applies in the programming world. You might not like the diversity, but as a Gnome user I'd be annoyed if I had to do things the KDE way, and vice versa. There are so many choices because there's a demand for so much choice amongst the existing user base. It might not be the best way to attract new users, but I'd argue that hanging on to the ones you've already got is just as important, if not moreso because in this case they're also the people developing the stuff.
I've nothing against competition. Competition is good. If there was more competition MS wouldn't be charging £170 for Windows XP home edition. That's why i'd like to see Linux really step up to the mark as an alternative to Windows and OSX. The point you make about satisfying your installed base is a good one, but ultimately if Linux is going to be anything more than niche on the desktop, a coherent approach is important. Divide and conquer and all that. But hey, I'm not the one giving my time, so those choices aren't up to me.
xav wrote:I know I shouldn't bite, but I guess I'm a sucker for punishment...
I'm not trolling, just pontificating :)
User avatar
Dungeon-Dave
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3925
Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2005 12:01 pm 0
Location: UK
Contact:

Post by Dungeon-Dave »

Bubba wrote:Thing is, it's quite different from an end user using Linux as an operating system, or the services that are provided by Linux.
True, I was probably sucking on the Pedantic MuthaTit when I wrote that - but it irks me when people feel computers finish with their desktop system and don't think any further than outside of their real.

Not that Roob was - he was making a valid point, nonetheless.

I'll also agree that Linux isn't ready for the desktop - but I'll argue that Windows isn't ready for the server market in the same breath. Those things that make Windows a dream for the novice user make it an irritant for the sysadmin trying to get work done, in the same way that those fast-productive magical green commands on a black background are archaic and hostile to the home user, but time-saving to the BOFHs of the world.

Different strokes, different folks. Whatever the outcome, I'm GLAD that there is choice, at least.

/me passes around big fluffy hugs, but only 'cos he's been drinking and feels the lurrrrve.
User avatar
Bubba
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10013
Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2003 12:52 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: BubbaFatAss
PSN: BubbaFatAs
Location: Cambridge

Post by Bubba »

xav wrote:This feature has been in Ubuntu for ever (well, at the very least for the past couple of releases).
Ace :).
xav wrote:In the past upgrading to new releases of Ubuntu (the equivalent of upgrading from Win95 to 98, or 2000 to XP) required you to point the update tool at the new repositories. The easiest way to do this was to replace the repository name wherever it occurred in the configuration file - it was as simple as a search and replace to put "dapper" in place of "breezy", for example.
Sorry, but gotta disagree here. The sheer quantities of upgrades nullifies this arguement as it isn't the same as a 95 to 98 or 200 to XP update as they happen once every few years, not every few months. I'd consider it more of a service pack than a full blown windows upgrade. And starting editing plaintext files is not something a typical user wants to be doing.
xav wrote:With the latest version, however, upgrading to a new release is also handled by the update manager. When the new release goes live an additional button will appear in the GUI: pressing it will perform the upgrade.

For more details, see this blog entry, although note that step 1 is only required because the new version isn't out yet (the -d switch lets the update manager also consider development releases). I believe that when the new release is out this button will appear without the need to do that.
Now that's how it should have been from the beginning, surely?! Ho hum, glad to see it's being addressed - it'll really help uptake with typical Windows-esque users. Can I configure it to just happen automagically though, a la windows update?
xav wrote:Something tells me that upgrading XP to Vista will require a little more than clicking a single button :wink:
Yeah, it'll be buy dvd, place in drive and click the mouse a couple of times ;).

Of course, no guarantees it'll actually work mind afterwards :D

Cheers

Bubba
||Work || Flickr||
User avatar
Acronym
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3982
Joined: Wed Feb 19, 2003 8:18 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: andrew_walkingshaw
Contact:

Post by Acronym »

Dungeon-Dave wrote:
Acronym wrote:ASR? Get out more, man. :)
What's your forum account? *clickety-click*
I know quite a few of the crowd who decamped ASR for bofhnet - part of what living in Cambridge does to you...
User avatar
Flojomojo
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2341
Joined: Mon Jul 29, 2002 6:21 am 0
XBL Gamertag: jindofox
PSN: jindofox
Location: Washington DC, USA

Post by Flojomojo »

Two more suggestions: web-based quizzes that ask you what you need, and try to make recommendations for you:

http://www.zegeniestudios.net/ldc/
http://eedok.voidofmind.com/linux/chooser.html

I had never heard of BeatrIX before this ... looks like it might be right for you.
http://www.watsky.net/
Post Reply