Football: WORLD CUP 06 and close season/transfer discussion.
Really enjoyed the Argentina - Ivory Coast match, best so far! Ivory Coast look a very good side indeed even against Argentina who were commanding throughout the game. After that and the T&T performance, it makes the England game look even more poor in comparison.
Oh but the refereeing? It needs to improve or its going to spoil the competition - I don't think any of the teams who've played so far have avoided being on the wrong end of a dodgy decision. The England match referee was particularly bad - yes, he was third choice due to injury (I think) but he should never have been at the tournament. Woeful.
Crouch needs to realise that at this level, you are always going to be penalised for raising your hands against a defender - there's no real need for him to do it, he has a comfortable height advantage. And will someone PLEASE shoot Owen Hargreaves? And Downing whilst you're at it (*).
And once again, there's question marks about the Gerrard/Lampard partnership in midfield. In the second half, both were faceless - mostly because the defence continued to play the long ball over the top of them, despite noone being there to benefit from Crouch's flick-ons, but even still, Paraguay had a worrying freedom through the midfield, especially with England sitting so deep at the end. I just wish Sven would react more positively in his substituting when the team fall into this rut (which they seem to do with alarming regularity). On the up side, three points is three points and if they progress through the group stage, noone will remember how crap they played against Paraguay anyway.
Holland - Serbia tomorrow, hopefully that should live up to expectations...
edit: (*) and someone tell Ashley Cole how to mark/hold position too? Carragher at left-back is looking more of an attractive proposition already.
Oh but the refereeing? It needs to improve or its going to spoil the competition - I don't think any of the teams who've played so far have avoided being on the wrong end of a dodgy decision. The England match referee was particularly bad - yes, he was third choice due to injury (I think) but he should never have been at the tournament. Woeful.
Crouch needs to realise that at this level, you are always going to be penalised for raising your hands against a defender - there's no real need for him to do it, he has a comfortable height advantage. And will someone PLEASE shoot Owen Hargreaves? And Downing whilst you're at it (*).
And once again, there's question marks about the Gerrard/Lampard partnership in midfield. In the second half, both were faceless - mostly because the defence continued to play the long ball over the top of them, despite noone being there to benefit from Crouch's flick-ons, but even still, Paraguay had a worrying freedom through the midfield, especially with England sitting so deep at the end. I just wish Sven would react more positively in his substituting when the team fall into this rut (which they seem to do with alarming regularity). On the up side, three points is three points and if they progress through the group stage, noone will remember how crap they played against Paraguay anyway.
Holland - Serbia tomorrow, hopefully that should live up to expectations...
edit: (*) and someone tell Ashley Cole how to mark/hold position too? Carragher at left-back is looking more of an attractive proposition already.
- biggestjim
- Baaaa!

- Posts: 893
- Joined: Fri Jul 04, 2003 7:58 pm 0
- Location: Zzapland
- Contact:
I think it's unbelievable while we're in the 21st century, the ref still may not use videomaterial for reference in goal/not a goal cases.
I mean within 10 seconds they could have found out that Argentina had a goal yesterday.
Shame Ivory Coast couldn't equalise though, they deserved it!
Holland and Serbia are warned now anyway. Great match.
I mean within 10 seconds they could have found out that Argentina had a goal yesterday.
Shame Ivory Coast couldn't equalise though, they deserved it!
Holland and Serbia are warned now anyway. Great match.
Now that I have my coffee, I'm ready to watch radar.
- Arthur Ringworn
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1276
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2003 10:20 am 0
- Yahoo Messenger: arthur_ringworn
- Location: Oxford, Alabama
Well England didn't play too well, I doubt we're most peoples second favourites anymore. The ref was a proper jobsworth, far too fond of himself, not that that excuses England's poor performance. Paraguay were worse though.
Sweden appeared to have bad luck for their match, but I also can't believe how well T&T not only defended with 10 men but also carried on launching their own attacks, tremendous stuff. Ljundberg was getting really frustrated towards the end.
Argentina look the best team I've seen so far but their constant diving was really shameless (and bloody annoying). Ivory Coast I thought were slightly disappointing, some of them could really run with the ball but their crossing was a bit hit and miss.
Sweden appeared to have bad luck for their match, but I also can't believe how well T&T not only defended with 10 men but also carried on launching their own attacks, tremendous stuff. Ljundberg was getting really frustrated towards the end.
Argentina look the best team I've seen so far but their constant diving was really shameless (and bloody annoying). Ivory Coast I thought were slightly disappointing, some of them could really run with the ball but their crossing was a bit hit and miss.
"The ability to weasel out of things is what separates man from the animals....... Except the weasel."
Or not. I'm not convinced that the whole ball crossed all of the line. Particularly when they showed the goal line camera version.biggestjim wrote:I think it's unbelievable while we're in the 21st century, the ref still may not use videomaterial for reference in goal/not a goal cases.
I mean within 10 seconds they could have found out that Argentina had a goal yesterday.
Still, I'm with you on the use of video-evidence. Especially as they have a 5th official as well this year.
Is this going to take long, only my foot's gone to sleep and I'd like to catch it up.
360 Gamertag: xGEENIUSx
http://www.fitnessin3steps.co.uk
360 Gamertag: xGEENIUSx
http://www.fitnessin3steps.co.uk
- Arthur Ringworn
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1276
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2003 10:20 am 0
- Yahoo Messenger: arthur_ringworn
- Location: Oxford, Alabama
Or to give them out after the match for unsportsmanlike conduct. A couple of the Ivory Coast players received yellow cards where there was no contact whatsoever, purely through play-acting/gamesmanship by the Argentinian players.Arthur Ringworn wrote:They should definitely use video evidence to remove unjust yellow cards.
I know people say "it's part of the game nowadays" but for me, that's just not satisfactory - I think FIFA have an opportunity to stamp it out by being tough on it after the match. If players are under the threat of suspension due to gamesmanship, they will stop doing it. That's the way to remove it from the game - make the players themselves pay by missing matches. Then, they come under pressure from their own clubs to not do it.
And of course, this means that the England players that have started doing it (badly)...Gerrard is one of the recent offenders, will also fall foul of the rule. So be it. It's always embarassing to watch anyway because we're so crap at it.
- Arthur Ringworn
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1276
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2003 10:20 am 0
- Yahoo Messenger: arthur_ringworn
- Location: Oxford, Alabama
Re video, I'd like to keep the goal or not situations as they are, but:
Agreed, after or during a match. Strange that FIFA hasn't reacted more strongly in this issue over the years. Maybe they could show every bad fake dive on the big screen over and over in the stadium. One thing leads to another of course, but the balance between dangerous play and stupid fake diving should be adressed better.Loada wrote:Or to give them out after the match for unsportsmanlike conduct.Arthur Ringworn wrote:They should definitely use video evidence to remove unjust yellow cards.
- biggestjim
- Baaaa!

- Posts: 893
- Joined: Fri Jul 04, 2003 7:58 pm 0
- Location: Zzapland
- Contact:
Well, after seeing it three times (ok, but still do-able within +/- 15 seconds) I'm 100% sure it was 100% in.Geenius wrote: Or not. I'm not convinced that the whole ball crossed all of the line. Particularly when they showed the goal line camera version.
Still, I'm with you on the use of video-evidence. Especially as they have a 5th official as well this year.
Especially when he finally sort of clamps the ball after jugling it, even both his hands are behind the goal line.
But hey, I know that in England they have trouble spotting if a ball's in or not. Hehe.
Although I cannot remember which button I presses when I was at Wembley.
Now that I have my coffee, I'm ready to watch radar.
- biggestjim
- Baaaa!

- Posts: 893
- Joined: Fri Jul 04, 2003 7:58 pm 0
- Location: Zzapland
- Contact:
I don't mind him, although I do dislike the commentary of Bright and Le Saux. I'm hoping they don't get used. I also wish they'd lose Ian Wright, with his constant "f's", instead of "th's". He certainly shouldn't be presenting a lottery show
Nice goal from Robben, although I'm not so sure about the quote from someone (I think I read on the BBC web site, but can't see it now) about "Robben is better than Rooney". If he is, why does he feel the need to cheat (dive)?
Nice goal from Robben, although I'm not so sure about the quote from someone (I think I read on the BBC web site, but can't see it now) about "Robben is better than Rooney". If he is, why does he feel the need to cheat (dive)?
Is this going to take long, only my foot's gone to sleep and I'd like to catch it up.
360 Gamertag: xGEENIUSx
http://www.fitnessin3steps.co.uk
360 Gamertag: xGEENIUSx
http://www.fitnessin3steps.co.uk
- Gorecki
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 5962
- Joined: Sat Aug 31, 2002 1:39 am 0
- Location: Essex, home of the Boy Racer
There's two problems that I can see with implementing new & video technology into refereeing decisions.Samus wrote:Re video, I'd like to keep the goal or not situations as they are, but:
Agreed, after or during a match. Strange that FIFA hasn't reacted more strongly in this issue over the years. Maybe they could show every bad fake dive on the big screen over and over in the stadium. One thing leads to another of course, but the balance between dangerous play and stupid fake diving should be adressed better.Loada wrote:Or to give them out after the match for unsportsmanlike conduct.Arthur Ringworn wrote:They should definitely use video evidence to remove unjust yellow cards.
The first is the problem you have using it is when you have to make on the spot decisions. Cricket has managed to use video replays to judge run-outs very succesfully. But cricket is a tactical game played at a slow pace. Gaps and breaks in play are all part of the game so the odd minute lost to a video replay decision doesn't really make any difference. But football is completely different, it's fast paced and flowing, decisions have to be made quickly, often instantly otherwise you break up the flow of the game. So any technology has to fit inside that remit and keep the game fast and flowing, which isn't easy.
The second problem is the issue of issueing/repealing cards or decisions after the match. The idea is a good one, it'd punish the cheaters and the divers but it'd strip the referee of all authority and make a mockery of his decisions. Imagine if the world cup final was decided by a penalty. If a video referee looked at the foul after the match and over turned the decision, what happens then?
Tang Sou!


