Roobarb wrote:Darkfame wrote:<Pixart sensor is special>
It's just a standard CMOS image sensor array and image processor. Nothing new, just a different flavour of well established technology. The image processing algorithms may be novel, but calculating the spatial location of 8 dots is hardly earth-shattering compared with the “Automatic Exposure Control, Automatic White Balance, Gamma Correction, Color Saturation Correction, Edge Enhancement, Lens Shading Compensation and Defect Compensation†etc you get in even a simple digital camera. Pixart themselves already make several
30fps VGA SoC cameras. They are capable of capturing and processing @15fps and consuming <25mA current. Given known figures for how long the WiiMote will last on two AA's*, we can assume the Pixart sensor will consume ~50mA. Substitute a half VGA sensor array, up the sample rate to 60fps (which is as fast as the standard PC mouse sample rate), program in your new image processing algorithms and you're sorted: motion tracking sensor consuming ~50mA.
You completely changed the point.
The point was the specific MOT chip probably hasnt been mass produced before.
I said in my post it was highly related technology, I wasnt claiming it was really special.
Can PixArt supply these in quanitys quick enough for Nintendo? I guess so, but its just that, a guess.
Just like you are doing.
(the cameras they have been makeing longer then this chip, so its more likely the is a logical development from their camera tech, rather then the cameras containing this sensor system)
Darkflame wrote:It also isn't using visible light to do that.
Any CMOS sensor is sensitive to near infrared as well as visible light. Many digital cameras remove the near infrared by using a filter in front of the sensor (many cheaper cameras and phones don't - that's why we saw pictures of the infrared LED's on the Wiibar). The Wiimote just does the opposite: it uses a filter in front of the sensor to remove visible light.
[/quote]
Probably yes.
Do nintendo make that filter or buy it in?
No, it isnt hard technology, its probably about as simple as you can get...but I still cant remember Nintendo needing to sort that out before. Its a new supplier, or a new bit to the production line.
Darkflame wrote:<Lens variability>
The tolerances required to produce a reasonable quality picture on a cameraphone are going to be at least as great as to be able to track 8 bright dots.
[/quote]
And has Nintendo ever produced cell phones or cameras before?
Has Nintendo ever had a factory production line dealing with this issue before?
Your constantly saying "THIS IS EXISTING TECHNOLOGY" and "THIS IS EASY".
Im not argueing with that. (its easy once someone has thought of it, mind)
Your missing the point which is "Nintendo hasnt been set up to do this before, this is the most complex controller they have ever had to produce, and it requires new sensors being supplied, new suppliers for lens, ect......imo, your seeing this from a absolutely technical standpoint and not a relative manufactoring one for Nintendo.
Darkflame wrote:But I was talking of the controller, because I cant see anything possible to hold up the Wii manufactor itself.
Where do you get this idea anything is holding up the manufacture of any part of Wii, including the remote?[/quote]
err..I didnt.
Im just saying that
if anything is holding them back, its the controller.
There were reports, for instance, at some demos the controller not picking up the sensors correctly. (the rooms had to be kept fairly dark..guess the diodes wernt strong enough, or the filter wasnt right).
This seems to be fixed in recent shows, but there are issues surrounding any new device.
Also, that the controller will be, initialy, the most expensive one Nintendo has ever made.
Camera/soc,bluetooth, 3 axis sensors, "sensorbar", more axis sensors for nunchuck, rumble.......each bits cheap, but the sum comes to much greater then a typical Gamecube pad.
Darkflame wrote: Its much more tested and established.
Hunh? Not a single subsystem in that console will be the same as in Gamecube.
Again, we dont know.
But the system is still just, as people love to point out, a gamecube shrunk and giving a clockspeed boast.
While the chips are different, its still just a motherboard, chips,sockets put together. Its also dead-easy to test.
Mind you, that any-size slot loading drive could be an issue.
I dont know how it works, but whatever moving parts it use's could be vulnerable to mass-production. [/didnt think of that before]
Bubba wrote:Hell, I wonder if Ninty can manufacture their whole console for less money than Sony can make a blu-ray drive, or even a Cell / RSX Die(s). Honestly wouldn't suprise me
Ninty can probably
sell their whole console, at a profit, for less money than Sony can make a blu-ray drive, or even a Cell / RSX Die(s)

Thats sonys fault for wanting a new movie market.
I dont see gamers screaming for bluray.
Also, I'm skeptical the cell is that expensive to make.
Wouldnt be supprised if Sony is leaking out more expensive prices to get the "percieved value" higher. Thats just my conspiracy theory though.
Nicely worked out.