Dave wrote:The reviewer has been given the duty to create a stateless, general review of something [...] That's not reviewing. It's editorializing. (sic)
*snip*
Er, no. Utter nonsense. Here's my "editorial":
The reviewer, or should I say
journalist, is there to write copy which sells. When copy sells, ideas spread, be that for better or worse (admittedly). While this neither justifies nor excuses this chump, one has to ask why people perceive journalists as scum?
This review is clearly gutter tabloid bullshit. And from the amount of pan-forum discussion generated it seems to have done its job.
However, there is much to be said for "all publicity is good publicity".
A 4 or a 6 would have been *far* more devastating. Who wants mediocrity? I think from what I've read in these pages is that some consideration needs to be put into how these scores should be read. Is it reasonable to believe the publicity would have been better if Space Giraffe got a score like this?
And this being from the "Official" Xbox Magazine? From a conspiracy point of view, this little excercise will probably/hopefully cause more copies to be sold. 2 out of 10 is so *conspicuous*. I see a cult classic in the making. You just wait for the other reviews. And the sales.
I sympathise with your points of view - it must be really hard at this stage but don't take this apparent "criticism" to heart; don't believe a word of it. Believe in the forums. Believe in the word of mouth generated by this and the support rallying around you and the consequent units sold.
I hate it in a way as well, but step back from it, try to laugh at the idiocy - the idiotic lunacy of this supposed ignorant review - and try to see it as the
ultimate compliment in a world of banal and boring games and even duller/annoying associated marketing bullshit and moribund print journalism.
Hang in there Jeff and Giles, my men, it will all come good. If there is a conspiracy, it's in your favour. You've got a great game, an artistic statement, and sure, this view is all a bit postmodern, but I am genuinely looking forward to buying it because from what I can see, it looks like a stormingly fun game.
And it seems I am not alone in thinking this.
EDIT: Various typos