Muttley wrote:After mulling things over last night I've gone and pre-ordered a PS4.
What really swung it for me was the apparently decent support Sony appear to be throwing at indie developers, which is where all the interesting game design stuff seems to come from these days.
There are only two things I'm really concerned about, and the first is the discoverability of these games in the online store (something nobody has got right yet), and also the controller. The PS3 controller is fucking awful compared to the 360, and I really hope they rectify that.
I've never got a console on release day before...
I think that you are right "nobody got it right yet", and I think there are various problems at once and maybe with only a
few solutions, if any.
First of all "sad but true", if you want to avoid flooding of applications which leads to "an ocean of too much stuff one see
and does not see" you need some restrictions in place, at the very least define a "top max" of apps you want to see
appearing per year or month.
This of course could mean that quite some good stuff could be on a waiting list "for ages" waiting to have its turn but
at this point there could be still "lot of less good stuff that came out first and lot of good stuff still waiting" so you need
something to set "some standards" to say "this is too weak to be here, this not".
Then "how you set those standards" and how long it takes to be evaluated within those standards ?
Still "if the door is too easily open to anyting" you'll get into the iOS/Android domain where "eveything goes online" you'll
fill up your shelves pretty fast with 'gazillions' of thigs and no matter what at that point you get into the "visibility problem".
One way could be maybe "better categorization" so at least try to partition more that ocean, still it would be an ocean
of semi chaos, that clearly does not do much.
Then "the top X problem", if "top X" is always the same list and other stuff that maybe is just a bit below "top X" still takes
too long to appear you need at least some more "rotation" of that list, I don't say that in that sense "something that is not
top has to become top" but at least let's say "you know that people can't really see more than 20 apps at time", get the
first 100 and makes those 100 maybe in 5 groups of 20 and rotate them.
The main thing I think is at least "give people the possibility to really see things and make a choice by themselves" but this
means when you have "a lot" of appls make a way so "they really get seen at least some time X EACH ONE of them".
You could say "the user should do it by its own" but you know "it does not really work like that" because really where there
is too much stuff to look at you get lost and you don't really have the time/will to look at it all, you'll watch "a bit" and you'll
leave "the other bit" maybe for later an if meanwhile more stuff comes out how much you are ever going to see ?
Better search engine as well, one needs to be able to say "I want to see something around this kind of style" and be
presented with a real good selection of that, again this does not really solves the problem but it's just another aid.
It's .. messy because the quantity of stuff one should look at is really "too big" I really don't know for sure what one
could do to improve all that because no matter how you twist the thing the real thing is that there's really so much out there.
As a first "gamers should have well in mind what they want to play" .. but even this "is no good" because they may end
up in always playing the same things missing new stuff they never tried or tought they may enjoy to play.
But at the very least *hint* *hint* I hope they will avoid "some unexplicable decisions" like .. why "someone" created a
"category" "Retro" and Yak's game did not go even once in that "category" ?
If that's not "Retro" what else is

?
Anyway in all an all "marketplaces where things are like that" makes me scratch my head, true that in absence of those
you'd be/are totally by your own but yet it's never an 'optimal' situation, you do your best and that's all you can do.
What's "optimal/better" ? .. eh .. when for example you are going out not like "one game among other 20000" but like "one of the games in the 10 games of the year with a fuckload of marketing behind already and people drooling to see it".
Of course ..