Nice post.
I think that's a very interesting point of view and not one I necessarily disagree with. One could view the PS3 as being either technically brave (Cell, Blu-ray) or very very stupid (Cell, Blu-ray).
I'd view it as both. I mean, it's quite brave (and very ambitious) to launch a console with two unproven technologies. And it's quite awesome from a tech point of view. But ultimately, I'm not convinced it's going to add much to the gaming experience which, in the end, is what it's all about.
I mean, optical discs on the PS1 changed gaming. The PS2 was a nice console all-round, despite it not being as powerful as the competition. The processor/graphics/UMD in the PSP all adds up to make an amazing gaming experience. But ... Cell+Bluray doesn't do anything that PPC/x86+DVD couldn't do. So my point is that all the technologies that Sony have previously developed have added to the gaming experience. I don't see that with the PS3.
I'm not sure if I'm just jaded or not, but I think this is quite an unexciting time for gaming despite the tech, there just doesn't appear to be the anticipation or enthusiasm that was part of the Gamecube/Xbox/PS2 era. Some franchises are looking tired, and yet there's plenty of new IP (mostly from the PS2) that should be mind-blowing in HD. It's just that the "here and now" looks a bit dull.
I see what you're saying. I'm feeling a bit underwhelmed by the "HD-era". Lair was a game that I was getting really excited about, but after watching those videos, I'm not excited anymore. A while back my friend showed me a video of Dark Sector ... he was all excited about it, but it looked bland to me. I mean, it looked
gorgeous, but ultimately uninteresting. GTA4 I'm still very excited about, but the GTA formula is stale in my mind. After I played LCS on the PSP, I realised that I've been playing the same game for the past, what, 5 years? Graphics backed up with no new gameplay just won't cut it.
But I'm not entirely convinced. Nintendo first-party looks better than it's ever been. God Of War on the PSP looks ace. The indy developer will be in full force this gen. The DS is still spawning all sorts of crazy games.
Most importantly, we've got ... five, FIVE different consoles (ps3, 360, wii, ds, psp) that are all unique systems. Okay, the ps3/360 are interchangeable, but I can't remember the last time there were this many ways to play games. Each console brings something unique to the table, which is more than I can say about the ps2/xbox/gc.
I agree that the PSP has blossomed into pretty much must-have gaming kit when it looked almost dead not so long ago. The PS3 may well take the same slow-burn approach.
I don't think it can ... I don't think Sony can afford it! And theres a difference. The PSP & DS can co-exist peacefully in a household ... but once little Jonny decides to buy a 360 over a PS3, there isn't as much incentive to go off and buy a PS3 as well.
It's just that given how uber-successful the last round was, playing the waiting game for new gaming fixes isn't sitting easily. I'm already seeing people selling Wiis because of a perceived lack of games, it makes no sense.
I think there's too much impatience. Like come on now, there are lots of solid games on the Wii! Zelda, Elebits, Excite Truck, SSX, Sonic, etc, etc. It's the same situation on the PSP ... people *still* go on about how there aren't any games for it, which is crap!
It makes me wonder what people actually want and whether there is a degree of dissatisfaction and impatience creeping in. The video games industry is certainly looking a bit weird right now.
I think people want too much, all the time. If a good game comes out on a platform, the internet raves on about it for a couple of days, and then forgets about it. This just cements the idea that video games are disposable entertainment, and I'm not very happy with that notion.
SiN