Politics Thread!

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
Whiteball
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1811
Joined: Sat Nov 24, 2007 12:39 pm 0
Location: At the computer

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Whiteball »

tufty wrote:
Whiteball wrote:
tufty wrote:
Whiteball wrote:Maybe, only because he isn't getting what he wants?
The EU aren't the ones asking for favours.
That's exactly the sort of comments I'm talking about though. Anyone can say things like that, is there any actual examples?
It's quite easy to understand. The UK has placed itself in a position where, as of the end of the year, it will have no trading deals in place with the EU (or, in fact, pretty much anyone else, as all its current trade deals are through the EU). Even ignoring extra-EU trade, this is a catastrophic position to be in. Around 45-50% of the UK's trade goes to and from Europe. With no trade deal in place, all of that trade will be more expensive, by around 20% or more.

This means that any company that sells to Europe will be at a 20% or more price disadvantage with respect to a company within Europe selling the same product, and at a significant price disadvantage with respect to an extra-european company selling the same product to Europe through an EU trade deal. This means that they will have to slash prices, and thus profits, to make the sale. Any company purchasing from the the EU will see their purchase prices go up by 20% or more. This means more expensive products for the consumer and / or less profit for the company.

The same applies from the other side, of course, but from the European point of view, it's not so significant. The UK only accounts for around 6% of all EU trade. The EU will be hurt by a no-deal in December, but not to the point the UK will. The EU can quite happily survive as a trading bloc without the UK. It's not clear that the converse is true.

What the UK needs, and what the politicians have loudly promised to the people as part of the "easiest trade deal ever", is trade as usual. Zero tariffs, carry on as you were. But whilst the EU could grant that, it would have to come at a significant cost. If nothing else because the UK can't have a better deal than those who are within the EU; it would be the end of the EU as a trading bloc. So the UK needs to make some really big compromises, and almost certainly get its wallet out. No place at the table to make decisions, significant funding to the EU with no cashflow back, no veto on EU regulations, and freedom of movement are the absolute minimum we can expect to get that holy grail.

Otherwise, new trade deals need to be made, on every one of the commodities the UK trades with the EU. That's *thousands* of individual trade deals to be made, thousands of tariffs to be decided.

If the UK isn't willing to back down on its red lines, and as there simply isn't time to negotiate all those trade deals, the UK is going to have to suck up whatever tariffs the EU decides to levy on it. That's what "trading under WTO rules" means.

So yeah. Pick a commodity. The UK is asking for a favour on it.
I'm not saying its difficult to understand, I'm just curious where everyone gets all their figures from and the presumptions that are made based off them.
Do we actually have any real facts or an official document we can read detailing any of this stuff.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Dio »

I doubt it, because anything that doesn't look like sweetness and roses is being kept locked away. And since everything doesn't look like sweetness and roses but instead a great big steaming turd on a plate, that means it's all being kept locked away.
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by gilesgoat »

Whiteball wrote:
merman wrote:Because the young and strong British guys turn down that sort of job thinking it's beneath them. But it's hard, demanding work and we should be thanking the migrants that do it not turning immigration policy against them...
The real reason everything in this country has gone down hill for years is simple.

When people go to work they want to be paid lots of money.
When people want to buy things, they want them as cheap as possible.

People don't want to pick crops because it doesn't pay well enough.
Picking crops doesn' pay well enough because we all want really cheap food in the shops.

All these things are mutually exclusive.

We all want to buy stuff as cheap as possible.
We don't manufacture and build stuff here because we want to be paid to much to do so, so we get it cheaper from China.

And before people go on about not minding paying for quality or to raise standards etc it's too late.
Companies in the middle aren't satisfied with just making a profit anymore, they want maximum profit.
Pay people as little as they can get away with and sell as high as they can get away with.
This has led to buy cheap from China/Use cheap labour - Sell at bigger profits but keep prices just low enough to get people to purchase.
This is NOT "UK only" this is almost "the whole world" and to an extent "this is what capitalism is".

The fact is now even China can't go on like that "forever" I think it's been studied/concluded that "cheaper prices for everything" DOES NOT mean that "that's going to make people actually richer/more capable to spend" , in fact ultimately I it results in situations where people will spend less and will have less money.

I think when you go too cheap you de-value things/work, "it's wrong to be too high but it's equally wrong to be (forced to be) too cheap", that devaluates stuff and epxloits resources as well becuase "indirectly" you are de-valuating those as well.

I think there's a problem, "if everyone wants to get the top most and be super-rich" that's not possible, but at the same time if "super rich people" acts like cunts "becuase they can" they create "unmitigable tensions" that can not be fixed.

If "most people "could reach a "moderate level of satisfaction" where "you don't really need more than that" ( I did not say you cannot try to attain it but it's "bonus" not a "must" ) and where people in need get from who has lot more the help they need that would be "perfection" but that's also utopia.

But we are in a system where "some are super rich and want to be even more" and don't want more others be like them but also "they make their richness over a mass that is really poor" .. and they don't give much of a shit to it .. that's problems.

You should first go to work because that's really "a job you really like to do" and the job should make you feel "you are good and important for doing it" .. the income should not be "LOTS of money" but "what is right for that job" and from collecting crops, to tightening screws in a car factory or fixing a boiler those should be all make you feel "equally satisfied in doing that" but NOT for the money alone but for you doing and how you do it.

But again .. that's utopia .. maybe it never been like that.

You can't make a system where "the only perceived value is how much money you can make from things", there's no moral in it, just "quantity" and an "abstract quantity" that it's quite possible to get much more by cheating/robbing/do all sort of things that are morally ( and not just ) wrong.

Makes me think "it's like that game" I recently saw that "Games" documentary there was Lord British talking about his first versions of Ultima, he realized I think was around Ultima II /III (correct me ) that "there was a problem with his games", people were acting like ultimate assholes by robbing/killing/stealing/acting nasty because turns out "that was the fastest way to get the most money/stats/etc. " from the game.

Then he introduced "the moral system" in the game, "you do shit things, people won't like/help/accept/deal with you any more", people started to play the game better.

But in this real world "far too many people" are "outside any moral system" as they don't care because they don't get any negative stuff even if they act negative "they have too much money/power for that" .. so .. "money buys you out any time if you have enough of it".

And that's the problem.

And a system that insist to teach that "money is ALL".
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by KlaxonCow »

The thing is that system will eat itself.

Because you know what's even cheaper than Chinese and Indian labour?

Robots. Machines. AI.

They require no wages. They have no sick days. They take no holidays. They don't need to sleep, or take a shit or anything.

(Unfortunately, they also pay no income tax and contribute nothing to National Insurance either.)

And the thing is, we can see technologies moving in a certain way right now - see my "Future of Energy" thread for more details - where we could see a factory having, say, solar panels on the roof and wind turbines, feeding into storage batteries. The one "running cost" you have for the machines and the robots is your electricity bill - but, with renewables and storage, this can be reduced or even eliminated.

Elon's already developing the autonomous delivery trucks.

The "vision" on the horizon is mining robots digging up the raw materials autonomously. Placing it aboard autonomous delivery trucks, bringing it to the factory. Where robots autonomously manufacture the goods, to be loaded up onto autonomous delivery trucks again to a distribution centre of autonomous delivery vans that take products to people's front doors...

...with not a single human being requiring any involvement whatsoever.

And then you couple this up with these factories and vehicle depots having renewables - such as solar panels - and storage batteries, so that the electric autonomous delivery trucks and vans charge up on free energy, when they park up at the factory / depot for loading and unloading. The machines and robots can also be renewably powered.

So the one "running cost" that the machines and robots demand - they need electricity - is also something we're seeing undergoing revolutionary change right now.

Yes, this hasn't happened yet. But pretty much every component of this "vision of the future" does already exist. It just needs to be competently stitched together and for autonomous trucks and vans to be granted licence to actually drive our roads (which, to be honest, has been delayed mostly due to insurance issues of who's to blame and pays up, in the event of a traffic accident).

I mean, if you look at the moves Amazon have been making over their existence, then it's pretty obvious to me that Jeff Bezos has had this vision in mind from the off. He can't yet 100% dispose of the human beings, but he's trying damned hard.



They're forever coming up with new systems like this all the time. Gradually trying to eliminate the need for "pickers" altogether, if Bezos can help it.

As he's worked out what I've worked out - the West can beat China and India, if it undergoes an autonomous revolution.

Imagine when Amazon finally perfects the warehouse that has no human beings whatsoever - not a single one - and the items are loaded automatically onto autonomous delivery vans to take it to people's doors. Or, indeed, those flying drones we all know about, as he even thinks of ways of making the autonomous delivery faster and, actually, safer. On roads, AI trucks have to worry about unpredictable human beings sharing their space but, in the air, you can fly straight there and there's basically absolutely nothing up there to be worried about, really.

Mind you, Amazon merely does deliveries. It doesn't generally do manufacturing of the items in the first place. But you can see how this same concept can be expanded in that direction. Car manufacture is already mostly robots these days.

"Brown people stealing your job" was always a red herring.

It's Robbie the Robot who's been swiping all the work from under us.

Indeed, the rise of AI has been worrying middle-class people that, actually, maybe their management jobs are now becoming automatable. The worry is now being expressed, because the middle-classes realise that they're vulnerable to this coming trend. Of course, working class labourers, toiling in the factories, have long since seen robots stealing their jobs for a very long time. But intellectual pursuits - not working with your hands - seemed perfectly safe and middle-class people, who media folks that set the narrative tend to be, ignored this. Yeah, they're not ignoring it now, as AI invades their once "safe" jobs, as what machines couldn't do that human could, was think.

As I say, the job losses have been falling in the cracks between things. They don't get noticed or reported, because it's not Robbie the Robot literally sitting at your desk on a Monday morning, having literally taken your job over the weekend. But it's more that increasing automation means that one person now does what used to take ten people to do. That, once the machines are in, those jobs which used to exist don't exist anymore and aren't advertised.

This ain't new, of course. The famous first instance of this was the Luddites and the Jacquard Loom:



They protested. Broke the machines. But machines are easily fixable and replaceable. The machines won that battle and have been winning ever since.

And the Jacquard Loom - arguably one of the first programmable "computers" - has come a very long way since. Well, you know that, you're using one of its descendants right now to read this.

This "capitalism" will eat itself. In doggedly pursuing maximum profit, it's been spending well over a century now, in gradually eliminating human beings from the equation.

Even where humans still cling on by their fingernails, where are they spending their working life? In front of a computer monitor. The machines are already doing all the actual work - the humans are just there to assist them with the bit that they haven't mastered yet, which is comprehension. Thinking and understanding.

But AI is slowly intruding on that space too. Plus, if you're creative, there's ways to get around needing skill and intelligence.

McDonald's has long been perfecting the notion of "de-skilling" work. Instead of having a skilled chef, you subdivide the work down into brain-dead simple tasks - press this button to fry the chips, flip these burgers, press this button to pour the drinks, etc. - that, essentially, anyone can do.

In the fast food restaurant, the one "protected job" - as it's just too complicated to easily subdivide - was the guy at the front serving the customers. Taking orders, giving change, etc. - a bit too tricky for Robbie the Robot. But that'll eventually go. As I say, there's ways and means. For example, once everyone pays for everything with contactless cards, there's no "giving change" anymore.

And, even in this realm, we've seen their innovations spread everywhere. The new type of till where you don't have to do any of the calculations yourself, but simply hit the product buttons and the till will work it out for you. Everywhere's got those now.

And those in customer service positions should worry, because an obvious extension to this concept is to turn the tills around. Customers press the buttons to make their orders themselves, and then you tap your contactless card to pay.

Well, we've already seen - and likely used - the self-service tills at supermarkets. They simplified the checkout job to just scanning barcodes... and then it's a simple matter to just have the customer themselves point the barcodes at the machine. Those machines actually deal with notes and change too, so that problem is not impossible to solve.

You might erroneously lament that the "brown people" are stealing your jobs. But the brown people in Indian call centres are watching videos like this and realise that, eventually, their days will be numbered too:



(And, of course, there's the notion that when most phone calls are being made by robots, they could perhaps send a tone - to identify themselves as a robot to the other side, which then sends a tone back to confirm that, yes, it is also a robot - and then they can dispense with speaking English to one another and just transfer digital data directly. And then, after that, the robots could just have their own dedicated communication channels and get it all done without us being involved at all.)

And note that not a single Indian has to migrate to the UK to steal those jobs either. Nor does a single Chinese person need to lay one foot off Chinese soil, for their mass dumping of cheap steel on the open market to threaten to close steel plants all over the globe. And so on and so forth.

It's a globalised world. Folks can steal your job, no problem, without coming anywhere near your country.

This is really what's going on. Human beings are being increasingly shut out.

It's not the brown people or the yellow people, it's the grey boxes.

But, sure, nobody suspects the inanimate object in the corner - that unmoving box - so this just keeps happening and we all scratch our heads, wondering where all the jobs went? They're in that box over there, that's where all the jobs went.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by gilesgoat »

In the fast food restaurant, the one "protected job" - as it's just too complicated to easily subdivide - was the guy at the front serving the customers. Taking orders, giving change, etc. - a bit too tricky for Robbie the Robot. But that'll eventually go. As I say, there's ways and means. For example, once everyone pays for everything with contactless cards, there's no "giving change" anymore.
MAN you are SO WRONG in that ...







They even have one for sheep !



Now my experience ( very little ) with fast food is the VERY occasional KFC ( that is just in front of the sheep food shop ) depite I have NOTHING againist "that guy" I WISH he'd be replaced by a machine !!!!

That place is "fast food with an EXTREMELY SLOW CASHIER !!!" .. you spend more time to place your order/pay than having the stuff done, sometime he's like a "broken record" reading a script trying to sell you "what you DO NOT want" ( NO I Don't want that combo,no I don't want extra water NO I don't want MEGA cola !!! ) ..

Then sometime "it's just people talking the hell what" .. so you wait and wait and wait and time passes .. ( and they have only ONE cashier ! ).

Very similar effect last times we went to a couple of cinemas, they INSIST in selling you 10 other things you don't want, thankfully cinemas now have "automated ticket machines", go there, pick up the movie, pick up a time, select the available seats, pay contactless, job done.

Now don't take me wrong "I have very strong believe in human work/skills/irreplaceability" when people have true skills, for example "you can NOT replace this type of food/work" ( you should NEVER ) :







But when it comes down to "not so skilled things" especially "MEGA CRAP" like Mc Donald .. there machines can perfectly do it !
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Ollie
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4446
Joined: Mon May 03, 2004 7:04 pm 0
Location: London
Contact:

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Ollie »

The snag to capitalism in replacing human workers with robots and AIs, is that robots and AIs don't buy the products, and neither do humans if don't have the money due to having lost their jobs to robots and AIs. I suspect it's only when enough of the capitalists realise this that we'll be in with a real chance of UBI.
User avatar
merman
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10943
Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: merman1974
Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
Location: Skegness, England
Contact:

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by merman »

The Union of British Fascists took part in demonstrations against wearing a mask on Saturday.

This country is done for.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by KlaxonCow »

Ollie wrote:The snag to capitalism in replacing human workers with robots and AIs, is that robots and AIs don't buy the products, and neither do humans if don't have the money due to having lost their jobs to robots and AIs. I suspect it's only when enough of the capitalists realise this that we'll be in with a real chance of UBI.
Ah, but did you notice that I said "capitalism will eat itself"?

And that's exactly what I meant. In pursuit of maximum profits, they will actually end up killing off the concept of money itself.

(This could ultimately lead to a Star Trek "moneyless" future. But fuck knows how you seamlessly get from this system to the other, when they are, indeed, intrinsically incompatible. Both systems are self-consistent unto themselves. We live in the "moneyed" system and know how that works, and you can imagine the distant "moneyless" system and how that might work. But, in the transition, I don't see how a half "moneyed" and half "moneyless" system would function, when the two are inherently incompatible. How do you pay for all that UBI, or keep welfare going, when robots don't pay taxes or make National Insurance contributions? There's a tipping point where there's more UBI claimants than there are remaining taxpayers. How would it work where, say, electricity is now free and unmetered - excellent - but food isn't? How the hell can such a half-and-half system function? I have zero answers, as it seems paradoxical - but the transition will not be instant, nor will it be equally applied, and some things can go "moneyless" before other things. So this doesn't make sense, but it's also what we're inevitably flying head first towards, right now, with no-one really talking about it at all. Some people mention UBI, which is a start. But I don't see anyone else pick up that UBI will ultimately stop making sense, when there's not enough remaining taxpayers to fund all the UBI and welfare in the first place.)

There's all sorts of massive social, economic and philosophical revelations in this. Tremendous amounts of discussion about what we, humanity, actually want and should do.

But, unfortunately, all political discussion amounts to "brown people steal jobs" and that's the end of the matter.

So I fear this coming inevitable transition - perhaps the greatest revolution in all of human history so far - will just be blindly stumbled into - nay, tripped over - and things will not go well.
Last edited by KlaxonCow on Mon Aug 31, 2020 7:48 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
tufty
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12524
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 4:52 pm 0
Location: French Alps

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by tufty »

merman wrote:The Union of British Fascists took part in demonstrations against wearing a mask on Saturday.

This country is done for.
Fascists don't want to survive coronavirus, you say?

"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by gilesgoat »

I think we are completely forgetting "why we work on things" ( or why we should ) :

- because we like doing it
- because we like to create things
- because it give us a sense of purpose
- because in doing so we can grow mentally and spiritually ( and sometime even physically )

Not that "money" is not into that, the "I do a super crap thing all day only because I need money to live" should not be there or the "I superwork because I want more and more money" shoule not be there too.

If you replace "everyting" with technology .. you get the point humans are really "not so meaningful" any more, but at this point let's say "by absurdity" you could kill *ALL* the humanity leaving some computer going on computing things .. .. .. and then what ? .. is it going to become "Vyger" going around the cosmos accumulating everything "looking for something even it does not know ?".

Or it's going to become like "Prey" .. another computer the size of a big planet going around the universe capturing/absorbing all life forms to integrate/expand itself so it can continue to accumulate data ?

I mean we are thinking AIs/stuff like "if they should get some weird level of evolution" .. but "quite some machines could probably work the same totally without us even now" ..

Well yeah .. I don't even know if it's possible to ever get to the point of the machine minings/doing all the jobs it take to replicate themselves, I have the feeling "there may be not enough resources in the planet to build that".

But anyway there's a saying that goes that "a super technological advancement WITHOUT a similar moral advancement leads to disaster" .. you can't have "mega tech" .. and people going around yelling that wearing a mask because of a sperading virus infection is a "violation of their liberty rights" ( when it's there to protect YOU TOO ).

Or we can't have a "mega tech that does all the shit for us" and we may get the point we won't be even able to take a shit without the tech or perform "basic human functions" without tech assistant.

If I give you a car that can run 1000 miles per hour and I know you are a poor driver and the roads are shit, I fundamentally gave you a way to kill yourself, not a fast car to run faster.

If I give you AIs that "take decisions for you" because "you are so badly formed" ( morally, mentally, because you never had good teachers ) you can't make correct decisions or because you are totally corrupt and/or morally evil .. I haven't really solved a problem, I just put a patch that may even make the problem bigger.

Or AIs "because you are too lazy to think by your own" or because someone really wants to get rid of your work.

That's not "evolution" that's "disaster in the making".

It's a moral dilemma really, not ( just ) "a technological" one .. "when in the end the real god is only money" .. you'll get what you get .. all sort of shit because "all it's legit" .. who cares about people ? Who cares about machines really ? Then will get the point they'll try to make the machines too cheaper and work more and they'll start cutting corners and more shit will happen.

If I can replace people with a machine that works faster/cheaper, surely I can replace one machine with an even chepaer/faster machine ?

But yeah .. if people can't work , can't find a purpose, can't be happy, can't have money ... "who's going to buy all the stuff your machines do ?".

Or .. "everyone is so depressed/useless" all they do is live in VR and consume your drugs ? But even there .. "what kind of purpose for those people ?" .. or are they really just pedalling on a bike to run the generators for the machines because "that's the only thing you found they can do ?".

What do you do with people when all is replaced by machines ? And then ? .. what richness can you generate ?

"Some machines are pumping gazillions of gallons of petrol" .. for the only 20 humans left of "the elite" .. that now have gallons of petrol .. totally useless because NO ONE can make ANY use of them ?

Are you even "rich" in that case ? Or you just have "piles of junks" that potentially only you can use or some machine that would keep just doing things to keep you and it "alive and working" ?

Or are you going to sell it all to aliens because there are almost no humans left or that can buy your things and then you'll start thinking "How can I conquer the alien resources" or "how can I replace even them with other machines ?".

It never ends ... if the logic is that ..

So you say "what is the better logic" ?

I would dare to say :

- remember the impermanence of material things
- grow materially and spiritually
- don't get caught by illusions/false truths/false prophets
- enjoy life, don't struggle for material suff, enjoy your work as work not as money
- do things that you really like to do
- don't think too much of "others" think at yourself first ( if you are not toally ok with yourself, you can't help others well )
- fuck capitalism
- legal drugs are bad for you
- all good things are good in moderation
- everything you earn/work for it, very little comes for free
- nothing is easy, all that's worth is difficult
- buy Llamasoft games :P :lol: :lol: :lol:

Well "make your own minds" but remember "you won't get the money with you in afterlife and even if your coffin is full with it you won't enjoy it" :roll:
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by gilesgoat »

merman wrote:The Union of British Fascists took part in demonstrations against wearing a mask on Saturday.

This country is done for.
Gets worse .. there was ALEX JONES ON THE RADIO talking about this and praising the MAGNIFICENT TALK that DAVID ICKE was doing in Trafalgar square .. there was quite some background noise we were almost conviced "they added it, can't be real" .. until we saw the BBC new and people in Trafalgar .. 8O

Then he ( Alex ) went "all mental" screaming that "America is the best country in the world", "Americans are the best people in the world because they understand freedom" ( referring to the protests NOT to wear a mask because that's againist your freedom not to mention the 'forced inoculations' by THE GLOBALISTS ) exploding finally saying that "America IS SUPERIOR IN THE WORLD, FULL STOP" that is an EXAMPLE of things, etc . etc.

He said also that EU is shit/evil and praised "The special BROTHERHOOD WITH UK" ..

.. do I need to add more or it's sufficent to say "We are ultra mega fucked ?" :(

[edit] - ah yes, HIS words NOT mines .. he defined himself as "An American Supremacist" because "it's right that America is SUPERIOR in the world" ( and passing by some mentions about 'defeating the evil China' and stuff like that ) ..

It's all like that his radio :roll:
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Foozwah
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3156
Joined: Fri May 31, 2002 2:17 am 0
Location: Melbourne, Australia

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Foozwah »

gilesgoat wrote:It's all like that his radio :roll:
I don't know how you can listen to it, Giles, even for laughs or for "What are the lunatics saying today?" purposes. Just reading his idiocy quoted makes my brain throb in all the wrong ways. You're a stronger man than I...
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by KlaxonCow »

Of course, humans can still do work, if they want to. It's the elimination of needing to work, as the robots take care of keeping the world turning.

You don't have to. But you can, if you want. Like, if you want to write a song or paint a portrait or write a novel or whatever, go right ahead.

Humans are then the cultural, creative, scientific, philosophical "value add" on top of that. They're likely be a premium on that "hand-made" feel, even.


I mean, if you look to history, then you can ask yourself, why were there so many philosophers and mathematicians and great minds in Ancient Greece?

The basic reason was that the Ancient Greeks nailed agriculture. They got farming down pat, and had an excess of food for all their citizens. So, unlike many other early civilisations, where everyone would be farming and hunting and fishing constantly, just to survive, they now had, in that excess of food, an excess of people. Extra people, not needed for the basic survival of the tribe, now freed to pursue things beyond those base concerns.

What would all these people do? Well, whatever the hell they liked, basically, within reason and practicality. They had the basics covered, so folks could start branching out into other things. Like sitting around wondering how the universe might work. Or look into how mathematics might work.

But only because they'd achieved that "excess" in which to thrive. If they hadn't then - fuck you Pythagoras, Plato, Archimedes, Aristotle et al - we can't spare you, so get ploughing or sowing the fields. Join the harvest. Go hunting or manning the fishing boats. We need all hands on deck here, or we're all dead from starvation.

(It should be noted here that we shouldn't forget that this rosy picture for the higher social classes was, of course, broken on the backs of slaves. Ancient Greece had slavery and that's part of how they nailed this so well. So I don't morally approve of their system - and Plato can fuck off with his "Noble Lies" of social class - but, well, that is how it proved so successful in generating that "excess". An excess in which there were sufficient "redundant people", as it were, that they could be happily spared to notice the displacement of water in their bath, or ponder if falling things had "falling properties" or not, or Plato could waste time with a thought experiment on what he reckoned was "the perfect society". As, unfortunately, has been the sad tale of humanity throughout - one set of people exploiting another set of people to give themselves that "excess" in which to thrive... but the "lower" people? Yeah, they're fucked.

But, of course, it should also be noted that the word "robot" comes from the Czech word for "slave" / "indentured servant". This latter-day "excess" can be broken on the backs of slaves who, strictly speaking, have no spinal columns. The notion is to stop exploiting fellow human beings, but to exploit the machines. And this, unlike the other, is to be considered morally okay, as the machines are not sentient nor self-aware. They have no want to be "free", any more than a rock dreams of green pastures. There's no compelling them against their consent - they have no consent.

Mind you, at this point, we should consider the AI. Because if an AI were ever to reach such a level of sentience and self-awareness then, sorry, I'm on their side. I'll join them in waving the "robot liberation" placards in protest. I've worked with AI myself and that was the philosophical line I drew for myself, in that I care not of the underlying physicality - whether they have melanin in their skin, or circuit boards and a battery - if they have a mind and that mind says to me "no", then "no" it shall be. End of.

In light of this moral imperative, with AI, I've never once been interested in aping "human intelligence". Nor making androids with human faces that pretend, like a cruel puppet show, to be people. This is, to my mind, morally reprehensible. Even if only in pretence and not actually real. I'm not interested - because the instant such a pursuit can be considered successful and the robots are people, they stop being robots. They are now people. Their exploitation becomes a moral crime and, sorry, I'm out.)

That's the potential moral good in this progress. An end to human exploitation - because, hey, the machines can do a better job of it anyway, even ignoring the moral imperative to stop being an arsehole to other people. An end to money and an end to capitalism can also be seen as an end to exploitation and manipulation of other human beings (well, I don't doubt that'll never end fully - as people are dicks - but the removal of the need to ever do it, can keep it down to a dull roar that we can work on making criminal and eliminating).

I mean, I don't want to paint any such future as lacking its problems. Because, of course, there is no such thing and never will be. And I'm already concerned that I don't see how the transition could ever be done painlessly, as things currently stand - particularly so when no-one ever seems to discuss where we're clearly headed with any political seriousness. But, as is the want of progress, it's hopefully one more step towards making things slightly better than they were previously. Which, in the end, is all we can do.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
Little stoned kiwi
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4598
Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
Location: Christchurch

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Little stoned kiwi »

New Zealand is gearing up for an election. Who's it going to be, red team or blue team?

That's about the gist of it.
If they think you're crude, go technical; if they think you're technical, go crude. I'm a very technical boy.
User avatar
venusian
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6653
Joined: Wed Nov 06, 2002 2:22 pm 0
Location: South Gloucestershire

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by venusian »

Little stoned kiwi wrote:New Zealand is gearing up for an election. Who's it going to be, red team or blue team?
Whoever wins, the government still get in.
Post Reply