We don’t really have a similar period to compare. The current government has been in power for less than a year. It does seem that the Lords has in recent years become more assertive. E.g. on tax credits many thought they should have let that through as a manifesto commitment, under the £12bn the Tories said they would cut from welfare. That may seemed vague but it was for voters to decide whether they accepted the Tory plans to cut the deficit or Labour’s. The Lords used that vagueness to oppose the cut, but using that logic they could oppose any and all benefit cuts and so stop the government implementing this part of their manifesto.gravy wrote:There's more conservative peers in the Lords than any other party and there's not been a disparity in con bills rejected vs Labour bills during a similar period.
There is an imbalance compared to seats in the main house but it's not that big if you compare it to how people voted as a whole in the last election.
This isn't any more or less of an issue than it's been for a while. The only reason it's a topic of debate is Cameron's just a much bigger crybaby about not getting his own way.
For my money there should be a 2nd house but one that's filled via 5 years appointments based on proportions of the mass vote.
I actually agree, the House of Lords should be elected directly with a different system to the commons. Possibly PR, though that would not help parties on the left much as the Tories and UKIP got enough votes in 2015 to form a majority under any rational PR system. Labour and the Lib Dems still need to solve their unpopularity problems if they want to play a part in a future democratically elected government of the UK.



