The definitive Space Giraffe thread

XBLA and PC.
Post Reply
Dr Derek Doctors
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 44
Joined: Mon Sep 15, 2003 4:46 pm 0
Location: Manchester, UK
Contact:

Post by Dr Derek Doctors »

Dave wrote: But the publication is providing the review, not the reviewer. The reviewer has been given the duty to create a stateless, general review of something, and not sway the opinion of the entire publication to one extreme or another. That's not reviewing. It's editorializing.

There's a difference between a movie critic who analyzes a movie and formulates a review for the entire world to see, and someone who writes their opinion about the movie on Rotten Tomatoes. One comes from a professional who spends their life doing nothing but movies, while the other is an amateur who has an opinion, but not that life-long knowledge of what goes into making a good movie.
I suspect that you and I look for very different things in a review, and so we simply aren't going to agree on what makes for a good one. Personally I'd rather read informed opinion from someone who understands games. Whether this reviewer truly does, I don't know, but to dismiss him out of hand doesn't strike me as the correct course of action.
Dave wrote: Jeff's games are purposely inherently difficult to see, "unless" you're a skilled gamer who realizes that it's not all madness in there, but well thought out design and structure.

One can easily miss that structure if they don't give the game enough play time. And you do need to be a particular type of hardcore gamer to fully enjoy it too.
Y'see that's a statement which just turns me off. The idea of a game who tries to hide what I need to know from me really doesn't appeal to me at a basic level. Also I don't think it's a description I agree with, given my experiences with those games of Jeff's that I've played. I don't think that many of them have tried to make it difficult to see them, in fact it's really only Space Giraffe which appears to have taken that approach.
Dave wrote: All valid points. And you're right, reading the review and playing the game should be done before jumping to conclusions. Hopefully in a few weeks we'll all be playing and enjoying SG en-masses. :D
Hear hear!
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Post by gilesgoat »

rockwaldo wrote:*SNIP*

You didnt make this game for them anyway - so who cares what they think?
"I didn't make it for you !" - Frank N Further :wink:
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Post by gilesgoat »

Dr Derek Doctors wrote:
Dave wrote: But the publication is providing the review, not the reviewer. The reviewer has been given the duty to create a stateless, general review of something, and not sway the opinion of the entire publication to one extreme or another. That's not reviewing. It's editorializing.

There's a difference between a movie critic who analyzes a movie and formulates a review for the entire world to see, and someone who writes their opinion about the movie on Rotten Tomatoes. One comes from a professional who spends their life doing nothing but movies, while the other is an amateur who has an opinion, but not that life-long knowledge of what goes into making a good movie.
I suspect that you and I look for very different things in a review, and so we simply aren't going to agree on what makes for a good one. Personally I'd rather read informed opinion from someone who understands games. Whether this reviewer truly does, I don't know, but to dismiss him out of hand doesn't strike me as the correct course of action.
Dave wrote: Jeff's games are purposely inherently difficult to see, "unless" you're a skilled gamer who realizes that it's not all madness in there, but well thought out design and structure.

One can easily miss that structure if they don't give the game enough play time. And you do need to be a particular type of hardcore gamer to fully enjoy it too.
Y'see that's a statement which just turns me off. The idea of a game who tries to hide what I need to know from me really doesn't appeal to me at a basic level. Also I don't think it's a description I agree with, given my experiences with those games of Jeff's that I've played. I don't think that many of them have tried to make it difficult to see them, in fact it's really only Space Giraffe which appears to have taken that approach.
Dave wrote: All valid points. And you're right, reading the review and playing the game should be done before jumping to conclusions. Hopefully in a few weeks we'll all be playing and enjoying SG en-masses. :D
Hear hear!
You wrote that review haven't you ? :wink:
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Kamineko
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7569
Joined: Fri Dec 17, 2004 2:53 pm 0
Contact:

Post by Kamineko »

gilesgoat wrote:
rockwaldo wrote:*SNIP*

You didnt make this game for them anyway - so who cares what they think?
"I didn't make it for you !" - Frank N Further :wink:
Can't help it!
User avatar
grue
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 9178
Joined: Sun Jan 18, 2004 1:33 pm 0
Location: Greece
Contact:

Post by grue »

Dr Derek I can't believe what you're going on about. You are ready to take the opinion of a nameless (so far) reviewer who for all that we know didn't play the game for more than 5 minutes. Here you are though reading the opinions of so many people who have played it repeatedly over the last few months. I really can't understand how can you trust the former more than the later.
Armed with a Cintiq+4+bless I'm off to fight bad taste!
Take a look at my art and t-shirts
User avatar
Yak
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 20266
Joined: Wed Apr 17, 2002 10:22 am 0
Location: Wales
Contact:

Post by Yak »

And the fact is that bullets *never* pop out of nowhere to surprise you. Enemies are specifically forbidden to fire at a range closer than would be fair to allow for the player to react. Every shot is accompanied by visual and auditary cues that are plainly visible and audible for anyone who actually wants to look.

Being accused of that kind of crap specifically rankles because I *know* that the necessary cues are provided through more than one sensory channel, quite comprehensively. To say that the cues are absent is just wrong and stupid.
Justified and Ancient.
Dr Derek Doctors
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 44
Joined: Mon Sep 15, 2003 4:46 pm 0
Location: Manchester, UK
Contact:

Post by Dr Derek Doctors »

Yak wrote: Yes, but landing a job as a game reviewer implies that one have a degree of competence. And really, SG is no Ikaruga in terms of difficulty. I actually dislike diff curves that are onerously steep at the outset.
Yes, I agree that people who suck at games shouldn't review them. And likewise people shouldn't review outside of their comfort zone.

It may well be that due to the perceived 2nd-tier nature of XBLA titles this review was seen as less important and not given to the right person to do, but it may also be that it was, and they couldn't see the bullets. I won't know which version of events I agree with until I play the game.
Yak wrote: We had all sorts playing the game during alpha and subsequent test and if it weren't possible to see the enemies then I'd've heard about it and the scores would've reflected the truth of it. But everyone actually had a good time and the game was universally perceived to be fair. I did have a few people say that it took a few goes to get into it at first, but that once past that it was fine.

So do I believe all those people were wrong and/or deluded, or that mateyboy at OXM never bothered to progress past the few goes necessary to acclimatise?

Occam's razor would lead me to conclude the latter.
Tbh - and I'm treading on thin ice here I know - I'd have to know the precise makeup of the people who played it and their previous opinion of your works before I decided if that was a compelling argument.

For instance, where these testers by and large people at retro events, then I'm fairly sure that's a pretty forgiving crowd, by and large. It's also quite a social crowd who won't want to say "Actually, I really don't like this at all".

However, were it genuine neutral test groups, then that makes your argument quite convincing. But again, until I play it, my thoughts about the game are all conjecture.
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Post by gilesgoat »

.. and also thanks to all this now I have that fucking word spinning in
my mind .. "sophomoric" .. what the hell ?

It makes me thinks at a medicine .. at something like "oxymoron" ..
at something that probably makes you sleep but should not ..

..

..

.. "sophomoric" .. .. for some weird thing it makes me think it has to be
a kind of medicine that comes in a powder form ..

..

..

Or looks like a quality of wood .. .. mah ...
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
Dr Derek Doctors
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 44
Joined: Mon Sep 15, 2003 4:46 pm 0
Location: Manchester, UK
Contact:

Post by Dr Derek Doctors »

grue wrote:Dr Derek I can't believe what you're going on about. You are ready to take the opinion of a nameless (so far) reviewer who for all that we know didn't play the game for more than 5 minutes. Here you are though reading the opinions of so many people who have played it repeatedly over the last few months. I really can't understand how can you trust the former more than the later.
I think I would equally distrust the opinions of both a nameless reviewer (who - for all we know played the game for many hours) and those of people who are self-confessed fans of Jeff's work and who quite often vociferously attack dissenters. :)
Last edited by Dr Derek Doctors on Fri Aug 17, 2007 12:12 am 0, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Yak
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 20266
Joined: Wed Apr 17, 2002 10:22 am 0
Location: Wales
Contact:

Post by Yak »

er, our alpha test was a bit more rigorous than "a bunch of people at a retro weekend" and yes, I would have expected real criticism if I'd been doing stuff wrong.

But purely empirically and outside of anyone's opinions, the lie can be comprehensively given to the "impossible to see the bullets" argument simply by the fact that good SG players consistently score better than less good ones. As I said before, if the game's cues were genuinely not visible then scores would be pretty homogeneous due to random, unfair deaths. This is very much not the case (and I can, if necessary, post screencaps of leaderboard rankings and scores showing that to be true).

So I can *prove* that the "bullets aren't visible" argument is a flat-out lie or a simple lack of competence.
Justified and Ancient.
Dr Derek Doctors
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 44
Joined: Mon Sep 15, 2003 4:46 pm 0
Location: Manchester, UK
Contact:

Post by Dr Derek Doctors »

Yak wrote:And the fact is that bullets *never* pop out of nowhere to surprise you. Enemies are specifically forbidden to fire at a range closer than would be fair to allow for the player to react. Every shot is accompanied by visual and auditary cues that are plainly visible and audible for anyone who actually wants to look.

Being accused of that kind of crap specifically rankles because I *know* that the necessary cues are provided through more than one sensory channel, quite comprehensively. To say that the cues are absent is just wrong and stupid.
I'm happy to hear you don't fire bullets close to people - that's gameplay 101. However - theoretically - if a person couldn't discern a bullet fired some distance away until it got a lot closer then that would have a similar effect, wouldn't it?
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Post by gilesgoat »

By the way ..

British way : someone takes out a cup of tea

Italian way : Giles takes out the guitar and begins to play and sing
"Reviewers .. reviewers .. revievers that rate all those games . ... .. "

( you must be completely Italian to understand this one :roll: :mrgreen: )
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Post by gilesgoat »

Dr Derek Doctors wrote:
Yak wrote:And the fact is that bullets *never* pop out of nowhere to surprise you. Enemies are specifically forbidden to fire at a range closer than would be fair to allow for the player to react. Every shot is accompanied by visual and auditary cues that are plainly visible and audible for anyone who actually wants to look.

Being accused of that kind of crap specifically rankles because I *know* that the necessary cues are provided through more than one sensory channel, quite comprehensively. To say that the cues are absent is just wrong and stupid.
I'm happy to hear you don't fire bullets close to people - that's gameplay 101. However - theoretically - if a person couldn't discern a bullet fired some distance away until it got a lot closer then that would have a similar effect, wouldn't it?
You are the one that wrote that review aren't you ? Or you know the one that did isn't it ? :wink:
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
james_bass
Posts: 5
Joined: Sun Jul 01, 2007 1:14 am 0

Post by james_bass »

Dave wrote:The reviewer has been given the duty to create a stateless, general review of something [...] That's not reviewing. It's editorializing. (sic)
*snip*

Er, no. Utter nonsense. Here's my "editorial":

The reviewer, or should I say journalist, is there to write copy which sells. When copy sells, ideas spread, be that for better or worse (admittedly). While this neither justifies nor excuses this chump, one has to ask why people perceive journalists as scum?

This review is clearly gutter tabloid bullshit. And from the amount of pan-forum discussion generated it seems to have done its job.

However, there is much to be said for "all publicity is good publicity".

A 4 or a 6 would have been *far* more devastating. Who wants mediocrity? I think from what I've read in these pages is that some consideration needs to be put into how these scores should be read. Is it reasonable to believe the publicity would have been better if Space Giraffe got a score like this?

And this being from the "Official" Xbox Magazine? From a conspiracy point of view, this little excercise will probably/hopefully cause more copies to be sold. 2 out of 10 is so *conspicuous*. I see a cult classic in the making. You just wait for the other reviews. And the sales.

I sympathise with your points of view - it must be really hard at this stage but don't take this apparent "criticism" to heart; don't believe a word of it. Believe in the forums. Believe in the word of mouth generated by this and the support rallying around you and the consequent units sold.

I hate it in a way as well, but step back from it, try to laugh at the idiocy - the idiotic lunacy of this supposed ignorant review - and try to see it as the ultimate compliment in a world of banal and boring games and even duller/annoying associated marketing bullshit and moribund print journalism.

Hang in there Jeff and Giles, my men, it will all come good. If there is a conspiracy, it's in your favour. You've got a great game, an artistic statement, and sure, this view is all a bit postmodern, but I am genuinely looking forward to buying it because from what I can see, it looks like a stormingly fun game.

And it seems I am not alone in thinking this.

EDIT: Various typos
Last edited by james_bass on Fri Aug 17, 2007 12:17 am 0, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
Yak
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 20266
Joined: Wed Apr 17, 2002 10:22 am 0
Location: Wales
Contact:

Post by Yak »

Dr Derek Doctors wrote:
Yak wrote:And the fact is that bullets *never* pop out of nowhere to surprise you. Enemies are specifically forbidden to fire at a range closer than would be fair to allow for the player to react. Every shot is accompanied by visual and auditary cues that are plainly visible and audible for anyone who actually wants to look.

Being accused of that kind of crap specifically rankles because I *know* that the necessary cues are provided through more than one sensory channel, quite comprehensively. To say that the cues are absent is just wrong and stupid.
I'm happy to hear you don't fire bullets close to people - that's gameplay 101. However - theoretically - if a person couldn't discern a bullet fired some distance away until it got a lot closer then that would have a similar effect, wouldn't it?
didn't you read my second paragraph?

"Being accused of that kind of crap specifically rankles because I *know* that the necessary cues are provided through more than one sensory channel, quite comprehensively. To say that the cues are absent is just wrong and stupid".
Justified and Ancient.
Post Reply