If You Believe We Put A Man On The Moon
Apperently, with the materials in the dust and on the moons surfact very crude solar panels can be made.
Sure, efficiancy would be too good, but you could build fecking MASSIVE ones.
I think they should set rovers auto-building these crude panels so we can be "pluged in" when we want to viste again.
Sure, efficiancy would be too good, but you could build fecking MASSIVE ones.
I think they should set rovers auto-building these crude panels so we can be "pluged in" when we want to viste again.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
It's true! They say it works by tri-an-gra-lay-shun but it's clearly not true. I've asked a triangle where I was and it didn't say a thing. They're brainwashing us with calcium in the water! And bees! Just look at 'em!chub wrote:Satellite phones are just old expensive mobile phones. Iridium is a chemical element, not a satellite network. Navigation satellites are fake too. GPS devices just guess your positionDio wrote:What about communications satellites? I've heard they're all faked.
- teamonkey
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 12082
- Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2002 1:07 am 0
- XBL Gamertag: itsthetaste
- PSN: teamonkey_ca
- Contact:
You ever pointed a telescope at the moon? The moon has two states, day is very bright and night is very dark. Without an atmosphere there is no in between.zip accident wrote:Eh? Bright? what are you talking about?
Day is very bright indeed. It reflects an enourmous amount of sunlight, enough to cast clear shadows on Earth on a clear night (and you wouldn't be looking on any other night). With any optical telescope capable of seeing moon lander the light from the moon would simply drown out any detail. It would also be bright enough to blind you, but that's immaterial.
Night time, however, is too dark to see anything with an optical telescope. There's no heat source so infra-red won't pick it up, nor ultra violet spectra. No other wavelength will do, really.
So unless we can shine a big torch at a new moon we're not going to spot it from Earth or NEO. A satellite in orbit around the moon is a different matter entirely.
Hubble can take lunar pictures (although not as good as using other methods); there are several reasons why it nots done often. Some are technical - some of Hubbles instruments are very sensitive to light and could be damaged, but there ways round it. Next, there is a long queue of scientists trying to get time with Hubble; NASA receives about six times as many proposals for use of Hubbles time as there is available each year. Hubble was designed to look at the fartherest reaches of the Universe, using it to look at the Moon (unless you have very good academic reasons) is something of a waste of its time.Dio wrote:I'm not sure about that. Sure, I can believe contrast might be a problem if you were looking to see a bright spot against a brighter spot, but by making use of the long shadows (plus generally lower light intensity) at dawn I'm pretty sure it would be visible.
The other - primary - reason for not using Hubble to find the lunar lander is because we already have many very good photos of it. They were taken from the Moons surface. When we went there.
(summarised from "Bad Astronomy", by Philip Plait. Recommended, if only to throw at people who run up to you and ask you to swear on a Bible that you didn't go to the Moon...
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
No, I haven't looked at the moon through a telescope.teamonkey wrote:
It would also be bright enough to blind you, but that's immaterial.
However I do know a little about optics.
A telescope designed to pick out Mars or Jupiter would at it's standard setting do exactly as you say. All telescopes are not created equal. Binoculars (which I'm more familiar with) are graded by their magnification, and the areas of front lens, the latter gives the light gathering power. A good 7 by 50 cm binocular will be very bright, compared to normal eyesight. A good 10 by 50 cm binocular will have higher magnification, but because of that, the area from which the light being viewed is coming from will be smaller, so they will be slightly less bright, than the 7 by 50 cm. You could increase the brightness by increasing the front lens diameter.
Reflecor telescopes have an effective diameter that is very large, but to get the sort of brightness needed to view the planets the magnification has to be kept down (higher than the average binocular sure, but if you were using the same diameter lens to view objects on Earth, which is as bright as the moon, then you could use a higher magnification than you would have to use to make planets visible).
Okay somebody tell me I'm wrong (but please have reasons, if you do
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
- teamonkey
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 12082
- Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2002 1:07 am 0
- XBL Gamertag: itsthetaste
- PSN: teamonkey_ca
- Contact:
Maybe, but the lunar lander isn't a big feature at all. I don't know that even an elongated shadow would be big enough to spot from Hubble, plus you've got the weird reflective qualities of the moon dust.Dio wrote:I'm not sure about that. Sure, I can believe contrast might be a problem if you were looking to see a bright spot against a brighter spot, but by making use of the long shadows (plus generally lower light intensity) at dawn I'm pretty sure it would be visible.
Brightness has nothing to do with magnification. For greater brightness you need more light on the focus plane: a wider aperture or a longer exposure are the only ways to do that. A 10x50mm pair of binoculars will appear dimmer than a 7x50mm pair because the number of photons collected per second is spread out over the larger eyepiece lens but the number of photons collected on the focus plane remains the same.Reflecor telescopes have an effective diameter that is very large, but to get the sort of brightness needed to view the planets the magnification has to be kept down (higher than the average binocular sure, but if you were using the same diameter lens to view objects on Earth, which is as bright as the moon, then you could use a higher magnification than you would have to use to make planets visible).
Now Hubble's aperture is huge, but the brightness of the moon makes it difficult to resolve features as it has to be quite heavily filtered to avoid the CCD array from burning out from the huge amount of photons hitting it. That filtering softens the contrast that would let you see any sort of small-scale structure.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
I don't think it's possible because of the atmosphere. I've no data to back this up, but consider this. Earth orbiting satellites taking pictures of the earth can resolve detail down to a few metres. You can just about make out cars on stretch of road in Google Maps/Earth for example. A good comparison as the Lunar Lander is of a similar size.zip accident wrote:Why Hubble particularly? You'd need a lot of magnification, but I think a big enough ground based telescope should be able to do it (except I think one of the landings might have been on the "dark" side, and I doubt Hubble can see that one).
Looking the other way you are looking through the same distorting atmosphere, but at an over a thousand times more distant object. Objects on the moon appear a lot smaller, so the same distorting effect blurs a lot larger real area, probably measured in km rather than m.
You can do things to improve on this - you can build bigger telescopes and site them where you like, such as on mountains. (Google has little choice over the location of the cities it maps). But above a certain size it makes no difference because of the atmosphere. Which is why Hubble exists - it probably cost the same as thousands of top quality Earth optical telescopes but it trumps them all.
Brightness is by the by anyway.
The angular resolution of a telesope is inversely proportional to the diameter:
And the size of the lander (5 metres) at that range (384,000,000m) means that the angular size of the lander is approximately:
So, to be able to make itout as a speck of different intensity, you need a diameter of:
In practice, to get any sort of detail you would want at least 10x this resolution, and until we get a 3km telescope Im afraid you're going to be out of luck.
Which is precisely what the government WANT you to believe...
<Edit: A large radio interferometer would cope easily, but the lander isnt a source of radio waves sadly, & the only optical interferometer is only about 10metres or so.>
The angular resolution of a telesope is inversely proportional to the diameter:
Code: Select all
angle = wavelength / diameter
therefore:
diameter = wavelength / angleCode: Select all
5 / 384,000,000 = 0.000,000,013,02 radiansCode: Select all
visible light, approx 500nm = 0.000,000,5m wavelength
d = 0.000,000,5 / 0.000,000,013,02 = 384Which is precisely what the government WANT you to believe...
<Edit: A large radio interferometer would cope easily, but the lander isnt a source of radio waves sadly, & the only optical interferometer is only about 10metres or so.>
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
I'm coming to believe that we probably would need a bigger telescope than we've got to see the landers on the moon.
However:
Think of the viewed object as a plane, perpendicular to the Axis of the lens(es). It reflects light at x photons per second per square metre. As the magnification goes up, the area being viewed goes down. There are photons being reflected from the area not being viewed, but they're not getting though the lenses to the viewing apparatus.
However:
Sorry, no offence intended, but that statement is wrong.teamonkey wrote:
Brightness has nothing to do with magnification.
Think of the viewed object as a plane, perpendicular to the Axis of the lens(es). It reflects light at x photons per second per square metre. As the magnification goes up, the area being viewed goes down. There are photons being reflected from the area not being viewed, but they're not getting though the lenses to the viewing apparatus.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Actually teamonkey and Mr Dom are right. Basically if something's not bright enough you just expose your picture for longer. For serious astronomy you're going to use either photographic film or a CCD exposed for several seconds, minutes or hours, even over several nights, to get your picture.zip accident wrote:Sorry, no offence intended, but that statement is wrong.teamonkey wrote:
Brightness has nothing to do with magnification.
Think of the viewed object as a plane, perpendicular to the Axis of the lens(es). It reflects light at x photons per second per square metre. As the magnification goes up, the area being viewed goes down. There are photons being reflected from the area not being viewed, but they're not getting though the lenses to the viewing apparatus.
Large telescopes have mountings that can rotate under computer control, and this can be used to not only point the telescope at the right spot in the sky but rotate it to track the thing being photographed as the heavens turn above us. Hubble has thrusters and lots of gyroscopes.
This is more of a problem for amateur telescopes, which can be kept steady but not moved to keep up with the sky. Its even more of a problem for hand held equipment, where camera shake blurs exposures of even a fraction of a second, forcing photographers to use all sorts of fixes (high ISO film, flash, image stabalisers) for low light and nighttime shots.
- teamonkey
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 12082
- Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2002 1:07 am 0
- XBL Gamertag: itsthetaste
- PSN: teamonkey_ca
- Contact:
I thought even if you couldn't resolve it properly you might see a smudge under certain conditions with an elongated shadow. I've just reworked Dom's stuff for a 2.4m reflector mirror in the infra-red band and you end up with Hubble having a 200m resolution for something on the moon. So no, Hubble wouldn't even see a smudge, not even close.Dio wrote:In shadow == no light == no reflection, thoughteamonkey wrote:plus you've got the weird reflective qualities of the moon dust.. Any dispute is about resolving power - not whether or not it can be seen. There's no doubt it could be if the telescope can resolve the thing.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
I have no problem with what Mr Dom said. I'm not sure I follow it, but I don't have a problem with it, and it sounds plausible.pogo wrote:
Actually teamonkey and Mr Dom are right.
However, for a given diameter of lens, magnification is inversely propotional to brightness (I don't know what the particular mathematical function is). There is an effect of this in every day camera usage. The maximum available aperture of a zoom lens will decline as you zoom in on a subject (though I suppose the manufacturer could make the zoomed in maximum aperture the maximum at all magnifications).
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.


