Got to keep optimistic that democracy will rule the day.merman wrote:And yet 20 Conservative MPs voted AGAINST the Government on an amendment designed to PREVENT No Deal.(o)(o) wrote:Yes some Tories are saying they will vote against the government - to ensure parliament cannot prevent No Deal Brexit.Cloudane wrote:Yeah I've since been talked into the possibility that no confidence could happen and that some of the Tories might actually vote that way too (to hope they oust May and install someone like Boris if they win a GE), which then might trigger said GE. Which opens a route to A50 extension and who knows....
A second defeat for Maybe this evening, a new amendment to the Withdrawal Bill seeking to make her publish new plans within three days of losing the Parliamentary vote on her dodgy deal.
EU referendum are you in or out
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
-- everyone since 2016gilesgoat wrote:.. I am lost .. what's going on ?
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
OK Corbyn now is calling for a GE .. what .. really means ? That the government is going to be re-formed ?
But then what ? Does this 'automatically' means that "May Deal is rejected they want a new/modified one ?" .. and at this point "will EU leave/give even MORE TIME to make yet-another-deal-attempt ?"
Is that actually an attempt/move to buy even more extra time to try to make an even more different deal ?
So also "re-formed" .. are they really hope/going to get a Labour majority this time or will be 'all for nothing' returning things to 'as they just are' ???
But then what ? Does this 'automatically' means that "May Deal is rejected they want a new/modified one ?" .. and at this point "will EU leave/give even MORE TIME to make yet-another-deal-attempt ?"
Is that actually an attempt/move to buy even more extra time to try to make an even more different deal ?
So also "re-formed" .. are they really hope/going to get a Labour majority this time or will be 'all for nothing' returning things to 'as they just are' ???
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
-
The ghost of raids past
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1682
- Joined: Sat Dec 03, 2005 7:38 pm 0
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
A General Election can only be called if 2/3 rd of the MPs vote for it. Hence Jeremy Corbyn cant trigger an election without the Majority of the Tories backing him. This is very unlikely to occur.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
One can also be called if no Government is formed within fourteen days of a no confidence vote.The ghost of raids past wrote:A General Election can only be called if 2/3 rd of the MPs vote for it. Hence Jeremy Corbyn cant trigger an election without the Majority of the Tories backing him. This is very unlikely to occur.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
Something to think about.. Whilst a lot of Remainers/Libbers out there saying Corbyn MUST mandate for a 2nd ref / peoples vote.. and he's getting it in the neck again today for not doing so...
Corbyn (and indeed the party base) is IMO a lot smarter than people give credit for. It's a moving target, but since Game Theory and exploitation of media influence is Tory modus operandi, one has to take a strategic long view position.
Can you picture how he would be annihilated by the press and Tory party if he did right now?Absolute_Zero wrote:[edit]perhaps you might explain how EU Ref-II would guarantee a Labour loss.
Corbyn (and indeed the party base) is IMO a lot smarter than people give credit for. It's a moving target, but since Game Theory and exploitation of media influence is Tory modus operandi, one has to take a strategic long view position.
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
Annnd today, it got personal. What I've been fearing for the last 2 years happened - I've been specifically requested to work on Brexit by my employer. 
Regardless of whatever difficulties this means with the requirements in the immediate future [and next 10 odd years??], the biggest challenge will be to stay professional, working on something I'm utterly against and have very little motivation to give a rat's arse about in terms of "quality".
I did say "could you not have found someone a bit more impartial?"
My honest opinion is they should round up the people that voted leave in the company and make them do everything that's required at minimum wage / unpaid overtime.
Twats.
Ah well, I guess I can't have it both ways. If I'm going to 'float with the stream' rather than 'swim toward a goal' [of a different job] then I have to do what I'm asked + do it the best I can.
Regardless of whatever difficulties this means with the requirements in the immediate future [and next 10 odd years??], the biggest challenge will be to stay professional, working on something I'm utterly against and have very little motivation to give a rat's arse about in terms of "quality".
I did say "could you not have found someone a bit more impartial?"
My honest opinion is they should round up the people that voted leave in the company and make them do everything that's required at minimum wage / unpaid overtime.
Twats.
Ah well, I guess I can't have it both ways. If I'm going to 'float with the stream' rather than 'swim toward a goal' [of a different job] then I have to do what I'm asked + do it the best I can.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
Can you explain what is this 'working on Brexit' ?rowan wrote:Annnd today, it got personal. What I've been fearing for the last 2 years happened - I've been specifically requested to work on Brexit by my employer.
Regardless of whatever difficulties this means with the requirements in the immediate future [and next 10 odd years??], the biggest challenge will be to stay professional, working on something I'm utterly against and have very little motivation to give a rat's arse about in terms of "quality".
I did say "could you not have found someone a bit more impartial?"
My honest opinion is they should round up the people that voted leave in the company and make them do everything that's required at minimum wage / unpaid overtime.
Twats.
Ah well, I guess I can't have it both ways. If I'm going to 'float with the stream' rather than 'swim toward a goal' [of a different job] then I have to do what I'm asked + do it the best I can.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
For me, the immediate thing I'm aware of is making some changes to various documents like order confirmations, invoices, delivery notes etc.gilesgoat wrote:Can you explain what is this 'working on Brexit' ?
No idea what the details are yet, the people who work on requirements are still forming them. They're currently in workshops [probably getting some kind of external guidance] and apparently looking almost as confused as the prime minister. Hardly any of them are from the UK, mostly it's guys from mainland Europe working on it.
Over time, I imagine there will be various further legal requirements [documents and crap] to produce, additional pricing logic for tariffs, taxes or whatever.
Basically all the thoroughly mundane kind of shite software that needs to be in place to run a large business.
For what it's worth, I never studied, applied for or tried to get into this line of work. It somehow found me without even changing desks. Once upon a time my job was a lot more "exciting" with graphic design, lasers and robots and stuff.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
In and ideal world, that does not exits, you'd be simply looking for another job and you'd have another one already.rowan wrote:For me, the immediate thing I'm aware of is making some changes to various documents like order confirmations, invoices, delivery notes etc.gilesgoat wrote:Can you explain what is this 'working on Brexit' ?
No idea what the details are yet, the people who work on requirements are still forming them. They're currently in workshops [probably getting some kind of external guidance] and apparently looking almost as confused as the prime minister. Hardly any of them are from the UK, mostly it's guys from mainland Europe working on it.
Over time, I imagine there will be various further legal requirements [documents and crap] to produce, additional pricing logic for tariffs, taxes or whatever.
Basically all the thoroughly mundane kind of shite software that needs to be in place to run a large business.
For what it's worth, I never studied, applied for or tried to get into this line of work. It somehow found me without even changing desks. Once upon a time my job was a lot more "exciting" with graphic design, lasers and robots and stuff.
.. but the world is far from ideal ..
Said that I'd like to point out that the moment I started to feel truly homicidal feelings for my ex-boss THEN I REALLY CHANGED JOB, I was faced with "do something weird and go to prison for the rest of your life OR change work"
.. it did work, made me find another job
Sometime all you need is "motivation"
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
It seems they are getting a bit panicky on the European side of the "Brexit Series". They, being the media and the politicians, not exactly the people on the streets.
They're saying the UK never offered another counter proposal to the one agreed so there is nothing more to negociate , they're saying 'Hard Brexit' will be hard on Europe but also very hard on the UK, and apparently there is some maybe speculation that they could extend the date to have more negotiations. I heard that on telly from a known conservative political commentator generally not badly informed.
Ow, the Port Wine Industry is definitively against Brexit (some of the exporters are British, some are national) because they are worried the costs of selling to the UK will not be as cheap as they are under the EU.
They're saying the UK never offered another counter proposal to the one agreed so there is nothing more to negociate , they're saying 'Hard Brexit' will be hard on Europe but also very hard on the UK, and apparently there is some maybe speculation that they could extend the date to have more negotiations. I heard that on telly from a known conservative political commentator generally not badly informed.
Ow, the Port Wine Industry is definitively against Brexit (some of the exporters are British, some are national) because they are worried the costs of selling to the UK will not be as cheap as they are under the EU.
- matt303
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4219
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 3:37 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: matt303uk
- Location: Derbyshire
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
No deal won't happen unless Labour block their MPs from voting for any other action (I sometimes think Corbyn would like a hard Brexit so he can build his workers utopia from the ashes), the systems simply aren't in place physically and legally for it to happen, let alone the political fallout of an 80's style economic realignment mostly hitting the areas that still feel the pain of the 80's.
My guess is if we don't see a Norway Plus deal put together quickly when the deadline gets near we'll see an extension or possibly withdraw of A50.
My guess is if we don't see a Norway Plus deal put together quickly when the deadline gets near we'll see an extension or possibly withdraw of A50.
Re: EU referendum are you in or out
Without a repeal or extension, Article 50 - ratified in both UK and EU law - automatically cancels all EU treaties on 29th March.
An extension requires the unanimous agreement of all 28 nations - yes, 28, because that includes the UK Parliament as well. A single veto scuppers it all.
And - aye, here's the rub - there are European elections in May. The EU will not extend to that point or beyond, as it leads to the absurdity of the UK voting in European elections that it will then have nothing whatsoever to do with thereafter, upon leaving. UK MEPs could win seats that they then all simultaneously leave upon Brexit. The UK public will be asked to partake in a pointless election that ultimately offers them no democratic representation at all, so why even bother?
And what for anyway? The EU negotiated in good faith and has made its offer. This is not going to fundamentally change.
Two years was wasted getting to this point. We only found out, for the first time, what May's deal even was back in November. Which is absurd.
But not half as absurd as the notion that, within three days, they're all going to magically agree on the same thing and convert the LARGEST GOVERNMENT DEFEAT ON RECORD to a happy-happy-joy-joy agreement that commands a majority of Parliament to pass.
The "no confidence" vote will be interesting, because though Tories + DUP command a majority - so if they all stay firm to hold onto power, it'll arithmetically fail - nobody saw a government defeat on this scale coming. So many Tory MPs betrayed their own Prime Minster - are we entirely sure that they wouldn't even sacrifice power for their "rainbows and unicorns" ideals of Brexit? It's barely a majority with the DUP needed to make the numbers, so even a rather minor betrayal could tip it over.
But, by the numbers, the "no confidence" seems improbable, as you're asking Tory MPs to vote against staying in power. Then what exactly, if it doesn't succeed?
Because, without a "no confidence", we don't get a General Election, not unless May volunteers.
And here's the thing. A General Election guarantees nothing.
We could end up with the Tories winning again - thanks, in large part, to the never-ending anti-Corbyn hysteria of the press (because, hey, that sort of "scare story" bullshit swayed the Brexit referendum, right?) - and we're back to square one.
We could very much end up with, for example, Labour only being able to command a majority, if it teams up with the SNP, Plaid Cymru, the Lib Dems, etc., etc. in a massive rainbow coalition.
I mean, every election since the end of New Labour - nearly a decade - has been a coalition and / or "confidence and supply", so why are we thinking that another GE would prove any different in the currently highly divisive environment?
And, even if Labour win, then Corbyn will seek to renegotiate with the EU. What if the EU simply say "no, fuck off, we've done that already. We gave you a deal and that's all we're ever offering"? On the EU side of things, that's exactly what they're broadly thinking.
This only compounds what I've been saying. There's no clear logical way out of this. Every path is seemingly a dead end.
And if nothing is sorted by 29th March, then we auto-leave regardless. All EU treaties cease - in both UK and EU law - on that date.
Truth is, we haven't even got our WTO schedules in order. That's something else that also needs to be negotiated to even be on "WTO rules".
And absolutely none of these outcomes is desirable anyway. The "deal" is shite - which is why so many MPs rejected it. "No deal" is shite - which is why so many MPs also reject that.
I'd love to see a "cancel Brexit" - a unilateral withdrawal from Article 50 - but that can't realistically happen without a Second Referendum to grant it, as that would be MPs directly voting against the result of the referendum. Which is electoral suicide.
I want a "cancel Brexit", but if they did it without public approval, even I'd have to question that on democratic grounds. Yes, the answer I want but, no, the totally wrong method of obtaining it. I can't philosophically sanction such autocracy, even if the autocrat is on "my side", as it were.
And a Second Referendum - just like the General Election - is a dice roll. What if they call a Second Referendum and Brexit wins yet again?
(And a Second Referendum that's three-way - accept EU deal, no deal or cancel Brexit - gives you the arithmetical illegitimacy that you can win on a third plus one. Which is not a majority. So the biggest constitutional decision ever is not even mathematically legitimately "the Will of the People"?)
I mean, seriously, in recent times, does anyone trust a public vote on anything anymore?
The only positive is that there is a majority consensus that we shouldn't just crash out on 29th March. But if no-one can supply any actual realistic consensus path to avoiding it, then how the hell is it ever going to happen?
Fuck knows. We live in interesting times.
An extension requires the unanimous agreement of all 28 nations - yes, 28, because that includes the UK Parliament as well. A single veto scuppers it all.
And - aye, here's the rub - there are European elections in May. The EU will not extend to that point or beyond, as it leads to the absurdity of the UK voting in European elections that it will then have nothing whatsoever to do with thereafter, upon leaving. UK MEPs could win seats that they then all simultaneously leave upon Brexit. The UK public will be asked to partake in a pointless election that ultimately offers them no democratic representation at all, so why even bother?
And what for anyway? The EU negotiated in good faith and has made its offer. This is not going to fundamentally change.
Two years was wasted getting to this point. We only found out, for the first time, what May's deal even was back in November. Which is absurd.
But not half as absurd as the notion that, within three days, they're all going to magically agree on the same thing and convert the LARGEST GOVERNMENT DEFEAT ON RECORD to a happy-happy-joy-joy agreement that commands a majority of Parliament to pass.
The "no confidence" vote will be interesting, because though Tories + DUP command a majority - so if they all stay firm to hold onto power, it'll arithmetically fail - nobody saw a government defeat on this scale coming. So many Tory MPs betrayed their own Prime Minster - are we entirely sure that they wouldn't even sacrifice power for their "rainbows and unicorns" ideals of Brexit? It's barely a majority with the DUP needed to make the numbers, so even a rather minor betrayal could tip it over.
But, by the numbers, the "no confidence" seems improbable, as you're asking Tory MPs to vote against staying in power. Then what exactly, if it doesn't succeed?
Because, without a "no confidence", we don't get a General Election, not unless May volunteers.
And here's the thing. A General Election guarantees nothing.
We could end up with the Tories winning again - thanks, in large part, to the never-ending anti-Corbyn hysteria of the press (because, hey, that sort of "scare story" bullshit swayed the Brexit referendum, right?) - and we're back to square one.
We could very much end up with, for example, Labour only being able to command a majority, if it teams up with the SNP, Plaid Cymru, the Lib Dems, etc., etc. in a massive rainbow coalition.
I mean, every election since the end of New Labour - nearly a decade - has been a coalition and / or "confidence and supply", so why are we thinking that another GE would prove any different in the currently highly divisive environment?
And, even if Labour win, then Corbyn will seek to renegotiate with the EU. What if the EU simply say "no, fuck off, we've done that already. We gave you a deal and that's all we're ever offering"? On the EU side of things, that's exactly what they're broadly thinking.
This only compounds what I've been saying. There's no clear logical way out of this. Every path is seemingly a dead end.
And if nothing is sorted by 29th March, then we auto-leave regardless. All EU treaties cease - in both UK and EU law - on that date.
Truth is, we haven't even got our WTO schedules in order. That's something else that also needs to be negotiated to even be on "WTO rules".
And absolutely none of these outcomes is desirable anyway. The "deal" is shite - which is why so many MPs rejected it. "No deal" is shite - which is why so many MPs also reject that.
I'd love to see a "cancel Brexit" - a unilateral withdrawal from Article 50 - but that can't realistically happen without a Second Referendum to grant it, as that would be MPs directly voting against the result of the referendum. Which is electoral suicide.
I want a "cancel Brexit", but if they did it without public approval, even I'd have to question that on democratic grounds. Yes, the answer I want but, no, the totally wrong method of obtaining it. I can't philosophically sanction such autocracy, even if the autocrat is on "my side", as it were.
And a Second Referendum - just like the General Election - is a dice roll. What if they call a Second Referendum and Brexit wins yet again?
(And a Second Referendum that's three-way - accept EU deal, no deal or cancel Brexit - gives you the arithmetical illegitimacy that you can win on a third plus one. Which is not a majority. So the biggest constitutional decision ever is not even mathematically legitimately "the Will of the People"?)
I mean, seriously, in recent times, does anyone trust a public vote on anything anymore?
The only positive is that there is a majority consensus that we shouldn't just crash out on 29th March. But if no-one can supply any actual realistic consensus path to avoiding it, then how the hell is it ever going to happen?
Fuck knows. We live in interesting times.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes

