Car servicing - are you sitting down?
- Viscount Charles
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2008
- Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2002 5:34 pm 0
I feel you pain. My first set of rear brake discs lasted just 20,000 miles, under a year - cost about £500 to replace, no question about it being done under warranty, "wear and tear item, sir, pay up."
Yet my CURRENT pads (which I EXPECT to wear) AND discs have together done something like 30-40,000 (I keep expecting them to tell me the pads need doing, they keep telling me that they're fine). So let me get this right - a set of pads on the front wheels have lasted longer than my first set of rear discs? And I've now done 100,000 miles, and the rear didcs haven't been replaced after that first time - still just wear and tear? Hmph.
Yet my CURRENT pads (which I EXPECT to wear) AND discs have together done something like 30-40,000 (I keep expecting them to tell me the pads need doing, they keep telling me that they're fine). So let me get this right - a set of pads on the front wheels have lasted longer than my first set of rear discs? And I've now done 100,000 miles, and the rear didcs haven't been replaced after that first time - still just wear and tear? Hmph.
"Put me back on my bike!"
I'd question the clutch going as non-warranty as well; a clutch should not fail inside five years unless there's a mechanical fault or your driving's seriously shafted.
Brake pads are a bit different - different types do have quite radically different wear patterns. The discs going early I would question though.
Brake pads are a bit different - different types do have quite radically different wear patterns. The discs going early I would question though.
- Nerdsville
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1423
- Joined: Mon Jun 16, 2003 11:07 am 0
- Yahoo Messenger: nerdsville
- Location: Nottinghamshire
- Contact:
I used a Nissan main dealer in Lincoln who at 70,000 miles told me my front discs on my XTrail were getting worn, asked if I need to replace them said "Oh no should be fine till next service but we will make a note so when you book your next service we will have them in stock..."Dio wrote:Brake pads are a bit different - different types do have quite radically different wear patterns. The discs going early I would question though.
This main dealer goes into receivership so at the 82,000 mile service I had to take it to another main dealer in Grantham and mentioned about the discs, they took a look at them and said they were absolutely fine but I was in need of some new pads that should really have been replaced at last service!
- Kelloggs
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1859
- Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2005 11:38 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: TheAntiKelloggs
- Location: Widnes or Altrincham. Take your pick.
(Note: This is what happens when I go to bed. Everyone wakes up while I'm asleep!)
The clutch on the last car was slipping, which I've experienced before. I could still drive it, but it was too far gone for others to. The only problem with this time was that selecting reverse (and only when it hadn't been run, and only in our drive) would *GRIND* four times out of five.
As an experiment, I tried backing into the drive, so the car would be parked the opposite way on the slight incline. Result: No grind. Only did that once, though, so I wouldn't treat it as statistically significant, but that sounds more like lubricant shifting under gravity to me.
I don't think it's my driving, but this is now the third bit of clutchwork needed in seventeen years' driving. I'm of the mind that - despite Ford's best protestations - such a major subsystem shouldn't be developing a fault quite so soon, unless I'm doing something so daft with the car as to leave evidence elsewhere.
However, I may have a secret weapon. My dad. Imagine, if you will, a Victor Meldrew-esque character who has, as one of his (few!) hobbies in life, writing extremely polite letters to high-ups in large companies, pointing out that the behaviour of their peons might not quite be commenurate with the image of the company that he's sure they would want to give. He and my mum are on holiday at the moment (hence why I am, too - I'm just Enjoying the Silence, to paraphrase Depeche Mode) and by my calculations, he'll have a good head of steam when he gets back next Tuesday to come up with something scathing.
While I'm off to Costco for new tyres, I might get a large tub of popcorn...
The clutch on the last car was slipping, which I've experienced before. I could still drive it, but it was too far gone for others to. The only problem with this time was that selecting reverse (and only when it hadn't been run, and only in our drive) would *GRIND* four times out of five.
As an experiment, I tried backing into the drive, so the car would be parked the opposite way on the slight incline. Result: No grind. Only did that once, though, so I wouldn't treat it as statistically significant, but that sounds more like lubricant shifting under gravity to me.
I don't think it's my driving, but this is now the third bit of clutchwork needed in seventeen years' driving. I'm of the mind that - despite Ford's best protestations - such a major subsystem shouldn't be developing a fault quite so soon, unless I'm doing something so daft with the car as to leave evidence elsewhere.
However, I may have a secret weapon. My dad. Imagine, if you will, a Victor Meldrew-esque character who has, as one of his (few!) hobbies in life, writing extremely polite letters to high-ups in large companies, pointing out that the behaviour of their peons might not quite be commenurate with the image of the company that he's sure they would want to give. He and my mum are on holiday at the moment (hence why I am, too - I'm just Enjoying the Silence, to paraphrase Depeche Mode) and by my calculations, he'll have a good head of steam when he gets back next Tuesday to come up with something scathing.
While I'm off to Costco for new tyres, I might get a large tub of popcorn...
If it grinds when you try to select reverse (or is stiff to select 1st) it means that the gearbox shafts are turning. They basically shouldn't be when you've got the clutch fully pressed and the car is stationary.
I'd definitely go back and ask exactly what they did to fix it, what parts they changed etc.
I'd definitely go back and ask exactly what they did to fix it, what parts they changed etc.
(just show, no stabby stabby)
- Kelloggs
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1859
- Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2005 11:38 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: TheAntiKelloggs
- Location: Widnes or Altrincham. Take your pick.
The itemised bill I have contains such lines as:
(all ex. VAT, which then goes at the end). That's the only mention of Clutch in it.
When I brought the car home last night, reverse was silent; I'm out shopping today (for petrol, if nothing else) and I'll be listening very carefully for grinding noises.
Code: Select all
KIT - CLUTCH RE 95.15
:
:
SUPPLY AND FIT NEW CLUTCH 315.00
When I brought the car home last night, reverse was silent; I'm out shopping today (for petrol, if nothing else) and I'll be listening very carefully for grinding noises.
Flipping Heck! I would of swallowed my own tounge hearing that. Don't replace the pads and they'll damage the discs eventually, and then they get to sell you disc/pad combo next service, cheeky sob's.Nerdsville wrote:I used a Nissan main dealer in Lincoln who at 70,000 miles told me my front discs on my XTrail were getting worn, asked if I need to replace them said "Oh no should be fine till next service but we will make a note so when you book your next service we will have them in stock..."Dio wrote:Brake pads are a bit different - different types do have quite radically different wear patterns. The discs going early I would question though.
This main dealer goes into receivership so at the 82,000 mile service I had to take it to another main dealer in Grantham and mentioned about the discs, they took a look at them and said they were absolutely fine but I was in need of some new pads that should really have been replaced at last service!
01000101 01000100 01000111 01000101
http://www.redbubble.com/people/fotofill/ buy my photos!
Hmmm. If those have mostly been old motors (5 years plus) that's nothing to worry about. If they've been significantly newer than that, I would say that's an odd statistical blip - but could still be within the grounds of random chance, particularly if you live in a hilly area...Kelloggs wrote:I don't think it's my driving, but this is now the third bit of clutchwork needed in seventeen years' driving.
Don't remember ever having had a clutch change myself, although I've had cable problems (but that car was best part of 15 years old at that point
Weird. Suppose a warped clutch disc could have caused it but that's pretty rare. You haven't been towing heavy things with it or anything like that?Kelloggs wrote:The itemised bill I have contains such lines as:
(all ex. VAT, which then goes at the end). That's the only mention of Clutch in it.Code: Select all
KIT - CLUTCH RE 95.15 : : SUPPLY AND FIT NEW CLUTCH 315.00
When I brought the car home last night, reverse was silent; I'm out shopping today (for petrol, if nothing else) and I'll be listening very carefully for grinding noises.
(just show, no stabby stabby)
- Kelloggs
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1859
- Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2005 11:38 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: TheAntiKelloggs
- Location: Widnes or Altrincham. Take your pick.
--> Dio: I should clarify that. Last car was sold with a (six-month old) replacement clutch in it, after it slipping to buggery. Car before that was sold with the clutch slipping (back to the dealership. Tee hee!)
This, however, is the only car with this particular (grinding on reverse selection) problem.
--> kalmar: No towball. The only heavy thing that's been anywhere near this car is me.
This, however, is the only car with this particular (grinding on reverse selection) problem.
--> kalmar: No towball. The only heavy thing that's been anywhere near this car is me.
- hairy_pete
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 7217
- Joined: Mon May 27, 2002 8:10 pm 0
- Location: A Tiny Village in Bavaria
There's the fairly common driving "style" of depressing the clutch when approaching corners, releasing again on exit when it's time to accelerate again - typically with the same (high) gear selected that you had before the corner. Now, this eats clutch like there's no tomorrow, particularly true for modern age turbo diesels or anything else that does have low-rev grunt.Kelloggs wrote:(Note: This is what happens when I go to bed. Everyone wakes up while I'm asleep!)
The clutch on the last car was slipping, which I've experienced before. I could still drive it, but it was too far gone for others to.
I don't think it's my driving, but this is now the third bit of clutchwork needed in seventeen years' driving. I'm of the mind that - despite Ford's best protestations - such a major subsystem shouldn't be developing a fault quite so soon, unless I'm doing something so daft with the car as to leave evidence elsewhere.
Nobody admits to doing that, yet when I'm in the passenger seat, I find this astonishingly popular.
Probably not. Reverse has no synchromesh so it'll be likely to crunch, especially if you've just stopped moving.Mayhem wrote:My car occasionally suffers grinding on reverse... to worry yet?
If you don't want it to happen, put it into 3rd first and then quickly go to reverse, that will stop the gearbox shafts spinning.
(just show, no stabby stabby)
- lis0r
- Baaaa!

- Posts: 894
- Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2006 9:26 am 0
- Location: The Frozen Wastelands Of The North
Doesn'tthis massively increase the chance of losing traction on the corner?hairy_pete wrote:There's the fairly common driving "style" of depressing the clutch when approaching corners, releasing again on exit when it's time to accelerate again - typically with the same (high) gear selected that you had before the corner. Now, this eats clutch like there's no tomorrow, particularly true for modern age turbo diesels or anything else that does have low-rev grunt.


