EU referendum are you in or out
- phattslagg
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3578
- Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
- Location: Worcester, England
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
Any fucking idiot who thinks the low pound will help British manufacturing is clearly forgetting to factor in the fact that most of the parts will be sourced from abroad, so any potential reduction in price to, for instance, US customers is offset by increased manufacturing costs.
Try again.
Try again.
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
There's really nothing any kind of leadership can do to make things better. Financially brexit can only make things worse and the best a good leader could do is to negotiate to minimise the harm it will do, which still isn't a good enough outcome to turn things around. Either that or to throw out the result of the referendum altogether, which I dare say at this stage would make the racist abuse worse still.Little stoned kiwi wrote:It would be fine if there was some strong leadership. Someone to say everything will be okay and the backbone to forge ahead with optimism and potential.
Pity the UK doesn't have that.
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
The idea is that what you export is worth more than what you imported to make it (if its not then you should stop doing it!), so the gain is in the difference in value between the import and export.phattslagg wrote:Any fucking idiot who thinks the low pound will help British manufacturing is clearly forgetting to factor in the fact that most of the parts will be sourced from abroad, so any potential reduction in price to, for instance, US customers is offset by increased manufacturing costs.
Try again.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
phattslagg is right: UK manufacturing is much more value added today. We export very little that is entirely sourced in this country. This means the benefit to manufacturing, of a fall in the pound, is only a small fraction of each firm’s revenue.
The last recession is a clear illustration of this: we did not see an export-led recovery, even though the pound fell much more. Perhaps the main reason was the weakness in the eurozone, where most of our exports go.
The good thing in 2008-09 was that firms faced with a recession were able to use the weaker pound to mitigate the bad business conditions. Wages fell in real terms but this meant firms did not have to lay off workers to cut costs. I.e. the fall in the pound helped shield us from much worse unemployment.
But that is unlikely to be true this time. The fall in the pound is much less. And the employment effect is much more direct. It’s not just firms weathering a few lean years knowing things will get better. It’s firms making long term and permanent decisions to expand/relocate outside the UK.
The last recession is a clear illustration of this: we did not see an export-led recovery, even though the pound fell much more. Perhaps the main reason was the weakness in the eurozone, where most of our exports go.
The good thing in 2008-09 was that firms faced with a recession were able to use the weaker pound to mitigate the bad business conditions. Wages fell in real terms but this meant firms did not have to lay off workers to cut costs. I.e. the fall in the pound helped shield us from much worse unemployment.
But that is unlikely to be true this time. The fall in the pound is much less. And the employment effect is much more direct. It’s not just firms weathering a few lean years knowing things will get better. It’s firms making long term and permanent decisions to expand/relocate outside the UK.
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
You can't leadership a shit sandwich into anything other than a shit sandwich.Little stoned kiwi wrote:It would be fine if there was some strong leadership. Someone to say everything will be okay and the backbone to forge ahead with optimism and potential.
Pity the UK doesn't have that.
However charismatic the bullshitter is ultimately reality has a nasty habit of asserting itself
That all said we do have fuckwits at the helm who will make the worst of an already bad situation
- Little stoned kiwi
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4598
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
- Location: Christchurch
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
Which is my point. The markets aren't just reacting to Brexit, they are reacting to the overreaction.gravy wrote: That all said we do have fuckwits at the helm who will make the worst of an already bad situation
If they think you're crude, go technical; if they think you're technical, go crude. I'm a very technical boy.
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
That's different from claiming that the savings are offset by the cost of import.pogo wrote:phattslagg is right: UK manufacturing is much more value added today. We export very little that is entirely sourced in this country. This means the benefit to manufacturing, of a fall in the pound, is only a small fraction of each firm’s revenue.
I don't know what people would ever buy from the UK other than things that have enormous differences between material cost and retail value (eg., Hi-fi). Anything I'm aware of with only small value added comes from China or Malaysia.
That said, the market of things that don't come from China is pretty niche, so it's certainly not an industry that can save the country or even help in any non-negligible way.
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
There's a few heads I'd shove into the forge with great optimism.Little stoned kiwi wrote:Someone to say everything will be okay and the backbone to forge ahead with optimism
No, but you can make it look tasty.gravy wrote:You can't leadership a shit sandwich into anything other than a shit sandwich.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
Looking for leadership is like escaping from prison and then looking around for a prison guard to tell you what to do next.
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
So you're saying we need someone who can lead the financial markets in a confident and reassuring way?Little stoned kiwi wrote:Which is my point. The markets aren't just reacting to Brexit, they are reacting to the overreaction.gravy wrote: That all said we do have fuckwits at the helm who will make the worst of an already bad situation
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
The comparison with China is interesting. Perhaps the clearest argument is that we have no manufacturing exports that benefit from a lower pound as the ones that are price sensitive left the UK years if not decades ago. They left for Southern or Eastern Europe under the Single Market, or to the Far East under WTO rules. It’s not that long ago that e.g. quotas were eliminated on clothing and in the space of a few years everything except niche, boutique stuff shifted manufacturing to China, India and a few smaller countries.gumboot wrote:That said, the market of things that don't come from China is pretty niche, so it's certainly not an industry that can save the country or even help in any non-negligible way.
China though is suffering now, as it is no longer the cheapest country to manufacture in, in Asia. High growth, high wage growth, and a shrinking labour force due to the One Child Policy have driven many firms, even Chinese firms, overseas to places like Vietnam which are even cheaper.
We can’t compete with them on cost, and a 10% fall in the pound makes little difference one way or another. Manufacturing here tends to be high value niche goods – pharmaceuticals, luxury goods, local specialities – which are not easily substitutable or very price sensitive.
- Little stoned kiwi
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4598
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
- Location: Christchurch
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
Everyone needs to stop running around in circles screaming, "The World is burning!" It doesn't give others confidence the fires will be put out. The political instability is fanning the flames.gumboot wrote:So you're saying we need someone who can lead the financial markets in a confident and reassuring way?
But yes, a sociopathic businessman spinning bullshit to the media is exactly what the UK needs. Ours is a former currency trader who was known as the 'smiling assassin'.
If they think you're crude, go technical; if they think you're technical, go crude. I'm a very technical boy.
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
Since the referendum my pay has gone up. This month I'm quids in to the tune of an extra 400 pounds, which isn't to be sniffed at. It was £300 extra, but then some housing/mortgage companies panicked so I get a bit more because of that.
I did vote to remain, but I'm certainly reaping the benefits so not really complaining too loudly at this point.
More uncertainty please!
I did vote to remain, but I'm certainly reaping the benefits so not really complaining too loudly at this point.
More uncertainty please!
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
Politicians have always been dicks; I doubt anybody's reacting differently to that development.Little stoned kiwi wrote:Everyone needs to stop running around in circles screaming, "The World is burning!" It doesn't give others confidence the fires will be put out. The political instability is fanning the flames.
Most major decisions to abandon the UK seem perfectly rational to me. Maybe there's still a chance that they'll reach some non-catastrophic arrangement with the EU, but it's a shit gamble and even if they do (they won't) most money is still better off somewhere better connected to a decent-sized market.
Too much of the UK's value was bound up in its position in the EU. Without that there's just not a lot of point dealing with them anymore.
Proper international British companies are floating up and over the crash. If there was a genuine panic then they wouldn't be able to do that.
Last edited by gumboot on Wed Jul 06, 2016 8:31 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
Not really, the bus is going over the cliff whatever. It's only marginally worst because Mr Tumble is in the driving seat.Little stoned kiwi wrote:Which is my point. The markets aren't just reacting to Brexit, they are reacting to the overreaction.gravy wrote: That all said we do have fuckwits at the helm who will make the worst of an already bad situation


