I'm not saying its difficult to understand, I'm just curious where everyone gets all their figures from and the presumptions that are made based off them.tufty wrote:It's quite easy to understand. The UK has placed itself in a position where, as of the end of the year, it will have no trading deals in place with the EU (or, in fact, pretty much anyone else, as all its current trade deals are through the EU). Even ignoring extra-EU trade, this is a catastrophic position to be in. Around 45-50% of the UK's trade goes to and from Europe. With no trade deal in place, all of that trade will be more expensive, by around 20% or more.Whiteball wrote:That's exactly the sort of comments I'm talking about though. Anyone can say things like that, is there any actual examples?tufty wrote:The EU aren't the ones asking for favours.Whiteball wrote:Maybe, only because he isn't getting what he wants?
This means that any company that sells to Europe will be at a 20% or more price disadvantage with respect to a company within Europe selling the same product, and at a significant price disadvantage with respect to an extra-european company selling the same product to Europe through an EU trade deal. This means that they will have to slash prices, and thus profits, to make the sale. Any company purchasing from the the EU will see their purchase prices go up by 20% or more. This means more expensive products for the consumer and / or less profit for the company.
The same applies from the other side, of course, but from the European point of view, it's not so significant. The UK only accounts for around 6% of all EU trade. The EU will be hurt by a no-deal in December, but not to the point the UK will. The EU can quite happily survive as a trading bloc without the UK. It's not clear that the converse is true.
What the UK needs, and what the politicians have loudly promised to the people as part of the "easiest trade deal ever", is trade as usual. Zero tariffs, carry on as you were. But whilst the EU could grant that, it would have to come at a significant cost. If nothing else because the UK can't have a better deal than those who are within the EU; it would be the end of the EU as a trading bloc. So the UK needs to make some really big compromises, and almost certainly get its wallet out. No place at the table to make decisions, significant funding to the EU with no cashflow back, no veto on EU regulations, and freedom of movement are the absolute minimum we can expect to get that holy grail.
Otherwise, new trade deals need to be made, on every one of the commodities the UK trades with the EU. That's *thousands* of individual trade deals to be made, thousands of tariffs to be decided.
If the UK isn't willing to back down on its red lines, and as there simply isn't time to negotiate all those trade deals, the UK is going to have to suck up whatever tariffs the EU decides to levy on it. That's what "trading under WTO rules" means.
So yeah. Pick a commodity. The UK is asking for a favour on it.
Do we actually have any real facts or an official document we can read detailing any of this stuff.





