SPACE

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: SPACE

Post by zip accident »

Darkflame wrote:
Dio wrote:Even more expensive, even less reliable, and even less safe.
By that logic, why arn't we all in Ford Model T cars then :?

If your arguing the shuttle was the pinnacle of mankind's designs in that area, you need to cit what limits it was pushing up against which newer designs couldn't have improved upon.
"Cite".

The sounds of vowels ('a' 'e' 'i' 'o' 'u' sometimes 'y') travel back through single consonants (b, c, d, other letters that aren't vowels) changing the sounds of the previous vowels. That's why sometimes some consonants are doubled, to stop the effects of following vowels going back. It doesn't always apply. In this case, cit rhymes with hit, cite rhymes with bright.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
tufty
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12525
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 4:52 pm 0
Location: French Alps

Re: SPACE

Post by tufty »

ss2 fired up its engines in flight for the first time.

http://www.aero-news.net/index.cfm?do=m ... 95eeabe706
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Dio »

Darkflame wrote:
Dio wrote:Even more expensive, even less reliable, and even less safe.
By that logic, why arn't we all in Ford Model T cars then :?
Well first of all, safety and reliability are not as inherently coupled in cars the way they are in space vehicles. In a car a failure is much less likely to result in a total loss of vehicle, except as the owner gives up on it.

You're right to point out that it's a flaw in my argument though. Increased complexity can be countered by increased engineering skill. But that didn't happen with the shuttle compared with previous or even competing contemporary systems.

Are you seriously arguing that you think the shuttle, or something closely resembling it, is anything other than the deadest of dead-ends? You can't cheaply push that much mass around in space. It's too expensive in propellant (I mean 'expensive' not in pure cost of goods, but the cost of the energy to get the propellant to where the vehicle is). The vehicle can't afford to carry anything beyond the bare minimum of weight. Sure, you can employ a truck to push lighter bits around - e.g. the Apollo Service module) but as soon as you equip that to do anything beyond its intended task you are wasting energy.

The only purpose of a vehicle like the shuttle is to carry big, heavy objects out of (very low) orbit. For delivering things - including people - to orbit, or to travel beyond orbit, those wings and a cargo bay capable of withstanding the stresses of re-entry are phenomenally expensive dead weight and force massive complexity and design compromises on the whole system. It can't possibly be anything other than insanely expensive and unreliable.

A (reusable) capsule is an obviously infinitely cheaper and simpler idea because it carries no dead weight into orbit beyond a cheaply replaced ablative heat shield.

The Apollo engineers knew what they were doing. Their system was selected to minimise the energy budget, despite the enormous risks of lunar rendezvous. That NASA spent so long defending the shuttle indicates intellectual bankruptcy, defending the indefensible. Even before Challenger came along and proved the total descent of those involved in running the Shuttle program from engineers into fantasists - and then Columbia came along and proved that despite Feynman's best efforts, the foolers of nature were still in charge.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Dio »

Realised I left that without a conclusion, so here it is:

So fundamentally the shuttle's problems are nothing to do with problem X or issue Y. They are that the vehicle itself is an expensively overengineered turkey designed for a specific US military mission that never materialised at all - and even if it had, wouldn't have been common enough to warrant the expense of shuttle use in civilian projects.
User avatar
sack
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7077
Joined: Fri May 10, 2002 4:13 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: evilgopher
PSN: sixFiveOhTwo
Location: Rijswijk, The Netherlands
Contact:

Re: SPACE

Post by sack »

zip accident wrote: The sounds of vowels ('a' 'e' 'i' 'o' 'u' sometimes 'y') travel back through single consonants (b, c, d, other letters that aren't vowels) changing the sounds of the previous vowels. That's why sometimes some consonants are doubled, to stop the effects of following vowels going back. It doesn't always apply. In this case, cit rhymes with hit, cite rhymes with bright.
This is what 'Look and Read' unfortunately referred to as 'the magic E'

User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: SPACE

Post by pogo »

False colour images of the storm at Saturn's north pole. In the first you can just about make out the circumpolar hexagon that's been identified before. The false colours, corresponding to different infra-red wavelengths, pick out clouds at different heights.

http://saturn.jpl.nasa.gov/photos/image ... ageId=4806

Image
Image
User avatar
Firefox
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11412
Joined: Fri Apr 26, 2002 6:15 pm 0
Location: Sheffield

Re: SPACE

Post by Firefox »

Dio wrote:They are that the vehicle itself is an expensively overengineered turkey designed for a specific US military mission that never materialised at all - and even if it had, wouldn't have been common enough to warrant the expense of shuttle use in civilian projects.
I thought it was designed for launching and retrieving huge spy satellites? Or was there something else I hadn't heard about? :?
"I am a very considerate person. If I want to go out all night on my miniature golf course and shoot lizards, well, no reason to keep the neighbours awake..."
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Dio »

Retrieval of satellites is the main reason for the cargo bay. The wings are dictated by a mission which required a launch, a single polar orbit to deploy a military payload, and then a landing at the launch base (and at Vandenberg, without overflying Cuba, although polar launches aren't possible from Kennedy because it would overfly a heavily populated area), which required huge cross-range capability. Columbia accident investigation report:

"The Department of Defense wanted the Shuttle to carry a 40,000-pound payload in a 60-foot-long payload bay and, on some missions, launch and return to a West Coast launch site after a single polar orbit. Since the Earth's surface -- including the runway on which the Shuttle was to land -- would rotate during that orbit, the Shuttle would need to maneuver 1,100 miles to the east during re-entry. This "cross-range" requirement meant the Orbiter required large delta-shaped wings and a more robust thermal protection system to shield it from the heat of re-entry."
User avatar
axel000
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2905
Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2005 4:02 am 0
PSN: huckwee
Location: Philadelphia, USA

Re: SPACE

Post by axel000 »

That is a curious requirement. What possibly could the Pentagon have wanted in the 1970s when the Shuttle was being designed which would fit such a mission profile of one polar orbit and a return to base.

What possibly could it have delivered that an ICBM couldn't have done ? You don't do spy satellite launches on a whim like this, so that can't have been it. Odd.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Gamertags:
[Steam] scottish_usa
[PSN] huckwee
[Star Citizen] Zander9
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Dio »

The take from, followed by the loss of, the U2 gave them an addiction to aerial photography that they'd do almost anything to satisfy.

When the shuttle was defined (long before the later KH series with digital cameras) US spy satellites were expendable, short-lived assets - the Corona sats had some (couple of hundred?) film capsules on board, which after exposure were dropped in miniature re-entry vehicles and caught by planes on the way down. Yes, really.

But they knew everyone knew the orbits of the sats and were worried that people could be hiding things. So what they wanted was the ability to deploy a spaceship (notably, something that very clearly wasn't an ICBM, since flying missiles with no warning in a marginal orbit over the pole in the 1970s would have been, err, bad) to go get a photograph NOW. Essentially, to use the Shuttle as an orbital (and hence legal) U2. At a thousand times the cost.

There's also theories about going to steal Russian sats, or deploy antisat weapons, but one suspects that such missions never got even as far along as the spy-sat mission did - or didn't, since it was never done, someone obviously looked at the budget column and quite rightly had a heart attack. Or they worked out that an inevitable consequence of using such a system would be the Russians building missile technology that could shoot the Shuttle down, which was largely the same reason they never used the SR-71 in actual Soviet airspace.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Dio »

Wikipedia has decent coverage on the early Corona satellites - the first few revs were genuine one-shot satellites, and the second could drop two separate cans. From the KH-9 there were 4 or 5.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Darkflame »

Dio wrote:
Darkflame wrote:
Dio wrote:Even more expensive, even less reliable, and even less safe.
By that logic, why arn't we all in Ford Model T cars then :?
Well first of all, safety and reliability are not as inherently coupled in cars the way they are in space vehicles. In a car a failure is much less likely to result in a total loss of vehicle, except as the owner gives up on it.

You're right to point out that it's a flaw in my argument though. Increased complexity can be countered by increased engineering skill. But that didn't happen with the shuttle compared with previous or even competing contemporary systems.

Are you seriously arguing that you think the shuttle, or something closely resembling it, is anything other than the deadest of dead-ends? You can't cheaply push that much mass around in space. It's too expensive in propellant (I mean 'expensive' not in pure cost of goods, but the cost of the energy to get the propellant to where the vehicle is). The vehicle can't afford to carry anything beyond the bare minimum of weight. Sure, you can employ a truck to push lighter bits around - e.g. the Apollo Service module) but as soon as you equip that to do anything beyond its intended task you are wasting energy.

The only purpose of a vehicle like the shuttle is to carry big, heavy objects out of (very low) orbit. For delivering things - including people - to orbit, or to travel beyond orbit, those wings and a cargo bay capable of withstanding the stresses of re-entry are phenomenally expensive dead weight and force massive complexity and design compromises on the whole system. It can't possibly be anything other than insanely expensive and unreliable.

A (reusable) capsule is an obviously infinitely cheaper and simpler idea because it carries no dead weight into orbit beyond a cheaply replaced ablative heat shield.
Thats exactly what I was looking for; specific reasons why the idea of the shuttle was bad, rather then specific design decisions which could be improved upon.
Thanks.

That said, I am still not sure if the capsule method isn't itself a dead-end - albeit it a better end to be in.

Can capsule based designs improve over the next decade to incorporate more use cases?

For example; could we have repaired Hubble with a capsule?
Can capsules ever be good for not just going to space - but creating and repairing spare infer-structure?

Or should be split the tech - have "human delivery" and "human activity once up" as separate crafts?
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Dio »

Space tech, to be energy-efficient, needs to be quite closely configured for the job it does. As soon as you add weight that you're not using on a given mission, you're wasting energy. It's essential to focus on what's important. But at the same time it's important to avoid unnecessary customisation because that's one guaranteed way to drive (fiduciary) cost through the roof.

So one probable way forward would be something modular. If you can have standard ways of connecting units together, then you can put a given spaceship on top of a rocket made out of bits A (manned returnable capsule), B (low-orbit propulsion system, basically retros) and C (large lightweight cargo unit - essentially little but an aeroshell, unless it needs to be pressurised). For a different mission you might replace C with D and E, D an airlock connected to the capsule and a couple of EVA suits, and E, a small unpressurised cargo unit. Or you might replace B and C with F, a larger propulsion system and extended life-support module capable of TLI (i.e. the Service Module). And if you find you need D and C and F all at the same time, then launch two rockets and mate them up in orbit.

If Musk gets (any more) serious about the manned space business, I wouldn't be remotely surprised if he went some way similar to this, since he's already espoused modularity plans for the Falcon.
User avatar
axel000
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2905
Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2005 4:02 am 0
PSN: huckwee
Location: Philadelphia, USA

Re: SPACE

Post by axel000 »

Remember - the capsule does not itself embody the full size or capabilities of a deep space ship. Most long range mission concepts floated by Nasa, Lockheed and Boeing utilize multiple joined capsules and/or capsules joined with additional living space (ISS-like or re-purposed segments, or inflatable sections as being pioneered by Bigelow).

The actual available space and components on such a mission won't really be limited by the dimensions of the capsule itself, rather by cost and interest of the appropriate govt authorities.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Gamertags:
[Steam] scottish_usa
[PSN] huckwee
[Star Citizen] Zander9
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
User avatar
F-ZeroOne
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8212
Joined: Wed Sep 29, 2004 8:27 pm 0

Re: SPACE

Post by F-ZeroOne »

Regards "shooting the shuttle down" - the Russians actually very secretly (I believe it violated a number of treaties) tested automatic cannons fitted to some of their space stations.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Post Reply