VNVObit wrote:unfortunately he sees the EU as a block to state investment (state aid) so he wants out too (and happy to respect the referendum but not his party on that score).
he is highly unlikely to cancel Brexit given his desire to invoke Article 50 immediately after the vote https://labourlist.org/2016/06/corbyn-a ... voked-now/
Surprised this wasn't mentioned yet (or did I skip it?):
Even though his party and most of his young supporters explicitely declared they want to remain and want a 2nd referendum to stop the madness, he just says, "fuck that, let's do Brexit anyway and of course I will magically pull a better deal with the EU out of my arse once I'm PM."
Even though his party and most of his young supporters explicitely declared they want to remain and want a 2nd referendum to stop the madness, he just says, "fuck that, let's do Brexit anyway and of course I will magically pull a better deal with the EU out of my arse once I'm PM."
Corbyn wrote:As to what stance Labour would take if a referendum were held, Corbyn said, “it would be a matter for the party to decide what the policy would be; but my proposal at this moment is that we go forward, trying to get a customs union with the EU, in which we would be able to be proper trading partners.”
He explicitly says it would be a matter for the party to decide. What's the problem with that? (Apart from all the headlines basically lying about what he said so masses of people who don't bother to read the articles get the wrong idea and go apeshit about it.)
Well, you don't expect him to actually say "fuck that, let's do Brexit", do you? He's a politician, and that involves the kind of diplomatic speech that you can see here. "My proposal for the moment" is code for "my policy for now", "my" being code for "the party I'm leader of".
No more than I’d expect him to say “Fuck it - let’s go all-out Remain!”. He was literally clarifying what was promised in the manifesto, in the context of what was decided at conference.
In any case, as he is not leader of the government, and likely never will be, what Corbyn says quite literally doesn't matter, except in as much as it clarifies that ~50% of the population have no mainstream party supporting them.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
skab wrote:Well, you don't expect him to actually say "fuck that, let's do Brexit", do you? He's a politician, and that involves the kind of diplomatic speech that you can see here. "My proposal for the moment" is code for "my policy for now", "my" being code for "the party I'm leader of".
He's making both his own position and that of the party clear, and his own position is being widely reported as if it is the official position of the party. He has also been clear in the past that he wants policy decisions to be made democratically rather than by diktat from the leader.
It's all a consequence of Jeremy being a closet Brexiteer whilst his power-base in Momentum is largely remain... hence the manic shovelling of bull-shite from the Politburo.
The second referendum avoid-dance is particularly obvious. Presumably inspiring this YakYak gem...
"if you REALLY want the Tories to reign endlessly let's just demand a 2nd ref/peoples vote right now because that'll guarantee Labour lose a GE"
Veni, vidi, effugi.
Loyalists: what does he do if May manages to wind it down to a binary her-deal/no-deal vote? Can he whip against May and risk being blamed for no-deal?
@A_Z - sorry, that take is as hilariously misinformed as it is patronising, and clearly indicative that your assessment of the situation amounts to nothing more than spouting what comes off the top of your head, instead of bothering to read literally anything on why Labour has adopted its current policies and strategies, other than the drivel written by his centrist opponents.
What I'd say is that it doesn't matter what Corbyn does or doesn't personally believe.
In that it is not physically possible for him to be our "white knight in shining armour" here, even if he was minded to do so.
Because the fastest route to him becoming PM would be a Parliamentary vote of no confidence - which would require the Tories / DUP to hate May more than they hate being in power, as the arithmetic does require them to vote against their own interests of staying in power - then triggering a General Election - on the assumption that Labour even win that, because they might not (or it could even end up being a complicated Labour + SNP + Lib Dems + Greens rainbow coalition, so that Corbyn's in the same fragile position as May is now, holding a minority government that's only a majority through cooperation with others) - and then... what?
A complete renegotiation from scratch with the EU before March? When the above aforementioned process will, itself, take months and probably take us into March already? With an EU that has zero obligation - nor reason - to renegotiate anything, so after all that they can simply say "no". Or, even if you can convince them to re-engage, then they're not going to completely 180 on their position. So, at best, from all this process and upheaval - on the long assumption that any of the above, each bit not terribly likely unto itself, all aligns perfectly - we get a little bit of wiggle on "the fine details" only.
One route has been shut down. After the failed coup, May now cannot be toppled from leadership of the Tory party for a year. Internal Tory party rules.
Perhaps, afterwards, something could be slowly clawed back - again, on the assumption that any of the leaders / parties give a shit to do so - but it seems quite impossible, and deeply unlikely with the way things are stacked, that there is any means of avoiding a "no deal" on Brexit Day (and the only realistic hope of that is accepting May's deal - which everyone, on all sides, agrees is a bit shit - so there's that to look forward to).
On Saturday, it'll be 3 months to Brexit Day. The clock is ticking.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
phattslagg wrote:@A_Z - sorry, that take is as hilariously misinformed as it is patronising, and clearly indicative that your assessment of the situation amounts to nothing more than spouting what comes off the top of your head, instead of bothering to read literally anything on why Labour has adopted its current policies and strategies, other than the drivel written by his centrist opponents.
I assume you choose to believe Mr Principles' assertion over that of professional lip-readers. If so then there's not much to discuss.
tufty wrote:In any case, as he is not leader of the government, and likely never will be, what Corbyn says quite literally doesn't matter, except in as much as it clarifies that ~50% of the population have no mainstream party supporting them.
They should have fucking voted for one in 2017 then
tufty wrote:In any case, as he is not leader of the government, and likely never will be, what Corbyn says quite literally doesn't matter, except in as much as it clarifies that ~50% of the population have no mainstream party supporting them.
They should have fucking voted for one in 2017 then :lol:
Which one? Labour and the Conservatives were going full steam ahead for Brexit. Nobody even vaguely "left" is ever going to vote for the LibDems again; they not only kept the Conservatives in power, but they empowered Cameron's referendum in the first place. That leaves what - the Greens?
I'll say it again - ~50% of the population are effectively disenfranchised*, about the only option available to them is to form a pro-European party of their own. But it's too late for that, and even if they did, and managed to win a general election, that would still leave the country horribly split along leave/remain lines.
* I won't even mention the >1m brits living in the EU who are not only directly affected, but also truly disenfranchised.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
tufty wrote:
Nobody even vaguely "left" is ever going to vote for the LibDems again; they not only kept the Conservatives in power, but they empowered Cameron's referendum in the first place.
The LibDims took a chance on potentially changing the whole game vis PR. Which the Great British public rejected and here we are... ~50% representation.
I note that way back when, it was Wedgie himself that persuaded Wilson of the utility of holding a referendum in papering over the internal party divisions on the then EEC. So it goes.
tufty wrote:… Nobody even vaguely "left" is ever going to vote for the LibDems again; they not only kept the Conservatives in power, but they empowered Cameron's referendum in the first place. …
According to many metrics I am very left. I still vote LibDem.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.