Cloudane wrote:Society currently considers seasonal flu deaths to be acceptable.
I don't think it does. Or, at least, I hope it doesn't.
I don't see any deaths as "acceptable". The point with seasonal flu deaths is that we can't really do much more than we're doing.
We've got annual flu jabs on offer - and the UK has the biggest vaccination take-up of these jabs in the world. We do try to keep up with this virus. But the thing with the flu is that it mutates all the bloody time.
I would not phrase this in terms of "acceptable" and "unacceptable" - that, to me, stinks of the sort of language that our right-wing eugenicists are trying to steer the narrative towards - but rather that this is the best we could ever hope to do, with an endemic ever-mutating virus.
Now that we've all actually watched a vaccine go through development and trials and approval - how long and complicated the whole process is (and, remember, with the Covid vaccines, this stuff was all fast-tracked and the more standard procedure is even longer and more laboured than even this!) - then we can perhaps appreciate just how much constant effort is placed into making those annual flu jabs.
Until the pandemic, we never looked at this. But it focused our eyes on seeing what vaccine development involves. Now, consider that this - in fact, an even more complicated and laboured process, as Covid got special "fast track" treatment here - has been happening every year, over and over, for the annual flu jabs.
Indeed, because trials and approval take so long, the annual flu jab requires a bit of guessing. They track the current strains of flu doing the rounds and try to predict which ones will be dominant by the time that the jab is done and approved. They don't necessarily always get those guesses exactly right, unfortunately, and a different strain might gain dominance or a new strain pop up in the meantime.
But, again, you have to 100% ensure that a jab is safe before you start jabbing people with it, so what else can ever be done?
I don't see it as society thinking flu deaths are "acceptable". I think it's more that the nature of the influenza virus means that we can't ever get ahead of it. This is, regrettably, the best we can do. And a heck of a lot of effort is continuously put into keeping up with the 'flu virus. We might not have noticed before, but what we've seen with the Covid vaccines, is continuously happening with the annual 'flu jab. All the time. No rest. Once they've got this year's flu jab sorted, they immediately start predicting what next year's one will need to look like.
And another thing about the influenza virus is that its hatred of heat - that it does largely disappear in Summer, and then kicks off seasonally in Winter - gives us the opportunity to do this at all. Because it is seasonal - every Winter - then we've got that time in-between to rush efforts to get a new jab done and approved in time.
It's not "acceptable". I don't see it that way. This is, regrettably, simply the best we can do with this virus. We do offer vulnerable groups a jab every year (and we are a free country, so if you don't want to take up the jab offer, then you will not be physically forced to do so).
I think phrasing it in terms of "acceptability" is wrong. This is the best we can do - at least, not unless you want to start making jabs compulsory.
We don't lockdown for the 'flu, because the nature of the virus - constantly mutating - means that lockdowns would only be of limited utility. I mean, we have been under lockdown - on and off - for over a year now. It was for Covid, but it's also implicitly locking down for 'flu and the common cold too. But the 'flu still exists and the problem is that it throws up new "variants" so often, that if one case survives through lockdown, then it re-emerges, as everyone's previous immunity - or annual jab - no longer works for next year's strains.
We can't lockdown the 'flu out of existence. It's rapidly changing nature defies that particular tactic (not totally, but we'll never eradicate it that way, only temporarily knock it back). And, for the 'flu, by its nature, our best protection is to offer annual jabs for the vulnerable and to allow those who're very unlikely to die from it - young and healthy - to get it for "herd immunity" purposes, which does help protect the more vulnerable.
I mean, we can't lockdown Covid out of existence either (not anymore, once it became endemic, that possibility was lost). The point of lockdown was and is to "flatten the curve" - keep healthcare systems working, keep "variant" mutations as low as possible, etc. - until we had the vaccine and treatments and such to actually fight back. Which is what's going on now. Hopefully, vaccination will work and though Covid won't, unfortunately, disappear that easily, it can be consigned, hopefully, to being "small pockets" of outbreak here and there, and we fight those fires as they happen (but now actually armed with some weapons to do so).
I think that if a doctor said - and it was proved true - that they could actually totally eradicate the 'flu once and for all, with it never coming back, but it would require going into lockdown for a year, then I think society would - or, at least, ought to - take that. It's a bargain at the price to make influenza permanently extinct forever more.
I'm suspicious that whoever's lead the charge to paint 'flu deaths in the language of "acceptable" or "unacceptable" is someone with a "living with it" agenda that's trying to paint things in their terms, to have people accept the idea that "acceptable death" is a thing. It really isn't. There are no "acceptable deaths", but this is the best we can do against an enemy like the 'flu.
Because it's thoroughly endemic, lockdowns alone cannot eradicate (and the same is now true, unfortunately, for Covid). But the point of a lockdown is to buy time. Stop the NHS overloading, stop "variants" springing up alarmingly fast that we can't keep up with them, and buy time for the scientists to create the vaccines and the treatments.
Lockdown cannot be permanent. That's not how this can or should work.
The point is that it's bought us time to now have the vaccines, roll them out and build up some "herd immunity" in the population - in a safe way, that doesn't result in suffering and death - but, ultimately, "herd immunity" is our protection. Lockdown is what we do when we haven't got that, to buy the time for the vaccines to come online to give it to us. To keep "variants" at bay - yeah, that part of the plan was missed by certain politicians - so that our vaccines remain good by the time they are rolled out.
I wouldn't ever go near the phraseology of "acceptable" and "unacceptable". I see it more as "possible" and "impossible". We don't accept these deaths, we just can't do any better than that. And herd immunity has to be our long-term protection - we locked down to buy the time for the vaccines to give it to us, and for treatments to come along that can hopefully reduce fatality rates.
p.s. to provide something more positive, the Covid vaccines have proved that the new "mRNA" technique works (and, indeed, works bloody well, if it honestly is producing efficacies as high as 90% or 95%, as that kind of level was previously unheard of, and we thought 60-70% was awesome with previous techniques). And this technique is faster to modify - to keep up - and some scientists have been talking about the possibility that, mastering this technique, they could develop more generic vaccines. One that targets common elements of ALL coronaviruses, for example. So it's not going for the spike protein, but aiming for something that all coronaviruses - all Covid variants, all common cold variants - share and makes a more generic attack against the whole class of viruses in one go.
Obviously, all minds are focused on Covid right now, but the new technique - applied to old enemies, like the 'flu - might offer more effective annual jabs, and the prospect of more generic vaccines (but still potentially having that high 90+% efficacy too) could mean that we start hitting these bastards back even more widely, even more effectively and being able to "keep up" way faster than before. The "emergency" of Covid unlocked funds, research and development of new techniques that could well prove massively more effective - against everything - going forward.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes