My little Brony...

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: My little Brony...

Post by Cloudane »

Sweet, nice that your friends enjoyed it too. Whilst mine don't give me a hard time or anything I can't see any of them having any desire to see MLP :P

In my headcanon Discord is Q. It goes something along the lines of the continuum getting fed up of him mithering Starfleet captains and humanity in general, and exiling him to a world in some distant galaxy where they've observed the kind of life forms that would drive him up the wall. Which they do, but as fate would have it some thousand or whatever years later he learns the magic of friendship and flowers and ponies and bleh :)

They'd never be able to canonise something like that of course, but you can't help but wonder if privately the writers have similar thoughts.
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: My little Brony...

Post by Cloudane »

Beware, a bunch of leaks have happened and people are posting spoilers like crazy. (None here please!)

The following isn't a spoiler, nothing plot related, but it's a major revelation/bombshell on the direction of MLP as a whole
Spoiler: show
FiM will be ending with season 9 then they're moving on to a Gen 5 reboot, punctuated by a second movie in between.

It'll be tough watching our beloved characters and world get replaced, but now we'll know how G1 and G3 fans felt I suppose ^^
All good things...

We're looking at 2021 for G5 though, so plenty of time to enjoy FiM until then.

Personally, I don't really mind - it's sad but it needs closure eventually (vs. the Simpsons alternative) and will probably be a good excuse to back off on the obsession a bit.
User avatar
toxibunny
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5906
Joined: Thu Jun 17, 2004 11:59 pm 0
Location: limb clock land

Re: My little Brony...

Post by toxibunny »

Well, the movie sucks. The story, the New characters and locations - they're all wrong. It's too grimy, adversarial and violent in a way that the cartoons deliberately are not, and even the main ponies themselves aren't drawn quite right, and act out of character - they've changed pinkie pie from a ditsy whimsical party pony into someone borderline psychotic. The main bad guy, I think, offers us a glimpse into the minds of the film's makers when he bellows "I'm so OVER this cutesy happy pony thing!" Not long before
Spoiler: show
being turned into stone and plummeting off a parapet, smashing into pieces.
The Simpsons movie was better than this, being merely disappointing. The Simpsons was at least authentic. This just seems like a cash-in, lacking the 'friendship is magic' ethos, and not even managing a cohesive visual style. My 5-yr-old frowned for much of it, only perking up when she spotted Discord in the background during the end credits.
I made a deviantart page.
'....The baron is a gay old rogue with an eye for the ladies....'
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: My little Brony...

Post by gilesgoat »

Ok I will reveal the fact that "it's been quite some time since I stopped watching MLP" :|

Actually I did stop I can't even remember when but around when they introduced that new character Starlight Glimmer and such, I got the feeling that "something was starting to be a bit lost in there".

So I went from "deeply in love for MLP" to "forget it" in nearly 1 day :|

For some reasons I cannot fully explain I had the impression they were turning into something I wasn't totally sure if it was the thing I loved to watch, to me the UGLIEST thing they ever done was those "Equestria Girls" :evil: :evil:

Anyway out of "big abstinence" and such I HAD to see the movie to see where things were at.

Sure .. "graphics is not the same" I noted that immediately, did not like much at all the "excessive work" they done in the eyes with all those reflections and crap, the "shading" effect was a bit like "yeah ok but strange".

I can see why Discord wasn't it, it probably would have make "a too powerful character difficult to manage in a story" about "psychotic" hard to say "who is worse" if Pinky Pie or Twilight Sparkle .. actually Twilight Sparkle IS probably "the weirdest of all" :mrgreen:

They certainly made a point over the fact that "even Equestria is not such a happy happy place" if you see what actually happened to Tempest.

I don't know "some people could call me mad" but "the most cutiest pony-like stuff" you can see that in G3 ponies :mrgreen: I mean the one with Sweetheart, Teddy, Lancer, Bon Bon, Starlight and such :lol:

This movie in effect seem to be made more "for a bit more adult fans" than children, I wasn't sure about certain characters in it, I mean the whole idea of that town in the desert and such .. hum ..

I don't know what to think really, said that I should also say that basically "there are 0 cartoons I am watching nowadays", can't find one I really would like to follow or say "ah this is the thing I really want to watch", MLP was one up to a point, now not any more.

I don't say the movie is bad anyway, had some fun from it, certainly not sure if that is the thing I'd expected or not.

But overall .. overall can't even remember what been the last animation movie I really had some fun with , ah yes, I remember it now, was "Sing", and the only "serious" movie I found quite nice recently been the new Murder on the Orient Express, that was good.

Animation .. well .. not really ANYTHING in particular I am looking forward to except maybe that "Ferdinand" that for obvious reasons Jeff wants to see :lol:

But apart from that yeah .. at the moment "nothing exceptional comes into my mind".
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: My little Brony...

Post by Cloudane »

Yeah I'd say there have been a few major "fan exodus" moments

One was EQG (which I actually really liked in the end, even though I disagreed with the concept and also wasn't keen on the designs) which many saw as an insult to Lauren Faust after she herself went on 4chan to vent about it.

Another was the 1984 homage with Starlight which came across like "equality is bad and you're all a pack of dirty commies and leftists" which just seemed so contrary to the spirit of MLP and unnecessary political commentary at a time when the last thing the world needs is more politics, in a show people watch for escapism. I have a good friend I met through Bronydom who dropped it like a stone after that episode in that same "from loving it to zero in 1 day" fashion. There was never one that political again since that I can think of but the damage was done for a lot of staunch liberal types.

And then there was the introduction of the reformed Starlight as this awkward seventh wheel, never officially part of a "mane 7" but always a "mane 6 +1" and no one really knows why (it was just kinda... you're our best friend now as at least now you're not some evil dictator) which I think made a lot of people consider it to have lost its way. Tho I will say they did great with her character recently (like in the S7 finale for example) but too little too late for a lot of fans who were already starting to get burned out on it.

I think season 7 was great stuff though, after a middling-to-good S5 and a middling S6 far as I recall.

As for the future as FiM heads towards its conclusion, it looks great. I didn't catch (or want to catch) all the spoilers and leaks but I saw the general premise for the final seasons (8+9). Quickly averted my eyes but this is what I understand of it

No specific plot points so not really spoilers per se, but there are details of general premise going forward:
Spoiler: show
The movie was very important as the rest of FiM revolves around the other lands and species we saw in the movie - along with the dragons and changelings I think - and the mane 6+ being sort of "friendship ambassadors" sent around that world, spreading the pony ideals of friendship and harmony beyond equestria. I like the idea - it gives ponies like Twilight a wider destiny (after FiM was originally designed to end at S3 after the whole wings and princess of friendship thing), a much richer world to explore, the potential for some great Trek-like diplomacy stories, and I imagine - just my own theory - a "new era of peace, friendship and harmony around the world" kind of ending. It seems quite relevant to the real world as well, as in something we need at a time of more partisanship than we've seen in the west for a long time.
I won't lie, I did feel the "meh" from season 5 onwards and "convince myself it was good" to a degree (more genuinely good with S7 I think) but as for 8 and 9.... I am SO excited to see it.
User avatar
randomdude
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4609
Joined: Sat Aug 02, 2003 3:54 am 0

Re: My little Brony...

Post by randomdude »

Cloudane wrote:major "fan exodus" moments
I must admit, I kinda think they're a bit overblown. I mean, I don't really hang out in any pony circles, sometimes I wonder if there's a perspective that people lack - like, it's a kids TV show, it has some cool messages here and there about friendship, but it's not Casablanca (someone already made that movie). I dunno. I guess I'm just worried that if I overthink and overanalyze it, it'll lose its "haha that horse did a funny face" appeal.
Cloudane wrote:reformed Starlight as this awkward seventh wheel
I dunno, I kinda really like Starlight and how she's on the fringe of the mane six. To me, it feels kinda "you were evil and now you're sorry and that's okay, so come be a friend, but you're never going to be as close as the people who weren't evil in the first place". Like, it feels like it makes the point that being 'a baddie' has consequences? I dunno, I don't really think about my pony too deeply, maybe I'm missing some big point here.

Also, I love the interplay between her and Trixie - like, friendship is still magic, even if you aren't part of Twilight's Special A-Team Of Friendship. The great and all powerful consolation prize of friendship! :D
Cloudane wrote:they did great with her character recently (like in the S7 finale for example)
Oh shit, I've been slacking on my horse-watching recently, I haven't even finished season 7 yet - if there's more Starlight then maybe that'll be the push I need to finish it! :lol:
Cloudane wrote:FiM heads towards its conclusion, it looks great.
I spent a few days thinking "aww no more FiM" but the more I think about it, the more I think you're right, in that it's beginning to find its natural end. I also "felt the meh" with s5/6, as you say. You're right that if it got to simpsons-level length, half of us would be following it just because "it's a meme" rather than for actually liking it, which would be sad.

ty for spoiler-tagging btw, I'll be avoiding spoilers hard as I can, too. And yes, about Q.. that's how I imagine the writers thinking, or the Q-Actor-Guy at least..
Giles wrote:G3 ponies :mrgreen: I mean the one with Sweetheart, Teddy, Lancer, Bon Bon, Starlight and such :lol:
Well, I guess that's what I'll be watching then! Haha. I kinda agree with a lot of your points Giles, about animation and such.
toxibunny wrote:My 5-yr-old frowned for much of it
Hi toxibunny, how goes, I haven't said hi for a while, hope you're doing alright.
Shame you didn't like the film, and your 5-year old didn't either. I always wonder how the "actual kids" received the film, vs us "grown ups".. .. .. (I use the "Giles Quote Marks" there because I'm a thirty-something not-grown-up).

Oh, also, is it appropriate to suggest/talk about other animated shows in this thread? I've been away from YY and forums for so long, I don't wanna commit some faux pas! Speaking of which, uh, sorry for the super-long post..
I am both the king and the queen of cheese.
<Wife_of_Snake> Random the sugar rush fairy!
<}stinky_beast{> I'd do a zebra if it'd stand still
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: My little Brony...

Post by Cloudane »

randomdude wrote:I must admit, I kinda think they're a bit overblown. I mean, I don't really hang out in any pony circles, sometimes I wonder if there's a perspective that people lack - like, it's a kids TV show, it has some cool messages here and there about friendship, but it's not Casablanca (someone already made that movie). I dunno. I guess I'm just worried that if I overthink and overanalyze it, it'll lose its "haha that horse did a funny face" appeal.
Yeah I rather agree - I stopped hanging around on ponychan which was the worst for this and taking fun cartoon horse show EXTREMELY SERIOUSLY, it got kind of depressing hanging around people who seem to hate what they're watching and feel the need to tell everyone why it sucks every week. (Why I also don't participate in Whodom much). I have been around other areas of pony circles though and I'd say there were marked declines around those times even if only a vocal few were doing the whole attention grabbing "never watching this again" flouncey thing.
I dunno, I kinda really like Starlight and how she's on the fringe of the mane six. To me, it feels kinda "you were evil and now you're sorry and that's okay, so come be a friend, but you're never going to be as close as the people who weren't evil in the first place". Like, it feels like it makes the point that being 'a baddie' has consequences? I dunno, I don't really think about my pony too deeply, maybe I'm missing some big point here.
Yeah true. I mean, I quite liked her in S7 and she felt like she had more of a purpose. It just felt at first like they had this idea to bring her on board but weren't sure what to do with her. I do agree it's probably a good thing that she can't just become an integral part of the main group who have a lot of history as it'd sort of cheapen what they have.
Before the gen 5 revelations I thought they were maybe amassing a secondary circle of friends for a spinoff or gen 4.5 series with her, Sunburst, Trixie etc. Though that's not to say it wouldn't happen a there can be multiple plans and nothing set in stone til it's done.

Agree with you on Trixie, it came out of the left field to me but works so well. One of those genius unexpected friendships that makes total sense once it's in place.
Oh shit, I've been slacking on my horse-watching recently, I haven't even finished season 7 yet - if there's more Starlight then maybe that'll be the push I need to finish it! :lol:
Do it! The S7 finale makes some controversial decisions (nothing bad imo), but it really treated Starlight well. Not to give anything away (she's that way from the start) but her character is used really well as "the voice of reason".
I spent a few days thinking "aww no more FiM" but the more I think about it, the more I think you're right, in that it's beginning to find its natural end. I also "felt the meh" with s5/6, as you say. You're right that if it got to simpsons-level length, half of us would be following it just because "it's a meme" rather than for actually liking it, which would be sad.
Yeah I'm in two minds, I don't want to see it end BUT I can see why it would, and the arguments people have made that the characters are so well developed. I tend to think "we're always learning and developing so why not ponies" but I guess it's different with storytelling and you can only send them on so many development arcs. Then it becomes a Simpsons-y slice of life thing.

G5 is a wait and see thing. I think Lauren Faust is what made G4 successful through the foundations she set really, but it could be good. I'd be excited to see some form of change in a way.
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: My little Brony...

Post by Cloudane »

The ride ends. But it's been 2 seasons longer than any Star Trek series, so can't exactly complain!
https://twitter.com/TheBiggestJim/statu ... 8914736130

Gen 5 looks interesting from the leaks. Some very interesting changes in the concept art.
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: My little Brony...

Post by Cloudane »

Horse has ended. Went out on a high IMO, enjoyed that finale, there were feels :cry:

End of an era
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: My little Brony...

Post by gilesgoat »

Cloudane wrote:Horse has ended. Went out on a high IMO, enjoyed that finale, there were feels :cry:

End of an era
For a stange weird looking fate I know how it ends, I haven't seen the episodes tough.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: My little Brony...

Post by Cloudane »

It was monumentally difficult avoiding spoilers with all the leaks and early airings. It's nice to be able to use Twitter again (I think)
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: My little Brony...

Post by Cloudane »

So now this is a new show that is a thing (and just realised how much it reminds me of Littlest Pet Shop)



Putting aside that for some reason they now have televisions and mobile phones...

Who actually thought "hey, here's a pitch: there's this previously unknown time during the original FiM timeline (sometime between seasons 4 and 9) where the mane six all got addicted to potions AND THEN NEVER SPOKE OF IT AGAIN" :lol: :lol: :lol:
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: My little Brony...

Post by gilesgoat »

Cloudane wrote:So now this is a new show that is a thing (and just realised how much it reminds me of Littlest Pet Shop)



Putting aside that for some reason they now have televisions and mobile phones...

Who actually thought "hey, here's a pitch: there's this previously unknown time during the original FiM timeline (sometime between seasons 4 and 9) where the mane six all got addicted to potions AND THEN NEVER SPOKE OF IT AGAIN" :lol: :lol: :lol:
So ... are we doomed with "sloppy graphics and weird humour" for all next cartoons in this day and age ????


.. I also think that Miyazaki is NOT that great ...
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: My little Brony...

Post by Cloudane »

CalArts is definitely overrated. That said, despite going for THOSE MOUTHS, I rather enjoyed Steven Universe

I still have hope... PL isn't terrible (they do seem to have a knack for taking terrible concepts and making them good, see also EQG) and in any case it's just filler until this

Image

Which last I heard was going down an action/adventure route with mythology in a similar vein to FiM S1. And has a black actress for AJ, which will hopefully weed the racists out of the fandom (they're not very happy about it)
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: My little Brony...

Post by gilesgoat »

Cloudane wrote:CalArts is definitely overrated. That said, despite going for THOSE MOUTHS, I rather enjoyed Steven Universe

I still have hope... PL isn't terrible (they do seem to have a knack for taking terrible concepts and making them good, see also EQG) and in any case it's just filler until this

Image

Which last I heard was going down an action/adventure route with mythology in a similar vein to FiM S1. And has a black actress for AJ, which will hopefully weed the racists out of the fandom (they're not very happy about it)
Besides .. still looking for the DVD sets of Seasons 8/9 .. nothing yet ?
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
Post Reply