Next Gen - The Verdict

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Next Gen - The Verdict

Post by zip accident »

pogo wrote:
tufty wrote:
zip accident wrote:What if the current economic theory becomes a religion? It's rubbish enough.
It already is. Pogo's applying for the job of pope.
No, no interest in being able to wear a dress, fiddle kiddies then forgive myself and suppress all the evidence.
How about having the heads of those that are disagreeable to you hacked off. If that doesn't appeal, how about not having your own head hacked off by those who disagree with you? I hear the latter became quite popular in the latter stages of the French Revolution, and may explain many totalitarianist atrocities.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
RiK
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 16092
Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 11:32 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Dr Olpin
PSN: Dr Thumpy
Location: The Shire
Contact:

Re: Next Gen - The Verdict

Post by RiK »

Image
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: Next Gen - The Verdict

Post by Darkflame »

Its more of a two, imho.
User avatar
SuperMappy
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2109
Joined: Fri Jun 10, 2005 5:30 am 0
Location: Circleville, OH

Re: Next Gen - The Verdict

Post by SuperMappy »



'Murica, Fuck YEAH! (Honestly though, this guy is hilarious)
Bustin' Naughty Folks since 1983
MAME: Forever Young!

"If you buy a game at launch, you are paying the most amount of money for the worst version of the game" - TotalBiscuit
User avatar
RiK
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 16092
Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 11:32 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Dr Olpin
PSN: Dr Thumpy
Location: The Shire
Contact:

Re: Next Gen - The Verdict

Post by RiK »

Excellent post on NeoGAF (thanks to HGFB posting elsewhere) about the second hand sales tax malarky etc.
If the secondhand market is not having a major detrimental effect on the primary market, then why would it need to be addressed?

If it were the case for movies and games, then yes, I'd favor similar measures by music/movie industries to protect themselves against it.
Well, this is the disconnect I guess. You admit you only hold this view because of the detrimental effects (you think) are impacting the industry. You are asserting that a fundamental aspect of property rights and consumer rights as it has existed since the beginning of trade should be adjusted and recodified on a per-industry basis, not because it's inherently bad or unethical, but just because you think it's a threat to the industry's health. Which means you are essentially arguing for protectionism for corporations--consumers are free to exercise their consumer rights only up to a certain point, but if that free exercise is perceived to threaten the viability of the industry, then their rights must be limited in order to save the industry.

I don't think I can put into words my disgust at this demeaning display of groveling at the feet of your game developer overlords. Even a die-hard laissez-faire capitalist would not be so subservient, because even a capitalist would accept that sometimes industries die and that's the way the world works. As much as I enjoy games, there is no inherent good in this industry. The ends do not justify the means here; there is nothing that makes the gaming industry inherently worthy of preservation, not to the point that would justify carving out a special exemption for them where used games are somehow magically not OK when they are OK for every other packaged good on the planet. Just because your favored set of content producers couldn't properly adapt does not justify rewriting the rules of what "property ownership" means and fundamentally removing the ability to preserve, inherit, pass on, lend, and share its products.

The industry does not come first; consumers do. I have no sympathy for an industry that cannot properly stumble its way around a viable secondhand market like every other mature industry in the world. Sometimes your old product just isn't good enough, and the way you solve it is by making a better product, not by forcing consumers to adapt to your archaic and myopic business model with your dying breath. If this industry can't find a way to make money off the primary market -- even with DLC and exclusive pre-order content and HD re-releases and map packs and online passes and annualized sequels and "expanding the audience" and AAA advertising and forced multiplayer -- then, if I may be so blunt, fuck it. It doesn't deserve our money in the first place. If an entire industry has its head so far up its ass, is so focused on short-term gains, and has embraced such a catastrophically stupid blockbuster business model in the pursuit of a stagnant market of hardcore 18-34 dudebros that it thinks it has no choice but to take away our first-sale rights as its last chance of maybe, finally, creating a sustainable stream of profits, then it can go to hell. It doesn't need your protection, it needs to be taken out back and beaten until it remembers who its real masters are.

I especially have a hard time having any sympathy because so many of the industry's problems are of its own making. They chose to focus on shaderific HD graphics over long-lasting appeal and gameplay; they chose to focus on linear scripted cinematic B-movie imitations that were only good for one playthrough instead of replayability and open-ended design; they chose to pour so much money and marketing into military porn and fetishized violent shootbang Press A to Awesome titles, exactly the kinds of games that hardcore gamers, the most likely gamers to trade in games quickly were prone to buying and reselling; and perhaps most galling, they chose to give Gamestop loads of exclusive pre-order bonuses while they knew exactly what Gamestop would say to those customers once in the store. They kept making insanely lavish and nonsensical displays of spectacular whizz-bang, despite that being exactly the kind of game most susceptible to trading after one week because there was nothing left to do with it. And now they're discovering that putting so many insanely expensive eggs into one fragile and easily breakable basket is maybe not the most sustainable business model ever.

So forgive me if I find myself not caring one bit when the industry complains that it's just so hard to sell six million copies of Gears of Medal of Battle of Uncharted Angry Dudes VII in the first week and that's why they need to take away used sales for the entire platform. No, the problem isn't at this end.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: Next Gen - The Verdict

Post by Dio »

That's broadly misdirected, though.

The problem perceived by developers, publishers and platform-holders with the second hand model isn't the consumer: it's the retailers, who take 100% of the profit from the second-hand market. It's actively in their interests to minimize the number of new games in circulation and maximize the number of churning second-hand ones and there's strong evidence that most of the high street retailers are doing this.

Fundamentally the sales model is broken at both ends.
User avatar
Governmentyard
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11757
Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard

Re: Next Gen - The Verdict

Post by Governmentyard »

zip accident wrote:
Governmentyard wrote:Turn it off at the fucking socket, like I've had to do with my noisy-PSU XBox 360 for the last five years.

It's not a problem, just switch it on when you want to use it, and switch it off afterwards. Just like ALL OF THE THINGS. In any case, plan B is a little blu-tack on the camera and a little on the mic array.
I turn off my PC at night, every night. However it's not really off, because it's not off at the socket. That's not possible (i.e. easy enough to be worth the effort) because the socket is connected via a multisocket thingy, as it happens that is switched (I paid the extra for the switches), but it's NOT easy to get at.

There may come a time when turning things off at the socket is illegal (if you read EULAs, that may have been last year).

What if the current economic theory becomes a religion? It's rubbish enough.

I foresee a return to religious control of the state, not in my time (lucky me, only not). What if it was your religion? wouldn't that be good? no, it wouldn't, not for the outsiders and non-conformers and anybody with an unorthodox view, which whether the orthodoxy varies day by day or century by century is eventually everybody.
Well, if you don't bother making your sockets accessible, you're going to have problems. But hopefully not ones relating to religious totalitarianism.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: Next Gen - The Verdict

Post by Darkflame »

Fundamentally the sales model is broken at both ends.
Agreed.
I'd say it is unfair on developers but its being countered by something unfair on consumers.
Sometimes your old product just isn't good enough, and the way you solve it is by making a better product,
Dangerously close to saying "its ok you developers get nothing for your old stuff...its OLD" though.

Kinda weird, because the penultimate paragraph praises, quite rightly, timeless things.
Things where a game being a bit older shouldn't take away from the experience and thus value.
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Next Gen - The Verdict

Post by zip accident »

Darkflame wrote:
Fundamentally the sales model is broken at both ends.
Agreed.
I'd say it is unfair on developers but its being countered by something unfair on consumers.
Sometimes your old product just isn't good enough, and the way you solve it is by making a better product,
Dangerously close to saying "its ok you developers get nothing for your old stuff...its OLD" though.

Kinda weird, because the penultimate paragraph praises, quite rightly, timeless things.
Things where a game being a bit older shouldn't take away from the experience and thus value.
Yeah, but what about e.g. chess sets? should the makers get a fee every time someone plays a game? I'd say not, but there is probably some sort of case to be made for it. What about copyright on chess pieces? do the makers of sets pay that? currently they don't (though on speciality sets like, say, Lord of The Rings, they probably do), but presumably they could be asked to. Not without an overhaul of copyright, but that's fairly obviously coming whether it's wanted by particular people in particular cases or not. Suppose all public domain copyright became property of the state, and everybody who used it then had to pay the state, would that solve anything?
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
Jamesac
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6677
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2003 7:23 am 0
Location: Maine
Contact:

Re: Next Gen - The Verdict

Post by Jamesac »

Anyone have a reason used games are different from used book, movies, or any other product? Original creators get zero profit, stores get 100%. All those industries are fine. How are games so weak that the used market is slaughtering them so badly?

James
User avatar
fog
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6022
Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 1:08 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Dense Fog
PSN: DenseFog
Location: Newcastle, England
Contact:

Re: Next Gen - The Verdict

Post by fog »

Jamesac wrote:Anyone have a reason used games are different from used book, movies, or any other product? Original creators get zero profit, stores get 100%. All those industries are fine. How are games so weak that the used market is slaughtering them so badly?
Exactly what I'm thinking. Are there any other consumer items where a proportion of second-hand sales money goes to the original producer?

Spend more developing a game than you receive in sales and you're going to struggle. It's not difficult. They are trying to increase the second part of that equation by screwing the consumer when they should be addressing the first part.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: Next Gen - The Verdict

Post by Darkflame »

Other products tend to have a longer shelf life mind, and hold their value (a bit) better over time.

Also, taken to extreme, second hand book usage is called a library.
Yeah, but what about e.g. chess sets? should the makers get a fee every time someone plays a game? I'd say not, but there is probably some sort of case to be made for it.
I'd say yes - for stuff in copyrighted still, in a ideal "zero overheads" magic world being charged proportional for use would be fair.

With no upfront costs people would try just about anything - and people that makes the most played games, the most listened too music etc would be most rewarded.

Advertising would go down a lot in value relative to product creation - pointless spamming adverts at people if they don't genuinely end up liking the end product.

--

Of course in the real world, in order for the "usage fees" to be in any way reasonable, the transaction overhead would be hugely more then any payments going to the creators.
User avatar
Whiteball
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1811
Joined: Sat Nov 24, 2007 12:39 pm 0
Location: At the computer

Re: Next Gen - The Verdict

Post by Whiteball »

There losing sales not because of the second hand market but because of the empty shallow shit their shoveling in the first instance.

I've completely gone of 'mainstream' gaming and turned to (selected) mobile offerings as they tend to be offering the types of things that kick started the whole industry in the first place. Originality, diversity and value for money (well value for us, not the actual devs as most mobile stuff is too cheap I reckon).

The real question is can they see it and don't want to admit it and so try to explain it away by other means or can they truly not see it? Maybe they are so closely wrapped up in it all they've been swept up in the tide of good times and lost sight of the core values that got them there to start with?

It's happened through the industry, through the years. Just happens the scale is larger and more prominent now than ever before as console games sales have been in nothing but decline for a number of years.
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Next Gen - The Verdict

Post by gilesgoat »

Dio wrote:That's broadly misdirected, though.

The problem perceived by developers, publishers and platform-holders with the second hand model isn't the consumer: it's the retailers, who take 100% of the profit from the second-hand market. It's actively in their interests to minimize the number of new games in circulation and maximize the number of churning second-hand ones and there's strong evidence that most of the high street retailers are doing this.

Fundamentally the sales model is broken at both ends.
I think THIS is exactly the problem but also opens a question about "where you draw the line ?".

If Bob buys my game and after 1 year decides to sell to his friend Alice for 10 quids and grab 10 quids for its own ( and maybe use them to buy another game of mines )
one can't see anything wrong in this, it's like you bought a book let's say for 20 and you decide to make a "personal sale" to your friend Alice for 10.

In this case, let's not forget "the book is only one", NO ONE copied ( i.e. generated a +1 extra ) the book.

BUT

But there's "a huge difference" in this, first of all is you and your friend, second and most important by buying that you OWN the BOOK.

Now here comes the problem.

Suppose Bob SELLS his BOOK to a "old used book store", the store gives him 8 for the book Bob is happy, can he do it ? Some says "yes of course".

Then the STORE sells the book to Alice but the store makes a better deal with Alice and sells the book to Alice for 10, can the store do that ? Some say "yes of course".

But then the book writer says "Hey wait a minute store, you are making a profit selling something I wrote and you are not giving me anything how's that ?".

What does the law say about this ? Should the book store effectively give a % of that sale to the book writer .. or not ?

OR .. the law says "this is valid only on a brand new sale NOT on a re-sale of a USED book ?".

Don't know, we should check what law says.

BUT .. NOW we are talking Software ..

You BUY that SW, do you OWN it ?

I am quite sure in 90% of cases the answer is NO, you DO NOT own the SW, you own a "license to USE it", in fact you can use it, play it, but you are not supposed
to crack it, modify it, open it, etc. you can just use it as it is.

Can you resell it ?

"Let's look what the law says" .. if you DO NOT OWN it, then you can't re-sell it, but supposedly/maybe you can give to someone else your right to use it.

But now then "what is the EULA saying about it ?" can you transfer that "license to use it" ?

Yes "ok fine" ( but it's still not a right to re-sale it, in fact you don't have the right to sell it at all ).

No ? So what should happen ? I suppose "Eula in the hand read the fine print" probably says "if you don't want to use it any more your only options are giving it back
to the developer or destroy it completely".

So let's restart it again, "is it legal/can you re-sell a used game ?" .. "depends" .. on what the EULA says .. some SW I know for sure cannot be re-sold and/or re-distributed at all and you are really supposed to give it back or destroy it and some SW is not transferable so you can't give it to anyone else.

Anyway the point is not much about "what the end user does" but the point is "a shop, that incidentally IS ALSO the 'distributor one' of my SW is re-selling my own
SW 'N other times' and the developers gets nothing" .. and that's the problem, because it's a SHOP not just "a person".

I think all this probably came out because someone realized this "used market" is quite big and probably used games do a "tour" in and out shop multiple times so they
get re-sold not only once but many times.

The other problem is that the developer gets only "a little %" ( on retail ) on the FIRST sale, but then the shop thanks to re-sales continues to re-get stuff in that I am
sure can end up in being > of what developers ever took on the single "first sale".

So I don't think is totally bad that the SHOP would give again a % if it re-sells a used game, what I just think is that "%" should stay the same it was, but price should be
free according, is that "35 pounds suggested price" that seems a bit odd.

However I am sure that, if they really would like ( and again it could be NOT "so totally wrong" as it seems ) they could say "no, you shop can't resell this used game X and full stop".

People could still do it by themselves "as they prefer" but not via a shop.

Anyway yes it's still a bit of a grey line with many greys and of a bit of difficult interpretation.

One could even say "if the shop can make money from an old rope, so why who made the rope in the first place should not have something too then ?".

Yeah it's an old rope .. but yeah while you are still paying RIAA and stuff like that when you play Wagner in public or such ?

So why you should not pay when you re-sell an old game in a shop ?

Where do you draw the line in all this and why ?
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: Next Gen - The Verdict

Post by pogo »

Whiteball wrote:I've completely gone of 'mainstream' gaming and turned to (selected) mobile offerings as they tend to be offering the types of things that kick started the whole industry in the first place. Originality, diversity and value for money (well value for us, not the actual devs as most mobile stuff is too cheap I reckon).
But why is it cheap? One reason is because there are no second hand sales: if you buy a game you don't like or finish a game you do you can't then sell it to someone else. The same with Xbox Live Arcade games which are cheaper than games sold at retail.

It's not the only reason; the lack of physical media is another, and probably the main one is decisions made by MS to keep the price of boxed retail discs high, to maintain prices at a particular level so they can extract the most in fees, to cover their losses on the hardware.

MS (and I've no doubt Sony too) are looking at how Apple (both their iOS Store and Mac App Store) and Valve (Steam) are able to extract the maximum value from sales, with no second hand sales, and want to do the same. You can see their point; whether it's on disc or downloaded they're just selling the software. They'd like to do away with the physical media altogether but not everyone has fast and cheap broadband that would require.
Post Reply