Dio wrote:People focus on manufacturing but that's not the issue really. Manufacturing has spent the last 100 years moving wherever can do it at a better price/cost ratio: the US in the 30s, Japan and Germany in the late 50s through the 70s, Taiwan in the 80s, China in the 00s, increasingly the rest of south-east Asia now as even China's cost base is starting to rise.
Manufacturing jobs that do exist in this country are typically held by locals, because they tend to be (or at least promise) the kind of long term employment that's attractive to people who want to be settled. The jobs that (unskilled) immigrants are doing are "unattractive" - more likely to be A. temporary, B. in a place they don't want to be or C. underpaid, so only people prepared to live in limited circumstances can do it. (Meanwhile, the skilled immigrants go where the jobs and the money are: whether that's an A&E consultant or a plumber - again, people have been doing this for years, it was the whole principle of Auf Wiedersehen, Pet wasn't it!)
The perception is we don't have people to do these jobs, but the real problem is that the jobs aren't attractive enough. If they paid better and offered solid long term prospects there would be zero problem finding 'locals' to do it.
There's a bit of truth in this but also you have to keep in mind 'the world is changed' the idea of 'the fixed job I never move/change' is gone, it's the nature of things, if this also means that people in the future will move all over the places this I don't know, possible, the way I see it's more leading to a way where you have to create your own job/business.
Unfortunately 'temp jobs' that are really temp by nature or 'not super paid jobs' will always be, not all jobs can be 'super nice'.
But on the other side 'every paid job is better than no money', 'underpaid' should be illegal so that's a law/government problem, if by 'underpaid' you mean 'minimal wage' again that's a law/government problem that set minimal wages too low and you should complain to them, if you / an immigrant takes a minimal wage job that 'someone else does not want to' it's perfectly legal, unattractive maybe, but it's still money someone pays.
"Temp jobs" guess what EVERYONE nowadays works with "temp jobs" if you have the security to say "I can see me working in this place in the next 5 years" you just should kiss the soil where you walk and the chair you sit on and thanks the gods every night, also "you are among the blessed ones that can think about a retirement/pension" I should remind you that's another thing 'that probably is never going to be any more'.
Everything is volatile, jobs/contracts nowadays you are talking 'from year to year', again that's already quite some luck, are we going to be transformed into a society of semi nomads moving from place to place and job to job following the stream of things ? Some people already are. The more time passes, the more entropy raises the more creating any sort of stability gets increasingly costly and hard to obtain.
Look around you ... "your job 5 years ?" ... you government won't last 5 years ... so it's anywhere else on the planet ..
On the other side it's still possible to make out some decent living out of things, it's not too bad, at least for now there are no riots on the streets

( let's forget France for the moment ) ..
Anyway if the local business are better then go with the local business also you keep saying about those 'skilled migrants' .. so where are those 'skilled british' taking the same jobs that migrants are taking ?