The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

zip accident wrote: However they wouldn't be if doctrinaire capitalists got their way.

There are essentially two reasons for privatising the NHS, doctinaire capitalism, and making a big big profit on the quiet.
That's simply wrong. 'doctrinaire capitalists'?? You mean like all the governments we've elected over the last 25 years, which have been the ones who introduced and expanded NHS privatisation. It's not 'doctrinaire'. Many people, including myself, think capitalism is best as it works. Not for everything but for a wide range of things. Other systems, such as state socialism, have been tried and failed.
However, there are a lot of monopolies that go completely unchallenged.

Most businesses are small operations with few workers and almost no capital. They won't be part of anything significant to the NHS, and they won't be the ones raking in the profits from its destruction.

The market is a bad joke. There is no market. There are a lot of individuals and companies interacting. There is no institution that you can point to and say "that is the market". It is all a bunch of individual deals, being done at the same time.
Which monopolies? NHS destruction?? It's still the best in the world despite decades of privatisation. And that is the market, or markets. Firms and individuals competing as firms and individuals.
We don't need to abandon dealing. We do need to tackle abuse, because every case that's permitted to continue increases the probability of abuse in every other deal that arises.
I agree, but it's hard. It's hard to get too worked up about insider trading though. The losers are other traders on the wrong side of crooked deals. It doesn't affect the real economy of firms doing business.
rowan wrote:However in the private sector, there is less ability for a health provider to balance costs across a portfolio of businesses. You probably wouldn't see a private medical company deciding to diversify into tobacco products for example, to prop up the med costs.
Private firms don't need to diversify though. It's OK if they specialise, then the NHS buys services from different firms: one that makes drugs, another that makes equipment, one that does cleaning, etc.. The cost balancing takes place on the NHS budget: paying more to firms which provide more expensive services, less to firms providing cheaper basic ones. It's up to govt. to make sure it's funded, from taxation, tobacco duty or wherever.

This also refutes the idea that private firms will cherry pick the profitable bits of the NHS. They can do both easy cheap things and expensive hard things, and should charge accordingly. They'll only get the work if they can do it for less than competitors which limits their ability to make excess profits. The NHS can also ensure this my making sure contracts are up for renewal regularly, to cope with changing costs and requirements.
User avatar
Barney
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2131
Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 7:59 pm 0
Location: UK, Broughton, Brigg

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by Barney »

Darkflame wrote: ...and yet somehow the NHS is one of the cheapest per-person medical cares in the world.
Actually, although the treatment costs are small (big pharma has to supply medicines at cost to the NHS, and they don't get Ok'd by the NICE foundation if they're not absolutely necessary) the associated costs of healthcare are huge to the NHS.

One example: On my ward, we were looking at making things a bit more comfortable for our patients. The chairs at each bedside (30 beds) were getting old, the needs of using high-risk foam surfaces to prevent pressure ulceration and newer designs that made mobility easier meant that we should look at upgrading them.

We went online to have a look at what was available - chairs cost about £150 without wheels, £175 with lockable wheels direct from the manufacturer. We went to the NHS supplies catalogue and looked up the cost to the ward. £800 for the basic model, £1,100 for the ones with wheels. We asked if we could go to the manufacturer and save thousands - we were informed that the company that handles furniture had to be routed through and their markup was reasonable as they also did things like fire certification.

The fact that the company is owned by a member of parliament is just coincidental, of course.

But to get away from the financial aspects there's also other aspects that are killing our service off.

When I trained, we were highly educated to prescribe and provide care. To understand the effects of all the medications in the formulary, to be aware of all the side-effects and how to mitigate them with other medications. To recognise health emergencies before they became life-threatening; to be able to manage them if they advanced to the point where we need life-support procedures to stabilise the patient. In short, we were taught to think for ourselves.

Now, we're told that a computer will be able to diagnose problems better than we can - we input a patient's vital observations into a system (running in Java on IE 7) which scores each number (resps/min, pulse bpm, systolic/diastolic BP, temp, AVPU score, O2 saturation) and produce a score. If it's not 0 or 1, we have to report to a Doctor. We can no longer assess the patient for ourselves which means that patients with COPD (breathless as a norm, saturations low to prevent CO2 retention) are having their observations done hourly even up to the point they leave the ward for home. We can't assess a patient's nutritional state without a computerised score to tell us if they're malnourished or if they need dietician input - and dieticians won't see a patient unless they have a high score. There are similar systems for mobility, pressure area care, diabetic monitoring etc.

And as nurses, we now spend more time writing in the documentation and calculating scores than we do with the patient. As a result, patients are not getting the care they need and we have no time to help them. On my ward, ten years ago we had three nurses on a night shift - three rounds of care every night (10pm, 2am, 6am) alongside two medication rounds and we had time between jobs to sit and have a coffee.

Now we have four or five nurses on the ward overnight and cannot cope with the workload.

Nurses are leaving the trust in droves, and as patient care suffers the management add more and more checks and restrictions on our practice to try and stop the bad things from happening. More nurses leave in disgust... You get the idea.

That is what is killing our health service. Not the bean counters; the managers that used to be nurses that are making things worse for us on the shop floor.
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by Darkflame »

Actually, although the treatment costs are small (big pharma has to supply medicines at cost to the NHS, and they don't get Ok'd by the NICE foundation if they're not absolutely necessary) the associated costs of healthcare are huge to the NHS.
If overall costs are much lower, is not higher costs of, say, beds, a worthy sacrifice?
els. We asked if we could go to the manufacturer and save thousands - we were informed that the company that handles furniture had to be routed through and their markup was reasonable as they also did things like fire certification.

The fact that the company is owned by a member of parliament is just coincidental, of course.
And you think that will happen less with more private firms? Getting in bed with government is basically big business 101.

The fact the MP was running a business and thus had a conflict of interest is a massive issue - but not one solved by more privatization.


As for complaints about automation and reducing staff.....umm...again, thats what private companies do. Thats how most of them increase their profits for shareholders.
User avatar
merman
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10943
Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: merman1974
Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
Location: Skegness, England
Contact:

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by merman »

Shareholders. That in a nutshell is why the NHS should NOT be privatised.

Let's look at the facts. The NHS is underfunded. Other countries spend a higher percentage of GDP on healthcare. We should spend more on the actual services. And even then, the NHS underspend has been clawed back by the Treasury.

What has happened under the Tories? Competition lawyers, increased bureaucracy and contracts going to companies who want a big return on their investment. Huge wastage on firing experienced staff and hiring agency staff. All so the shareholders and rich Tory party donors running healthcare companies can make money.

Those who can afford to pay for private healthcare can do so. If there is spare capacity in the private system, it can be used to relieve the burden on the public system. But there is no way all NHS care should be out in the hands of businesses.

The USA spends billions every year on fraud and lawyers BECAUSE of private healthcare. Hundreds of thousands of people are deep in debt BECAUSE of private healthcare.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

merman wrote:Shareholders. That in a nutshell is why the NHS should NOT be privatised.
...
The USA spends billions every year on fraud and lawyers BECAUSE of private healthcare. Hundreds of thousands of people are deep in debt BECAUSE of private healthcare.
A few posts back privatisation was being labelled doctrinaire. But nothing's more doctrinaire than that first paragraph. 'Shareholders'?? Hate to break it to you but shareholder owned companies have been making money off the NHS for a very long time. Even before PFI, the privatisation of hospital building, began under Major who do you think makes the drugs the NHS buys? The specialised equipment? The less specialised stuff like chairs, beds, food? Much of its bought from private companies. Ones with shareholders.

So shareholders, or their companies are already heavily involved in the NHS. Would you cut them all off, force the NHS to make its own drugs, furniture, grow its own food?

Or would you say no more? So all privatisation to this point is good (after all we do have a wonderful NHS). All future privatisation is bad. That makes no sense at all.

As I've pointed out already the problem with the US is a lack of a single payer (they do have one for some things, such as Medicare for old people). But if they end up with a single payer it will still be largely privatised. The failures in the US have nothing to do with it being privatised, and it's simply wrong to say so. Other countries have privatised healthcare provision without the problems of the US. Canada for example.
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by (o)(o) »

Greed Profit is an excellent motivator!

Only 6% of the NHS is currently privatised - just wait till American firms get their claws into large sections of the NHS - inescapable if TTIP proceeds.

Does anyone want 'americanized' health care?

Pogo surely must as he's in favour of putting the health service at the mercy of psychopathic profit-seeking entities.

I don't think there should be profit in other peoples suffering. Decent salaries reflecting hard work - sure - but when privatisation really kicks in.. it's going to be "big bonuses" all round. That profit is going to be reflected in a deficit in the quality of service, staff salaries or patient care.

I believe a report on NHS efficiency proved that - despite the ceaseless propaganda from neoliberalist lizards who spent much of 2013 vilifying the professionals operating the now recognised as No.1 health service - the NHS was in fact plenty efficient. The fact that it's very cheap per head and yet delivers world leading service is a pretty effective demonstration of this.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

No, sigh, not "americanized" (which should be capitalised and spelt with a s not z, unless you're American yourself). Privatisation does not imply the US system. Their system privatised but that's not what's wrong with it.

A quick explainer for those who've clearly missed the debate over there. The problem with the US is it's insurance based. Everyone buys insurance to cover their own health care costs. There are many problems with that.

* It's expensive for many reasons: the extra bureaucracy; the lack of cost control (as clinicians or experienced managers aren't in charge or purchasing); the legal system adding costs and encouraging defensive medicine (too many tests); costs of advertising and marketing.

* With everyone paying for themselves it places far more burden on the poor/low paid

* With insurance based on individual circumstance it's especially hard on those with pre-existing conditions

* Many insurers limit how much they'll pay, sometimes cutting off funding after a certain time/based on non-clinincal criteria

* All these problems lead many to go without insurance, causing sometimes much worse outcomes when they eventually get treated (emergency/life saving care is govt. guaranteed but for things like cancer by the time you're dying its far too late), and overall much worse healthcare

Obamacare tries to fix this in a number of ways. Subsidies for the poor and low paid so everyone can afford insurance. Forcing firms to charge everyone the same so no problems with pre-existing conditions. Forcing people to sign up, to prevent just the unhealthy getting insurance which would drive up costs.

It's not ideal though. It does little to control costs, especially as it's still insurance based. Coverage is very uneven as it's done through the states, only some of which have supported it with most obstructing it.

What they really need is single payer. The govt paying for everyone, as we have here, as they have in Canada. Take insurers out of it altogether. That was seen as a step too far last time, but hopefully next time. The problems with their system are plain to see and they really need to fix it.
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by (o)(o) »

pogo wrote:No, sigh, not "americanized"..
LOL at you sighing. :D

If american companies get in - of course it's going to get americannibalizardized.

TTIP gives US companies the legal right to DEMAND access to the NHS 'market'.

I don't think you are grasping the implications of TTIP.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

I understand TTIP perfectly. There seem to be two misconceptions about it. First that it changes the landscape of privatisation. But it doesn't: privatisation is going ahead and has been for decades. The rules on it won't change, or at least won't change according to TTIP. All it does is gives foreign firms some of the protections of local firms. Not all of them, but some.

At least some of the problem is people who should know better simply making things up. I.e. they are deliberately misleading people about how this will lead to more privatisation. It won't and they know it. Probably they know they can't reverse privatisation at the ballot box, given how every major party has supported it. They know it won't damage the NHS as it's been going on for a long time and the NHS is still excellent. So they're pretending it's something new and evil to get people's support. But it's utter nonsense: privatisation's happening already, TTIP won't make any difference to it.

The other misconception is we should fear US firms coming over as there's something bad about them. There isn't – they're just like firms here. In fact many of them are the same firms operating internationally already. Drugs and specialist medical supplies are already international businesses (they're some of our main exporters).

The problem with US healthcare is the system, which is down to the unique politics over there. It's not going to come over here with US firms. We won't have US lawyers coming here causing problems suing the NHS, they have no right to operate here. US insurers won't be setting up US style insurance here, we've got single payer. And so on. They'll operate under the same rules that EU firms operate already.
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by (o)(o) »

pogo wrote:I understand TTIP perfectly.....

.....We won't have US lawyers coming here causing problems suing the NHS
Perfectly :lol:

It's not idle speculation that this will happen - it's already occurring in other similar agreements.

The structure of the agreement makes it so.

Nations will be unable to afford doing anything that might provoke a corporate lawsuit.

It levels regulations, and takes them away from the sovereign democratic sphere to a technocratic arena.

We don't want America's shitty standards thank you very much.
pogo wrote:There seem to be two misconceptions about it. First that it changes the landscape of privatisation. But it doesn't: privatisation is going ahead and has been for decades..... some of the problem is people who should know better simply making things up.......[privatisation] won't damage the NHS as it's been going on for a long time and the NHS is still excellent.
Could you stop blatantly lying please?

Only 6% of the NHS is privatised that is only recently changing because of the coalition reforms in 2013 which opened up the markets and contracts are now being handed out to private firms at a rate over 70%.

Suggesting the NHS is fully privatised now therefore privatisation is spiffing is simply and outright lie.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

Again, we aren't importing "America's shitty standards". Our rules aren't changing at all in response to TTIP. US Firms won't have any rights that aren't already enjoyed by EU firms.

And America's standards aren't "shitty". Their health care provision is pretty good, for some things the best in the world (all those sports stars that fly out there to get their injuries fixed for example aren't stupid). Its problems are its' very expensive, costing about double what it costs almost anywhere else, and it's rationed by ability to pay.

And lying? It's you that thinks that 70% is a fact. Remember the headline was Private firms 'win 70% of NHS contracts'. The BBC doesn't believe it and nor should you.

I never wrote it is 'fully privatised'. But privatisation has been going on for decades in one form or another. It's not a new threat to the NHS as some of the more shrill commentators on it have been suggesting. Certainly TTIP will make little to no difference to it. The only possible difference is it will make it easier for foreign firms to compete for contracts which in theory will drive down prices, and so leave the NHS with more money to spend on other things. But I imagine the effect will be minimal.
User avatar
merman
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10943
Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: merman1974
Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
Location: Skegness, England
Contact:

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by merman »

Turning the NHS into a business will NOT drive down costs.

It will send costs up because shareholders have to have their profit.
Costs will increase because of increased opportunity for fraud.
Costs will increase because of more litigation over treatment (something this Coalition said it would crack down on and has failed to do).
Costs will increase because of all the extra accountants, lawyers and managers that will be employed to run the businesses, instead of putting money into the staff who actually treat patients.

And TTIP will mean the businesses will have the right to sue the Government when things don't go the way they want. Meaning more money wasted.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

merman wrote:Turning the NHS into a business will NOT drive down costs.
Privatisation will drive down costs, simply as contracts will only go to private companies if they're cheaper. How they manage that is up to them: they may be more efficient, they may be able to achieve economies of scale, they may operate with little or no profit to get the business, they may as is true of most firms have no shareholders so not need to make a profit.
And TTIP will mean the businesses will have the right to sue the Government when things don't go the way they want. Meaning more money wasted.
People keep writing this but without explaining how. TTIP doesn't change any of the rules of privatisation or procurement. Firms can already sue the government if they think they have a case. Even foreign firms.

The problem now is going to court internationally is expensive. It's especially expensive for small firms who don't have their own legal dept and/or an office in the other country. It's especially expensive in the USA (though it's not cheap here).

So the arbitration side of TTIP will mostly help small firms, especially small firms here looking to do business in the US. It won't change the laws to favour them, but will mean that when they have a dispute they can use arbitration, not the expensive and risky legal system.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by Dio »

So how do you reconcile with the above with the statement that the US system is very expensive?

Privatisation will inevitably drive up costs because the incentive will be - as in the US - to deploy treatment which is unnecessary or overzealous in order to make a profit on the provision of that treatment. If the gorvernment tries to block such excess treatment, private firms will pay for patients to sue the government for the treatment - as they do in the US with uncooperative insurers, and as is already happening here with some drugs.

As with all these sorts of things, look at the incentives that the system provides. The incentive for the private firm is much less "be efficient" - any gains made there are small potatoes - than it is "treat more people" - where the potential rise in profit is unlimited.
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by gilesgoat »

When I was in the secondary or so school I remember once asking something to the teacher along the lines "Why don't they do this thing to make a profit then ?" ..

.. and the answer was something around the lines, still remember it, "That a State has not to run on a profit logic but on the logic to supply the best possible service at the most convenient conditions for all the people" ..

Nobody wants to see inefficiency and waste of course nor things "that don't work" .. but when "profit" kicks in things CAN go dangerous if not very well controlled by some authority that can and is able to effectively exercise a control when needed.

Also for things to work well there should be a lot of "education" for people about "how to use not abuse resources" .. without that even the best efforts can have very hard times.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
Post Reply