Darkflame wrote:Dio wrote:Even more expensive, even less reliable, and even less safe.
By that logic, why arn't we all in Ford Model T cars then

Well first of all, safety and reliability are not as inherently coupled in cars the way they are in space vehicles. In a car a failure is much less likely to result in a total loss of vehicle, except as the owner gives up on it.
You're right to point out that it's a flaw in my argument though. Increased complexity can be countered by increased engineering skill. But that didn't happen with the shuttle compared with previous or even competing contemporary systems.
Are you seriously arguing that you think the shuttle, or something closely resembling it, is anything other than the deadest of dead-ends? You can't cheaply push that much mass around in space. It's too expensive in propellant (I mean 'expensive' not in pure cost of goods, but the cost of the energy to get the propellant to where the vehicle is). The vehicle can't afford to carry anything beyond the bare minimum of weight. Sure, you can employ a truck to push lighter bits around - e.g. the Apollo Service module) but as soon as you equip that to do anything beyond its intended task you are wasting energy.
The only purpose of a vehicle like the shuttle is
to carry big, heavy objects out of (very low) orbit. For delivering things - including people -
to orbit, or to travel beyond orbit, those wings and a cargo bay capable of withstanding the stresses of re-entry are phenomenally expensive dead weight and force massive complexity and design compromises on the whole system. It can't possibly be anything other than insanely expensive and unreliable.
A (reusable) capsule is an obviously infinitely cheaper and simpler idea because it carries no dead weight into orbit beyond a cheaply replaced ablative heat shield.
The Apollo engineers knew what they were doing. Their system was selected to minimise the energy budget, despite the enormous risks of lunar rendezvous. That NASA spent so long defending the shuttle indicates intellectual bankruptcy, defending the indefensible. Even before Challenger came along and proved the total descent of those involved in running the Shuttle program from engineers into fantasists - and then Columbia came along and proved that despite Feynman's best efforts, the foolers of nature were still in charge.