GeeZa wrote:It just doesn't seem quite the right time, the fact remains that the whole show feels younger. It just does, some people have a really hard time accepting that. The whole dynamic of the assistant has pretty much been revolutionised almost from the get go. It's much more intimate, more romantic, definitely more modern than the teacher-student dryness of old. Going back to someone like Nighy (whom everyone seemed to want at one point), I dunno, bad move would be my gut feeling. I grew up with Pertwee and Baker but I guess I might be in a minority in thinking New Who basically shits on Old Who. Perhaps it is unfair to compare completely different, er, generations, but it's pretty astonishing how they've managed to turn what was basically a fucking awful crapheap of a show (i.e. McCoy), into something vibrant, emotional, entertaining and exciting. Hey, it even has its risqué moments. And I do think it has something to do with age, I really do. D
The whole show feels more naive to me - as meatpuppet says, it feels more like Cbeebies than the old show used to. It might have more snogging and innuendo and armchair psychology than it used to, but the whole thing feels far more like the first year of McCoy, particularly
Time and The Rani or
Delta And The Bannermen than it does any other era of the show. The same mistakes are present, the same embarrassments, but on a far grander scale. It feels younger in some ways, but far more like a bunch of old gits trying to make a show for kids. It never seems as dark or deep as Doctor Who should, and the Doctor himself is a pretty one-note deal. There are larger themes, but all dealt with in such a ham-fisted manner that it nulls the point. There is more emotion and excitement in Patrick Troughton's little speech about his family, for example, in any of that dreadful guff about Rose getting a poundshop Doctor as a runner's up prize. Older Doctor Who may have been made with cardboard and string, but it hit the mark with performances and writing so much more often. The heartstrings that new Who pulls at are shiny neon nylon and, for me, it doesn't convince or reach me.
And as for McCoy bashing, I think both Remembrance of the Daleks and The Curse Of Fenric are classics, and McCoy gives strong, iconic performances in them. I like the Seventh Doctor, and whilst McCoy could be a bit shit (particularly in his first year) he wasn't nearly as embarrassing to me as Tennant.