gilesgoat wrote:"How much British stuff is really British" ?
Well, I did cover some of this earlier in the thread.
That most of the UK railway franchises are actually owned / operated by (the commercial arms of) Deutsche Bahn, SNCF, Netherlands Rail, Trenitalia and so forth. The national state-owned railway operators of other EU countries.
So, in truth, the privatised railways are still owned and run by government. Just not the UK government.
I mean, this is perfectly logical, if you think about it. For example, let's say that the American government decides it wants to privatise and sell off NASA. Who's most likely to buy into this?
Elon Musk's SpaceX, who're already in the field - and have the expertise, have the contacts, have the technology, have the interest and all the rest of it - or Marks and Spencer, who've never done anything like that before and have no fucking clue how any of it works?
Or, even more unlikely, that a bunch of ordinary people are going to - I don't know - club together their life savings and create a brand new space agency startup from their garage, which wouldn't really have the capacity to do anything useful with NASA's assets anyway?
Put that way, it's bloody obvious, really, isn't it? If you're going to sell a national railway, then those most likely to buy it would be... other national railways in other countries. And that's EXACTLY what largely happened.
Which is the fundamental flaw in the "privatisation" theory, as the argument is that private companies - due to competitive pressure and such - will run such ventures better than governments would.
Slight problem with that theory. When they actually sell these things, who mostly buys them and operates them? Governments.
Because who the fuck else has the resources and experience to operate infrastructure on a massive national scale? Well, governments.
Anyway, criticisms of economic theories to one side, I put it plainly.
When they say "take back control" then, indeed, what exactly does Britain still own anyhow? After now decades of the Tory / New Labour "fire sale" of all the national assets?
Answer: Very, very little indeed.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes