Darkflame wrote:Not quite sure what the advantage of Kinect for chat would be anyway. Only if you have multiple people in the rooms at each end - how many games have that?
And, for many games, that would actually be a very major disadvantage indeed and, arguably, a rather silly design flaw.
As little Johnny can't play Call of Duty on the big telly today, because Mummy and Daddy are talking - and they neither want their conversation to be incidentally broadcast over the Internet, nor to be constantly interrupted with a cacophony of 12 year olds shouting "faggot!" and "Leeeeerooooy Jenkins!!" every ten seconds (plus being able to hear all of their Mums and Dads talking in the background too).
Insisting on the use of Kinect for voice chat assumes a living room with zero background noise - and that assumption's going to quickly fail in the real world.
Can you imagine the immense cacophony that would result from having 8 or 16 players all broadcasting all the noise from their living rooms simultaneously, when they've all got family and friends chatting away in the background as they play?
That's a serious design flaw.
It'll render voice chat quite unusable - or, against Microsoft's wish to "own the living room", it'll send everyone back to playing their games by themselves in their bedrooms (and you can't invite your friends around to watch you play either, as, if they start chatting amongst themselves, they'll start confusing everyone playing the game), as the only practical way to control the noise levels enough to make the bloody thing even useful.
More over, you can't have any TV or music on in the background while you play - or you'd be inherently breaking copyright by incidentally making a public broadcast of it. Not to mention that if more than one person does that at the same time, the resulting noise of 3 or 4 songs all playing at the same time, with the sound of Phil Mitchell doing a monologue on EastEnders, AND having all the players trying to coordinate themselves - "you go first, Leeroy" - on top of that?
Not usable. Everyone will be forced to turn off the voice chat.
They seem to have given no thought to real world conditions in the design - and I'm tempted to think that this U-turn is the result of someone having tapped them on the shoulder and explained to them how disastrous such a policy would actually be, when applied to busy households, where there's all sorts of background noise going on all the time.
Multiplied by 8 or 16 players and it'll become a headache-inducing cacophony that everyone will necessarily have to turn off (or be forced to muffle the microphone, if Microsoft bizarrely decide that shit has to be "always on" too, for no particularly logical reason), because it's just not practically usable.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes