Recommend a Linux distribution for a non-techie?

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
User avatar
tufty
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12524
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 4:52 pm 0
Location: French Alps

Post by tufty »

Bubba wrote:
xav wrote:Something tells me that upgrading XP to Vista will require a little more than clicking a single button :wink:
Yeah, it'll be buy dvd, place in drive and click the mouse a couple of times, reboot, click mouse a few more times, reboot, click mouse a few more times, reboot ... nuke and pave.
Fixed that for you :)

Simon
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
User avatar
Dungeon-Dave
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3925
Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2005 12:01 pm 0
Location: UK
Contact:

Post by Dungeon-Dave »

tufty wrote:
Bubba wrote:
xav wrote:Something tells me that upgrading XP to Vista will require a little more than clicking a single button :wink:
Yeah, it'll be buy dvd, place in drive and click the mouse a couple of times, reboot, click mouse a few more times, reboot, click mouse a few more times, reboot ... nuke and pave.
Fixed that for you :)

Simon
Ohhh, come now! Harsh! Unfair!

Yep, I giggled - but I've gotta remember that the VistaWankers scorn *nix also with "download, extract, compile, symlink, find dependent libraries, change anorak..."

Anyhow, getting off the subject, SycroMoth have a "is your PC Pasta-ready?" tool:

http://www.reghardware.co.uk/2006/05/19 ... ware_tool/

Dunno if it'll be of use to people here. (Certainly not to me; I'm about to take the plunge and upgrade 98SE to W2K onto my wankstation.)
Acronym wrote:I know quite a few of the crowd who decamped ASR for bofhnet - part of what living in Cambridge does to you...
Hmmm... interesting! I don't lurk anymore in ASR (only since I changed newsreader and not added it in yet) so I may start scanning those groupen also. Ta for that.
User avatar
xav
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2455
Joined: Thu Jun 06, 2002 5:32 pm 0
Location: Bucks, UK
Contact:

Post by xav »

Roobarb wrote:As you and Tufty pointed out, the volume control is there, just not where a Windows user would expect it to be.


Image

Ubuntu Dapper, stock install, top right of the screen. Maybe not the same place as the Windows equivalent (bottom right of the screen, often hidden out of site anyway once you get a few icons in the status panel), but it's not the hardest thing to find either.
Roobarb wrote:I know she'd just rather the pay the money for something she's familiar with instead.
Which leads me to wonder why you bothered asking the question in the first place. If she wants something that behaves exactly the way Windows does, then it seems that the most obvious option would be Windows.

Roobarb wrote:It did leave me wondering though, given that OpenOffice goes to the trouble of making the user experience pretty close to what an MS office user would expect, why does there seem to be this aversion to making a desktop skin that sticks things in the same place as Windows?
KDE is a bit more Windows-like in that the default setup has a "Start Button" and a "Control Panel", and so on. For my money it has too many advanced options, so I wouldn't recommend it for a beginner, but if you want something that has the desktop widgets in the same place by default, that's probably the best-known option.

There have been one or two attempts to make a desktop environment that mimics Windows - some trying to be pixel perfect in the process. They either don't manage the job well enough, or they tend to wither due to lack of user support (or both). Windows might be familiar, but that doesn't make it an inherently good UI. Most Linux desktop environments seek to improve the UI rather than just replicate someone else's mistakes.

However I did modify a stock Ubuntu system to make it look a bit more like Windows. It took less than 2 minutes (admittedly I know what I'm doing, but it's not that hard either). I didn't go so far as installing new window decorations or desktop icons, but that's a fairly easy task too.

Image

Roobarb wrote:The hardware support was the real clincher though. I can't exactly tell her she needs to check that her next printer or camera purchase will work with Ubuntu, when there's no easy way for her to find that out without significant technical knowledge
https://wiki.ubuntu.com/HardwareSupport

In particular:

https://wiki.ubuntu.com/HardwareSupport ... tsPrinters
https://wiki.ubuntu.com/HardwareSupport ... talCameras

These lists are by no means exhaustive, but they are a good starting point.
Roobarb wrote:If greater adoption of Linux is an aim of Linux developers, and from all the feedback i've had, it's clear that it is, then why not provide a GUI option that is close to what they are used to, and how about promoting a single Distro as a Windows alternative? It's worked wonders for Firefox.
If you modify Linux so much that it looks, feels and behaves the same way as Windows, then is it still the same Linux that developers want to have greater adoption - or even that developers want to use at all.

Hey, if Apple want to get more market share then why not make OSX behave the way Windows users expect? "Linux" is a different system to Windows, and to MacOS, and to many other systems out there (including other Linux distros). Just because Windows has the market share right now, it doesn't mean that everything else should change to match it.
Roobarb wrote:
xav wrote:Catch-22. Without hardware support it will never be more appealing to the mass market, in which case by your argument it doesn't deserve to get hardware support.
Well to clarify my point, it is rather that someone's got to start the ball rolling, and it ain't going to be hardware manufacturers who are commercial entities paying peoples wages with sod all margin as it is. It's not just a question of 'providing good documentation'. What guarantee does the manufacturer have that the device driver writer doesn't just release a buggy PoS that will up their support calls to the point of unprofitabilitly? Maybe there is a suitable QA procedure for linux driver release, but if there isn't, there's a process problem here that needs to be fixed first.
Yes, someone's got to get the ball rolling - and that someone has been the Open Source developers who have provided so many drivers for so much hardware by reverse engineering and, occasionally, by manufacturers releasing useful documentation.

Yes, an Open Source driver could be a buggy PoS, but by the very nature of Open Source it probably won't stay that way for long (assuming that there's adequate documentation available).

Just out of interest, what guarantee does a user have that the manufacturer's Windows drivers aren't a buggy PoS? In my experience they often are - and that's despite Microsoft having a driver signing service. I'd rather have an Open Source driver that many developers can potentially fix than rely on a closed source driver from a company that may or may not be around next year.
Roobarb wrote:It's also a fact of life that consumers expect drivers to be shipped with the product (or at the very least be advised on where/what versions to download), so like it or not the hardware manufacturer has to get involved.
But in the Linux world most drivers ship as part of the distro. There's no need for them to be shipped with the product, and no need to know where to get them - you've already got them. In theory it should be as simple as plugging a device in. Admittedly there's a little way to go before this is always the case, but we'd get there a lot faster with adequate documentation.

Bubba wrote:Sorry, but gotta disagree here. The sheer quantities of upgrades nullifies this arguement as it isn't the same as a 95 to 98 or 200 to XP update as they happen once every few years, not every few months.
Just because it happens more frequently, it doesn't mean it's not an equivalent upgrade. Note that I didn't compare it to upgrading from 98/ME to 2000 (different kernel), but rather to upgrades within a "series".
Bubba wrote:I'd consider it more of a service pack than a full blown windows upgrade.
Potato, potahto. There are day-to-day fixes and patches to deal with security issues and bugs. There are (roughly) six-monthly releases which upgrade just about everything in the system. Consider them as service packs if you wish, but after applying one you still have the latest version of Ubuntu. I doubt there'll be a service pack to get you from XP to Vista.

The Open Source approach generally tends to be more incremental, rather than occasional big releases. But just because you can upgrade incrementally it doesn't mean that the cumulative effect is any less than if you just did one big upgrade every 3-5 years instead.
Bubba wrote:And starting editing plaintext files is not something a typical user wants to be doing.
That was my point. It was a simple edit, but even that hurdle has been removed.
Bubba wrote:Now that's how it should have been from the beginning, surely?!
Define "beginning". Windows hasn't always had Windows Update. Ubuntu is based off Debian which doesn't have this functionality as standard. Someone had to write it at some point. By definition it wasn't there in the beginning, but should they have not released any Ubuntu versions until it was added? And what about all the other features?

Besides which, it's a historical note. It's there now, so what does it matter whether or not it should have been there previously.
Co-creator of The Greys, Monsters, Inked & Elvie webcomics
• Web Site • Twitter • Patreon •
User avatar
stealthbanana
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2805
Joined: Wed Nov 09, 2005 11:59 pm 0
Location: Over Here.

Post by stealthbanana »

Personally I would go with kubuntu for a new user.

Its simple, straight forward, and KDE as set up is not that far removed from windows (where do you think M$ gets a lot of its ideas from :P )

I started linux on suse 5.4, kept with suse, tried mandrake, installed fedora core1 (for an afternoon, it was too liminting), have an lfs box (no better way to understand the system)

I just had to reinstall debian sid on my main home PC, it was an updated debian system from potato, and moving via several stable versions and testing and now unstable had left a lot of cruft in /usr. The install was relatively painless, detected everything I wanted it to. The newish way of loading firmware for devices is very simple (drop it in /lib/firmware).

The only bugger is I changed to a radeon graphics card from using nvidia for years, and the ati drivers are utter pigs to install and set up correctly (only supports up to x.org 6.9, not 7.0). Use nvidia graphics cards for linux if you want to play quake4 or whatever, but if just doing desktop work without all the possible translucency, 3d desktop etc. bells and whistles and not needing hyperfast graphics support, the standard X.org drivers are more than fine. Mesa is nice, but just too slow.
User avatar
Anders
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 9692
Joined: Tue Feb 17, 2004 4:29 pm 0
Location: Sweden

Post by Anders »

xav wrote:Which leads me to wonder why you bothered asking the question in the first place. If she wants something that behaves exactly the way Windows does, then it seems that the most obvious option would be Windows.
I think the frustration a lof of users feel comes from the fact that they're ready to accept Linux as an alternative to Windows (which is how it's been described for years now), but are put off and confused by the various quirks, difficulties, features and distros that abound. As noted, there are various flavors of Windows too, but MS usually manage to get the message across and explain what is what.

And whenever they voice their criticism, the Linux hardcore crawl out and put them in their place again and the result is that nothing much changes. Not saying that's what's happening here, though.
User avatar
Cadmium Lemon
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 112
Joined: Sat May 20, 2006 2:25 am 0
Location: The Orient. (Leyton).

Post by Cadmium Lemon »

xav wrote:
Yes, an Open Source driver could be a buggy PoS, but by the very nature of Open Source it probably won't stay that way for long (assuming that there's adequate documentation available).

Just out of interest, what guarantee does a user have that the manufacturer's Windows drivers aren't a buggy PoS? In my experience they often are - and that's despite Microsoft having a driver signing service. I'd rather have an Open Source driver that many developers can potentially fix than rely on a closed source driver from a company that may or may not be around next year.
Quite. The things that baffles me in this thread is how Windows has been granted "user-friendly, hassle-free OS" status. I've been a Windows user for six years, and it's been hell on a stick - particularly before I upgraded to XP.

I've been using Kubuntu for about a month now, and I'm constantly reminded of my experiences as a generally un-techie W98SE user. They're not equivalent in terms of functionality (Synaptic pisses all over everything else, ever, as long as you know what you're looking for *cough* Java *cough*), but the general user experience of wondering how something works, googling it, working it out, making it happen...

As I say, I'm not a techie by default, but if something is broken, I'll fix it myself. As a result, I've learnt a ridiculous amount of stuff about PC hardware, DOS, Windows drivers, and god knows how much else nonsense over the last six years. Consequently, I'm now the 24hr PC/Windows tech support guy for most of my friends and family.

I'm beginning a similar learning process now with Linux, but thankfully, I now have a large and helpful community of people and online resources to help me out. Sure, it's frustrating sometimes, but being frustrated by computers is nothing new for me...
User avatar
xav
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2455
Joined: Thu Jun 06, 2002 5:32 pm 0
Location: Bucks, UK
Contact:

Post by xav »

Anders wrote:I think the frustration a lof of users feel comes from the fact that they're ready to accept Linux as an alternative to Windows (which is how it's been described for years now), but are put off and confused by the various quirks, difficulties, features and distros that abound.
It is an alternative to Windows. A sherman tank is an alternative to a mini. A dog is an alternative to a cat. And a PS3 is an alternative to a Wii (okay, I might be stretching it with that last one).

For some people Linux is a viable alternative to Windows. For other people it's not. It all depends what you want (and expect) from it.

Personally I've always been baffled by the "Linux is/isn't ready for the desktop" claims. Whose desktop are we talking about? People use the term "desktop" to differentiate from "server" as though all desktops are equal.

1) The desktop of a call-centre employee: needs email, possibly a web browser, maybe a word processor, and some kind of interface to their call centre database. Yes, Linux is potentially ready for the desktop here.

2) Secretary. Needs email, web, word processor: Yes, potentially ready for the desktop here as well.

3) New user, never used a computer before, just wants to get online: Yes, probably good enough for these people, as they're unlikely to be the ones maintaining the machine and having to worry about drivers and hardware. Not having to worry about viruses is an added bonus.

4) Intermediate user, the type who likes to pick up bargains in PC World, or even in Tesco: Probably not ready for these desktops because of hardware and driver support - and because the 99p copy of "Tetroids" they found in the bargain bin is Windows only.

5) Advanced user: May or may not be ready for the desktop, depending on what they want to do. But if they're really an advanced user they should be able to work that out for themselves anyway ;)

6) Gamer: Almost certainly not ready for this desktop.

7) Anyone who absolutely must run a particular bit of Windows software: Again, not really ready unless you happen to get very lucky with WINE.

8 ) Me: Linux has been ready for my desktop for years now ;)


Based on my usage* I would say that in my case Windows isn't ready for the desktop :lol:





* Including, but not limited to:
Virtual desktops
A decent CLI
Multiple panels and taskbars
Genuine multi-user system (multiple users logged in simultaneously via the network - but without the expense of a Windows server system)
Lack of viruses and spyware
Advanced package management tools (something better than Windows Update and Add/Remove Software)
Decent selection of desktop software available without having to download it separately (and track these separate sources for updates), or pay extra for it.
Co-creator of The Greys, Monsters, Inked & Elvie webcomics
• Web Site • Twitter • Patreon •
Post Reply