Little stoned kiwi wrote:If the UK ends up being sold on the cheap after hard Brexit, it would be ironic if the EU buys it.
Well, as I covered before, when the UK railways were privatised, that's pretty much exactly who bought it all.
Arriva Trains Wales, Chiltern Railways, CrossCountry, Grand Central, and Northern - these are all run by Deutsche Bahn, who're Germany's national train operator that the German government is a majority stakeholder in.
Thameslink, Southern, South Eastern, Great Northern, and Gatwick Express - these are run by Govia. Govia is jointly owned by the UK "Go Ahead" group and Keolis. Keolis is basically the commercial private arm of SNCF, which is the French national train operator, owned by the French government.
Greater Anglia, Stansted Express and Scotrail - these are run by Abellio. Abellio is run by Netherlands Rail, whose only shareholder is the Dutch government. Also, along with the Japanese companies Mitsui & Co. and East Japan Railway it runs London Northwestern and West Midlands Rail. They also run Merseyrail with the UK-based Serco.
The C2C franchise is run by Trenitalia, which is owned by the Italian government.
The only UK-owned rail franchises are FirstGroup, Stagecoach, and Virgin Trains (and despite the name, Virgin Trains is actually partly Stagecoach and partly the Virgin group). While FirstGroup and Stagecoach are originally bus operators, who decided to expand into trains.
And this is only the trains. You can do a similar breakdown with the privatised energy markets (and you can also note that Deutsche Post owns a significant chunk of the UK's postal service too).
So, actually, the grand irony you're talking about is, by and large, already true. Has been for decades.
When the UK - through Tory ideology, it should be noted - decided to sell off its public infrastructure under privatisation, it was almost all bought up by the non-privatised nationalised operators of other EU countries.
Oh, yes. The irony is writ very large on this one.
But if you think about it, then it does make abundant sense. If you're selling off a nationalised railway, then who has the interest and experience to want to and know how to run a nationalised railway? Who already had the contacts and the suppliers? The ability to construct the trains? Well, the national railway operators of other countries, of course. They're already doing all this at home and they can make a bit of extra cash - to fund their own railway operations back home - by expanding their operations (under a different "commercial" name, as they realise it's better to call themselves "Arriva" or "Northern" in an English-speaking country than to go by "Deutsche Bahn") across the channel.
So when the UK privatised its railways (and other similar markets), they did not, in fact, cease to be operated by government. They just ceased to be operated by the UK government. They're largely operated instead by the German, French and Dutch governments (with a sprinkling of the Japanese and Italians, and a couple of UK-based bus companies "upgrading" to trains).
In the context of Brexit, this poses a bit of a problem. As part of the EU, these governments could operate their foreign train operations in the UK without tariffs or impediment to free movement. We're throwing up a wall and leaving the EU - but these companies will still, for the foreseeable, be run largely by EU governments (or, well, for legal purposes, the "commercial arms" thereof, operating as private companies, but their shareholders are majority or completely government-owned, so that's just a "legal paperwork" thing only).
We've already sold most of our infrastructure to the EU. We did that decades back. And they'll still own it after Brexit.
Thus, what we've really voted for is making it far harder and more expensive for these EU governments to run our infrastructure for us. And, of course, you can expect to see that reflected in the cost of train tickets and utility bills. They'll naturally shift that extra cost on us, the consumers.
If, that is, they bother to stick around. As the impediments might simply prove too much and they just quit. Fold up their operations and get out of the UK, as it's not profitable anymore. And, well, who's going to step in to take over?
Because we don't have the home-grown capacity. Privatisation - though this might have been the ideological purpose of it - did not, in fact, create brand new UK-based startup companies. Pretty much every other country on Earth - even uber-capitalist America - has not de-nationalised its railway infrastructure, as the UK has, so that privately-owned experience also does not exist outside the UK either.
Indeed, I would suggest that if the Oxford Dictionary does choose to include "omnishambles" into the dictionary, then the illustrative example would have to be Brexit. Brexit is the canonical definition of "an omnishambles".
Take back control? Of what exactly?
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes