Paranormal season
Paranormal season
Unexplained things, living in a 600 year old house sounds, blasts of cold air. Children talking about 'George' talking to them. Spooky, but is it real?
Holier than thou
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Paranormal season
... if you believe in ghosts ...Orava wrote:Unexplained things, living in a 600 year old house sounds, blasts of cold air. Children talking about 'George' talking to them. Spooky, but is it real?
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Paranormal season
Is what real?
Unexplained things? Yes, there are things that people cannot explain.
What are those unexplained things? Well, that's the whole point. We don't know. That's why they are unexplained things. If we could say what they are, then they wouldn't be unexplained.
So, are unexplained things real?
Yes, it is real that we don't know everything. What things do we not know? If we knew that, then we'd know those things, and they'd therefore not be things we do not know.
The point where it becomes a logical fallacy is when you don't say "I don't know", but say "it was a ghost". Because then it's not an unexplained thing anymore, it's a ghost. You've explained it with a ghost.
Whichever way you cut it, the correct answer is "I don't know". Otherwise, you're lying.
(You might believe that there are ghosts but don't know that there are ghost. Fair enough. But believing something doesn't make it true, of course, so this still doesn't tell us whether ghosts are real and you should still say "I don't know". You can be "I don't know. But I have this really strong conviction". Sure, why not? That strong conviction tells us absolutely nothing, as your beliefs could be entirely wrong. But you can have them. What you can't do is make the logical leap from "I believe it, so it's true". No, believing things doesn't make anything true. That's not how belief or truth works. Again, whichever way you want to cut this, the only correct answer is "I don't know".)
Unexplained things? Yes, there are things that people cannot explain.
What are those unexplained things? Well, that's the whole point. We don't know. That's why they are unexplained things. If we could say what they are, then they wouldn't be unexplained.
So, are unexplained things real?
Yes, it is real that we don't know everything. What things do we not know? If we knew that, then we'd know those things, and they'd therefore not be things we do not know.
The point where it becomes a logical fallacy is when you don't say "I don't know", but say "it was a ghost". Because then it's not an unexplained thing anymore, it's a ghost. You've explained it with a ghost.
Whichever way you cut it, the correct answer is "I don't know". Otherwise, you're lying.
(You might believe that there are ghosts but don't know that there are ghost. Fair enough. But believing something doesn't make it true, of course, so this still doesn't tell us whether ghosts are real and you should still say "I don't know". You can be "I don't know. But I have this really strong conviction". Sure, why not? That strong conviction tells us absolutely nothing, as your beliefs could be entirely wrong. But you can have them. What you can't do is make the logical leap from "I believe it, so it's true". No, believing things doesn't make anything true. That's not how belief or truth works. Again, whichever way you want to cut this, the only correct answer is "I don't know".)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Paranormal season
Orava wrote:Children talking about 'George' talking to them.

"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
Re: Paranormal season
Is the Tank Museum home to a haunted tank? (and not just any tank, but to many, the tank [1]):
[1] Unstoppable armoured titan of the Wehrmacht, or useless overweight unreliable fuel-guzzling failure? Those are the only two sides, pick one!
[1] Unstoppable armoured titan of the Wehrmacht, or useless overweight unreliable fuel-guzzling failure? Those are the only two sides, pick one!
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
- Deckard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10749
- Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 11:27 pm 0
- Location: Falmouth, Cornwall, UK
Re: Paranormal season
Nope its not real - see the complete lack of high quality footage from a world that has cameras literally everywhere...total moon shite and I really cant believe the Beeb have a ghost programme (UNcanny) but not a car or gaming one...
See also people seeing witches in the sky 100s years ago and then replaced with UFOs as nasa and sci-fi hit.....
People and their minds are very very unreliable witnesses -
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IGQmdoK_ZfY
Plus you're actual vision is 20 / 20 on a postage stamp as arms length....
Remember even your reality as you read this is warped - where is your nose ?
Give me a hard 4k Video as proof please...
Occams razor plays out here a lot - that door that just creaked open - Was it pushed from the spiritual realm by a long dead relation of yours or did an air current catch it ?
Did those aliens travel billions of miles just to abduct you even though you're joe average and know zilch or was it a falling star ?
And as for belief most people would benefit from believing in themselves.....
See also people seeing witches in the sky 100s years ago and then replaced with UFOs as nasa and sci-fi hit.....
People and their minds are very very unreliable witnesses -
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IGQmdoK_ZfY
Plus you're actual vision is 20 / 20 on a postage stamp as arms length....
Remember even your reality as you read this is warped - where is your nose ?
Give me a hard 4k Video as proof please...
Occams razor plays out here a lot - that door that just creaked open - Was it pushed from the spiritual realm by a long dead relation of yours or did an air current catch it ?
Did those aliens travel billions of miles just to abduct you even though you're joe average and know zilch or was it a falling star ?
And as for belief most people would benefit from believing in themselves.....
Now with a new Mac Mini Pro so dont judge me !
Re: Paranormal season
Before the recent resurgence in UFO nonsense I thought the whole Fortean phenomena genre had been largely wiped out by ubiquitous cameraphones. Why that part of the crazy is surviving I don't know.
(Let's be quite clear - very large sums of money have been offered to people to produce any actual evidence of ghost-like phenomena, and lots of people go investigating it. The evidence produced so far totals exactly zero.)
Although having experienced a bereavement recently, I can say for sure that it sure can feel like you're being haunted at times. When my family came back from a week away my wife asked what my week was like and I replied "I was alone with the ghost of my brother". Our heads are funny things.
(Let's be quite clear - very large sums of money have been offered to people to produce any actual evidence of ghost-like phenomena, and lots of people go investigating it. The evidence produced so far totals exactly zero.)
Although having experienced a bereavement recently, I can say for sure that it sure can feel like you're being haunted at times. When my family came back from a week away my wife asked what my week was like and I replied "I was alone with the ghost of my brother". Our heads are funny things.
- Deckard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10749
- Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 11:27 pm 0
- Location: Falmouth, Cornwall, UK
Re: Paranormal season
Yep funny how that prize hasn't been accepted -
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One_Milli ... _Challenge
And the horse that could read minds is interesting too -
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lady_Wond ... 0Wonder%20(February%209%2C%201924,the%20more%20than%20150%2C000%20visitors.
The human mind and its ability to fool its owner and other people are incredible...
Again the Mandela effect is truly odd too -
"Specific false memories can sometimes be shared by a large group of people. This phenomenon was dubbed the "Mandela effect" by paranormal researcher Fiona Broome, who reported having vivid and detailed memories of news coverage of South African anti-apartheid leader Nelson Mandela dying in prison in the 1980s, despite Mandela actually dying in 2013, decades after his release and after serving as President of South Africa from 1994 to 1999. Broome reported that "perhaps thousands" of other people had written online about having the same memory of Mandela's death since 2010, and she speculated that the phenomenon could be evidence of parallel realities."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One_Milli ... _Challenge
And the horse that could read minds is interesting too -
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lady_Wond ... 0Wonder%20(February%209%2C%201924,the%20more%20than%20150%2C000%20visitors.
The human mind and its ability to fool its owner and other people are incredible...
Again the Mandela effect is truly odd too -
"Specific false memories can sometimes be shared by a large group of people. This phenomenon was dubbed the "Mandela effect" by paranormal researcher Fiona Broome, who reported having vivid and detailed memories of news coverage of South African anti-apartheid leader Nelson Mandela dying in prison in the 1980s, despite Mandela actually dying in 2013, decades after his release and after serving as President of South Africa from 1994 to 1999. Broome reported that "perhaps thousands" of other people had written online about having the same memory of Mandela's death since 2010, and she speculated that the phenomenon could be evidence of parallel realities."
Now with a new Mac Mini Pro so dont judge me !
Re: Paranormal season
There is certainly a lot of stuff we just have no idea about (and probably never will).
Not ghosts (as we think of them anyway) but something we certainly can't explain or experience currently.
Like the vastness of sapce it is hard to get our heads around and so the brain will always try to assign it something we can make (some kind) of sense of, no matter how 'out there' it might seem at times and this accounts for all sorts of wierd experiences I'm sure.
Einstein's relativity is interesting because it does sort of allow for it to be possible for people to still be around somewhere after death (as we know it) because there is no 'now' in relativity. It's all wrapped up in speed of light and space-time etc and to deep to go into here, but fascinating and not really the parts of his theories that get talked about much.
Not ghosts (as we think of them anyway) but something we certainly can't explain or experience currently.
Like the vastness of sapce it is hard to get our heads around and so the brain will always try to assign it something we can make (some kind) of sense of, no matter how 'out there' it might seem at times and this accounts for all sorts of wierd experiences I'm sure.
Einstein's relativity is interesting because it does sort of allow for it to be possible for people to still be around somewhere after death (as we know it) because there is no 'now' in relativity. It's all wrapped up in speed of light and space-time etc and to deep to go into here, but fascinating and not really the parts of his theories that get talked about much.
- Deckard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10749
- Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 11:27 pm 0
- Location: Falmouth, Cornwall, UK
Re: Paranormal season
Yeah there is a theory that every moment that has ever existed always exists...and another that there is now only now and Time is just a human construct - there are lots of things I dont think humans will ever know....and I hate the idea of a multiverse as it just means choice doesnt matter.....
Now with a new Mac Mini Pro so dont judge me !
Re: Paranormal season
Used to live in a property that had a cellar with lots of children's toys about you really felt unconforantable down tjetr
Holier than thou
Re: Paranormal season
I've experienced the Mandela Effect. It's freaky as hell.
I vividly recall the news of Catchphrase's Roy Walker's death. I remember the clip of Mr.Chips they showed. The black-and-white still photo with the dates, as they do on obituaries. The solemn seriousness of Sophie Raworth, tasked with announcing it. I remember the room I was in, how I felt. The works.
I've got a good memory, so I remember a lot of the details of this incident. This must have been around 10 years ago.
Except, of course, at time of writing, Roy Walker is alive and well. So the incident I recall - vividly, complete with minor details - never actually happened.
It's a freaky as fuck feeling.
And, like, I'm not your normal candidate for this kind of thing. I don't believe the supernatural exists - nor, indeed, could logically exist. I'm Vulcan all the way down.
But I can confirm that the experience is definitely a real thing. Not, of course, that it's actually a real thing that history altered when no-one was looking, but just that, yup, the experience - and being utterly convinced of it, as you have vivid memories of it all, complete with fine details - is something that happens.
And, no, you do not have to be any kind of "believer" for this weird mind phenomenon to have a hold of you. I'm the first - quite literally, because look who came in with the "press X to doubt" in this thread - to point out that it's all bullshit.
But it really does happen. One theory I've been toying with is that maybe what it is, is that it's something I dreamt once. Because though I recall all these details, they do have that "fuzzy around the edges, can't zoom in on the details" dream-like feel to them.
So my alternative theory is that I dreamt this at some point. I was having a dream while sleeping and it featured the news of Roy Walker's death - don't ask me why, dreams are weird - and then when I saw something about Catchphrase, it triggered this memory. But it's not a memory of reality, it's a memory of a dream.
Usually, when we wake up from a dream, you've got a limited time window in which to recall it, and it fades away. Then you can't remember what it was.
I'm thinking that though I can't consciously access the memories of the dreams I've had, they're still in my brain somewhere. So, when thinking certain thoughts, it bubbles up these subconscious memories - reconnects me to the memories of the dream that I can't will myself to remember, but it's "leaked" out of the subconscious and now my conscious has a handle by which to fish it out again.
Granted, this only explains "the Mandela Effect" on an individual level, not the collective recollection of history that provably never happened. But then, you know, I've only experienced it on a personal level, so I don't know that the collective memory thing is real.
Unless, you know, some of you guys also remember Sophie Raworth announcing Roy Walker's death on the news as well?
At that point then, okay, maybe it really is "switching timelines" or something. I don't know.
I vividly recall the news of Catchphrase's Roy Walker's death. I remember the clip of Mr.Chips they showed. The black-and-white still photo with the dates, as they do on obituaries. The solemn seriousness of Sophie Raworth, tasked with announcing it. I remember the room I was in, how I felt. The works.
I've got a good memory, so I remember a lot of the details of this incident. This must have been around 10 years ago.
Except, of course, at time of writing, Roy Walker is alive and well. So the incident I recall - vividly, complete with minor details - never actually happened.
It's a freaky as fuck feeling.
And, like, I'm not your normal candidate for this kind of thing. I don't believe the supernatural exists - nor, indeed, could logically exist. I'm Vulcan all the way down.
But I can confirm that the experience is definitely a real thing. Not, of course, that it's actually a real thing that history altered when no-one was looking, but just that, yup, the experience - and being utterly convinced of it, as you have vivid memories of it all, complete with fine details - is something that happens.
And, no, you do not have to be any kind of "believer" for this weird mind phenomenon to have a hold of you. I'm the first - quite literally, because look who came in with the "press X to doubt" in this thread - to point out that it's all bullshit.
But it really does happen. One theory I've been toying with is that maybe what it is, is that it's something I dreamt once. Because though I recall all these details, they do have that "fuzzy around the edges, can't zoom in on the details" dream-like feel to them.
So my alternative theory is that I dreamt this at some point. I was having a dream while sleeping and it featured the news of Roy Walker's death - don't ask me why, dreams are weird - and then when I saw something about Catchphrase, it triggered this memory. But it's not a memory of reality, it's a memory of a dream.
Usually, when we wake up from a dream, you've got a limited time window in which to recall it, and it fades away. Then you can't remember what it was.
I'm thinking that though I can't consciously access the memories of the dreams I've had, they're still in my brain somewhere. So, when thinking certain thoughts, it bubbles up these subconscious memories - reconnects me to the memories of the dream that I can't will myself to remember, but it's "leaked" out of the subconscious and now my conscious has a handle by which to fish it out again.
Granted, this only explains "the Mandela Effect" on an individual level, not the collective recollection of history that provably never happened. But then, you know, I've only experienced it on a personal level, so I don't know that the collective memory thing is real.
Unless, you know, some of you guys also remember Sophie Raworth announcing Roy Walker's death on the news as well?
At that point then, okay, maybe it really is "switching timelines" or something. I don't know.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- Dvorak
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4560
- Joined: Wed May 08, 2002 7:37 am 0
- Yahoo Messenger: d3dxquaternion
- Location: Germany
Re: Paranormal season
Just confabulation, KC.
Wikipedia describes it mainly as something quite pathological (brain damage, at least).
But seeing AIs hallucinate I'd say confabulation is a basic process within any mind, bridging stepping stones of what we actually know.
Wikipedia describes it mainly as something quite pathological (brain damage, at least).
But seeing AIs hallucinate I'd say confabulation is a basic process within any mind, bridging stepping stones of what we actually know.
>take off sunglasses
Seamen and fishermen alike swear to have heard voices in the rising tide. Inhuman screams, some of them say.
Seamen and fishermen alike swear to have heard voices in the rising tide. Inhuman screams, some of them say.
Re: Paranormal season
One of the things about having quite a good memory is that you can eventually see places where you have overlapping but contradictory memories of the same event. I have at least three of those where I genuinely couldn't tell you if I actually did X instead of Y or I just thought at some point I might have done X and my brain eventually caused that to feel true.
I've always assumed this is basically just the brain manufacturing detail to fill out its lossy compression of things, but it doesn't distinguish well between manufactured detail and what actually happened when it comes to recording that thing as memory.
(And that process seems to be somewhat revealed in the whole generative AI process, right?)
I've always assumed this is basically just the brain manufacturing detail to fill out its lossy compression of things, but it doesn't distinguish well between manufactured detail and what actually happened when it comes to recording that thing as memory.
(And that process seems to be somewhat revealed in the whole generative AI process, right?)
Re: Paranormal season
Exactly. And that's entirely how I see it as well.Dvorak wrote:Just confabulation, KC.
Wikipedia describes it mainly as something quite pathological (brain damage, at least).
But seeing AIs hallucinate I'd say confabulation is a basic process within any mind, bridging stepping stones of what we actually know.
But, like, I also know what it feels like "from the inside" too, as it's happened to me. I can see it from both sides.
And, yeah, it's a "hallucination", just like we see with AI. A rational device - the brain - trying to make irrational data fit and make sense.
As I say, I do wonder if the "irrational data" is coming from a dream I once had or something. But where we normally forget dreams, this one has sneaked its way into being accessible to my conscious mind and, therefore, now feels like a real thing that actually happened. But it only "happened" in the dream world, in fact.
Something like that.
Neural networks are an impressive circuit. Able to find patterns in anything. Even stuff where, you know, there really isn't a legit pattern in there, but if a pattern can be made out of it regardless, a neural network will see that pattern.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes

