teroHei wrote:I don't know the details but sounds bad for TxK.
IP on old games is apparently growing in value. Maybe not really in games but related to other media. Films like Wreck-It Ralph and the upcoming Pixels might be considered as indicators.
So I suppose every company that might have a claim to something, however tenuous the connection, will be trying to re-assess their ownership to this stuff and grab as much as they can. So if someone wants to make an "Atari Movie" they can sell and license the well-known characters and pop-cultural icons, like the Tempest Claw and that blob in Missile Command.
"Tempest claw" has been used in countless clones over the years. Basically, it comes down to defend-it-or-lose-it in most copyright cases. Tempest claw is not iconic. It could be replaced quite easily. It is not the selling point of TxK. It is not a character. It has not been used in ad-spend - pretty much ever. Tempest claw is not a brand.
Whatever the merits of individual aspects of their case, "Atari" has nothing at all to gain from their attack. They could have negotiated for Llamasoft to change elements of the game, or for a cut in exchange for making the game an official sequel, but attacking a tiny indy dev that has contributed their heart and soul to the industry for relative peanuts - there is nothing to be gained from it. It makes them look like bullies, and even if they win, they lose, because they destroy the final remnants of the brand. You don't appeal to art lovers by setting fire to the Mona Lisa. "Atari" demanding the end of TxK is sacrilege. Unfortunately "Atari" is just 10 people now. It certainly seems they only care about trademarks and IP now. And maybe they are in the business of exploiting IP for short term gain, no matter the long term cost to the reputation of the umbrella brand. Let's see.
If Atari really wants to be relevant they would hire llamasoft to oversee updated versions of all their popular games. The Atari brands only mean something because they were FUN TO PLAY. If you want to "exploit" the IP, then you make more games that are FUN TO PLAY. Llamasoft gets this. "Atari" doesn't. It is trading on fading memories of fun, instead of levering their blueprints/branding for fun to make more quality games for customers. "Atari" really just needs to fall on their sword, give llamasoft the all clear from further legal action. Furthermore, the should commit to making fun games, not T-shirts, shitty casino games or play to win bollocks. I'm sure that the "Atari" name in the context of quality neo-retro titles would still attract top-talent if it was headed by someone they trust.
I know it won't happen, but one can dream of the heart of the undead corpse of Atari starting to beat again. One can dream.