Politics Thread!

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by pogo »

gravy wrote:There's more conservative peers in the Lords than any other party and there's not been a disparity in con bills rejected vs Labour bills during a similar period.

There is an imbalance compared to seats in the main house but it's not that big if you compare it to how people voted as a whole in the last election.

This isn't any more or less of an issue than it's been for a while. The only reason it's a topic of debate is Cameron's just a much bigger crybaby about not getting his own way.

For my money there should be a 2nd house but one that's filled via 5 years appointments based on proportions of the mass vote.
We don’t really have a similar period to compare. The current government has been in power for less than a year. It does seem that the Lords has in recent years become more assertive. E.g. on tax credits many thought they should have let that through as a manifesto commitment, under the £12bn the Tories said they would cut from welfare. That may seemed vague but it was for voters to decide whether they accepted the Tory plans to cut the deficit or Labour’s. The Lords used that vagueness to oppose the cut, but using that logic they could oppose any and all benefit cuts and so stop the government implementing this part of their manifesto.

I actually agree, the House of Lords should be elected directly with a different system to the commons. Possibly PR, though that would not help parties on the left much as the Tories and UKIP got enough votes in 2015 to form a majority under any rational PR system. Labour and the Lib Dems still need to solve their unpopularity problems if they want to play a part in a future democratically elected government of the UK.
User avatar
VNVObit
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4072
Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
PSN: VNV_Obit
Location: London

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by VNVObit »

pogo wrote:
We don’t really have a similar period to compare. The current government has been in power for less than a year. It does seem that the Lords has in recent years become more assertive. E.g. on tax credits many thought they should have let that through as a manifesto commitment, under the £12bn the Tories said they would cut from welfare. That may seemed vague but it was for voters to decide whether they accepted the Tory plans to cut the deficit or Labour’s. The Lords used that vagueness to oppose the cut, but using that logic they could oppose any and all benefit cuts and so stop the government implementing this part of their manifesto.

I actually agree, the House of Lords should be elected directly with a different system to the commons. Possibly PR, though that would not help parties on the left much as the Tories and UKIP got enough votes in 2015 to form a majority under any rational PR system. Labour and the Lib Dems still need to solve their unpopularity problems if they want to play a part in a future democratically elected government of the UK.

No it doesn't seem vague it stretches credulity to say it was an election commitment. They would need to have declared it in the manifesto explicitly to say it was a commitment. The fact the tories are in that position is because they were dishonest (through omission ) during the election
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford

My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single

"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by pogo »

Then Labour were even more dishonest. They said they would reduce the deficit but gave no timetable for eliminating it, so could have done it in 5 years or 50, essentially making it a problem for whoever followed them in office, as last time. They were especially vague about what cuts they would make. While the Tories were prepared to put a figure on e.g. their benefit cuts Labour weren’t. They were little better on taxes they would increase, as their sums did not add up and had at best vague guesses as to how much they would raise.

Even better few expected any party to get an overall majority in 2015. The expectation was for a coalition. That perhaps explains why some manifestos were so vague, as no party expected to implement their manifesto as-is, and they were as much negotiating positions as agendas for government. But if the government was another coalition one, say a Tory-UKIP one, would the Lords be right to reject everything they disliked that the elected government proposed, on the grounds that the policies matched neither manifesto? That would be a recipe for anarchy, or at least constitutional deadlock.
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by (o)(o) »

pogo wrote:...on tax credits many thought they should have let that through as a manifesto commitment, under the £12bn the Tories said they would cut from welfare. That may seemed vague but it was for voters to decide whether they accepted the Tory plans...
Voters cannot make informed decisions when they are being misled.

Cameron made specific promises which were lies.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by pogo »

Again, the Labour party were even more dishonest in not saying how they would eliminate the deficit, or when they did say their claims were vague to the point of being meaningless. E.g. they wanted to eliminate non-dom status but claimed only it would raise “hundreds of millions” of pounds. How many hundreds? Two? Nine? There is a big difference. Or even would it lose money as Ed Balls said only 3-4 months earlier?:


The Tories were willing to make the hard choices that are part of governing. Labour were engaged in gesture politics, with policies designed to soak the rich, not raise any money (as the small number targeted are very mobile and would not hang around to be taxed). This was fundamentally dishonest as it meant that if elected they would need new policies, not in their manifesto, to actually tackle the deficit. Voters could see this, and so did not trust Labour on the economy. Voters might not have liked Tory cuts but they were better than Labour’s hidden agenda which would only be revealed after the election.
User avatar
VNVObit
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4072
Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
PSN: VNV_Obit
Location: London

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by VNVObit »

pogo wrote: The Tories were willing to make the hard choices that are part of governing.
and what of these hard choices actually effect them?
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford

My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single

"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by pogo »

What? In case you have forgotten they had a timetable for eliminating the deficit and were clear about the scale of the cuts that would be needed, further breaking it down in terms of benefit cuts and departmental cuts, with some departments and benefits excluded. Those were the hard choices that I was referring to. Labour had nothing similar. They were in effect postponing making their hard choices until after the election, denying voters the chance to have their say on them.
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by (o)(o) »

It's Labour's fault the Tories lied about tax credits ?

The Conservatives edited that video to cut off the bit at the end which changes the meaning of Ed Balls comments.

Just another example of Tories lying as they have done repeatedly and on record including being rebuked on numerous occasions by official bodies. It's not even controversial. Anybody who refuses to accept clear factual evidence or who defends the practice of lying in politics isn't capable of rational thought.
pogo wrote:Then Labour were even more dishonest. They said they would reduce the deficit but gave no timetable for eliminating it
Image
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by pogo »

(o)(o) wrote:It's Labour's fault the Tories lied about tax credits ?

The Conservatives edited that video to cut off the bit at the end which changes the meaning of Ed Balls comments.
The video was a BBC news video, uploaded by the BBC, not the Tories. Seems to end with the reporter thanking him for giving the interview, so that’s the end of it. Unless you are crediting the BBC with some very clever and tricky editing.

I must admit I missed that statement by Ed Balls. The date is not in their manifesto, but more importantly they did not say what cuts they would enact to meet that deadline. Eliminating the deficit by 2020 would mean cutting as quickly as the Tories. But while the Tories were prepared to lay out in some detail the cuts they would make Labour were silent on theirs. They did have some tax rises, on non-doms, houses worth more than £2m, those earning £150000 or more, but those would do little if anything to close the deficit. The only way to significantly reduce it is cuts in spending. Cuts they would only reveal after the election.
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by (o)(o) »

pogo wrote:
(o)(o) wrote:It's Labour's fault the Tories lied about tax credits ?

The Conservatives edited that video to cut off the bit at the end which changes the meaning of Ed Balls comments.
The video was a BBC news video, uploaded by the BBC, not the Tories. Seems to end with the reporter thanking him for giving the interview, so that’s the end of it. Unless you are crediting the BBC with some very clever and tricky editing.
Here is the edited version the Tories distributed :

https://amp.twimg.com/v/7cb7f0ad-0fbc-4 ... 7c3dc593fb
pogo wrote:I must admit I missed that statement by Ed Balls.
What were you basing your false assertions on then?
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by pogo »

(o)(o) wrote:Here is the edited version the Tories distributed :

https://amp.twimg.com/v/7cb7f0ad-0fbc-4 ... 7c3dc593fb
pogo wrote:I must admit I missed that statement by Ed Balls.
What were you basing your false assertions on then?
So? I mean re the video, first I did not link to that but to the BBC one. Second it does not actually change the meaning. He still says abolishing non-dom status would end up costing Britain money. But that was in the Labour party manifesto, that they would abolish non-dom status.

And my assertion is that Labour did not spell out how they would cut the deficit, except for things that would not work. Abolishing non-dom status, which would cost Britain money. The 50% rate which had been tried already and failed. The mansion tax which would be the hardest of all these measures to enact and would also lose money. That is why they could not be trusted, as they must have had other plans to actually cut the deficit, but did not tell voters before the election what their plans were.
User avatar
merman
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10943
Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: merman1974
Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
Location: Skegness, England
Contact:

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by merman »

Pogo, you used exactly the same argument before.

And we pointed out to you after the election that the 50% rate "failed" because Osborne immediately allowed billions in assets to be transferred overseas in the previous financial year, before he changed the top rate back. By telling them it was going to happen, the rich got their accountants to act.

The only failure is Osborne. He promised to eliminate the deficit by 2015 and reduce Government borrowing. Instead he DOUBLED the national debt (which continues to rise) and had not even halved the deficit by 2015. Now he has vaguely promised to be in surplus by 2020, even when he has had THREE chances this year to trash his own projections and start again.

If you want to say that the manifesto determines what a party does in power, then WHY did Osborne seek to cut tax credits without any manifesto commitment (Cameron having clearly stated in the election debate he wasn't going to)? WHY did Jeremy Hunt cut bursaries for student nurses without any prior statement in the election literature? And WHY is Theresa May kicking out non-EU residents earning less than £35,000 without putting that policy to the voters?
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by (o)(o) »

pogo wrote:re the video ... it does not actually change the meaning. He still says abolishing non-dom status would [PROBABLY] end up costing Britain money...
" ... but we can be tougher and we should be. ".

You're wrong. The words the Tories cut out change the meaning.

Serious question. Is English your first language?
pogo wrote:I must admit I missed that statement by Ed Balls.
(o)(o) wrote:What were you basing your false assertions on then?
You asserted Labour didn't have a timetable. What did you base that assertion on?
User avatar
VNVObit
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4072
Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
PSN: VNV_Obit
Location: London

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by VNVObit »

pogo wrote:*answers completely different question*.
VNVObit wrote:
pogo wrote: The Tories were willing to make the hard choices that are part of governing.
and what of these hard choices actually effect them?
care to answer the actual question pogo?
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford

My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single

"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by pogo »

merman wrote:Pogo, you used exactly the same argument before.

And we pointed out to you after the election that the 50% rate "failed" because Osborne immediately allowed billions in assets to be transferred overseas in the previous financial year, before he changed the top rate back. By telling them it was going to happen, the rich got their accountants to act.
The expectation though is that if it had been in place for longer the behavioural response would have been much larger. Many of the decisions that are influenced by tax rates, in particular the top rate, are long term ones such as where to take a job as an individual, where to set up a business or establish a head office as a firm, where to emigrate to, where to retire or retire to. These are not decisions made every year but decisions made every few years, sometimes only once in a lifetime.

This is what we face in the modern world: global capital, top earners and the wealthy are all very mobile. The UK already has one of the highest top rates of income tax, pushing it much higher would drive people away. It’s not as if we have not tried it, we did. And analysis after the rate was raised last time suggested trying it again would lose money instead of raise it.
Post Reply