Cloudane wrote:major "fan exodus" moments
I must admit, I kinda think they're a bit overblown. I mean, I don't really hang out in any pony circles, sometimes I wonder if there's a perspective that people lack - like, it's a kids TV show, it has some cool messages here and there about friendship, but it's not Casablanca (someone already made that movie). I dunno. I guess I'm just worried that if I overthink and overanalyze it, it'll lose its "haha that horse did a funny face" appeal.
Cloudane wrote:reformed Starlight as this awkward seventh wheel
I dunno, I kinda really like Starlight and how she's on the fringe of the mane six. To me, it feels kinda "you were evil and now you're sorry and that's okay, so come be a friend, but you're never going to be as close as the people who weren't evil in the first place". Like, it feels like it makes the point that being 'a baddie' has consequences? I dunno, I don't really think about my pony too deeply, maybe I'm missing some big point here.
Also, I love the interplay between her and Trixie - like, friendship is still magic, even if you aren't part of Twilight's Special A-Team Of Friendship. The great and all powerful consolation prize of friendship!
Cloudane wrote:they did great with her character recently (like in the S7 finale for example)
Oh shit, I've been slacking on my horse-watching recently, I haven't even finished season 7 yet - if there's more Starlight then maybe that'll be the push I need to finish it!
Cloudane wrote:FiM heads towards its conclusion, it looks great.
I spent a few days thinking "aww no more FiM" but the more I think about it, the more I think you're right, in that it's beginning to find its natural end. I also "felt the meh" with s5/6, as you say. You're right that if it got to simpsons-level length, half of us would be following it just because "it's a meme" rather than for actually liking it, which would be sad.
ty for spoiler-tagging btw, I'll be avoiding spoilers hard as I can, too. And yes, about Q.. that's how I imagine the writers thinking, or the Q-Actor-Guy at least..
Giles wrote:G3 ponies

I mean the one with Sweetheart, Teddy, Lancer, Bon Bon, Starlight and such
Well, I guess that's what I'll be watching then! Haha. I kinda agree with a lot of your points Giles, about animation and such.
toxibunny wrote:My 5-yr-old frowned for much of it
Hi toxibunny, how goes, I haven't said hi for a while, hope you're doing alright.
Shame you didn't like the film, and your 5-year old didn't either. I always wonder how the "actual kids" received the film, vs us "grown ups".. .. .. (I use the "Giles Quote Marks" there because I'm a thirty-something not-grown-up).
Oh, also, is it appropriate to suggest/talk about other animated shows in this thread? I've been away from YY and forums for so long, I don't wanna commit some faux pas! Speaking of which, uh, sorry for the super-long post..
I am both the king and the queen of cheese.
<Wife_of_Snake> Random the sugar rush fairy!
<}stinky_beast{> I'd do a zebra if it'd stand still