gravy wrote:Dio wrote:There's nothing magic about beer that makes you fat, it's just about the balance of in vs. out. (At least, for some subset of people, I'm unconvinced it's true for everyone).
Wouldn't mind addressing the calories in / out hypotheses with regards to fat accumulation.
It's kind of nonsense isn't it?
That would mean it's impossible to gain fat while in calorific deficit.
It'd also mean that the body is pretty much the same as a calorimeter in how it extracts energy from completely different substances.
But both are not true. Your body choosing to store fat is a complex process that has variability across different people and can change even in one person according to their health or age. Here's a good example of how you can store and put on fat without eating more than you normally would. Type 1 diabetics have to inject insulin to to help control their glucose levels. It's important when injecting insulin that you rotate the injection points over time. Why? Because if you inject in the same place continually over time you will accumalate fat deposits. This is pretty much irrespective of what you're eating. It doesn't matter, the insulin injections will cause fat to deposit locally. Here's what can happen:
You state that as if it's obvious, but if you were to ask any qualified medical professional the vast majority would disagree. Research clearly points to increased fat intake leading to increased body weight. And you appear to be overly-defensive of criticism of this fad diet (despite inviting discussion on the subject). Why is that? You can't pick from a few medical cases in defending this idea where there is clearly a disorder (type I or type II diabetes) and apply it to the rest of the population. They have other problems with metabolizing food related (but not restricted) to dysfunctional HDL cholesterol (the 'good' type). For the vast majority of people, you get fat when you take in excess calories, no matter what the source. Most of the new diets (such as the misnamed Paleo diet) are to do with calorie restriction. Couple this with exercise and you will lose weight. I'd agree that a big fat steak will keep me feeling full longer, and I will reduce my calorie intake if I forgo the carbs found in macaroni and cheese or french fries as sides. The meals you posted a bit later suggest they are low calorie, although I obviously don't know the quantities eaten or any other specifics.
A frequent criticism of Gary Taubes is that he's highly selective of the evidence supporting his idea, and the way he ignores findings that don't support him borders on unscientific.
Your body doesn't digest fibre but it does burn in a calorimeter.
True, but insoluble dietary fiber does not contain any calories, and (in the US at least) is not counted.
Basically, as stated by others, if it makes you healthier, then do it. Just because medical opinion is against the inflated, pseudo-medical claims of Taubes (amongst others) doesn't mean that you can't lose weight by cutting carbs (only that the reasons for the weight loss are different). There is a definite case to be made about satiety and protein intake, which must make the diet easier to follow, although I have some reservations about eating increased quantities of meat (coronary heart disease).