That's simply wrong. 'doctrinaire capitalists'?? You mean like all the governments we've elected over the last 25 years, which have been the ones who introduced and expanded NHS privatisation. It's not 'doctrinaire'. Many people, including myself, think capitalism is best as it works. Not for everything but for a wide range of things. Other systems, such as state socialism, have been tried and failed.zip accident wrote: However they wouldn't be if doctrinaire capitalists got their way.
There are essentially two reasons for privatising the NHS, doctinaire capitalism, and making a big big profit on the quiet.
Which monopolies? NHS destruction?? It's still the best in the world despite decades of privatisation. And that is the market, or markets. Firms and individuals competing as firms and individuals.However, there are a lot of monopolies that go completely unchallenged.
Most businesses are small operations with few workers and almost no capital. They won't be part of anything significant to the NHS, and they won't be the ones raking in the profits from its destruction.
The market is a bad joke. There is no market. There are a lot of individuals and companies interacting. There is no institution that you can point to and say "that is the market". It is all a bunch of individual deals, being done at the same time.
I agree, but it's hard. It's hard to get too worked up about insider trading though. The losers are other traders on the wrong side of crooked deals. It doesn't affect the real economy of firms doing business.We don't need to abandon dealing. We do need to tackle abuse, because every case that's permitted to continue increases the probability of abuse in every other deal that arises.
Private firms don't need to diversify though. It's OK if they specialise, then the NHS buys services from different firms: one that makes drugs, another that makes equipment, one that does cleaning, etc.. The cost balancing takes place on the NHS budget: paying more to firms which provide more expensive services, less to firms providing cheaper basic ones. It's up to govt. to make sure it's funded, from taxation, tobacco duty or wherever.rowan wrote:However in the private sector, there is less ability for a health provider to balance costs across a portfolio of businesses. You probably wouldn't see a private medical company deciding to diversify into tobacco products for example, to prop up the med costs.
This also refutes the idea that private firms will cherry pick the profitable bits of the NHS. They can do both easy cheap things and expensive hard things, and should charge accordingly. They'll only get the work if they can do it for less than competitors which limits their ability to make excess profits. The NHS can also ensure this my making sure contracts are up for renewal regularly, to cope with changing costs and requirements.


