The Dr Who thread

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
phattslagg
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3578
Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
Location: Worcester, England

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by phattslagg »

Meatpuppet wrote:Dr Who = Cbeebies

Terrible and predictable choice of actor. Every time I see Russel Twat Davies's face, I want to punch it. He doesn't love or understand sci-fi is not Terry Nation. Piss off back to Why Don't You. :evil:
Yeah, so predictable that no-one managed to predict the selection anywhere even close.

And it wasn't R.T.'s choice.
User avatar
Meatpuppet
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1116
Joined: Fri Apr 26, 2002 4:53 pm 0
Location: Living up north.. in an old shop.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Meatpuppet »

phattslagg wrote:
Meatpuppet wrote:Dr Who = Cbeebies

Terrible and predictable choice of actor. Every time I see Russel Twat Davies's face, I want to punch it. He doesn't love or understand sci-fi is not Terry Nation. Piss off back to Why Don't You. :evil:
Yeah, so predictable that no-one managed to predict the selection anywhere even close.

And it wasn't R.T.'s choice.
I know that. He was however, towing the line and blabbing on about how it was a great choice.
It's a shame. Who cares anyway, it's just a kids show.
User avatar
The Captain
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1672
Joined: Thu Nov 02, 2006 12:24 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Barbellion
PSN: Barbellion
Location: North Yorkshire

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by The Captain »

GeeZa wrote:It just doesn't seem quite the right time, the fact remains that the whole show feels younger. It just does, some people have a really hard time accepting that. The whole dynamic of the assistant has pretty much been revolutionised almost from the get go. It's much more intimate, more romantic, definitely more modern than the teacher-student dryness of old. Going back to someone like Nighy (whom everyone seemed to want at one point), I dunno, bad move would be my gut feeling. I grew up with Pertwee and Baker but I guess I might be in a minority in thinking New Who basically shits on Old Who. Perhaps it is unfair to compare completely different, er, generations, but it's pretty astonishing how they've managed to turn what was basically a fucking awful crapheap of a show (i.e. McCoy), into something vibrant, emotional, entertaining and exciting. Hey, it even has its risqué moments. And I do think it has something to do with age, I really do. D
The whole show feels more naive to me - as meatpuppet says, it feels more like Cbeebies than the old show used to. It might have more snogging and innuendo and armchair psychology than it used to, but the whole thing feels far more like the first year of McCoy, particularly Time and The Rani or Delta And The Bannermen than it does any other era of the show. The same mistakes are present, the same embarrassments, but on a far grander scale. It feels younger in some ways, but far more like a bunch of old gits trying to make a show for kids. It never seems as dark or deep as Doctor Who should, and the Doctor himself is a pretty one-note deal. There are larger themes, but all dealt with in such a ham-fisted manner that it nulls the point. There is more emotion and excitement in Patrick Troughton's little speech about his family, for example, in any of that dreadful guff about Rose getting a poundshop Doctor as a runner's up prize. Older Doctor Who may have been made with cardboard and string, but it hit the mark with performances and writing so much more often. The heartstrings that new Who pulls at are shiny neon nylon and, for me, it doesn't convince or reach me.

And as for McCoy bashing, I think both Remembrance of the Daleks and The Curse Of Fenric are classics, and McCoy gives strong, iconic performances in them. I like the Seventh Doctor, and whilst McCoy could be a bit shit (particularly in his first year) he wasn't nearly as embarrassing to me as Tennant.
Factory's no place for me, boss man leave me be.

Xbox Live Gamertag/PSN ID: Barbellion
Wii Console Number: 7017 0974 8271 2157
User avatar
HGFB
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 23575
Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by HGFB »

Bizarrely enough for something with so little direct connection to the new show you get a hell of a lot more out of New Who if you spent the wilderness years reading Virgin NAs. I can't explain it very well but a lot of the themes are lifted from story arcs there. Human Nature/Family of Blood is one of the more extreme examples (Considering it's an adaptation of a NA). Especially the ending. Beating the bad guys like that is pure, unadulterated Sylvester McCoy Virgin NAs. I was half expecting Benny to roll up drunk in a posh frock or Ace to show up and knife the smarmy fucker.
My bag is called Mr Shitface
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Dio »

I couldn't disagree more about comparing 'new' and 'old' Who. Claiming massive depth for the Tom Baker days - which, let's face it, were by far the best - is crazy, and I say this having rewatched everything as far as Robots Of Death this year. It's always been about producing entertaining TV for all ages and very rarely about high SF - and all the better for it. And it's always been hit and miss, and not just because of too many sparkly polythene monsters in the old days. I mean, everyone including me agrees how great Pyramids of Mars is but if you look deeply at it it's just another monster story (mummies! cool!) with cavernous plot holes.

I used to think I was a huge science fiction fan when I was a kid because I loved Doctor Who and Star Trek. Having tried to read a lot of SF and fantasy since, I realised that it's not specifically SF I liked, but witty, entertaining drama with plenty of action and a limited amount of realism.
User avatar
The Captain
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1672
Joined: Thu Nov 02, 2006 12:24 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Barbellion
PSN: Barbellion
Location: North Yorkshire

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by The Captain »

HGFB wrote:Bizarrely enough for something with so little direct connection to the new show you get a hell of a lot more out of New Who if you spent the wilderness years reading Virgin NAs. I can't explain it very well but a lot of the themes are lifted from story arcs there. Human Nature/Family of Blood is one of the more extreme examples (Considering it's an adaptation of a NA). Especially the ending. Beating the bad guys like that is pure, unadulterated Sylvester McCoy Virgin NAs. I was half expecting Benny to roll up drunk in a posh frock or Ace to show up and knife the smarmy fucker.
Well, this is it. I was fairly late to the NA party, but some of them were amazing, and I was very impressed with the evolution of the Doctor's role and the storytelling that some of them presented. To see a lot of the ideas used but so vacuously is pretty painful. That is part of the reason I find the new series, Tennant particularly, so very annoying. Human Nature was like a speedread of the book with the cast of Bodger and Badger performing.
Factory's no place for me, boss man leave me be.

Xbox Live Gamertag/PSN ID: Barbellion
Wii Console Number: 7017 0974 8271 2157
User avatar
HGFB
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 23575
Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by HGFB »

I do like the new series but at it went on I found myself liking RTD's writing less and less. Especially the Christmas specials. RTD did write some belters though. Love and Monsters was a (in my mind) hugely successful experimental episode and Midnight was probably the best one set drama I've seen in a long while.

However apart from Runaway Bride (Because pre-personality transplant Donna is the greatest thing ever) his Christmas specials have been vacant tosh. Some great set pieces but fluff pretty much. Russell writes good characters but often forgets (Or misappropriates) the science fiction. It's bizarre really since he can actually write very good sci-fi. ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Damaged_Goods )

I suspect Moffat isn't going to change a great deal (I doubt the BBC would let him tinker to any significant degree. Hence the addition of Tennant V1.5 to the cast) but with any luck he'll do less rewriting of other people's scripts. Reading RTD's book The Writers Tale I was struck by something. It was assumed that RTD would rewrite pretty much everything that passed by his desk and also that he was the *only* one available to write the christmas specials to the point where this years was nearly cancelled because he nearly didn't have the time.

First why not tell the writers what you want changing and let them do the rewrites? This frees up vast amounts of time for other things. Secondly why on earth should the showrunner have to write the Christmas specials? Could you imagine Moffat writing shit like Voyage of the Damned? If you haven't got time get someone else to do it. It's not like there aren't a vast amount of very talented writers available.
My bag is called Mr Shitface
User avatar
HGFB
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 23575
Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by HGFB »

The Captain wrote:Well, this is it. I was fairly late to the NA party, but some of them were amazing, and I was very impressed with the evolution of the Doctor's role and the storytelling that some of them presented. To see a lot of the ideas used but so vacuously is pretty painful. That is part of the reason I find the new series, Tennant particularly, so very annoying. Human Nature was like a speedread of the book with the cast of Bodger and Badger performing.
The later BBC McGann range started off fairly poorly (Stinkers like Terrance Dicks writing The Eight Doctors) but rapidly did some stuff that knocked the NAs out of the park. The addition of the Time War (In Alien Bodies) and later Faction Paradox and the rewriting of the Doctor's history (Interference Part 1 and 2). Fantastic characters like Fitz and Compassion (Dear lord. She's complicated). The destruction of Gallifrey, 100 years stuck on Earth, the Doctor a father, a replacement for the Master (Who Ace killed in the NAs btw :) ) and after a long parallel universe arc a very teasing and direct link right back to 1963 and the start of the series.

It also allowed Lawrence Miles to spin off the Faction Paradox stuff into their own universe and replace the Time War with the very, very complicated War in Heaven between the Great Houses and "The Enemy". Two books in the range that simply have to be read even if you have no interest in Doctor Who (Because they aren't) are This Town Will Never Let Us Go by Lawrence Miles (One of the biggest critics of Nu-Who) and Of the City of the Saved... by Philip Purser-Hallard
My bag is called Mr Shitface
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Cloudane »

I really wasn't a fan of Love and Monsters. It turned into an awful Peter Kay sitcom for an episode.

I also wasn't a huge fan of the Station 5(?) nonsense once the novelty had worn off; I kept thinking how ridiculous it'd look in 20 years' time when the repeats are on and it's all about robot Anne Robinson off some ancient game show. That said, I did find the pisstake on how things like Big Brother could get out of hand somewhat amusing.

The highlights for me were Dalek, Father's Day, The Empty Child / The Doctor Dances, The Parting of the Ways, School Reunion, The Girl in the Fireplace, The Idiot's Lantern, Blink, the Master arc, The Doctor's Daughter, Silence in the Library / Forest of the Dead and Midnight.

To be quite fair, a few of those are RTD episodes including the masterful (hur hur) Master arc, but in typical RTD style he ruined it with a deus ex rewind. In my opinion his talent really shone with Midnight (although it seemed to get mixed reviews). But for the most part they were written by other people, and notice how well Moffat seems to do.

Top stinkers were: Aliens of London / World War Three (admittedly probably hilarious if you're 12 years old and find fart gags deep and meaningful), Love & Monsters, Gridlock and Partners in Crime. I wasn't too fond of The Stolen Earth / Journey's End either, although the concept was good, but the execution sucked.

Well well, every single one of those stinkers was written by RTD. There's a difference between writing for children and writing silly/immaturely, IMO.

Nope, I won't miss him either. I think we're in good hands now, but we'll have to suffer the inevitably cheesy and silly specials first!
User avatar
The Captain
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1672
Joined: Thu Nov 02, 2006 12:24 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Barbellion
PSN: Barbellion
Location: North Yorkshire

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by The Captain »

Yes, The Eight Doctors was a deep embarrassment, and some of the other BBC books were arse of the worst order, but Lawrence Miles is a hero - haven't read the Faction Paradox stuff yet but I know fo' sho' it will be excellent. I'm currently reading The Adventuress Of Henrietta Street and loving it. The way Miles manages to combine the deepest fanwanky continuity references into the most exciting, broad stories is sublime - everything I read about what happened in Interference upset me so very much, and it was all true - but on actually reading the thing I was astonished. Larry proved with sensitive enough writing that you really can do pretty much anything with Who, and it is far more convincing, emotional and new than any of the guff we've had on telly recently.

I also loved the BBC books arc that began with The Burning - the whole idea of the Doctor's amnesia/being stranded was superb, even if I suspect that it went tits up later on (I didn't actually reach Escape Velocity).
Factory's no place for me, boss man leave me be.

Xbox Live Gamertag/PSN ID: Barbellion
Wii Console Number: 7017 0974 8271 2157
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Harlequin »

Another vote for Love and Monsters here. It is one of the few episodes that I enjoy rewatching even when alone. This might in part be because, as with The Runaway Bride, I was not particularly familiar with the comedian's previous work when I first saw it.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
betamax
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10520
Joined: Thu May 01, 2003 11:36 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Betamax_W
Location: Coalition Anxiety
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by betamax »

HGFB wrote:
The Captain wrote:Well, this is it. I was fairly late to the NA party, but some of them were amazing, and I was very impressed with the evolution of the Doctor's role and the storytelling that some of them presented. To see a lot of the ideas used but so vacuously is pretty painful. That is part of the reason I find the new series, Tennant particularly, so very annoying. Human Nature was like a speedread of the book with the cast of Bodger and Badger performing.
The later BBC McGann range started off fairly poorly (Stinkers like Terrance Dicks writing The Eight Doctors) but rapidly did some stuff that knocked the NAs out of the park. The addition of the Time War (In Alien Bodies) and later Faction Paradox and the rewriting of the Doctor's history (Interference Part 1 and 2). Fantastic characters like Fitz and Compassion (Dear lord. She's complicated). The destruction of Gallifrey, 100 years stuck on Earth, the Doctor a father, a replacement for the Master (Who Ace killed in the NAs btw :) ) and after a long parallel universe arc a very teasing and direct link right back to 1963 and the start of the series.

It also allowed Lawrence Miles to spin off the Faction Paradox stuff into their own universe and replace the Time War with the very, very complicated War in Heaven between the Great Houses and "The Enemy". Two books in the range that simply have to be read even if you have no interest in Doctor Who (Because they aren't) are This Town Will Never Let Us Go by Lawrence Miles (One of the biggest critics of Nu-Who) and Of the City of the Saved... by Philip Purser-Hallard

Your tales of novella interest me strangely- can you recommend a good starting point for some dead-tree staring?
"Shouting lager, lager, lager, lager. Shouting lager, lager, lager, lager. Is just one of the reasons you're not welcome at Claridges any more". -Psychic Bob
User avatar
WiteWulf
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10125
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 11:20 am 0
PSN: WiteWulf
Location: Loughborough(ish)

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by WiteWulf »

betamax wrote: Your tales of novella interest me strangely- can you recommend a good starting point for some dead-tree staring?
I Was wondering the same thing after finding masses of the stuff on demonoid.
:::G:::

PSN: WiteWulf
Switch: SW-3941-2878-7584
Steam: WITEWULF66
User avatar
HGFB
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 23575
Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by HGFB »

betamax wrote:Your tales of novella interest me strangely- can you recommend a good starting point for some dead-tree staring?
For some fine fine storytelling read the two Faction Paradox books I linked to. Amazon sell them. EDAs and NAs you're probably going to have to hit ebay for. Alien Bodies is a good one to start with. It introduces Tardises shaped like people, conceptual aliens and the time war.

There are some free NA ebooks for you to read on the BBC website

http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho/classic/ebooks/
My bag is called Mr Shitface
User avatar
Istar
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4869
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 4:42 pm 0
Location: London, UK.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Istar »

Re: Love & Monsters: the MotW in the shape of Peter Kay was very silly, and did nothing for me; but the concept of the story, told from the oblique angle of a Whovian observer, was really, really clever, and I love the episode despite Kay. Whilst I've found a lot of RTDs' writing purile, banal, juvenile and one-dimensional, I have to give him absolute credit for L&M (and for getting DW back on-screen in the first place). Oh, and my criticisms of his writing style are a reflection of my age; my kids have LOVED all the episodes I've found least satisfying - fart gags are the apotheosis of humour when you're 11.

For all the poor episodes, where I've wished I'd not bothered, there have been some absolutely storming ones. And even in the poor shows there's almost always something to enjoy - 'Gridlock', a piss-poor critique of the evils of pollution and drugs, has at the end such a sublime reflection by The Doc on his childhood on Galifrey that it sends shivers up my spine just thinking about it. Family of Blood, another least-favourite of mine, ends with a chilling insight into The Docs' vengeful personality aspect - the abiding message at the end being You Do Not Fuck With Timelords. Seriously. Don't.

I take the rough with the smooth - it's a price I'm more than prepared to pay in exchange for having my favourite alien scaring the shit out of the kids on a Saturday night again.
Post Reply